Abstract
Presettlement land survey records (PLSRs) are the records of early land surveys in North America, and contain data regarding vegetation conditions prior to widespread European-American settlement. Researchers have used the data within PLSRs to develop species distribution models (SDMs), in order to generate predictions of the historical distributions of tree species. Despite their value for SDMs, PLSRs contain positional error, which may hinder their usefulness for modeling species distributions at fine spatial resolution. Using data from the Holland Land Company (HLC) township survey (1797–1799 CE) of Western New York, USA, this study examines the positional error associated with different approaches for georeferencing vegetation data within PLSRs. The study then examines the impact of positional error upon the predictive performance of SDMs that utilize PLSRs. Our study indicates that the magnitude of positional error within PLSRs varies with georeferencing approach, and that more accurate georeferencing approaches produce better-performing SDMs. The study also indicates that the effects of positional error upon SDMs vary with the niche characteristics of species. Overall, this study affirms the importance of accurately georeferencing species data prior to developing SDMs, including applications that involve PLSRs.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrams MD, Ruffner CM (1995) Physiographic analysis of witness-tree distribution (1765–1798) and present forest cover through north central Pennsylvania. Can J For Res 25:659–668
Barrett LR, Liebens J, Brown DG, Schaetzl RJ, Zuwerink P, Cate TW, Nolan DS (1995) Relationships between soils and presettlement forests in Baraga County, Michigan. Am Midl Nat 134:264–285
Batek MJ (1994) Presettlement vegetation of the Current River watershed in the Missouri Ozarks. M.A. thesis, Department of Geography, University of Missouri Columbia, Columbia, MO USA
Beven KJ, Kirkby MJ (1979) A physically based, variable contributing area model of basin hydrology. Hydrol Sci Bull 24:43–69
Bien JR (1895) Atlas of the state of New York. Prepared under the direction of Joseph R. Bien, E.M., civil and topographical engineer from original surveys and various local surveys revised and corrected. Julius Bien & Company, New York
Black BA, Abrams MD (2001) Influences of Native Americans and surveyor biases on metes and bounds witness-tree distribution. Ecology 82:2574–2586
BLM (2011) Download Public Land Survey System (PLSS) Data. United States Department of the Interior, http://www.geocommunicator.gov/GeoComm/lsis_home/home/index.htm
Bouldin J (2003) Location and accuracy of a sample of General Land Office survey corners in a portion of western Yosemite National Park: a summary. Research report to Yosemite National Park and The Yosemite Fund. http://www.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/bouldin/pdf/GCDB_assessment.pdf
Bourdo EA Jr (1956) A review of the general land office survey and of its use in quantitative studies of former forests. Ecology 37:754–768
Carlson CL (1995) A comparative analysis of selected tax map conversion methods. M.S. thesis, Department of Geography, Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, IL USA
Cartography Associates (2013) David Rumsey Map Collection. http://www.davidrumsey.com/
Chazanof W (1970) Joseph Ellicott and the Holland Land Company: the opening of Western New York. Syracuse University Press, Syracuse
Cogbill CV, Burk J, Motzkin G (2002) The forests of presettlement New England, USA: spatial and compositional patterns based on town proprietor surveys. J Biogeogr 29:1279–1304
Dormann CF, Schymanski SJ, Cabral J, Chuine I, Graham C, Hartig F, Kearney M, Morin X, Römermann C, Schröder B, Singer A (2012) Correlation and process in species distribution models: bridging a dichotomy. J Biogeogr 39:2119–2131
Dyer JM (2001) Using witness trees to assess forest change in southeastern Ohio. Can J For Res 31:1708–1718
Dyer JM (2009) Assessing topographic patterns in moisture use and stress using a water balance approach. Landsc Ecol 24:391–403
Dyer JM (2013) Water Balance Toolbox (v.2) for ArcGIS. Ohio University. http://www.ohio.edu/people/dyer/water_balance.html
Elith J, Graham CH (2009) Do they? How do they? WHY do they differ? On finding reasons for differing performances of species distribution models. Ecography 32:66–77
Elith J, Graham CH, Anderson RP, Dudik M, Ferrier S, Guisan A, Hijmans RJ, Huettmann F, Leathwick JR, Lehmann A, Li J, Lohmann LG, Loiselle BA, Manion G, Moritz C, Nakamura M, Nakazawa Y, Overton JM, Peterson AT, Phillips SJ, Richardson K, Scachetti-Pereira R, Schapire RE, Soberon J, Williams S, Wisz MS, Zimmermann NE (2006) Novel methods improve prediction of species’ distributions from occurrence data. Ecography 29:129–151
Elith J, Leathwick JR, Hastie T (2008) A working guide to boosted regression trees. J Anim Ecol 77:802–813
Ellicott J (1937) Holland Land Company papers: reports of Joseph Ellicott as chief of survey (1797–1800), and as agent (1800–1831) of the Holland Land Company’s purchase in Western New York. Buffalo Historical Society, Buffalo
Esri (2012) ArcGIS 10.1. Redlands, CA USA
Estopinal SV (2008) A guide to understanding land surveys. Wiley, Hoboken
Fagin TD, Hoagland BW (2011) Patterns from the past: modeling public land survey witness tree distributions with weights-of-evidence. Plant Ecol 212:207–217
Fahey R, Lorimer C, Mladenoff D (2012) Habitat heterogeneity and life-history traits influence presettlement distributions of early-successional tree species in a late-successional, hemlock-hardwood landscape. Landsc Ecol 27:999–1013
Fawcett T (2006) An introduction to ROC analysis. Pattern Recognit Lett 27:861–874
Feeley KJ, Silman MR (2010) Modelling the responses of Andean and Amazonian plant species to climate change: the effects of georeferencing errors and the importance of data filtering. J Biogeogr 37:733–740
Fenneman NM (1938) Physiography of Eastern United States. McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York
Fernandez MA, Blum SD, Reichle S, Guo Q, Holzman B, Hamilton H (2009) Locality uncertainty and the differential performance of four common niche-based modeling techniques. Biodivers Inform 6:36–52
Field HL (2004) Landscape surveying. Thomson/Delmar Learning, Clifton
Franklin J, Miller JA (2009) Mapping species distributions: spatial inference and prediction. Cambridge University Press, New York
Girden E (1992) ANOVA: repeated measures. Sage, Newbury Park
Gottschalk TK, Aue B, Hotes S, Ekschmitt K (2011) Influence of grain size on species–habitat models. Ecol Appl 222:3403–3412
Graham CH, Elith J, Hijmans RJ, Guisan A, Peterson AT, Loiselle BA, NCEAS Predicting Species Working Group (2008) The influence of spatial errors in species occurrence data used in distribution models. J Appl Ecol 45:239–247
Guisan A, Graham CH, Elith J, Huettmann F, Distri NS (2007) Sensitivity of predictive species distribution models to change in grain size. Divers Distrib 13:332–340
Guo Q, Liu Y, Wieczorek J (2008) Georeferencing locality descriptions and computing associated uncertainty using a probabilistic approach. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 22:1067–1090
Hanberry BB (2013) Finer grain size increases effects of error and changes influence of environmental predictors on species distribution models. Ecol Inform 15:8–13
Hanberry BB, He HS, Palik BJ (2012) Comparing predicted historical distributions of tree species using two tree-based ensemble classification methods. Am Midl Nat 168:443–455
He HS, Dey DC, Fan XL, Hooten MB, Kabrick JM, Wikle CK, Fan ZF (2007) Mapping pre-European settlement vegetation at fine resolutions using a hierarchical Bayesian model and GIS. Plant Ecol 191:85–94
Hernandez PA, Graham CH, Master LL, Albert DL (2006) The effect of sample size and species characteristics on performance of different species distribution modeling methods. Ecography 29:773–785
Hirzel AH, Hausser J, Chessel D, Perrin N (2002) Ecological-niche factor analysis: how to compute habitat-suitability maps without absence data? Ecology 83:2027–2036
Johnson JB (1889) The theory and practice of surveying: designed for the use of surveyors and engineers generally, but especially for the use of students in engineering. Wiley, New York
Johnson CJ, Gillingham MP (2008) Sensitivity of species-distribution models to error, bias, and model design: an application to resource selection functions for woodland caribou. Ecol Model 213:143–155
Keys RG (1981) Cubic convolution interpolation for digital image processing. IEEE Trans Acoust Speech Signal Process 29:1153–1160
Kronenfeld BJ, Wang Y-C (2007) Accounting for surveyor inconsistency and bias in estimation of tree density from presettlement land survey records. Can J For Res 37:2365–2379
Kronenfeld BJ, Wang Y-C, Larsen CPS (2010) The influence of the “mixed pixel” problem on the detection of analogous forest communities between presettlement and present in Western New York. Prof Geogr 62:182–196
Leathwick JR, Elith J, Hastie T (2006) Comparative performance of generalized additive models and multivariate adaptive regression splines for statistical modelling of species distributions. Ecol Model 199:188–196
Manies KL, Mladenoff DJ, Nordheim EV (2001) Assessing large-scale surveyor variability in the historic forest data of the original US Public Land Survey. Can J For Res 31:1719–1730
Morisette JT, Jarnevich CS, Holcombe TR, Talbert CB, Ignizio D, Talbert MK, Silva C, Koop D, Swanson A, Young NE (2013) VisTrails SAHM: visualization and workflow management for species habitat modeling. Ecography 36:129–135
Moudry V, Simova P (2012) Influence of positional accuracy, sample size and scale on modelling species distributions: a review. Int J Geogr Inf Sci 26:2083–2095
Naimi B, Skidmore AK, Groen TA, Hamm NAS (2011) Spatial autocorrelation in predictors reduces the impact of positional uncertainty in occurrence data on species distribution modelling. J Biogeogr 38:1497–1509
Natural Resources Conservation Service (2013) Geospatial data gateway. United States Department of Agriculture, San Marcos
Natural Resources Conservation Service (2014) Description of SSURGO database. United States Department of Agriculture, San Marcos
NYS ITS GIS Program Office (2013) NYSGIS Clearinghouse
Osborne PE, Leitao PJ (2009) Effects of species and habitat positional errors on the performance and interpretation of species distribution models. Divers Distrib 15:671–681
Peterson AT, Soberón J (2012) Integrating fundamental concepts of ecology, biogeography, and sampling into effective ecological niche modeling and species distribution modeling. Plant Biosyst 146:789–796
PRISM Climate Group (2013) Gridded climate data for the contiguous USA. Northwest Alliance for Computational Science & Engineering, Oregon State University, http://www.prism.oregonstate.edu/
Robillard WG, Wilson DA, Brown CM (2009) Brown’s boundary control and legal principles. Wiley, Hoboken
Segurado P, Araujo MB (2004) An evaluation of methods for modelling species distributions. J Biogeogr 31:1555–1568
Shi W (2009) Principles of modeling uncertainties in spatial data and spatial analyses. CRC Press/Taylor & Francis, Boca Raton
Thrower NJW (1966) Original survey and land subdivision: a comparative study of the form and effect of contrasting cadastral surveys. Published for the association of American Geographers by Rand McNally, Chicago
Tulowiecki SJ (2014) Using vegetation data within presettlement land survey records for species distribution modeling: a tale of two datasets. Ecol Model 291:109–120
USGS (2013) The National Map Viewer and download platform. United States Department of the Interior, http://nationalmap.gov/viewer.html
Viera AJ, Garrett JM (2005) Understanding interobserver agreement: the kappa statistic. Fam Med 37:360–363
Wang Y-C (2005) Presettlement land survey records of vegetation: geographic characteristics, quality and modes of analysis. Prog Phys Geogr 29:568–598
Wang Y-C (2007) Spatial patterns and vegetation-site relationships of the presettlement forests in western New York USA. J Biogeogr 34:500–513
Wang Y-C, Kronenfeld BJ, Larsen CPS (2009) Spatial distribution of forest landscape change in Western New York from presettlement to the present. Can J For Res 39:76–88
White CA (1983) A history of the rectangular survey system. U.S. Dept. of the Interior Bureau of Land Management, Washington
Whitney GG (1996) From coastal wilderness to fruited plain: a history of environmental change in temperate North America, 1500 to the present. Cambridge University Press, New York
Wyckoff W (1988) The developer’s frontier: the making of the western New York landscape. Yale University Press, New Haven
Young SM (2010) New York Rare Plant Status Lists. New York Natural Heritage Program, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, Albany
Acknowledgments
This study received funding support from the University at Buffalo’s Hugh W. Calkins Applied GIS Award. The authors wish to thank four anonymous reviewers, whose comments helped to improve an earlier version of this research paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by J. P. Messina.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Tulowiecki, S.J., Larsen, C.P.S. & Wang, YC. Effects of positional error on modeling species distributions: a perspective using presettlement land survey records. Plant Ecol 216, 67–85 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11258-014-0417-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11258-014-0417-9