Abstract
Pragmatic approaches to genetic testing are discussed and appraised. Whilst there are various schools of pragmatism, the Deweyan appraoch seems to be the most appreciated in bioethics as it allows a historical approach indebted to Hegel. This in turn allows the pragmatist to specify and balance principles in various contexts. There are problems with where to draw a line between what is referred to here as the micro- and macro-level of doing bioethics, unless one is simply to be classified as a principlist. Whilst most discussions on genetics occur at a macro level, most specifying must be done also at a micro level – the clinical encounter. Whilst pragmatism encourages us to understand better social and scientific factors and puts into perspective statements like ‘playing God’, doubts are raised about the ‘consensus’ process and how one can put aside fundamental values such as the moral status of the embryo on which there is general disagreement. If those doing pragmatism do not endorse these values, there seems to be little ground for process and compromise with those who do. It seems therefore that pragmatism cannot ignore values, even those which are not endorsed by everyone.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Advisory Council on Science and Technology: 1993, Report on Medical Research and Health: Task Force on Screening, Diagnosis and Prevention. Cabinet Office.
E. Agius (1998) ‘Patenting Life: Our Responsibilities to Present and Future Generations’ E. Agius S. Busuttil (Eds) Germ-Line Intervention and our Responsibilties to Future Generations Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht 67–84
Bailey, R.: 1996, ‘Prenatal Testing and the Prevention of Impairment: A Woman’s Right to Choose?’, in: J. Morris (ed.), Encounters with Strangers: Femminism and Disability. London Women’s Press Ltd., pp. 143–167.
T.L. Beauchamp J.F. Childress (1994) Principles of Biomedical Ethics EditionNumber4 Oxford University Press New York and Oxford
M. Benjamin (2001) ArticleTitle‘Between Subway and Spaceship: Practical Ethics at the Outset of the Twenty-First Century’ The Hastings Center Report 34 IssueID4 24–31
R. Chadwick (1998) ‘Genetic Screening’ R. Chadwick (Eds) Encyclopaedia of Applied Ethics Academic Press London 445–450
A. Clarke (1998) ‘Genetic Councelling’ R. Chadwick (Eds) Encyclopaedia of Applied Ethics Academic Press London 391–406
J.H. Evans (2000) ArticleTitle‘A Sociological Account of the Growth of Principlism’ The Hastings Center Report 30 IssueID5 31–38
J.J. Fins M.D. Bacchetta F.G. Miller (1997) ArticleTitleClinical Pragmatism: A Method of Moral Problem Solving Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 7 IssueID2 129–145 Occurrence Handle11654986
J.J. Fins M.D. Bacchetta F.G. Miller (1998) ArticleTitle‘Clinical Pragmatism: Bridging Theory and Practice’ Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 8 IssueID1 37–42 Occurrence Handle11656752
S. Haack (2001) ‘Pragmatism’ J. Dancy E. Sosa (Eds) A Companion to Epistemology Blackwell Publishers Oxford And Massachusetts 351–357
P.S. Harper (1997) ‘China’s Genetic Law’ A.J. Clarke P.S. Harper (Eds) Genetics, Society and Clinical Practice Bios Scientific Publishers London 237–246
A.M. Hedgecoe (1998) ‘Gene Therapy’ R. Chadwick (Eds) Encyclopedia of Applied Ethics. Vol. 2 Academic Press London 383–390
Heidegger, M.: 1962, Basil Blackwell Oxford being and Time. Trans (Macquarrie, J. and Robinson, E.)
L.A. Jansen (1998) ArticleTitle‘Assessing Clinical Pragmatism’ Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 8 IssueID1 23–36 Occurrence Handle11656751
A. Jonsen (1994) ‘Foreward’ E.R. Dubose R. Hamel L.J. O’Connell (Eds) A Matter of Principles. Ferment In U.S. Bioethics Trinity Press International Pennsylvania ix–xvii
G. McGee (1997) The Perfect Baby–A Pragmatic Approach to Genetics Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc New York
G. McGee (1999) ‘Genetic Enhancement of Families’ in: G. McGee (ed.) Pragmatic Bioethics. Nashville Vanderbilt University Press pp. 168–180
D. Morgan R. Lee (1989) Birthrights Routledge London
Popkin, R.H.: 1999, ‘John Dewey’, in: R.H. Popkin (ed.), The Pimlico History of Western Philosophy. London, New South Wales, Auckland: pp. 600–603.
InstitutionalAuthorNamePresident’s Commission For The Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Science (1983) Splicing Life: A Report on the Social and Ethical Issues of Genetic Engineering with Human Beings Government Printing Office Washington, DC
R. Rorty (1998) ‘Pragmatism, Relativism, and Irrationalism’ University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis, MN 160–175
H. Saatkamp (1999) ‘Genetics and Pragmatism’ G. McGee (Eds) Pragmatic Bioethics Vanderbilt University Press Nashville 152–167
J.B. Schneewind (2001) ‘Modern Moral Philosophy’ P. Singer H. Kuhse (Eds) A Companion to Ethics Blackwell Publsihers Oxford and Massachusetts 147–157
C. Tollefsen (2000) ArticleTitle‘What would John Dewey Do? The Promises and Perils of Pragmatic Bioethics’ The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25 IssueID1 77–106 Occurrence Handle10.1076/0360-5310(200002)25:1;1-V;FT077 Occurrence Handle10732877
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mallia, P., Have, H.t. Pragmatic approaches to genetic screening. Med Health Care Philos 8, 69–77 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-6752-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-004-6752-1