Abstract
While doctors generally enjoy considerable status, some believe that this is increasingly threatened by consumerism, managerialism, and competition from other health professions. Research into doctors’ perceptions of the changes occurring in medicine has provided some insights into how they perceive and respond to these changes but has generally failed to distinguish clearly between concerns about “status,” related to the entitlements associated with one’s position in a social hierarchy, and concerns about “respect,” related to being held in high regard for one’s moral qualities. In this article we explore doctors’ perceptions of the degree to which they are respected and their explanations for, and responses to, instances of perceived lack of respect. We conclude that doctors’ concerns about loss of respect need to be clearly distinguished from concerns about loss of status and that medical students need to be prepared for a changing social field in which others’ respect cannot be taken for granted.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allsop, J., and L. Mulcahy. 1998. Maintaining professional identity: Doctors’ responses to complaints. Sociology of Health & Illness 20(6): 802–824.
Annandale, E.C. 1989. The malpractice crisis and the doctor–patient relationship. Sociology of Health & Illness 11(1): 1–23.
Armstrong, D. 2002. Clinical autonomy, individual and collective: The problem of changing doctors' behaviour. Social Science & Medicine 55(10): 1771–1777.
Barrow, M., J. McKimm, and S. Gasquoine. 2011. The policy and the practice: Early-career doctors and nurses as leaders and followers in the delivery of health care. Advances in Health Sciences Education 16(1): 17–29.
Benditt, T.M. 2008. Why respect matters. Journal of Value Inquiry 42(4): 487–496.
Berg, M., K. Horstman, S. Plass, and M. van Heusden. 2000. Guidelines, professionals and the production of objectivity: Standardisation and the professionalism of insurance medicine. Sociology of Health & Illness 22(6): 765–791.
Bhaskar, R., M. Archer, A. Collier, T. Lawson, and A. Norrie, (eds.). 1998. Critical realism: Essential readings. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge.
Bird, C. 2004. Status, identity, and respect. Political Theory 32(2): 207–232.
Burri, R.V. 2008. Doing distinctions: Boundary work and symbolic capital in radiology. Social Studies of Science 38(1): 35–62.
Charmaz, K. 2006. Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis. London: Sage.
Clarke, A.E. 2003. Situational analysis: Grounded theory mapping after the postmodern turn. Symbolic Interaction 26(4): 553–576.
Cockerham, W., and G. Scambler. 2009. Medical sociology and sociological theory. In The new Blackwell companion to medical sociology, ed. W.C. Cockerham, 1–26. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
Coulehan, J., and P.C. Williams. 2003. Conflicting professional values in medical education. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 12(1): 7–20.
Darwall, S. 1977. Two kinds of respect. Ethics 88(1): 36–49.
Darwall, S. 1992. Two kinds of respect. In Ethics and personality: Essays in moral psychology, ed. J. Deigh, 65–78. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Darwall, S. 2004. Respect and the second-person standpoint. Proceedings and Addresses of the American Philosophical Association 78(2): 43–59.
De Voe, J.E., and S.D. Short. 2003. A shift in the historical trajectory of medical dominance: The case of Medibank and the Australian doctors’ lobby. Social Science & Medicine 57(2): 343–353.
Dent, M. 2006. Disciplining the medical profession? Implications of patient choice for medical dominance. Health Sociology Review 15(5): 458–468.
Drucker, P.F. 1988. The coming of the new organization. Harvard Business Review 88(1): 45–53.
Dukerich, J.M., B.R. Golden, and S.M. Shortell. 2002. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder: The impact of organizational identification identity and image on the cooperative behaviors of physicians. Administrative Science Quarterly 47(3): 507–533.
Durkheim, E. 1964. The division of labor in society. Trans. G. Simpson. Toronto: Collier-Macmillan. Originally published as De la division du travail social (Paris: Les Presses Universitaires de France, 1858).
Gillespie, R., D. Florin, and S. Gillam. 2004. How is patient-centred care understood by the clinical, managerial and lay stakeholders responsible for promoting this agenda? Health Expectations 7(2): 142–148.
Hafferty, F.W., and D.W. Light. 1995. Professional dynamics and the changing nature of medical work. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 35(suppl): 132–153.
Hall, P. 2005. Interprofessional teamwork: Professional cultures as barriers. Journal of Interprofessional Care 19(suppl 1): 188–196.
Hardey, M. 1999. Doctor in the house: The Internet as a source of lay health knowledge and the challenge to expertise. Sociology of Health & Illness 21(6): 820–835.
Huo, Y.J., H.J. Smith, T.R. Tyler, and E.A. Lind. 1996. Superordinate identification, subgroup identification, and justice concerns: Is separatism the problem; is assimilation the answer? Psychological Science 7(1): 40–45.
Jeremier, J., D. Knights, and W. Nord. 1994. Resistance and power in organizations. London: Routledge.
Judge, T.A., R.F. Piccolo, and R. Ilies. 2004. The forgotten ones? The validity of consideration and initiating structure in leadership research. Journal of Applied Psychology 89(1): 36–51.
Kirschner, S.R., and W.S. Lachicotte. 2001. Managing managed care: Habitus, hysteresis and the end(s) of psychotherapy. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 25(4): 441–456.
Kocher, R., and N.R. Sahni. 2010. Physicians versus hospitals as leaders of accountable care organizations. The New England Journal of Medicine 363(27): 2579–2582.
Kurunmaki, L. 1999. Professional vs financial capital in the field of health care—struggles for the redistribution of power and control. Accounting, Organizations and Society 24(2): 95–124.
Lind, E.A., R. Kanfer, and P.C. Earley. 1990. Voice, control, and procedural justice: Instrumental and noninstrumental concerns in fairness judgments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59(5): 952–959.
Lupton, D. 1997. Doctors on the medical profession. Sociology of Health & Illness 19(4): 480–497.
Lupton, D. 1998. Doctors in the news media: Lay and medical audiences’ responses. Journal of Sociology 34(1): 35–48.
Maseide, P. 1991. Possibly abusive, often benign, and always necessary—on power and domination in medical practice. Sociology of Health & Illness 13(4): 545–561.
McKinlay, J.B., and L.D. Marceau. 2002. The end of the golden age of doctoring. International Journal of Health Services 32(2): 379–416.
Mechanic, D. 2003. Physician discontent: Challenges and opportunities. The Journal of the American Medical Association 290(7): 941–946.
Menke, W.G. 1971. Medical identity: Change and conflict in professional roles. Journal of Medical Education 46(1): 58–63.
Miller, D.T. 2001. Disrespect and the experience of injustice. Annual Review of Psychology 52: 527–553.
Morse, J.M. 1994. “Emerging from the data”: The cognitive processes of analysis in qualitative inquiry. In Critical issues in qualitative research methods, ed. J.M. Morse, 23–42. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Nettleton, S., R. Burrows, and I. Watt. 2008. Regulating medical bodies? The consequences of the “modernisation” of the NHS and the disembodiment of clinical knowledge. Sociology of Health & Illness 30(3): 333–348.
O’Flynn, N., and N. Britten. 2006. Does the achievement of medical identity limit the ability of primary care practitioners to be patient-centred? A qualitative study. Patient Education and Counseling 60(1): 49–56.
Peck, B., and S. Conner. 2011. Talking with me or talking at me? The impact of status characteristics on doctor–patient interaction. Sociological Perspectives 54(4): 547–567.
Pettit, P. 1989. Consequentialism and respect for persons. Ethics 100(1): 116–126.
Reichertz, J. 2007. Abduction: The logic of discovery of grounded theory. In The SAGE handbook of grounded theory, ed. A. Bryant and K. Charmaz, 214–228. London: Sage.
Rice, T. 2010. “The hallmark of a doctor”: The stethoscope and the making of medical identity. Journal of Material Culture 15(3): 287–301.
Samson, C. 1995. The fracturing of medical dominance in British psychiatry. Sociology of Health & Illness 17(2): 245–268.
Sennett, R. 2003. Respect: The formation of character in a world of inequality. London: Penguin.
Shekelle, P.G. 2002. Why don't physicians enthusiastically support quality improvement programmes? Quality & Safety in Health Care 11(1): 6.
Simon, B., and S. Sturmer. 2003. Respect for group members: Intragroup determinants of collective identification and group-serving behavior. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 29(2): 183–193.
Smith, H.J., T.R. Tyler, Y.J. Huo, D.J. Ortiz, and E.A. Lind. 1998. The self-relevant implications of the group-value model: Group membership, self-worth, and treatment quality. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 34(5): 470–493.
Snelgrove, S., and D. Hughes. 2000. Interprofessional relations between doctors and nurses: Perspectives from South Wales. Journal of Advanced Nursing 31(3): 661–667.
Thistlethwaite, J. 2005. Patient partnership and shared decision making: Involving patients in management decisions. Health Issues 83(Winter): 22–25.
Timmermans, S., and H. Oh. 2010. The continued social transformation of the medical profession. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 51(suppl): S94–S106.
Tufano, J.T., J.D. Ralston, and D.P. Martin. 2008. Providers’ experience with an organizational redesign initiative to promote patient-centered access: A qualitative study. Journal of General Internal Medicine 23(11): 1778–1783.
Tyler, T.R., and S.L. Blader. 2000. Cooperation in groups: Procedural justice, social identity, and behavioral engagement. Philadelphia: Psychology Press.
van Quaquebeke, N., S. Zenker, and T. Eckloff. 2009. Find out how much it means to me! The importance of interpersonal respect in work values compared to perceived organizational practices. Journal of Business Ethics 89(3): 423–431.
VanLear, C. 1998. Dialectic empiricism: Science and relationship metaphors. In Dialectic approaches to studying relationships, ed. B.M. Montgomery and L.A. Baxter, 109–136. Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Voogdt-Pruis, H.R., G.H.M.I. Beusmans, A.P.M. Gorgels, and J.W. van Ree. 2011. Experiences of doctors and nurses implementing nurse-delivered cardiovascular prevention in primary care: A qualitative study. Journal of Advanced Nursing 67(8): 1758–1766.
Warren, M.A. 1997. Moral status: Obligations to persons and other living things. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Watt, I., S. Nettleton, and R. Burrows. 2008. The views of doctors on their working lives: A qualitative study. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 101(12): 592–597.
White, C.B., A.K. Kumagai, P.T. Ross, and J.C. Fantone. 2009. A qualitative exploration of how the conflict between the formal and informal curriculum influences student values and behaviors. Academic Medicine 84(5): 597–603.
Whitehead, C., Z. Austin, and B. Hodges. 2011. Flower power: The armoured expert in the CanMEDS competency framework? Advances in Health Sciences Education 16(5): 681–694.
Zazzali, J.L., J.A. Alexander, S.M. Shortell, and L.R. Burns. 2007. Organizational culture and physician satisfaction with dimensions of group practice. Health Services Research 42(3 pt 1): 1150–1176.
Competing Interests
The authors have no financial or non-financial conflicts of interest.
Funding
This research was funded by a grant from the Sydney Medical School Foundation, University of Sydney. The Sydney Medical School Foundation played no role in the research or the writing of this article.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lipworth, W., Little, M., Markham, P. et al. Doctors on Status and Respect: A Qualitative Study. Bioethical Inquiry 10, 205–217 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-013-9430-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11673-013-9430-2