The Journal of Technology Transfer

, Volume 38, Issue 6, pp 788-808

First online:

University startups as a commercialization alternative: lessons from three contrasting case studies

  • Paul M. SwamidassAffiliated withCollege of Business, Thomas Walter Center for Technology Management, Auburn University Email author 

Rent the article at a discount

Rent now

* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.

Get Access


A recent National Research Council (NRC) report (2011) recommends that universities must craft policies and allocate resources to enable more university startups because some university technologies will never be commercialized unless licensed to a startup. However, the creation of university startups requires personnel skills and programs not typically associated with an university Office of Technology Transfer (OTT). Estimates show that 75 % of university inventions are not licensed at all. The conclusions of this study include university policies to turn some them to fuel university startups. Carefully selected case studies of three contrasting universities reveal patterns of successful startup policies and performance. MIT’s case is an example of long-term success, the University of Colorado’s case is an example of medium-term success, and Auburn University’s case is an example of a new-comer to the scene. Lessons from the case studies include: the need for very early evaluation of all inventions for their startup potential, the need for pre-license seed funds through proof-of-concept programs to advance early-stage inventions to the next stage, and the need for OTT personnel skilled in enabling startups. NSF’s recent I-Corps program invests heavily in the training of potential enablers and entrepreneurs for commercializing university inventions. Based on the findings of this study, I-Corps must also invest in pre-license proof-of-concept programs to advance early-stage university inventions closer to the market. Implementing the conclusions of this study would also accomplish the recommendations of the 2011 NRC report cited above.


University spinoffs and startups Proof of concept (POC) Technology development stages Management of innovation Technology transfer NSF I-Corps program Auburn University MIT The University of Colorado Stanford University

JEL Classification