Abstract
Institutions are one of the decisive factors which enable, constrain and shape adaptation to the impacts of climate change, variability and extreme events. However, current understanding of institutions in adaptation situations is fragmented across the scientific community, evidence diverges, and cumulative learning beyond single studies is limited. This study adopts a diagnostic approach to elaborate a nuanced understanding of institutional barriers and opportunities in climate adaptation by means of a model-centred meta-analysis of 52 case studies of public climate adaptation in Europe. The first result is a novel taxonomy of institutional attributes in adaptation situations. It conceptually organises and decomposes the many details of institutions that empirical research has shown to shape climate adaptation. In the second step, the paper identifies archetypical patterns of institutional traps and trade-offs which hamper adaptation. Thirdly, corresponding opportunities are identified that enable actors to alleviate, prevent or overcome specific institutional traps or trade-offs. These results cast doubt on the validity of general institutional design principles for successful adaptation. In contrast to generic principles, the identified opportunities provide leverage to match institutions to specific governance problems that are encountered in specific contexts. Taken together, the results may contribute to more coherence and integration of adaptation research that we need if we are to foster learning about the role of institutions in adaptation situations in a cumulative fashion.
References
Adger WN, Arnell NW, Tompkins EL (2005) Successful adaptation to climate change across scales. Global Environ Chang 15:77–86
Agrawal A, Perrin N (2009) Climate adaptation, local institutions and rural livelihoods. In: Adger WN, Lorenzoni I, O’Brien KL (eds) Adapting to climate change: thresholds, values governance. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, pp 350–367
Amundsen H, Berglund F, Westskog H (2010) Overcoming barriers to climate change adaptation – a question of multilevel governance? Environ Plann C 28:276–289
Arnell NW, Delaney EK (2006) Adapting to climate change: public water supply in England and Wales. Clim Chang 78:228–255
Bergsma E, Gupta J, Jong P (2012) Does individual responsibility increase the adaptive capacity of society? The case of local water management in the Netherlands. Resour Conserv Recycl 64:13–22
Berrang-Ford L, Pearce T, Ford JD (2015) Systematic review approaches for climate change adaptation research. Reg Environ Chang 15(5):755–769
Biesbroek GR, Swart RK, Carter TR, Cowan C, Henrichs T, Mela H, Morecraft MD, Rey D (2010) Europe adapts to climate change: comparing national adaptation strategies. Global Environ Chang 20:440–450
Biesbroek GR, Termeer CJAM, Klostermann JEM, Kabat P (2014) Rethinking barriers to adaptation: mechanism-based explanation of impasses in the governance of an innovative adaptation measure. Global Environ Chang 26:108–118
Coleman EA (2011) Common property rights, adaptive capacity, and response to forest disturbance. Global Environ Chang 21:855–865
Corfee-Morlot J, Cochran I, Hallegatte S, Teasdale PJ (2011) Multilevel risk governance and urban adaptation policy. Clim Change 104:169–197
Cots F, Tàbara JD, McEvoy D, Werners S, Roca E (2009) Cross-border organizations as an adaptive water management response to climate change: the case of the Guadiana river basin. Environ Plann C 27:876–893
Cox M (2012) Diagnosing institutional fit: a formal perspective. Ecol Soc 17(4):54
Cox M, Arnold G, Villamayor-Tomás S (2010) A review of design principles for community-based natural resource management. Ecol Soc 15(4):38
Daniell KA, Manez Costa MA, Ferrand N, Kingsborough AB, Coad P, Ribarova IS (2011) Aiding multi-level decision-making processes for climate change mitigation and adaptation. Reg Environ Change 11:243–258
Demeritt D, Langdon D (2004) The UK Climate Change Programme and communication with local authorities. Global Environ Chang 14:325–336
Doria MF, Boyd E, Tompkins EL, Adger WN (2009) Using expert elicitation to define successful adaptation to climate change. Environ Sci Policy 12:810–819
Dovers SR, Hezri AA (2010) Institutions and policy processes: the means to the ends of adaptation. WIREs Clim Change 1:212–231
Dupuis J, Biesbroek GR (2013) Comparing apples and oranges: the dependent variable problem in comparing and evaluating climate change adaptation policies. Global Environ Chang 23:1476–1487
Eakin H, Eriksen S, Eikeland PO, Øyen C (2011) Public sector reform and governance for adaptation: implications of new public management for adaptive capacity in Mexico and Norway. Environ Manage 47:338–351
Ekstrom JA, Moser SC (2014) Identifying and overcoming barriers in urban adaptation efforts to climate change: case study findings from the San Francisco Bay Area, California, USA. Urban Clim 9:54–74
Eisenack K (2012) Archetypes of adaptation to climate change. In: Glaser M, Krause G, Ratter B, Welp M (eds) Human-nature interactions in the anthropocene: potentials of social-ecological systems analysis. Routledge, New York, pp 107–122
Eisenack K, Moser S, Hoffmann E, Klein RJT, Oberlack C, Pechan A, Rotter M, Termeer C (2014) Explaining and overcoming barriers to climate change adaptation. Nat Clim Chang 4:867–872
Eisenack K, Stecker R (2012) A framework for analyzing climate change adaptations as actions. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Chang 17(3):243–260
Engle NL, Lemos MC (2010) Unpacking governance: building adaptive capacity to climate change of river basins in Brazil. Global Environ Chang 20:4–13
Eriksen S, Lind J (2009) Adaptation as a political process: adjusting to drought and conflict in Kenya’s drylands. Environ Manage 43:817–835
Falaleeva M, O’Mahony C, Gray S, Desmond M, Gault J, Cummins V (2011) Towards climate adaptation and coastal governance in Ireland: integrated architecture for effective management? Mar Policy 35:784–793
Few R, Brown K, Tompkins EL (2007a) Public participation and climate change adaptation: avoiding the illusion of inclusion. Clim Policy 7(1):46–59
Few R, Brown K, Tompkins EL (2007b) Climate change and coastal management decisions: insights from Christchurch Bay, UK. Coast Manage 35:255–270
Folke C, Hahn T, Olsson P, Norberg J (2005) Adaptive governance of social-ecological systems. Annu Rev Environ Resour 30:441–473
Füssel HM, Klein RJT (2006) Climate change vulnerability assessments: an evolution of conceptual thinking. Clim Change 75:301–329
Galaz V (2005) Social-ecological resilience and social conflict: institutions and strategic adaptation in Swedish water management. Ambio 34(7):567–572
Garrelts H, Lange H (2011) Path dependencies and path change in complex fields of action: climate adaptation policies in Germany in the realm of flood risk management. Ambio 40:200–209
Geist HJ, Lambin EF (2002) Proximate causes and underlying driving forces of tropical deforestation. Biosci 52(2):143–150
Giansante C, Aguilar M, Babiano L, Garrido A, Gomez A, Martinez EI, Wietze L, Del Moral L, Pedregal B (2002) Institutional adaptation to changing risk of water scarcity in the lower Guadalquivir basin. Nat Resour J 42:521–563
Glaas E, Jonsson A, Hjerpe M, Andersson-Sköld Y (2010) Managing climate change vulnerabilities: formal institutions and knowledge use as determinants of adaptive capacity at the local level in Sweden. Local Environ 15(6):525–539
Gupta J, Termeer C, Klostermann J, Meijerink S, van den Brink M, Jong P, Nooteboom S, Bergsma E (2010) The adaptive capacity wheel: a method to assess the inherent characteristics of institutions to enable the adaptive capacity of society. Environ Sci Policy 13:459–471
Hagedorn K (2008) Particular requirements for institutional analysis in nature-related sectors. Europ Rev Agric Econ 35(3):357–384
Harries T, Penning-Rowsell E (2011) Victim pressure, institutional inertia and climate change adaptation: the case of flood risk. Global Environ Chang 21:188–197
Herrfahrdt-Pähle E, Pahl-Wostl C (2012) Continuity and change in social-ecological systems: the role of institutional resilience. Ecol Soc 17(2):8
Hinkel J, Bisaro A (2014) Methodological choices in solution-oriented adaptation research: A diagnostic framework. Reg Environ Change (in press) DOI: 10.1007/s10113-014-0682-0
Hinkel J, Bisaro A, Swart R (2015) Towards a diagnostic adaptation science. Reg Environ Change DOI:10.1007/s10113-015-0850-x
Hjerpe M, Glaas E (2012) Evolving local climate adaptation strategies: incorporating influences of socio-economic stress. Mitig Adapt Strat Glob Chang 17:471–486
Höppner C, Whittle R, Bründl M, Buchecker M (2008) Linking social capacities and risk communication in Europe: a gap between theory and practice? Nat Hazards 64:1753–1778
Huitema D, Mostert E, Egas W, Moellenkamp S, Pahl-Wostl C, Yalcin R (2009) Adaptive water governance: assessing the institutional prescriptions of adaptive (co-)management from a governance perspective and defining a research agenda. Ecol Soc 14(1):26
Huntjens P, Pahl-Wostl C, Rihoux B, Schlüter M, Flachner Z, Neto S, Koskova R, Dickens C, Kiti IN (2011) Adaptive water management and policy learning in a changing climate: a formal comparative analysis of eight water management regimes in Europe, Africa and Asia. Environ Policy Gov 21:145–163
Huntjens P, Lebel L, Pahl-Wostl C, Camkin J, Schulze R, Kranz N (2012) Institutional design propositions for the governance of adaptation to climate change in the water sector. Global Environ Chang 22:67–81
Inderberg TH (2011) Institutional constraints to adaptive capacity: adaptability to climate change in the Norwegian electricity sector. Local Environ 16(4):303–317
Ivey JL, Smithers J, de Loe RC, Kreutzwiser RD (2004) Community capacity for adaptation to climate-induced water shortages: linking institutional complexity and local actors. Environ Manage 33(1):36–47
Johula S, Westerhoff L (2011) Challenges of adaptation to climate change across multiple scales: a case study of network governance in two European countries. Environ Sci Policy 14:239–247
Keskitalo ECH, Westerhoff L, Juhola S (2012) Agenda-setting on the environment: the development of climate change adaptation as an issue in European states. Environ Policy Gov 22:381–394
Klein RJT, Juhola S (2014) A framework for Nordic actor-centered adaptation research. Environ Sci Pol 40:101–115
Klein RJT, Midgley GF, Preston BL, Alam M, Berkhout FGH, Dow K, Shaw MR (2014) Adaptation opportunities, constraints, and limits. In: Barros V et al (eds) Climate change 2014: Impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability. Part A: Global and sectoral aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, New York, pp 899–943
Klijn F, Merz B, Penning-Rowsell EC, Kundzewicz ZW (2015) Preface: climate change proof flood risk management. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change 20(6):837–843
Krysanova V, Dickens C, Timmerman J, Varela-Ortega C, Schlüter M, Roest K, Huntjens P, Jaspers F, Buiteveld H, Moreno E, de Pedraza CJ, Slámová R, Martínková M, Blanco I, Esteve P, Pringle K, Pahl-Wostl C, Kabat P (2010) Cross-comparison of climate change adaptation strategies across large river basins in Europe, Africa and Asia. Water Resour Manag 24:4121–4160
Kundzewicz ZW, Lugeri N, Dankers R, Hirabayashi Y, Döll P, Pińskwar I, Dysarz T, Hochrainer S, Matczak P (2010) Assessing river flood risk and adaptation in Europe—review of projections for the future. Mitig Adapt Strategies Global Change 15(7):641–656
Larsen SV, Kørnøv L, Weijs A (2012) Mind the gap in SEA: an institutional perspective on why assessment of synergies amongst climate change mitigation, adaptation and other policy areas are missing. Environ Impact Asses 33:32–40
Lebel L, Manuta JB, Garden P (2011) Institutional traps and vulnerability to changes in climate and flood regimes in Thailand. Reg Environ Change 11:45–58
Lehmann P, Brenck M, Gebhardt O, Schaller S, Süßbauer E (2015) Barriers and opportunities for urban adaptation planning: analytical framework and evidence from cities in Latin America and Germany. Mitig Adapt Strategies Global Change 20(1):75–97
Libecap GD (2011) Institutional path dependence in climate adaptation: Coman’s “some unsettled problems of irrigation”. Am Econ Rev 101:64–80
Lövbrand E (2011) Co-producing European climate science and policy: a cautionary note on the making of useful knowledge. Science Pub Policy 38(3):225–236
McFadden L, Penning-Rowsell E, Tapsell S (2009) Strategic coastal flood-risk management in practice: actors’ perspectives on the integration of flood risk management in London and the Thames Estuary. Ocean Coast Manage 52:636–645
Moser SC (2009) Whether our levers are long enough and the fulcrum strong? Exploring the soft underbelly of adaptation decisions and actions. In: Adger WN, Lorenzoni I, O’Brien KL (eds) Adapting to climate change. Thresholds, values, governance. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, pp 313–334
Moser SC, Boykoff MT (eds) (2013) Successful adaptation to climate change. Linking science and policy in a rapidly changing world. Routledge, London, New York
Munaretto S, Vellinga P, Tobi H (2012) Flood protection in Venice under conditions of sea-level rise: an analysis of institutional and technical measures. Coast Manage 40(4):355–380
Næss LO, Bang G, Eriksen S, Vevatne J (2005) Institutional adaptation to climate change: flood responses at the municipal level in Norway. Global Environ Chang 15:125–138
North DC (1990) Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Oberlack C, Eisenack K (2014) Alleviating barriers to urban climate change adaptation through international cooperation. Glob Environ Chang 24:349–362
Oberlack C, Neumärker B (2013) A diagnostic approach to the institutional analysis of climate adaptation. Constitutional Economics Network Paper No. 01-2013, Freiburg
Olsson P, Folke C, Galaz V, Hahn T, Schultz L (2007) Enhancing the fit through adaptive co-management: creating and maintaining bridging functions for matching scales in the Kristianstads Vattenrike Biosphere Reserve Sweden. Ecol Soc 12(1):28
Osberghaus D, Dannenberg A, Mennel T, Sturm B (2010) The role of the government in adaptation to climate change. Environ Plann C 28:834–850
Ostrom E (1990) Governing the commons: the evolution of institutions for collective action. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ostrom E (2005) Understanding institutional diversity. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Ostrom E (2007) A diagnostic approach for going beyond panaceas. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104(39):15181–15187
Ostrom E (2009) A general framework for analyzing sustainability of social-ecological systems. Science 325:419–422
Ostrom E (2010) Polycentric governance of complex economic systems. Am Econ Rev 100:1–33
Ostrom E (2011) Background on the Institutional Analysis and Development framework. Policy Stud J 39(1):7–27
O’Sullivan JJ, Bradford RA, Bonaiuto M, de Dominicis S, Rotko P, Aaltonen J, Waylen K, Langan SJ (2012) Enhancing flood resilience through improved risk communications. Nat Haz Earth Sys 12:2271–2282
Paavola J (2007) Institutions and environmental governance: a reconceptualization. Ecol Econ 63:93–103
Pahl-Wostl C (2009) A conceptual framework for analysing adaptive capacity and multi-level learning processes in resource governance regimes. Global Environ Chang 19:354–365
Pelling M, High C, Dearing J, Smith D (2008) Shadow spaces for social learning: a relational understanding of adaptive capacity to climate change within organizations. Environ Plann A 40:867–884
Petrow T, Thieken AH, Kreibich H, Bahlburg CH, Merz B (2006) Improvement on flood alleviation in Germany: lessons learned from the Elbe flood in August 2002. Environ Manage 38:717–732
Roberts D (2008) Thinking globally, acting locally. Institutionalizing climate change at the local government level in Durban, South Africa. Environ & Urban 20(2):521–537
Rodima-Taylor D, Olwig MF, Chhetri N (2012) Adaptation as innovation, innovation as adaptation: an institutional approach to climate change. Appl Geogr 33:107–111
Rouillard JJ, Heal KV, Reeves AD, Ball T (2012) Impact of institutions on flood policy learning. Water Policy 14:232–249
Rudberg PM, Wallgren O, Swartling ÅG (2012) Beyond generic adaptive capacity: exploring the adaptation space of the water supply and wastewater sector of the Stockholm region, Sweden. Clim Chang 114:707–721
Rudel T (2008) Meta-analyses of case studies: a method for studying regional and global environmental change. Global Environ Chang 18:18–25
Ruigh-van der Ploen T (2011) Manifestations of adaptive capacity: an institutional analysis of adaptation of a local stormwater drainage system. Clim Law 2:201–217
Runhaar H, Mees H, Wardekker A, van der Sluijs J, Driessen PPJ (2012) Adaptation to climate change-related risks in Dutch urban areas: stimuli and barriers. Reg Environ Change 12(4):777–790
Schlager E, Heikilla T (2011) Left high and dry? Climate change, common-pool resource theory, and the adaptability of Western water compacts. Public Admin Rev 71(3):461–470
Sendzimir J, Magnuszewski P, Flachner Z, Balogh P, Molnar G, Sarvari A, Nagy Z (2008) Assessing the resilience of a river management regime: informal learning in a shadow network in the Tisza river basin. Ecol Soc 13(1):11
Sharma U, Scolobig A, Patt A (2012) The effects of decentralization on the production and use of risk assessment: insights from landslide management in India and Italy. Nat Hazards 64:1357–1371
Srinivasan V, Lambin EF, Gorelick SM, Thompson BH, Rozelle S (2012) The nature and causes of the global water crisis: syndromes from a meta‐analysis of coupled human‐water studies. Water Resour Res 48(10):1–16
Storbjörk S (2007) Governing climate adaptation in the local arena: challenges of risk management and planning in Sweden. Local Environ 12(5):457–469
Storbjörk S, Hedrén J (2011) Institutional capacity-building for targeting sea-level rise in the climate adaptation of Swedish coastal zone management: lessons from Coastby. Ocean Coastal Manage 54:265–273
Tol RSJ, van der Grijp N, Olsthoorn AA, van der Werff PE (2003) Adapting to climate: a case study on riverine flood risks in the Netherlands. Risk Anal 23(3):575–583
Tompkins EL, Eakin H (2012) Managing public and private adaptation. Global Environ Chang 22:3–11
Tyler NJC, Turi JM, Sundset MA, Strøm Bull K, Sara MN, Reinert E, Oskal N, Nellemann C, McCarthy JJ, Mathiesen SD, Martello ML, Magga OH, Hovelsrud GK, Hanssen-Bauer I, Eira NI, Eira IMG, Corell RW (2007) Saami reindeer pastoralism under climate change: applying a generalized framework for vulnerability studies to a sub-arctic social-ecological system. Global Environ Chang 17:191–206
Urwin K, Jordan A (2008) Does public policy support or undermine climate change adaptation? Exploring interplay across different scales of governance. Global Environ Chang 18:180–191
van Herk S, Zevenbergen C, Ashley R, Rijke J (2011) Learning and action alliances for the integration of flood risk management into urban planning: a new framework from empirical evidence from the Netherlands. Environ Sci Policy 14:543–554
Vatn A (2005) Institutions and the environment. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Villamayor-Tomás S (2014) Cooperation in common property regimes under extreme drought conditions: empirical evidence from the use of pooled transferable quotas in Spanish irrigation systems. Ecol Econ 107:482–493
Wamsler C, Lawson N (2012) Complementing institutional with localised strategies for climate change adaptation: a south–north comparison. Disasters 36(1):28–53
Wardekker JA, de Jong A, Knoop JM, van der Sluijs JP (2010) Operationalising a resilience approach to adapting an urban delta to uncertain climate changes. Technol Forecasting Social Change 77:987–998
Weichselgartner J, Kasperson R (2010) Barriers in the science-policy-practice interface: toward a knowledge-action-system in global environmental change research. Global Environ Chang 20:266–277
Werners SE, Flachner Z, Matczak P, Falaleeva M, Leemans R (2009) Exploring earth system governance: a case study of floodplain management along the Tisza river in Hungary. Global Environ Chang 19:503–511
West JJ, Hovelsrud GK (2010) Cross-scale adaptation challenges in the coastal fisheries: findings from Lebesby, northern Norway. Arctic 63(3):338–354
Westerhoff L, Johula S (2010) Science-policy linkages in climate change adaptation in Europe. Int J Clim Change Strategies Manage 2(3):222–241
Westerhoff L, Keskitalo ECH, Johula S (2011) Capacities across scales: local to national adaptation policy in four European countries. Clim Policy 11(4):1071–1085
Wilson E (2006) Adapting to climate change at the local level: the spatial planning response. Local Environ 11(6):609–625
Yates JS (2012) Uneven interventions and the scalar politics of governing livelihood adaptation in rural Nepal. Global Environ Chang 22:537–546
Yin RK (2014) Case study research: design and methods, 5th edn. Sage, Los Angeles, et al
Young OR (2008) Building regimes for socioecological systems in institutions and environmental change: Institutional diagnostics. In: Young OR, King L, Schroeder H (eds) Institutions and environmental change. Principal findings, applications and research frontiers. MIT Press, Cambridge MA, pp 115–144
Young OR (2010) Institutional dynamics: resilience, vulnerability and adaptation in environmental and resource regimes. Global Environ Chang 20:378–385
Young OR (2013) Sugaring off: enduring insights from long-term research on environmental governance. Int Environ Agree-P 13:87–105
Acknowledgments
Valuable comments by Klaus Eisenack, Bernhard Neumärker, Matteo Roggero, Maja Rotter, Stefanie J. Schmidt, Andreas Thiel, Stephan Wolf and the anonymous reviewers are gratefully acknowledged.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The author declares that he has no conflict of interest.
Appendix
Appendix
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Oberlack, C. Diagnosing institutional barriers and opportunities for adaptation to climate change. Mitig Adapt Strateg Glob Change 22, 805–838 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-015-9699-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11027-015-9699-z