Abstract
There is empirical evidence to show that global water resources management paradigm shifts, guided by neo-liberal principles, have played a significant role in the emergence of the integrated water resources management school of thought. In turn, this school of thought has guided most water sector reforms in Southern Africa. Using case studies from South Africa and Zimbabwe, the paper explores the structural influence of integrated water resources management discourses and mainstream development theories promoted at the global level on developing economies. It further explores the utility of the integrated water resources management framework at the local levels. The paper goes beyond theory and articulates some of the key processes that took place in the Mazowe catchment in Zimbabwe and the Inkomati catchment in South Africa where the water reform programmes were piloted. Some insights on the application of neo-liberal principles in the water sectors of Southern African countries begin to emerge from the paper.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson AJ (2005) Engaging disadvantaged communities: lessons from the Inkomati CMA establishment process. Paper presented at the workshop on ‘African water laws: plural legislative frameworks for rural water management in Africa’, 26–27 January 2005, IWMI/NRI, Pretoria
Ashton PJ, Turton AR, Dirk J, Rou DJ (2006) Exploring the government, society, and science interfaces in integrated water resource management in South Africa. J Contemp Water Res Educ 135:28–35 (December)
Basson MS, Van Niekerk PH, Van Rooyen JA (1997) Overview of water resources availability and utilization in South Africa. DWAF Report No. P RSA/00/0197, Pretoria
Biswas AK (2004) Integrated water resources management: a reassessment. Water Int 29(2):248–256
Bolding A (1997) Caught in the catchment: Past, present and future management of Nyanyadzi river water. In: Derman B, Nhira C (eds) Towards reforming the institutional and legal basis of the water sector in Zimbabwe. CASS, Harare
Brown J, Woodhouse P (2004) Pioneering redistributive regulatory reform: a study of implementation of a catchment management agency for the Inkomati water management area, South Africa. Draft report
Bruns BR, Meinzen-Dick R (2005) Frameworks for water rights: an overview of institutional options. In: Bruns BR, Ringler C, Meinzen-Dick R. Water rights reform: lessons for institutional design. IFPRI, Washington, DC
Butterworth J, Moriarty P, Van Koppen B (eds) (2004) Beyond domestic: case studies on poverty and productive uses of water at the household level. IRC, Delft
Cardwell EH, Cole AR, Cartwright AL, Martin AL (2006) Integrated water resources management: definitions and conceptual musings in. J Contemp Water Res Educ 135:8–18 (December)
Castells M (1992) Four Asian tigers with a dragon head: a comparative analysis of the state, economy and society in the Asian pacific rim. In: Henderson R, Applebaum J (eds) State and development in the Asian pacific rim. Sage Publications, London
Central Statistics Office (1998) Poverty in Zimbabwe. Central Statistics Office, Harare
Chikozho C, Latham CJK (2005) Implications of customary law for implementing integrated water resources management in Zimbabwe: Considerations of Shona customary law as an institutional alternative. Paper presented at the workshop on African water laws: plural legislative frameworks for rural water management in Africa, 26-27 January 2005, Willow-Park Conference Centre, Johannesburg
Cousins B (2000) Introduction: does land and agrarian reform have a future and, if so, who will benefit? In: Ben Cousins (ed) At the crossroads: land and agrarian reform in South Africa into the 21st century. PLAAS, University of the Western Cape, Cape Town
Department of Water Affairs and Forestry (1999) Government Gazette, October 1999 no. 20491
Department of Water Affairs and Forestry (2003) Catchment management agency establishment process guidelines. DWAF, Pretoria
Derman B (2003) The incredible heaviness of water: water policy and water reform in the new millennium in Southern Africa. Michigan State University, Michigan
Derman B, Hellum A (2003) Renegotiating water and land rights in Zimbabwe: some reflections on legal pluralism. Draft of paper prepared for presentation at the Conference on Remaking Law in Africa: Trans-Nationalism, Persons and Rights
Derman B, Nhira C (eds) (1997) Towards reforming the Institutional and legal basis of the water sector in Zimbabwe. CASS, Harare
FAO (1995) Reforming water resources policy – a guide to methods, processes and practices. FAO Irrigation and Drainage Paper 52, Rome
Galbraith JK (2002) A perfect crime: inequality in the age of globalization. Daedalus, Winter
Geldenhuys A (1997) The national water act: a short review. De Rebus, Pretoria, pp 58–61 (November)
Global Water Partnership (2002) Tool-box for integrated water resources management: policy guidance and operational tools, version 1. GWP, Stockholm
Hurrell A, Woods N (eds) (2000) Inequality, globalization, and world politics. Oxford University Press, UK
Kirsten J, Perret S, Van Zyl J (2000) Land reform and the new water management context in South Africa: principles, progress, and issues. Paper prepared for a seminar of the natural resources management cluster and land policy thematic group. The World Bank, Washington, DC (27 September)
Krugman P (1992) Toward a counter-revolution in development theory. In World Bank Economic Review Supplement (Proceedings of the Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics, pp 15–39
Lankford BA, Douglas J, Merrey DJ, Cour J, Hepworth N (2007) From integrated to expedient: an adaptive framework for river basin management in developing countries. Research Report 110, IWMI, Colombo
Lim JJ (2005) On the role of the state in an increasingly borderless world. Globalization, volume 5, issue 1
Meinzen-Dick RS, Van der Hoek W (2001) Multiple uses of water in irrigated areas in. Irrig Drain Syst 15:93–98
Merle S, Oudot S (2000) Strategies, technical systems and socio-economic status of small-scale farmers in an irrigation scheme in the northern province, South Africa: diagnosis and prospects in a rehabilitation and transfer of management context. CIRAD-CEMAGREF Report
Mkandawire T (2001) Thinking about developmental states in Africa. Camb J Econ 25(3):289–313
Moriarty PB, Batchelor CH, Smits SJ, Pollard JA, Butterworth J, Reddy B, Renuka B, James AJ, Reddy MYV (2004) Demands and entitlements: a framework for holistic and problem-focused water resources assessments. WHIRL Project Working Paper No. 10. (http://www.nri.org/whirl)
Mukhtarov FG (2006) Integrated water resources management from a policy transfer perspective. Department of Environmental Sciences and Policy, Central European University, Budapest
Pegram G, Bofilatos E (2005) Considerations on the composition of CMA governing boards to achieve representation. Paper presented at the workshop on African water laws: plural legislative frameworks for rural water management in Africa. Willow-park Conference Centre, Johannesburg (26–27 January)
RAWOO (2000) Coping with globalization: the need for research concerning local response to globalization in developing countries. Rawoo, The Hague
Schreiner B, Van Koppen B (2001) Catchment management agencies for poverty eradication in South Africa. Paper prepared for the 2nd WARFSA/WaterNet symposium: integrated water resources management: theory, practice, cases. Cape Town, pp 30–31 (October)
Shah T, Makin I, Sakthivadivel R (2005) Limits to leapfrogging: issues in transposing successful river basin management institutions in the developing world. In: Svendsen M (ed) Irrigation and river basin management: options for governance and institutions. CABI and IWMI, London, pp 31–50
Versfeld D (2003) Water for livelihoods: bringing equity and opportunity to the rural poor in South Africa”. Paper presented at the international symposium on water, poverty and productive uses of water at the household level. Muldersdrift, South Africa, 21–23 January
Wade R (2001) Global inequality, winners and losers. The Economist, p 72 (28 April)
Woodhouse P, Hassan R (1999) Implementation of the national water act: catchment management agencies, interests, access and efficiency: Inkomati Basin pilot study. DWAF and Department of International Development, Pretoria
World Bank (1989) Sub-Saharan Africa: from crisis to sustainable growth. World Bank, Washington, DC
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Chikozho, C. Globalizing Integrated Water Resources Management: A Complicated Option in Southern Africa. Water Resour Manage 22, 1241–1257 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-007-9223-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-007-9223-7