A more dangerous enemy? Philo’s “confession” and Hume’s soft atheism
- Benjamin S. Cordry
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
While Hume has often been held to have been an agnostic or atheist, several contemporary scholars have argued that Hume was a theist. These interpretations depend chiefly on several passages in which Hume allegedly confesses to theism. In this paper, I argue against this position by giving a threshold characterization of theism and using it to show that Hume does not confess. His most important “confession” does not cross this threshold and the ones that do are often expressive rather than assertive. I then argue that Hume is best interpreted as an atheist. Instead of interpreting Hume as a proto-logical positivist and arguing on the basis of Hume’s theories of meaning and method, I show that textually he appears to align himself with atheism, that his arguments in the Dialogues on Natural Religion support atheism, and that this position is most consistent with Hume’s naturalism. But, I hold that his atheism is “soft” and therefore distinct from that of his peers like Baron d’Holbach—while Hume really does reject theism, he neither embraces a dogmatically materialist position nor takes up a purely polemical stance towards theism. I conclude by suggesting several ways in which Hume’s atheistic philosophy of religion is relevant to contemporary discussions.
- Andre, S. (1993) Was Hume an atheist?. Hume Studies 19: pp. 141-166 CrossRef
- Buckle, S. (2007) Hume’s skeptical materialism. The Journal of Philosophy 82: pp. 553-578
- Capaldi, N. (1970) Hume’s philosophy of religion: God without ethics. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 1: pp. 233-240 CrossRef
- Clark, S. (2009) No abiding city: Hume, naturalism, and toleration. The Journal of Philosophy 84: pp. 75-94 CrossRef
- Costelloe, T. M. (2004) ‘In every civilized community’: Hume on belief and the demise of religion. International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 55: pp. 171-185 CrossRef
- Gaskin, J. C. A. (1988) Hume’s philosophy of religion. Humanities Press International, Atlantic Highlands, NJ
- Gaskin, J. C. A. (2008) Hume’s critique of religion. Journal of the History of Philosophy 14: pp. 301-311
- Hume, D. (1969). In E. C. Mossner (Ed.), A treatise of human nature. London: Penguin.
- Hume, D. (1947). In Kemp Smith (Ed.), Dialogues concerning natural religion (2nd ed.). Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill.
- Hume, D. (1992). In J. Fieser (Ed.), The natural history of religion. New York, NY: Macmillan.
- Hume, D. (1999). In T. L. Beauchamp (Ed.), An enquiry concerning human understanding. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
- Logan, B. (1992) The irregular argument in Hume’s Dialogues. Hume Studies 18: pp. 483-500 CrossRef
- Logan, B. (1993) A religion without talking. Peter Long Publishing, New York, NY
- Logan, B. (1996) Why Hume wasn’t an atheist: A reply to Andre. Hume Studies 22: pp. 193-202 CrossRef
- McEwen, B. (1907). Introduction to Dialogues concerning natural religion. Reprinted in S. Tweyman (Ed.) (1996), Hume on natural religion. Bristol: Thoemmes Press.
- Mossner, E. C. (1954) The life of David Hume. University of Texas Press, Austin
- Nelson, J. O. (1988) The role of part XII in Hume’s Dialogues concerning natural religion. Hume Studies 14: pp. 347-371 CrossRef
- Noxon, J. (1996). Hume’s agnosticism. Reprinted in V. C. Chappell (Ed.), Hume. Garden City, NY: Anchor Books.
- Noxon, J. (2008) In defense of ‘Hume’s agnosticism’. Journal of the History of Philosophy 14: pp. 469-473
- Parent, W. A. (1976) Philo’s confession. The Philosophical Quarterly 26: pp. 63-68 CrossRef
- Penelhum, T. (1983) Natural belief and religious belief in Hume’s philosophy. The Philosophical Quarterly 33: pp. 166-181 CrossRef
- Pike N. (1985) Hume on the argument from design. In: Pike N. (eds) Hume: Dialogues concerning natural religion. Macmillan, New York, NY
- Priestley, J. (1780). Letter 9: An examination of Mr. Hume’s Dialogues on natural religion. Reprinted in S. Tweyman (Ed.) (1996), Hume on natural religion. Bristol: Thoemmes Press.
- Tweyman, S. Natural belief and belief in an intelligent designer of the world. In: Tweyman, S. eds. (1996) Essays on the philosophy of David Hume. Caravan Books, Delmar, NY
- Yandell, K. E. Hume on religious belief. In: Livingston, D. W., King, J. T. eds. (1977) Hume: A re-evaluation. Fordham University Press, New York, NY
- Yoder, T. S. (2008) Hume on God. Continuum International Publishing Group, New York, NY
- A more dangerous enemy? Philo’s “confession” and Hume’s soft atheism
International Journal for Philosophy of Religion
Volume 70, Issue 1 , pp 61-83
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Soft atheism
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Division of Arts and Humanities, Lorain County Community College, Stocker Center 238, 1005 N. Abbe Rd., Elyria, OH, 44035, USA