Abstract
This paper addresses a curious disjuncture between one aspect of regional development theory and the empiricism required to test its implications.On the one hand, researchers long have argued that firm births fuel the growth and development of regional economies. Just as long, however, they have employed different, often ad hoc, approaches to the definition and measurement of key concepts and relationships. The inconsistency among the studies in this literature creates a validity problem. We begin by providing an omnibus definition of a start-up that applies to some degree to all the articles we reviewed, namely, that it is new, active, and independent. We explain why all three criteria should be applied, rather than a subset. Second, we review the data sources that are commonly used to identify start-ups, and compare them using seven criteria. We conclude that ES202 data is the best source. Third, we develop a step-by-step tracking system for identifying new firms. By matching ES202 files from two different years and applying direct enumeration techniques, it is possible to identify newly created establish-ments during that time period with accuracy. This article serves both to explain the differences among the published studies of new firms and economic development, and to provide a common standard that can enhance the validity of future work on the topic.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aldrich, H.E., J. Cater, T. Jones, D. McEvoy and P.Velleman, 1985, ‘Ethnic Residential Concentration and the Protected Market Hypothesis’, Social Forces 63, 996–1009.
Bergman, E., E. Feser and S. Sweeny, 1996, ‘Targeting North Carolina Manufacturing: Understanding the State’s Economy Through Industrial Cluster Analysis.’ Institute fore Economic Development. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
Birch, D.L., 1981, ‘Who Creates Jobs?’, The Public Interest 65, 3–14.
Birch, D.L., 1983, Share of Jobs vs. Share of Job Creation: A Flow Analysis. Cambridge, MA.
Birley, S., 1984, Finding the New Firm. Academy of Management Proceedings, 44th Annual Meetings, pp. 64–68.
Buss, T.F., X. Lin. and M.G. Popovich, 1991, ‘Locating New Firms in Local Economies: A Comparison of Sampling Procedures in Rural Iowa’, Journal of Economic and Social Measurement 17, 45–55.
Deutsch, L., 1975, ‘Structure, Performance, and the Net Rate of Entry into Manufacturing Industry’, Southern Economic Journal 41, 450–456.
Davidsson, P., L. Lindmark and C. Olofsson, 1994, ‘New Firm Formation and Regional Development in Sweden’, Regional Studies 28, 395–410.
Dunne, T. and M.J. Roberts, 1986, Measuring Firm Entry and Exit with Census of Manufactures Data. Department of Economics, Pennsylvania State University.
Dunne, T., M.J. Roberts and L. Samuelson, 1988, ‘Patterns of Firm Entry and Exit in U.S.Manufacturing Industries’, RAND Journal of Economics 19 (4), 495–515.
Garvin, D.A., 1983, ‘Spin-offs and the New Firm Formation Process’, California Management Review 2, 3–20.
Garofoli, G., 1994, ‘New Firm Formation and Regional Development: The Italian Case’, Regional Studies 28, 381–393.
Gorecki, P.K., 1976, ‘The Determinants of Entry by Domestic and Foreign Enterprises in Canadian Manufacturing Industries: Some Comments and Empirical Results’, Review of Economics and Statistics 58, 485–488.
Hadden, T., 1977, Company Law and Capitalism. London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson.
Harris, C.S., 1983, Small Business and Job Generation: A Changing Economy or Differing Methodologies? U.S. Small Business Administration.
Hart, M. and G. Gudgin, 1994, ‘Spatial Variations in New Firm Formation in the Republic of Ireland, 1980–1990’, Regional Studies 28, 367–380.
Highfield, R. and R. Smiley, 1987, ‘New Business Starts and Economic Activity: An Empirical Investigation’, International Journal of Industrial Organization 5, 51–66.
Jacobson, L., 1987, Texas Duns-UI Comparability Analysis- Phase II. Kalamazoo, Michigan: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.
Johnson, P.S., 1978, ‘New Firms and Regional Development: Some Issues and Evidence.’ Center for Urban and Regional Development Studies. Univ. of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Disc. Paper 11.
Johnson, P.S. and D.G. Cathcart, 1979, ‘New Manufacturing Firms and Regional Development:Some Evidence from the Northern Region’, Regional Studies 13, 269–280.
Kalleberg, A.L., P.V. Marsden, H.E. Aldrich and J.W. Cassell, 1990, ‘Comparing Organizational Sampling Frames’, Administrative Science Quarterly 35, 658–688.
Keeble, D., 1976, Industrial Location and Planning in the United Kingdom. London.
Keeble, D. and S. Walker, 1994, ‘New Firms,Small Firms and Dead Firms: Spatial Patterns and Determinants in the U.K.’, Regional Studies 28, 411–427.
Kirchkoff, B. and B. Phillips, 1988, ‘The Effect of Firm Formation and Growth on Job Creation in the U.S.’, Journal of Business Venturing 3, 361–372.
Ko, S., 1993, The Incidence of High-Technology Start-Ups and Spin-Offs in a Technology Oriented Branch Plant Complex: A Case of Research Triangle Region. University of North Carolina.
Mason, C., 1982, New Manufacturing Firms in South Hampshire:Survey Results. Discussion Paper 13. Department of Geography,University of Southamton.
Mason, C., 1983, ‘Some Definitional Difficulties in New Firms Research’, Area 15, 53–60.
Mason, C., 1989, ‘Explaining Recent Trends in New Firm Formation in the U.K.: Some Evidence from South Hampshire’, Regional Studies 23, 331–346.
McGuckin, R., 1972, ‘Entry,Concentration Change,and Stability of Market Share’, Southern Economic Journal 38, 363–370.
Morkry, B., 1988, Entrepreneurship and Public Policy. New York: Quorum Books.
Reynolds, P., S. West and M. Finch, 1985, ‘Estimating New Firms and New Jobs: Considerations in Using the Dun and Bradstreet Files’, Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research 1985, 384–399.
Reynolds, P. and B. Miller, 1988, 1987 Minnesota New Firms Study:An Exploration of New Firms and Their Economic Contributions. Center for Urban and Regional Affairs: MN.
Reynolds, P., 1994, ‘Autonomous Firm Dynamics and Economic Growth in the United States,1986–1990’, Regional Studies 28, 429–442.
Reynolds, P. and W.R. Maki, 1990, Business Volatility and Economic Growth. Project Report prepared for the U.S. Small Business Administration.
Reynolds, P., B. Miller and W.R. Maki, 1995, ‘Explaining Regional Variation in Business Births and Deaths: U.S. 1976–88’, Small Business Economics 7, 389–407.
Scott, M.G., 1980, Mythology and Misplaced Pessimism:A Look at the Failure Record of New Small Businesses. Paper to UKSBMTA 3rd annual conference.
Schumpeter, J., 1934, The Theory of Economic Development. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
White, S.B., J.F. Zipp, W.F. McMahon, P.D. Reynolds, J.D. Osterman and L.S. Binkley, 1990, ‘ES202: The Database for Local Employment Analysis’, Economic Development Quarterly 4, 240–253.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Luger, M.I., Koo, J. Defining and Tracking Business Start-Ups. Small Bus Econ 24, 17–28 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-005-8598-1
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-005-8598-1