Abstract
We investigated 923 cervical vertebrae belonging to late-antiquity and medieval skeletal remains and assessed the qualitative and quantitative structural characteristics of transverse foramens (TF) and additional vascular canals. We also reviewed the pertinent literature. Double TF were chiefly observed in C6 (with a right/left side prevalence of 35.7 and 44.4 %, respectively) and C5 vertebrae (23.6 and 23.9 %, right/left side, respectively), while unclosed TF were mainly documented in C1 vertebrae (8.4 %). Retrotransverse canal and retrotransverse groove were present in 8.5 and 17.8 %, respectively, of C1 vertebrae examined, while arcuate foramens and supertransverse foramens were found in 7.3 and 3.7 % of specimens, respectively. TF diameter decreased from C6 to C2 vertebrae, being smallest in C7 and greatest in C1 vertebrae, with no left/right significant difference. There was a significant correlation between TF diameter and stature, but only on the right side. The mean area of the arcuate foramen was lower than the mean area of the ipsilateral TF (24.5 ± 5.7 vs 28.5 ± 7.7 mm2, respectively; p = 0.048), possibly causing compression of the vertebral artery within the arcuate foramen. The study of human vertebrae excavated from archaeological sites is a simple and effective way to analyze the morphology and quantitative anatomy of vascular foramens.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abou Madawi A, Solanki G, Casey AT, Crockard HA (1997) Variation of the groove in the axis vertebra for the vertebral artery. Implications for instrumentation. J Bone Joint Surg Br 79:820–823
Agrawal R, Ananthi S, Agrawal S, Usha K (2012) Posterior arch of atlas with abnormal foramina in south Indians. J Anat Soc India 61:30–32
Allen W (1879) On the varieties of the atlas in the human subject, and the homologies of its transverse processes. J Anat Physiol 14:18–28
Aparicio Bellver L, Calatayud Fombuena M, Pérez Moltó F (1998) Variaciones morfológicas y numéricas en la columna vertebral. Rev S Traum Ort 18:215–221
Awadalla AK, Fetouh FA (2009) Morphometric analysis of the vertebral artery groove of the first cervical vertebra (atlas). Pan Arab J Neurosurg 13:66–71
Baeesa SS, Bokhari RF, Bajunaid KM, Al-Sayyad MJ (2012) Prevalence of the foramen arcuale of the atlas in a Saudi population. Neurosciences (Riyadh) 17:345–351
Barbosa Sueiro MB (1933) A morfogenia de algumas variações raquidianas no homen. Arq Anat Antropol 14:613–706
Bergman RA, Thompson SA, Afifi AK, Saadeh FA (eds) (1988) Compendium of human anatomic variations: text, atlas and world literature. Urban & Schwarzenberg, Baltimore
Billmann F, Le Minor JM (2009) Transverse foramen of the atlas (C1) anteriorly unclosed. A misknown human variant and its evolutionary significance. Spine 34:422–426
Bilodi AK, Gupta SC (2005) Presence of retro transverse groove or canal in atlas vertebrae. J Anat Soc India 54:16–18
Bolk L (1906) Zur Frage der Assimilation des Atlas am Schädel beim Menshcen. Anat Anz 28:497–506
Brocher J (1955) Die occipital-cervical Gegend. Thieme Ed, Stuttgart
Brown M, Verheyden C (2009) Posterior fossa infarction following cleft palate repair and the arcuate foramen. Plast Reconstr Surg 124:237e–239e
Buikstra JE, Ubelaker DH (eds) (1994) Standards for data collection from human skeletal remains. Arkansas Archeological Survey, Fayetteville
Cagnie B, Barbaix E, Vinck E, D’Herde K, Cambier D (2005) Extrinsic risk factors for compromised blood flow in the vertebral artery: anatomical observations of the transverse foramina from C3 to C7. Surg Radiol Anat 27:31–316
Cakmak O, Gurdal E, Ekinci G, Yildiz E, Cavdar S (2005) Arcuate foramen and its clinical significance. Saudi Med J 26:1409–1413
Cederberg RA, Benson BW, Nunn M, English JD (2000) Arcuate foramen: prevalence by age, gender, and degree of calcification. Clin Orthod Res 3:162–167
Chandravadiya L, Patel S, Goda J, Chavda V, Ruparelia S (2013) Double foramen transversarium in cervical vertebra: morphology and clinical importance. Int J Res Med 2:103–105
Chevrel JP, Pineau H, Delmas A (1965) L’arc postérieur de l’atlas. Ses variations. Etude morphologique et statistique. C R Assoc Anat 131:280–288
Chinnappan M, Manjunath K (2008) Variations of atlas. Anat Karnataka 3:77–82
Cho YJ (2009) Radiological analysis of ponticulus posticus in Koreans. Yonsei Med J 50:45–49
Curylo LJ, Mason HC, Bohlman HH, Yoo JU (2000) Tortuous course of the vertebral artery and anterior cervical decompression: a cadaveric and clinical cases study. Spine 25:2860–2864
Cushing KE, Ramesh V, Gardner-Medwin D, Todd NV, Gholka A, Baxter P, Griffiths PD (2001) Tethering of the vertebral artery in the congenital arcuate foramen of the atlas vertebra: a possible cause of vertebral artery dissection in children. Dev Med Child Neurol 43:491–496
Dahiphale VP, Bahetee BH (2009) The retro-articular vertebral artery ring of the atlas and its significance. J Anat Soc India 58:149–151
de Carvalho MF, Pereira CU, de Carvalho AF, Mtis GK, Silva D (2012) Ponticulus posticus incidence in Brazilian atlas vertebrae—a cadaveric study. Rev Chil Neurocirug 38:29–31
de Sousa CA, Ferreira AS, Rodrigues M (1989) Contribuição para o estudo da charneira occipito-vertebral. Sep Arq Anat Antropol 40:209–217
Duan S, Lv S, Ye F, Lin Q (2009) Imaging anatomy and variation of vertebral artery and bone structure at craniocervical junction. Eur Spine J 18:1102–1108
Dubreuil-Chambardel L (1907) Le Canal veineux transversaire. Bull Mém Soc Anthropol Paris 8:52–57
Dubreuil-Chambardel L (ed) (1921) L’atlas. Vigot, Paris
Elliott RE, Tanweer O (2014) The prevalence of the ponticulus posticus (arcuate foramen) and its importance in Goel-Harms procedure: meta-analysis and review of the literature. World Neurosurg 82:e335–e343
Falk D (1986) Evolution of cranial blood drainage in hominids: enlarged occipital/marginal sinuses and emissary foramina. Am J Phys Anthropol 70:311–324
Farman AG, Nortjié CJ, Joubert JJ (1979) Radiographic profile of the first cervical vertebra. J Anat 128:595–600
Fusari R (1889) Delle principali varietà presentate dalle ossa del tronco e della testa esistenti nel Museo Anatomico della R. Università di Messina. La Sicilia Medica, anno I, fase IV
Gopal K, Kumar V, Kumar V, Agarwal J (2013) Anatomical variations in conduit of vertebral artery in atlas. J Evol Med Dental Sci 42:8030–8037
Greiner HM, Abruzzo TA, Kabbouche M, Leach JL, Zuccarello M (2010) Rotational vertebral artery occlusion in a child with multiple strokes: a case-based update. Childs Nerv Syst 26:1669–1674
Gupta T (2008) Quantitative anatomy of vertebral artery groove on the posterior arch of atlas in relation to spinal surgical procedures. Surg Radiol Anat 30:239–242
Gupta SC, Gupta CD, Arora AK, Maheshwari BB (1979) The retrotransverse groove/canal in Indian atlas vertebrae. Anat Anz 514:145–516
Hasan M, Shukla S, Siddiqui MS, Singh D (2001) Posterolateral tunnels and ponticuli in human atlas vertebrae. J Anat 199:339–343
Hasebe K (1913) Die Wirbelsäule der Japaner. Z Morphol Anthropol 15:259–380
Hayek H (1927) Untersuchungen uber Epistropheus, Atlas, und Hinterhauptsbein. Morphol Jahrb 58:269–347
Hong JT, Lee SW, Son BC, Sung JH, Yang SH, Kim IS, Park CK (2008) Analysis of anatomical variations of bone and vascular structures around the posterior atlantal arch using three-dimensional computed tomography angiography. J Neurosurg Spine 8:230–236
Hong JM, Chung CS, Bang OY, Yong SW, Joo IS, Huh K (2009) Vertebral artery dominance contributes to basilar artery curvature and peri-vertebrobasilar junctional infarcts. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 80:1087–1092
Ilie A (2008) Anomaliile congenitale osoase in regiune cranio-vertebrala si cervicala. Studiu anatomo-imagistic. PhD thesis. Academia de Studii Economice, Bucureşti
Karau PB, Odula PO (2013) Some anatomical and morphometric observation in transverse foramina of the atlas among Kenyans. Anat J Afr 1:61–66
Karau PB, Ogengo JA, Hassanali J, Odula P (2010a) Anatomy and prevalence of atlas vertebrae bridges in a Kenyan population: an osteological study. Clin Anat 23:649–653
Karau PB, Ogengo JA, Hassanali J, Odula P (2010b) Morphometry and variations of bony ponticles of the atlas vertebrae (C1) in Kenyans. Int J Morphol 28:1019–1024
Katikireddi RS, Setty SNRS (2014) A study of double foramen transversarium in dried cervical vertebra. Int J Health Sci Res 4:59–61
Katsanos AH, Kosmidou M, Kyritsis AP, Giannopoulos S (2013) Is vertebral artery hypoplasia a predisposing factor for posterior circulation cerebral ischemic events? A comprehensive review. Eur Neurol 70:78–83
Kavakli A, Aydinlioglu A, Yesilyurt H, Kus I, Diyarbakirli S, Erdem S, Anlar O (2004) Variants and deformities of atlas vertebrae in Eastern Anatolian people. Saudi Med J 25:322–325
Kaya S, Yilmaz ND, Pusat S, Kural C, Kirik A, Izci Y (2011) Double foramen transversarium variation in ancient Byzantine cervical vertebrae: preliminary report of an anthropological study. Turk Neurosurg 21:534–538
Kendrick GS, Biggs NL (1963) Incidence of the ponticulus posticus of the first cervical vertebra between ages six to seventeen. Anat Rec 145:449–453
Kim C, Lee S-H, Park SS, Joon Kim B, Ryu W-S, Kim CK, Oh M-Y, Chung J-W, Yoon B-W (2012) A quantitative comparison of the vertebral artery and transverse foramen using CT angiography. J Clin Neurol 8:259–264
Kim KH, Park KW, Manh TH, Yeom JS, Chang BS, Lee CK (2007) Prevalence and morphologic features of ponticulus posticus in Koreans: analysis of 312 radiographs and 225 three-dimensional CT scans. Asian Spine J 1:27–31
Kimmerle A (1930) Ponticulus posticus. Rontgenprax 2:479–483
Kittel J (1985) Ponticulus lateralis of the atlas. Radiol Diagn Berl 26:643–648
Kotil K, Kilincer C (2014) Sizes of the transverse foramina correlate with blood flow and dominance of vertebral arteries. Spine J 14:933–937
Koutsouraki E, Avdelidi E, Michmizos D, Kapsali SE, Costa V, Baloyannis S (2010) Kimmerle’s anomaly as a possible causative factor of chronic tension-type headaches and neurosensory hearing loss: case report and literature review. Int J Neurosci 120:236–239
Krishnamurthy A, Nayak SR, Khan S, Prabhu LV, Ramanathan LA, Ganesh Kumar C, Prasad Sinha A (2007) Arcuate foramen of atlas: incidence, phylogenetic and clinical significance. Rom J Morphol Embryol 48:263–266
Lamberty BGH, Zivanovic S (1973) The retro-articular vertebral artery ring of the atlas and its significance. Acta Anat 85:113–122
Le Double AF (ed) (1912) Traité des variations de la colonne vértebrale de l’homme. Vogot Frères, Paris
Le Minor JM (1997) The retrotransverse foramen of the human atlas vertebra. A distinctive variant within primates. Acta Anat 160:208–212
Le Minor JM, Koritke JG (1991/92) Associations of non-metrical variants of the human atlas. Arch Anat Histol Embryol 74:11–26
Le Minor JM, Trost O (2004) Bony ponticles of the atlas (C1) over the groove for the vertebral artery in humans and primates: polymorphism and evolutionary trends. Am J Phys Anthropol 125:16–29
Loth-Niemirycz J (ed) (1916) Badania anatomiczne i antropologiczne nad kanałem wyrostków poprzecznych, canalis transversarius kręgów szyjowych człowieka i małp. Towarzystwo Naukowe Warszawskie, Warsaw
Macalister A (1893) Notes on the development and variations of the atlas. J Anat Physiol 27:519–542
Macalister A (1894) The development and variations of the second cervical vertebrae. J Anat Physiol 28:257–268
Malhotra VK, Tewari SP, Bajpai RN (1979) Study of vertebral artery foramen on atlas vertebra. J Anat Soc India 28:103–105
Manjunath KY (2001) Posterior bridging of atlas vertebra in South Indians. Indian J Med Sci 55:488–490
Maqbool A, Hameed O, Athar Z, Rafi Aisha (2013) Morphological study of native foramina transversaria in the cervical spine. Medical Forum Monthly 24:33–37
Metha G, Shamkuwar S, Mokhasi V (2014) Foramina transversaria “bipartita”: a study of cervical vertebrae. Int J Cur Res Rev 6:31–34
Miki T, Oka M, Urushidani H, Hirofuji E, Tanaka S, Iwamoto S (1979) Ponticulus posticus: its clinical significance. Acta Med Kinki Univ 4:427–430
Mitchell J (1998) The incidence and dimensions of the retroarticular canal of the atlas vertebra. Acta Anat 163:113–120
Munjal S, Chauha P, Ali S, Mongia M, Verma P, Ahmad A (2013) Prevalence of ponticulus posticus of atlas: a radiological and cadaveric study in Hilly regions of Uttarakhand. Nat J Med Dent Res 1:28–33
Murlimanju BV, Prabhu LV, Shilpa K, Rai R, Dhananjaya KV, Jiji PJ (2011) Accessory transverse foramina in the cervical spine: incidence, embryological basis, morphology and surgical importance. Turk Neurosurg 21:384–387
Nagar Y, Taitz C, Reich R (1999) What can we make of these fragments? Excavation at “Mamilla” Cave, Byzantine period, Jerusalem. Int J Osteoarchaeol 9:29–38
Neumann DA (2010) Kinesiology of the musculoskeletal system: foundations for physical rehabilitation. Mosby Elsevier, St Louis
Ossenfort WF (1926) The atlas in whites and negroes. Am J Phys Anthropol 9:439–443
Pang D, Li V (2004) Atlantoaxial rotatory fixation: part 1-Biomechanics of normal rotation at the atlantoaxial joint in children. Neurosurgery 55:614–625
Paraskevas G, Papaziogas B, Tsonidis C, Kapetanos G (2005) Gross morphology of the bridges over the vertebral artery groove on the atlas. Surg Radiol Anat 27:129–136
Pitzorno M (1899) Sur quelques nouvelles particularités de l’atlas et sur la coexistence de ses variétés. Arch Ital Biol 31:179
Poirier P (1892) Traité d’anatomie humaine, 1st edn. Imprimerie Darantiere, Dijon
Prescher A, Brors D, Adam G (1996) Anatomic and radiologic appearance of several variants of the craniocervical junction. Skull Base Surg 6:83–94
Pyo J, Lowman RM (1959) The “Ponticulus Posticus” of the first cervical vertebra. Radiol 72:850–854
Radojević S, Negovanović B (1963) La gouttière et les anneaux osseux de l’artère vertébrale de l’atlas. Étude anatomique et radiologique. Acta Anat 55:186–194
Ranganatha Sastry V, Manjunath KY (2006) The course of the V1 segment of the vertebral artery. Ann Indian Acad Neurol 9:223–226
Rathnakar P, Remya KS (2013) Study of accessory foramen transversaria in cervical vertebrae. NUJHS 3:97–99
Rekha BS, Neginhal DD (2014) Variations in foramen transversarium of atlas vertebra: an osteological study in South Indians. Int J Res Health Sci 2:224–228
Rekha BS, Rajeshwari T (2013) Study of ponticuli in human atlas vertebrae. JEMDS 2:8849–8855
Rieger P, Huber G (1983) Fenestration and duplicate origin of the left vertebral artery in angiography. Neuroradiology 25:45–50
Rosse C, Mejino JL, Modayur BR, Jakobovits R, Hinshaw KP, Brinkley JF (1998) Motivation and organizational principles for the Digital Anatomist Symbolic Knowledge Base: an approach toward standards in anatomical knowledge representation. J Am Med Inform Assoc 5:17–40
Sassu G, Barocci R, Casu L, Tedde G (1965) Morphological variations of the atlas of adult Sardinians. Studi sassaresi 43:228–237
Sato E, Noriyasu S (1978) Studies on the ponticulus posterior and ponticulus lateralis of the human first cervical vertebra. Sapporo Med J 47:599–617
Saunders SR, Popovich F (1978) A family study of two skeletal variants: atlas bridging and clinoid bridging. Am J Phys Anthropol 49:193–203
Scheuer L, Black S (2000) Developmental juvenile osteology. Elsevier Academic Press, Oxford
Schilling J, Schilling A, Suazo Galdames I (2010) Ponticulus posticus on the posterior arch of atlas, prevalence analysis in asymptomatic patients. Int J Morphol 28:317–322
Selby S, Garn SM, Kanareff V (1955) The incidence and familial nature of a bony bridge on the first cervical vertebra. Am J Phys Anthropol 13:129–141
Senoglu M, Gümüşalan Y, Yüksel KZ, Uzel M, Celik M, Ozbag D (2006) The effect of posterior bridging of C-1 on craniovertebral junction surgery. J Neurosurg Spine 5:50–52
Sharma A, Singh K, Gupta V, Srivastava S (2010) Double foramen transversarium in cervical vertebra: an osteological study. J Anat Soc India 59:229–231
Sharma V, Chaudhary D, Mitra R (2010) Prevalence of ponticulus posticus in Indian orthodontic patients. Dentomaxillofac Radiol 39:27–283
Shinde VS, Mallikarjun M (2012) Study of abnormal foramen over the posterior arch of atlas vertebra. Int J Morphol 30:557–558
Simsek S, Yigitkanli K, Comert A, Acar HI, Seckin H, Er U, Belen D, Tekdemir I, Elhan A (2008) Posterior osseous bridging of C1. J Clin Neurosci 5:686–688
Split W, Sawrasewicz-Rybak M (2002) Character of headache in Kimmerle anomaly. Headache 42:911–916
Stubbs DM (1992) The arcuate foramen. Variability in distribution related to race and sex. Spine 17:1502–1504
Taitz C, Nathan H (1986) Some observations on the posterior and lateral bridge of the atlas. Acta Anat 127:212–217
Taitz C, Nathan H, Arensburg B (1978) Anatomical observations of the foramina transversaria. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 41:170–176
Taylor WB 3rd, Vandergriff CL, Opatowsky MJ, Layton KF (2012) Bowhunter’s syndrome diagnosed with provocative digital subtraction cerebral angiography. Proc Bayl Univ Med Cent 25:26–27
Thierfelder KM, Baumann AB, Sommer WH, Armbruster M, Opherk C, Janssen H, Reiser MF, Straube A, von Baumgarten L (2014) Vertebral artery hypoplasia: frequency and effect on cerebellar blood flow characteristics. Stroke 45:1363–1368
Trotter M, Gleser GC (1952) Estimation of stature from long bones of American whites and negroes. Am J Phys Anthropol 10:463–514
Tubbs RS, Johnson PC, Mohammadali M, Shoja MM, Loukas M, Oakes WJ (2007a) Foramen arcuale: anatomical study and review of the literature. JNS 6:31–34
Tubbs RS, Shoja MM, Shokouhi G, Farahani RM, Loukas M, Oakes WJ (2007b) Simultaneous lateral and posterior ponticles resulting in the formation of a vertebral artery tunnel of the atlas: case report and review of the literature. Folia Neuropathol 45:43–46
Unur E, Erdogan N, Ülger H, Ekinci N, Ömer Ö (2004) Radiographic incidence of complete arcuate foramen in Turkish population. Erciyes Med J 26:50–54
Valdueza JM, von Munster T, Hoffman O, Schreiber S, Einhäupl KM (2000) Postural dependency of the cerebral venous outflow. Lancet 355:200–201
Varaglia S (1885) Di alcune varietà ossee del tronco. Giornale della R Acc di Med di Torino fase 8–9
Vasudeva N, Kumar R (1995) Absence of foramen transversarium in the human atlas vertebra: a case report. Acta Anat 152:230–233
Veleanu C, Barzu S, Panescu S, Udroiu C (1977) Retro transverse groove or canal of atlas and its significance. Acta Anat 97:400–402
Vijayalakshmi BM (2012) A study of presence of ponticuli in human atlas vertebra in south indian population. PhD thesis. University of Bangalore, Bangalore
Wysocki J, Bubrowski M, Reymond J, Kwiatkowski J (2003) Anatomical variants of the cervical vertebrae and the first thoracic vertebra in man. Folia Morphol 62:357–363
Young JP, Young PH, Ackermann MJ, Anderson PA, Riew KD (2005) The ponticulus posticus: implications for screw insertion into the first cervical lateral mass. J Bone Joint Surg Am 87:2495–2498
Zaborowski Z (1975) The sagittal foramen of the atlas. Folia Morphol (Wroclaw) 34:375–381
Zhao L, Xu R, Hu T, Ma W, Xia H, Wang G (2008) Quantitative evaluation of the location of the vertebral artery in relation to the transverse foramen in the lower cervical spine. Spine 33:373–378
Zoja G (1881) Intorno all’atlante. Studii Antropo-Zootomici. Classe di Sc. mat. E nat. vol. XIV, V della serie III, Milano
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by local funds from Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Università e della Ricerca, Rome, to the Department of Experimental and Clinical Medicine, Section of Anatomy, University of Udine Medical School. The authors are grateful to the Soprintendenza per i Beni Archeologici del Friuli Venezia Giulia for providing access to skeletal material.
Conflict of interest
None.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Travan, L., Saccheri, P., Gregoraci, G. et al. Normal anatomy and anatomic variants of vascular foramens in the cervical vertebrae: a paleo-osteological study and review of the literature. Anat Sci Int 90, 308–323 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12565-014-0270-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12565-014-0270-x