Abstract
This paper presents series studies on the toppling mechanism by centrifuge tests and numerical simulations. Two different discrete element methods, i.e., the continuum-based discrete element method (CDEM) and the discontinuous deformation analysis (DDA), are adopted. The modeling results show that both the methods can accurately capture the failure modes of the centrifuge tests, including three distinct zones and two failure surfaces. Comparisons are made between the physical test and numerical simulation results. The critical inclination angle of the tilting table where the slope models are fixed on can be moderately predicted by the two methods, with different degrees of precision. The error between the test results and the simulated results is within 1% for the slope models without rock-bridges by both CDEM and DDA. However, it is amplified for the staggered-joint models that simulate the rock-bridges. With DDA, the average error is about 5%, and the maximum error is up to 17%. While with CDEM, the errors for the aligned-joint models are ranged from 1% to 6%, and it is from 10% to 29% for the staggered- joint models. The two numerical methods show the capability in simulating toppling failure of blocky rock mass with and without rock-bridges. The model with rock-bridges which provides a certain bending resistance is more stable than the one without any rock-bridge. In addition, the two failure surfaces were observed, which is different from the common understanding that only one failure surface appears.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Whyter R J. A study of progressive hanging wall caving at Chambishi copper mine in Zambia using the base friction model concept. Dissertation of Master Degree. London: London University, 1973
Ashiby J. Sliding and toppling modes of failure in model and jointed rock slopes. Dissertation of Master Degree. London: Royal School of Mines, 1971
Hittinger M. Numerical analysis of toppling failure in jointed rock. Dissertation of Doctor Degree. Berkeley: University of California, 1978
Bray J W, Goodman R E. 1981. The theory of base friction models. Int J Rock Mech Min, 1981; 18: 453–468
Adhikary D P, Dyskin A V, Jewell R J, et al. A study of mechanism of flexural topping failure of rock slopes. Rock Mech Rock Eng, 1997; 30: 75–93
Zhang J H, Chen Z Y, Wang X G. Centrifuge modeling of rock slopes susceptible to block toppling. Rock Mech Rock Eng, 2007; 40: 363–382
Pritchard M A, Savigny K W. Numerical modeling of toppling. Can Geotech J, 1990; 27: 824–834
Lanaro F, Jing L, Stephansson O, et al. D.E.M. modeling of laboratory tests of block toppling. Int J Rock Mech Min, 1997, 34: 173
Barla G, Devin P, Zaninetti A. Validation of a distinct element model for toppling rock slopes. In: 8th ISRM Congress. Int. Cong, on Rock Mechanics of Int. Society for Rock Mechanics, Tokyo, 1995; 3: 417–421
Nichol S L, Hungr O, Evans S G. Large-scale brittle and ductile toppling of rock slopes. Can Geotech J, 2002; 39: 773–788
Goricki A, Goodman R E. Failure models of rock slopes demonstrated with base friction and simple numerical models. Felsbau, 2003; 21: 8–12
Koo C Y, Chern J C. Modification of the DDA method for rigid block problems. I Int J Rock Mech Min, 1998; 35: 683–693
Wu J H, Ohnishi Y Z, Shi G H, et al. Theory of three-dimensional discontinuous deformation analysis and its application to a slope toppling at Amatoribashi, Japan. Int J Geomec ASCE, 2005; 5: 179–195
Shi G H. Applications of Discontinuous Deformation Analysis (DDA) to Rock Engineering. Beijing: Tsinghua University Press & Springer, 2007. 136–147
Alzo’ubi A K, Martin C D, Cruden D M. Influence of tensile strength on toppling failure in centrifuge tests. Int J Rock Mech Min, 2010; 47: 974–982
Gu J, Zhao Z Y. Considerations of the discontinuous deformation analysis on wave propagation. Int J Numer Anal Meth Geomech, 2009; 33: 1449–1465
Scholtès L, Donzé F V. Modeling progressive failure in fratured rock masses using a 3D discrete element method. Int J Rock Mech Min, 2012; 52: 18–30
Ning Y J, Yang J, An X M, et al. Modeling rock fracturing and blast-induced rock mass failure via advanced discretisation within the discontinuous deformation analysis framework. Comput Geotech, 2011; 38: 40–49
Eberhardt E, Stead D, Coggan J S. Numerical analysis of initiation and progressive failure in natural rock slopes–the 1991 Randa rockslide. Int J Rock Mech Min, 2004; 41: 69–87
Zhang G X, Zhao Y, Peng X C. Simulation of toppling failure of rock slope by numerical manifold method. Int Comput Method, 2010; 7: 167–189
Feng C, Li S, Liu X, et al. A semi-spring and semi-edge combined contact model in CDEM and its application to analysis of Jiweishan landslide. J Rock Mech Geotec Eng, 2014; 6: 26–35
Schofield A N. Cambridge geotechnical centrifuge operations. Géotechnique, 1980; 30: 227–268
Kutter B L, Moquette L, Thompson P Y. Gravity-scaled tests on blast-induced soil-structure interaction. J Geotec Eng, 1988; 114: 431–447
Chen Z Y, Zhang J H, Wang W X, et al. Centrifuge modeling for rock slopes. In: Ng C, Zhang L M, Wang Y H, eds. Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference Physical Modelling Geotechnics, Hong kong, London: Taylor & Francis Group, 2006. 19–28
Li S H, Zhao M H, Wang Y N, et al. A new numerical method for DEM-block and particle model. Int J Rock Mech Min, 2004; 41: 414–418
Ma Z S, Feng C, Liu T P, et al. A GPU accelerated continuousbaseddiscrete element method for elasto dynamics analysis. Adv Mater Res, 2011; 320: 329–334
Wang J, Li S H, Feng C. A shrunken edge algorithm for contact detection between convex polyhedral blocks. Comput Geotech, 2015; 63: 315–330
Shi G H. Discontinuous deformation analysis-Anew model for the statics and dynamics of block systems. Dissertation of Doctor Degree. Berkeley: University of California, 1988
Shi G H. Simplex integration for manifold method and discontinuous deformation analysis. In: Working Forum on the Manifold Method of Material Analysis, Chungli, Taiwan, 1995. 2, 129–164
Jing L. Formulation of discontinuous deformation analysis (DDA)—animplicit discrete element model for block systems. Eng Geol, 1998; 49: 371–381
Jing L. A review of techniques, advances and outstanding issues in numerical modeling fro rock mechanics and rock engineering. Int J Rock Mech Min, 2003; 40: 285–353
Dooling D M, Sitar N. Time integration in discontinuous deformation analysis. J Eng Mech-ASCE, 2004; 130: 249–259
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chen, Z., Gong, W., Ma, G. et al. Comparisons between centrifuge and numerical modeling results for slope toppling failure. Sci. China Technol. Sci. 58, 1497–1508 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11431-015-5889-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11431-015-5889-x