Abstract
This essay analyzes Senator Bill Frist's 2001 address to the American Society of Thoracic Surgeons. The author argues that the address represents an attempt to reframe physicians' political identity to authorize more active participation by them. Frist authorizes and demands such participation through the construction of a medical jeremiad. He argues that American physicians must have greater involvement to preserve the health of the body politic and to reassert physician control over the biomedical system. Although Frist's arguments are built on an apparently democratic form of address, his jeremiad illustrates aristocratic possibilities in medico-political rhetoric.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
J. A. Barondess, “Medicine against Society: Lessons from the Third Reich.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 276 (1996): 1657–1621.
J. A. Barondess, “Care of the Medical Ethos: Reflections on Social Darwinism, Racial Hygiene, and the Holocaust.” Annals of Internal Medicine, 129 (1998): 891–898.
J. A. Barondess, “Care of the Medical Ethos, With Some Comments on Research: Reflections after the Holocaust.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine, 43 (2000): 308–324.
J. M. Bentley, “Barriers to Accessing Health Care: The Perspective of Elderly People within a Village Community.” International Journal of Nursing Studies, 40 (2003): 9–21.
S. Bercovitch, The American Jeremiad. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1978.
R. J. Blendon, T. S. Hyams, and J. M. Benson, “Bridging the Gap between Expert and Public Views on Health Care Reform.” Journal of the American Medical Association, 269 (1993): 2573–2578.
T. N. Bonner, “Crushing the Commercial Spirit in Academic Medicine: A Crusade that Failed.” Academic Medicine, 74 (1999): 1067–1071.
E. G. Bormann, “Fetching Good Out of Evil: A Rhetorical Use of Calamity.” Quarterly Journal of Speech, 63 (1977): 130–139.
S. Brint, “In An Age of Experts: The Changing Role of Professionals in Politics and Public Life (Princeton: Princeton UP, 1994).”
I. Brown, “Organizational Values in General Practice and Public Involvement: Case Studies in an Urban District.” Health and Social Care Community, 9 (2001): 159–167.
D. O. Buehler, “Permanence and Change in Theodore Roosevelt's Conservation Jeremiad.” Western Journal of Communication, 62 (1998): 439–458.
D. D. Cali, and C. Estrada, “The Medical Interview as Rhetorical Counterpoint to the Case Presentation.” Health Communication, 11 (1999): 355–373.
L. Crellin, “Caring in an Environment of Change and Casemix Funding.” Contemporary Nursing, 8 (1999): 14–22.
R. Dawidoff, The Genteel Traditional and the Sacred Rage: High Culture vs. Democracy in Adams, James, and Santayana (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1992).
R. Dell'Oro, “The Market Ethos and the Integrity of Health Care.” Journal of Contemporary Health Law Policy, 18 (2002): 641–647.
C. K. Francis, “The Medical Ethos and Social Responsibility in Clinical Medicine.” Journal of the National Medical Association, 93 (2001): 157–169.
C. K. Francis, “The Medical Ethos and Social Responsibility in Clinical Medicine.” Journal of Urban Health, 78 (2001): 29–45.
B. Frist, “Public Policy and The Practicing Physician.” Annals of Thoracic Surgery 71 (2001): 1410-1414.
B. Frist, “Frist Comments On Being Elected Senate Majority Leader.” Press release of Senator Bill Frist, United States Senate, http://frist.senate.gov/print-item.cfm?189496.
B. Frist, “Curriculum Vitae”, United States Senate, http://frist.senate.gov/cv.cfm.
G. Hanlon, “Professionalism as Enterprise: Service Class Politics and the Redefinition of Professionalism.” Sociology, 32 (1998): 43–46.
R. M. Harden, J. Grant, G. Buckley, and I. R. Hart, “Best Evidence Medical Education.” Advances in Health Science Education, Theory and Practice, 5 (2000): 71–90.
Hippocrates. On Ancient Medicine. Trans. F Adams (Chicago: Encylopaedia Britannica/Great Books of the Western World, 1952).
L. R. Jacobs, and R. Y. Shapiro, “Questioning the Conventional Wisdom on Public Opinion toward Health Reform.” PS: Political Science and Politics, 27 (1994): 208–214.
R. L. Johannesen, “The Jeremiad and Jenkin Lloyd Jones.” Communication Monographs 52 (1985): 156–172.
Z. Kmietovicz, R.E.S.P.E.C.T.—Why Doctors Are Still Getting Enough Of It. British Medical Journal, 324 (2002): 11.
E. A. Krause, Death Of The Guilds: Professions, States, And The Advance Of Capitalism (New Haven: Yale UP, 1996).
B. H. Lerner, “From Careless to Recalcitrant Patients: The Historical Construction of Noncompliance.” Social Science and Medicine, 45 (1997): 1423–1431.
J. Lobo-Antunes, “Emerging Unwanted Side Effects of Quality Control, Or the Value of the Immeasurable Qualities of Medical Care?” Acta Neurochirurgica Supplement, 78 (2001): 205–208.
K. S. McNeilis, “Analyzing Communication Competence in Medical Consultations.” Health Communication, 13 (2001): 5–18.
J. M. Murphy, “A Time of Shame and Sorrow: Robert F. Kennedy and the American Jeremiad.” Quarterly Journal of Speech, 76 (1990): 401–414.
S. A. Owens, “Memory, War and American Identity: Saving Private Ryan as Cinematic Jeremiad.” Critical Studies in Media Communication, 19 (2002): 249–282.
J. Pain, “Incoming Senate Majority Leader Frist, a Surgeon, Aids Victims of Accident on Florida Highway.” Associated Press State and Local Wire, 2 January 2003, BC cycle.
J. L. Pauley, “Reshaping Public Persona and the Prophetic Ethos: Louis Farrakhan at the Million Man March. Western Journal of Communication, 62 (1998): 512–536.
S. M. Peloquin, “Reclaiming the Vision of Reaching for Heart as Well as Hands.” American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 56 (2003): 517–526.
Plato. Gorgias. Trans.WC Hembold (New York: MacMillan/Library of the Liberal Arts, 1952).
B. Poyner, “Beyond the Jeremiad: The Isaiad As Prophetic Form.” In Generic Criticisms of American Public Address, ed. DD Call (Dubuque: Kendall Hunt, 1996), 185–199.
W. T. Reich, “The Care-Based Ethic of Nazi Medicine and the Moral Importance of What We Care About.” American Journal of Bioethics, 1 (2001): 64–74.
K. W. Ritter, “American Political Rhetoric and the Jeremiad Tradition: Presidential Nomination Acceptance Addresses.” Central States Speech Journal, 31 (1980): 153–171.
M. A. Schlesinger, “Loss of Faith: The Sources of Reduced Political Legitimacy for the American Medical Profession.” Milbank Quarterly, 80 (2002): 185–235.
M. Snow, “Martin Luther King's ‘Letter from Birmingham Jail’ as Pauline Epistle.” Quarterly Journal of Speech, 71 (1985): 318–334.
M. Stoda, and G. N. Dionisopoulos, “Jeremiad at Harvard: Solzhenitsyn and ’The World Split Apart.” Western Journal of Communication, 64 (2000): 28–52.
D. A. Stone, “The Doctor as Businessman: The Changing Politics of a Cultural Icon.” Journal of Health Politics, Policy, and Law, 22 (1997): 533–556.
M. B. Tonn, “Militant Motherhood: Labor's Mary Harris ‘Mother’ Jones.” Quarterly Journal of Speech, 82 (1996): 1–21.
G. Trotter, “Pragmatism, Bioethics, and the Grand American Social Experiment.” American Journal of Bioethics, 1 (2001): W11.
B. L. Ware, and W. A. Linkugel, “The Rhetorical Persona: Marcus Garvey as Black Moses.” Communication Monographs, 49 (1982): 50–62.
D. E. Wueste, “Wrongdoing in Biomedical Research: An Ethical Diagnosis and Prescription.” Critical Reviews in Biomedical Engineering, 28 (2000): 629–636.
M. Wynia, S. Latham, A. Kao, et. al. “Medical Professionalism in Society.” New England Journal of Medicine, 341 (1999): 1612–1616.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bates, B.R. Senator Bill Frist and the Medical Jeremiad. J Med Humanit 26, 259–272 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10912-005-7700-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10912-005-7700-7