Abstract
This study proposes a multi-criteria decision support methodology to enable the prioritization of potential alternative transportation system operations strategies and then demonstrates the effectiveness of the methodology using a case study involving truck operations. The primary feature of this methodology is its ability to help policymakers consider economic, public, and private sector standpoints simultaneously. The economic criterion is cost to the public sector where four criteria related to truck impacts on the transportation system are incorporated. These are traffic congestion, safety hazards, air pollution, and pavement damage. In addition, reliability and productivity are regarded as metrics representing the private sector viewpoint since they can significantly affect profitability. The methodology combines qualitative and quantitative aspects of these standpoints. In order to demonstrate the applicability of this methodology, a corridor with some of the highest truck traffic in the US is selected as a case study and three forms of left lane restrictions for trucks are considered. For qualitative analysis, survey data were collected from two groups classified as public agency and transportation industry professionals who are experts in trucking. In addition, a micro traffic simulation model was used to produce various performance measurements that can describe quantitative impacts. As a result, the methodology provides a rational argument for prioritizing potential alternative truck strategies.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Barth, M.J., Scora, G., Younglove, T.: Modal emissions model for heavy-duty diesel vehicles. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 1880, 10–20 (2005)
Bhushan, N., Rai, K.: Strategic Decision Making: Applying the Analytical Hierarchy Process. Springer, Berlin (2004)
Caltrans: Truck Data for the Year 2006. California Department of Transportation (2006)
Federal Highway Administration: Benefit-Cost Analysis of Freight Investments (2003)
Fischer, M.J., Ahanote, D.N.: Planning truck-only lanes. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 1833, 73–78 (2003)
Fitzpatrick, K., Middleton, D., Jasek, D.: Countermeasures for truck accidents on urban freeways: a review of experiences. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 1376, 27–30 (1992)
Fontaine, M.D., Torrance, K.: Evaluation of Truck Lane Restrictions in Virginia. Virginia Transportation Research Council, Virginia Department of Transportation, VTRC 07-CR11 (2007)
Fontaine, M.D., Bhamidipati, C.S., Dougald, L.E.: Safety impact of truck lane restrictions on multilane freeways. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 2096, 25–32 (2009)
Garber, N.J., Gadiraju, R.: Effects of truck strategies on traffic flow and safety on multilane highways. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 1256, 49–54 (1990)
Hoel, L.A., Peek, J.L.: A Simulation Analysis of Traffic Flow Elements for Restricted Lanes on Interstate Highway in Virginia. Virginia Department of Transportation (1999)
Holguin-Veras, J.: Comparative assessment of AHP and MAV in highway planning: case study. J. Transp. Eng. 121(2), 191–200 (1995)
Kim, K., Vince, B.: Application of an analytical hierarchy process at the Indiana department of transportation for prioritizing major highway capital investments. In: Proceedings of the 7th TRB Conference on the Application of Transportation Planning Methods, pp. 266–278 (2000)
Kirkwood, C.W.: Strategic Decision Making: Multiobjective Decision Analysis with Spreadsheets. Brooks/Cole Cengage learning. Duxbury Press, Pacific Grove (1996)
Mannering, F.L., Koehne, J.L., Araucto, J.: Truck Restriction Evaluations: The Puget Sound Experience. Washington State Transportation Center, University of Washington, Seattle (1993)
Mashrur, A., Paulin, T., Surekha, L.: An Interactive Multi-Objective Decision Support Framework for Transportation Investment. Midwest Regional University Transportation Center University of Wisconsin, Madison (2002)
MTC: Regional Transportation Plan. Metropolitan Transportation Commission (2001). www.mtc.gov/library/2001 rtp/project_notebook.htm
NCHRP: National Cooperative Highway Research Program Synthesis, vol. 314: Strategies for Managing Increasing Truck Traffic. Transportation Research Board (2003)
PeMS: Freeway Performance Measurement System (2003). www.pems.eecs.berkeley.edu/Public/
Quadstone: PARAMICS User Manual V5.1 Modeller User Guide. Quadstone Ltd. (2005)
Rakha, H., Flintsch, A., Ahn, M.K., El-Shawarby, I., Arafeh, M.: Evaluating alternative truck management strategies along interstate 81. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 1925, 276–287 (2005)
Ren R.: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Various Truck Lane Restriction Practices in Florida-Phase II. FAMU-FSU College of Engineering, Report, BD 543 RPWO 10 (2007)
Saaty, T., Vargas, L.: The Logic of Priorities: Application in Business, Energy, Health, and Transportation. Springer-Verlag, New York (1981)
Saaty, T.: Multicriteria Decision Making, vol. 1: The Analytical Hierarchy Process—Planning, Priority Setting, Resource Allocation. University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh (1990)
Sohn, K.: A systematic decision criterion for the elimination of useless overpasses. Transp. Res. Part A 42(8), 1043–1055 (2008)
Tanadtang, P., Park, D., Hanaoka, S.: Incorporating uncertain and incomplete subjective judgments into the evaluation procedure of transportation demand management alternatives. Transportation 32(6), 603–626 (2005)
Texas Transportation Institute: Selecting Travel Reliability Measures (2003)
TRB: Quantifying congestion, vol. 1 Final Report. National Cooperative Highway Research Program Report 398. Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC (1997)
TRB: Twin Trailer Trucks: Special Report 211. Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC (1986)
Tudela, A., Akiki, N., Cisternas, R.: Comparing the output of cost-benefit and multi-criteria analysis an application to urban transport investments. Transp. Res. Part A 40(5), 414–423 (2006)
Zavoina, M.C., Urbanik II, T., Hinshaw, W.: Operational evaluation of truck restrictions on I-20 in Texas. Transp. Res. Rec. J. Transp. Res. Board 1320, 24–31 (1991)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Yang, C.H., Regan, A.C. A multi-criteria decision support methodology for implementing truck operation strategies. Transportation 40, 713–728 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-012-9432-7
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11116-012-9432-7