Dispositions and interferences
- Gabriele Contessa
- … show all 1 hide
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
The Simple Counterfactual Analysis (SCA) was once considered the most promising analysis of disposition ascriptions. According to SCA, disposition ascriptions are to be analyzed in terms of counterfactual conditionals. In the last few decades, however, SCA has become the target of a battery of counterexamples. In all counterexamples, something seems to be interfering with a certain object’s having or not having a certain disposition thus making the truth-values of the disposition ascription and of its associated counterfactual come apart. Intuitively, however, it would seem that, if all interferences were absent, the disposition ascription and its associated conditional would have the same truth-value. Although this idea may seem obvious, it is far from obvious how to implement it. In fact, it has become widely assumed that the content of qualifying ceteris paribus clauses (such as ‘if all interferences were absent’) cannot be specified in a clear and non-circular manner. In this paper, I will argue that this assumption is wrong. I will develop an analysis of disposition ascriptions, the Interference-Free Counterfactual Analysis, which relies on a clear and non-circular definition of the notion of interference and avoids the standard counterexamples to SCA while vindicating the intuition that disposition ascriptions and counterfactual conditionals are intimately related.
- Ashwell, L. (2010). Superficial dispositionalism. Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 88(4), 635–653. CrossRef
- Bird, A. (1998). Dispositions and antidotes. The Philosophical Quarterly, 48, 227–234. CrossRef
- Bird, A. (2008). Nature’s metaphysics: Laws and properties. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Choi, S. (2008). Dispositional properties and counterfactual conditionals. Mind, 117, 795–841. CrossRef
- Clarke, R. (2008). Intrinsic finks. The Philosophical Quarterly, 58, 512–518. CrossRef
- Contessa, G. (forthcoming). Do extrinsic dispositions need extrinsic causal bases? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research.
- Fara, M. (2005). Dispositions and habituals. Noûs, 39, 43–82. CrossRef
- Gundersen, L. (2002). In defence of the conditional account of dispositions. Synthese, 130, 389–411. CrossRef
- Heil, J. (2003). From an ontological point of view. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef
- Humberstone, I. L. (1996). Intrinsic/extrinsic. Synthese, 108, 205–267. CrossRef
- Johnston, M. (1992). How to speak of the colors. Philosophical Studies, 68, 221–263. CrossRef
- Lewis, D. (1983). Extrinsic properties. Philosophical Studies, 44, 197–200. CrossRef
- Lewis, D. (1997). Finkish dispositions. The Philosophical Quarterly, 47, 143–158. CrossRef
- Malzkorn, W. (2000). Realism, functionalism and the conditional analysis of dispositions. The Philosophical Quarterly, 50, 452–469. CrossRef
- Manley, D., & Wasserman, R. (2008). On linking dispositions and conditionals. Mind, 117, 59–84. CrossRef
- Martin, C. B. (1994). Dispositions and conditionals. The Philosophical Quarterly, 44, 1–8. CrossRef
- Martin, C. B. (2008). The mind in nature. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- McKitrick, J. (2003). A case for extrinsic dispositions. Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 81, 155–174. CrossRef
- Mellor, D. H. (1974). In defense of dispositions. The Philosophical Review, 83, 157–181. CrossRef
- Quine, W.v. O. (1973). The roots of reference. LaSalle, IL: Open Court.
- Steinberg, J. R. (2010). Dispositions and subjunctives. Philosophical Studies, 48, 323–341. CrossRef
- Yablo, S. (1999). Intrinsicness. Philosophical Topics, 26, 479–505. CrossRef
- Dispositions and interferences
Volume 165, Issue 2 , pp 401-419
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Disposition ascriptions
- Intrinsic dispositions
- Extrinsic dispositions
- Ceteris paribus clauses
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Philosophy Department, Carleton University, PA 3A46, 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa, ON, Canada