Abstract
This paper deconstructs the ambitious claims made on behalf of the ability of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to empower adults with Down syndrome living in the parental home to take control over their sexuality. As a philosophical investigation into the subject matter at hand the method chosen to highlight the tension between moral and legal rights is that of the thought experiment. This pre-empts Ireland’s ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to construct a scenario where adults with Down syndrome in the parental home are granted legal capacity, and by extension the legal right to control their own sexuality. But how does this status fare when it comes into conflict against the perceived ‘moral right’ of the parent to prohibit their adult children from actualizing such legal rights? Arguably legal rights are effectively powerless in ensuring the legal right of adults with Down syndrome to control their own sexuality can be realised in the face of parental prohibitions. However, while the treaty is limited in its capacity to overcome the real world obstacles identified, this is not to suggest that it is impotent to effect changes when it comes to the issue of sexual empowerment for adults with Down syndrome. In addition to its discursive power, the treaty also provides the much needed impetus which will, once it becomes a part of Irish domestic legislation, see current Irish law which discriminates against the right of adults with intellectual disabilities to express their sexuality overhauled.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Goffman, E.: Stigma: Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity. Penguin Books, London (1990)
Shildrick, M.: Dangerous Discourses of Disability, Subjectivity and Sexuality. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke (2009)
Shildrick, M.: Silencing sexuality: the regulation of the disabled body. In: Carabine, J. (ed.) Sexualities: Personal Lives and Social Policy, pp. 123–158. The Open University, Milton Keynes (2004)
Shildrick, M.: Embodying the Monster: Encounters with the Vulnerable Self. Sage, London (2002)
Buckley, S.: Issues for Families with Children with Down Syndrome. Down Syndrome Educational Trust, Southsea (2002)
Brown, R.: Life for Adults with Down syndrome: An Overview. Down Syndrome Educational Trust, Southsea (2004)
Selikowitz, M.: Down Syndrome. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2008)
Bacik, I.: Kicking and Screaming. The O’Brien Press Ltd, Dublin (2004)
Kelly, F., Kelly, C., Craig, S.: HRB Statistics Series: Annual Report of the National Intellectual Disability Database Committee. Health Research Board, Dublin (2007)
McConkey, R., Mulvany, F., Barron, S.: Adult persons with an intellectual disability on the island of Ireland. J. Intellect. Disabil. Res. 50, 227–230 (2006)
Cunningham, C.: Down Syndrome. Souvenir Press, London (2006)
Gates, B.: The nature of learning disabilities. In: Gates, B. (ed.) Learning Disabilities Toward Inclusion, pp. 3–20. Elsevier, London (2007)
Stratford, B.: Down’s Syndrome. Penguin, London (1989)
Oliver, M.: Understanding Disability: From Theory to Practice. Macmillan, Basingtoke (1996)
Wolfensbeger, W.: Social role valorization: a proposed new term for the principle of normalization. Ment. Retard. 21(6), 234–239 (1983)
Wright, D.: Downs: The History of a Disability. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2011)
Freeman, M.: Human Rights. Polity Press, Cambridge (2011)
Keywood, K.: Supported to be sexual? Developing sexual rights for people with learning disabilities. Tizard Learn. Disab. Rev. 8(3), 30–36 (2003)
Löfgren-Mårtenson, L.: May I?’ About sexuality and love in the new generation with intellectual disabilities. Sex. Disabil. 22, 197–207 (2004)
Newton, R.: The Down Syndrome Handbook. Random House, London (2004)
Shakespeare, T.: Disability Rights and Wrongs. Routledge, London (2006)
Shakespeare, T.: Disabled sexuality: toward rights and recognition. Sex. Disabil. 18(3), 159–166 (2000)
Namhi: Who decides and how? People with intellectual disabilities-legal capacity and decision-making. Inclusion Ireland, Dublin (2003)
O’Callaghan, A.C., Murphy, G.H.: Sexual relationship in adults with intellectual disabilities: understanding the law. J. Intellect. Disabil. Res. 51, 197–206 (2007)
Watson, S., Venema, T., Molloy, T., Reich, M.: Sexual rights and individuals who have a developmental disability. In: Griffiths, D., Richards, D., Fedoroff, P., Watson, S. (eds.) Ethical Dilemmas: Sexuality and Developmental Disability, pp. 19–52. NADD Press, New York (2002)
Inglis, T.: Lessons in Irish Sexuality. UCD Press, Dublin (1998)
Shildrick, M.: Dangerous discourses: anxiety. Desire Disabil. Stud. Gend. Sex. 8(3), 221–244 (2007)
Weeks, J.: Sexuality and its Discontents. Routledge, London (1985)
Burton-Smith, R., Morgan, M.J., Davidson, J.A.: Does the daily choice making of adults with intellectual disability meet the normalisation principle?’. J. Intellect. Dev. Disabil. 30(4), 226–235 (2005)
May, D., Simpson, M.K.: The parent trap: marriage, parenthood and adulthood for people with intellectual disabilities. Crit. Soc. Pol. 23(1), 25–43 (2003)
McClimens, A.: Like a virgin? Learn. Disabil. Pract. 12(4), 10 (2009)
Velde, B., Emes, C.: Recreation and Adults with Down syndrome. Down Syndrome Educational Trust, Southsea (2006)
Baron, S., Riddell, S., Wilson, A.: The secret of eternal youth: identity, risk and learning difficulties. Brit. J. Sociol. 20, 483–499 (1999)
Cuskelly, M., Brown, I., Shearer, J., Singh, B.: Families of Adults with Down syndrome. Down Syndrome Educational Trust, Southsea (2006)
Evans, A., Rodgers, M.E.: Protection for whom? The right to a sexual or intimate relationship. J. Intellect. Disabil. 4, 237–245 (2000)
Knox, M.: Family control: the views of families who have a child with an intellectual disability. J. Appl. Res. Intellect. Disabil. 13, 17–28 (2000)
Jobling, A., Cuskelly, M.: Life styles of adults with Down syndrome living at home. In: Cuskelly, M., Jobling, A., Buckley, S. (eds.) Down Syndrome Across the Life Span, pp. 109–120. Wiley, London (2002)
Oakes, P.: Sexual and personal relationships. In: Gates, B. (ed.) Learning Disabilities: Toward Inclusion. Elsevier, London (2007)
Johnson, K., Walmsley, J., Wolfe, M.: People with Intellectual Disabilities: Towards a Good Life. The Policy Press, Bristol (2010)
Law Reform Commission: Consultation paper on vulnerable adults and the law in relation to capacity. The Law Reform Commission, Dublin (2005)
Namhi: Who decides and how? People with intellectual disabilities-legal capacity and decision-making. Dublin, Inclusion Ireland (2003)
Inclusion Ireland: People with an intellectual disability do not have clear rights to make decisions—law must be updated. http://www.inclusionireland.ie/topics_capacity.asp (2009). Accessed 3rd June 2012
NDA submission on capacity and sexual relations in the context of the mental capacity scheme of bill. http://www.nda.ie (2009). Accessed 12th June 2012
Quinn, G.: Bringing the UN convention on rights for persons with disabilities to life in Ireland. Br. J. Learn. Disabil. 37, 245–249 (2009)
Quinn, G.: Personhood & Legal Capacity: Perspectives on the Paradigm Shift of Article 12 CRPD. Inclusion Ireland Website. http://www.inclusionireland.ie/topics_capacity.asp (2010). Accessed 4th June 2012
Quinn, G.: An Ideas Paper, Seminar on Legal Capacity. Inclusion Ireland Website. http://www.inclusionireland.ie/topics_capacity.asp (2009). Accessed 4th June 2012
Edwards, J.: Sexuality, marriage and parenting for persons with Down syndrome. In: Pueschel, S.M. (ed.) The Young Person with Down Syndrome, pp. 187–204. Brooks, Baltimore (1988)
Carr, J.: The everyday life of adults with Down syndrome. J. Appl. Res. Intellect. Disabil. 21(5), 389–397 (2008)
Hamilton, C.A.: ‘Now I’d like to sleep with Rachael’—researching sexuality support in a service agency group home. Disabil. Soc. 24(3), 303–315 (2009)
Kelly, G., Hamilton, C., Crowley, H.: Rights, sexuality and relationships in Ireland: it’d be nice to be kind of trusted. Br. J. Learn. Disabil. 37, 308–315 (2009)
Priestly, M.: Disability: A Life Course Approach. Polity Press, London (2003)
Valenti-Hein, D., & Choinski, C.: Relationships and sexuality in adolescence and young adulthood. In: Carr, A., O’Reily, G., Noonan Walsh, P., McEvoy, J. (eds.) The Handbook of Intellectual Disability and Clinical Psychology Practice, pp. 729–756. Routledge, London (2007)
Carr, J.: Intellectual and daily living skills of 30-year-olds with Down syndrome: continuation of a longitudinal study. J. Appl. Res. Intellect. Disabil. 13, 1–16 (2000)
Craft, A.: Mental Handicap and Sexuality: Issues and Perspectives. Costello, London (1987)
Cuskelly, M., Bryde, R.: Attitudes towards the sexuality of adults with an intellectual disability: parents, support staff, and a community sample. J. Intellect. Dev. Disabil. 29, 255–264 (2004)
Docherty, J., Reid, J.: What’s the next stage? Mothers of young adults with down syndrome explore the path to independence: a qualitative investigation. J. Appl. Res. Intellect. Disabil. 22(5), 458–467 (2009)
Evans, D.S., McGuire, B.E., Carley, S.N.: Sexuality and personal relationships for people with an intellectual disability. Part II: staff and family carer perspectives. J. Intellect. Disabil. Res. 53, 913–921 (2009)
Jobling, A., Moni, K.B., Nolan, A.: Understanding friendship: young adults with Down syndrome exploring relationships. J. Intellect. Dev. Disabil. 25(3), 235–245 (2000)
May, D.: Becoming adult: school-leaving, jobs and the transition to adult life. In: May, D. (ed.) Transition and Change in the Lives of People with Intellectual Disabilities, pp. 78–96. Jessica Kingsley, London (2000)
Oakes, P.: Sexual and personal relationships. In: Gates, B. (ed.) Learning Disabilities: Toward Inclusion, pp. 549–567. Elsevier, London (2007)
Walmsley, J.: Doing what mum wants me to do: looking at family relationships from the point of view of adults with intellectual disability. J. Appl. Res. Intellect. Disabil. 9(4), 324–341 (1996)
Williams, V., Robinson, C.: More than one wavelength: identifying, understanding and resolving conflicts of interest between people with intellectual disabilities and their family carers. J. Appl. Res. Intellect. Disabil. 14, 30–46 (2001)
Lesseliers, J.: A right to sexuality? Br. J. Learn. Disabil. 27, 137–140 (1999)
Griffiths, D.: Sexuality and people who have intellectual disabilities. In: Brown, I., Percy, M. (eds.) A Comprehensive Guide to Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, pp. 432–462. Paul H. Brooks Publishing Co, Baltimore (2007)
Murphy, G.: Capacity to consent to sexual relationships in adults with learning disabilities. Br. J. Fam. Plann. 29, 148–149 (2003)
Royston, A.: Down Syndrome. Heinemann Library, Oxford (2005)
Barron, S., McConkey, R., Mulvany, F.: Family carers of adult persons with intellectual disabilities on the island of Ireland. JPPID 3, 87–89 (2006)
Murphy, G.: Intellectual disability, sexual abuse, and sexual offending. In: Carr, A., O’ Reily, G., Walsh, P.N., Mcevoy, J. (eds.) The Handbook of Intellectual Disability and Clinical Psychology Practice, pp. 831–866. Routledge, London (2007)
Schwier, K.M.: Self before sex: perspectives on support, self-esteem and sexuality. In: Pueschel, S.M. (ed.) Adults with Down syndrome, pp. 105–127. Brookes Publishing, Baltimore (2006)
NDA: NDA submission on capacity and sexual relations in the context of the mental capacity scheme of bill. http://www.nda.ie (2009). Accessed 12 June 2012
Caffrey, S.: Adult relationships and sexuality. In: Noonan Walsh, P., Gash, H. (eds.) Lives and Times: Practice, Policy and People with Disabilities, pp. 93–122. Rathdown Press, Wicklow (2004)
Bickenbach, J.: Disability, human rights, law, and policy. In: Albrecht, G., Seelman, K., Bury, M. (eds.) Handbook of Disability Studies, pp. 565–584. Sage Publications, London (2001)
Griffin, J.: On Human Rights. Oxford University Press, Oxford (2008)
Mackie, J.L.: Ethics. Penguin, London (1977)
Wittgenstein, L.: Philosophical Investigations. Blackwell, Oxford (1953)
Nickel, J.: Making Sense of Human Rights. University of California Press, Berkeley (1987)
Nagel, T.: The View from Nowhere. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1989)
Rubin, G.: Thinking sex. In: Vance, C.S. (ed.) Pleasure and Danger: Exploring Female Sexuality, pp. 143–178. Routledge, London (1985)
Singer, P.: Practical Ethics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2005)
Young, D., Quibell, R.: Why rights are never enough: rights, intellectual disability and understanding. Disabil. Soc. 15(5), 747–764 (2000)
Nietzsche, F.: Daybreak. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1982)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Foley, S. The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: A Paradigm Shift in the Sexual Empowerment of Adults with Down Syndrome or More Sound and Fury Signifying Nothing?. Sex Disabil 30, 381–393 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11195-012-9279-z
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11195-012-9279-z