Abstract
The main contribution of this paper is a novel account of ontological dependence. While dependence is often explained in terms of modality and existence, there are relations of dependence that slip through the mesh of such an account. Starting from an idea proposed by Jonathan Lowe, the article develops an account of ontological dependence based on a notion of explanation; on its basis, certain relations of dependence can be established that cannot be accounted by the modal-existential account. Dependence is only one of two main topics of this paper, for it is approached via a discussion of the category of substance. On a traditional view, substances can be characterised as independent entities. Before the background of a modal-existential account of dependence, this idea appears problematic. The proposed notion of explanatory dependence is shown to vindicate the traditional approach to substance.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aristotle (1991) ‘Categories’ J. Barnes (Eds) The Complete Works of Aristotle EditionNumber4 Princeton University Press Princeton, Guildford
Aristotle (1991) ‘Metaphysics’ J. Barnes (Eds) The Complete Works of Aristotle EditionNumber4 Princeton University Press Princeton, Guildford
Michael Ayers (1991) ArticleTitle‘Substance: Prolegomena to a Realist Theory of Identity’ Journal of Philosophy 88 69–90
Baumgarten, Alexander. (1779): Metaphysica (Reprinted: Hildesheim 1963)
Jonathan Bennett (1988) Events and Their Names Clarendon Press Oxford
Max Bordes (1998) ArticleTitle‘Abstract particulars in a four-dimensional frame’ Dialectica 52 3–12 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1746-8361.1998.tb00036.x
Campbell, Keith (1981): ‘The Metaphysics of Abstract Particulars’, in P. French et al. (eds.) (1981): The Foundations of Analytical Philosophy, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, (pp. 477–488), reprinted in D.H. Mellor & A. Oliver (eds.), (1997): Properties, (pp. 125–139), Oxford: Oxford University Press
Correia, Fabrice (2005): Existential Dependence and Cognate Notions, München: Philosophia Verlag
René Descartes (1985) ‘[1644]: Principia Philosophiae. Translation follows’ J. Cottingham D. Murdoch R. Stoothof (Eds) The Philosophical Writings of Descartes NumberInSeriesI Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Kit Fine (1994) ‘Essence and Modality’ J. Tomberlin (Eds) Logic and Language (Philosophical Perspectives 8) Ridgeview Atascadero 1–16
Kit Fine (1995a) ArticleTitle‘Ontological Dependence’ Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 95 269–290
Kit Fine (1995b) ‘Senses of Essence’ Walter Sinnott-Armstrong (Eds) Modality, Morality, and Belief University Press Cambridge 53–73
Joshua Hoffman Gary Rosenkrantz (1994) Substance Among Other Categories Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Joshua Hoffman Gary Rosenkrantz (1997) Substance – Its Nature and Existence Routledge London & New York
Ingvar Johansson (1989) Ontological Investigations Routledge London & New York
W.E. Johnson (1964) Logic (In Three Parts) I Dover publications New York
Jaegwon Kim (1973) ArticleTitle‘Causes and Counterfactuals’ Journal of Philosophy 70 570–572
Jaegwon Kim (1974) ArticleTitle‘Noncausal Connections’ Noûs 8 41–52
Wolfgang Künne (2003) Conceptions of Truth Clarendon Press Oxford
E.J. Lowe (1998) The Possibility of Metaphysics Clarendon Press Oxford
Peter Markie (1994) ‘Descartes’s Concepts of Substance’ John Cottingham (Eds) Reason, Will, and Sensation – Studies in Descartes’s Metaphysics Clarendon Press Oxford
Mill, John Stuart (1974): ‘A System of Logic’, in J.M. Robson (ed.), Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Vol. VII, University of Toronto Press
Kevin Mulligan Peter Simons Barry Smith (1984) ArticleTitle‘Truth-makers’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 44 287–320 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2107686
David Owens (1992) Causes and Coincidents University Press Cambridge
A.N. Prior (1971) Objects of Thought Clarendon Press Oxford
Augustin Rayo Stephen Yablo (2001) ArticleTitle‘Nominalism through De-nominalization’ Noûs 35 74–92
Richard Sharvy (1972) ArticleTitle‘Euthyphro 9d-11b: Analysis and Definition in Plato and Others’ Noûs 6 119–137
Peter Simons (1987) Parts Clarendon Press Oxford
Peter Simons (1994) ArticleTitle‘Particulars in Particular Clothing: Three Trope Theories of Substance’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 54 553–575 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2108581
Peter Simons (1998) ArticleTitle‘Farewell to Substance: A Differentiated Leave-Taking’ Ratio 11 235–252 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9329.00069
Ernest Sosa (1980) ArticleTitle‘Varieties of Causation’ Grazer Philosophische Studien 11 93–103
Spinoza, Baruch de (1677): ‘Ethica’, In C. Gebhart (ed.), Spinoza Opera II, Heidelberg 1925
Mark Steiner (1978) ArticleTitle‘Mathematical Explanation’ Philosophical Studies 34 135–151 Occurrence Handle10.1007/BF00354494
P.F. Strawson (1974) Subject and Predicate in Logic and Grammar Methuen & Co London
Amie L. Thomasson (1999) Fiction and Metaphysics Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Michael V. Wedin (2000) Aristotle’s Theory of Substance Oxford University Press Oxford
David Wiggins (1995) ‘Substance’ A.C. Grayling (Eds) Philosophy – A Guide Through the Subject University Press Oxford 214–249
Timothy Williamson (2000) ArticleTitle‘Existence and Contingency’ The Aristotelian Society Supp. Vol. 74 117–139 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1467-9264.00069
Nicholas Wolterstorff (1970) On Universals The University of Chicago Press Chicago & London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schnieder, B.S. A Certain Kind of Trinity: Dependence, Substance, Explanation. Philos Stud 129, 393–419 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-005-4636-8
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-005-4636-8