Skip to main content
Log in

When Data Speak Back: Resolving Source Conflict in Apache Residential and Fire-Making Behavior

  • Published:
International Journal of Historical Archaeology Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

Contradictions exist among primary sources as to the locations of historical Chiricahua and Mescalero Apache encampments. Modern elders state that residential sites were situated in low settings at the base of elevated landforms, whereas textual sources and archaeology suggest otherwise for much of the historic period and before. This contradiction is resolved when it is realized that Chiricahua cultural-specialist knowledge relating to key aspects of landscape use pertains to the last 25 years before Geronimo’s final surrender and removal to the east. This was a time of substantial and increased pressure from the American military using more effective tactics following the Civil War. These tactics included cooperation with Mexico, use of Apache scouts, deeper penetration of the mountains, and more persistent pursuit. Land claims interviews of Chiricahua informants from the 1950s mention this shift from high to low and the reason for it. This case study illustrates the importance of (a) seriating source material rather than assuming long-term continuity, (b) subjecting all sources, including elder knowledge, to standard forms of criticism, and (c) analyzing differences between informant factions.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Adams, C., White, D. E., and Johnson, D. M. (2000). Last Chance Canyon 1869 Apache/Cavalry Battle Site, Lincoln National Forest, Alamogordo.

    Google Scholar 

  • Anyon, R., Ferguson, T. J., Jackson, L., Lane, L., and Vicenti, P. (1997). Native American oral tradition and archaeology: Issues of structure, relevance, and respect. In Swidler, N., Dongoske, K. E., Anyon, R., and Downer, A. S. (eds.), Native Americans and Archaeologists, Stepping Stones to Common Ground, AltaMira, Walnut Creek, pp. 77–87.

    Google Scholar 

  • Ascher, R. (1961). Analogy in archaeological interpretation. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 17: 317–325.

    Google Scholar 

  • Bahr, D., Smith, J., Allison, W., and Hayden, J. (1994). The Short Swift Time of Gods on Earth: The Hohokam Chronicles, University of California Press, Berkeley.

    Book  Google Scholar 

  • Ball, E. (1970). In the Days of Victorio: Recollections of a Warm Springs Apache, University of Arizona Press, Tucson.

    Google Scholar 

  • Ball, E. (1988). Indeh: An Apache Odyssey, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Barrett, S. M., and Turner, F. W. (1996). Geronimo: His Own Story: The Autobiography of a Great Patriot Warrior, Meridian, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Basehart, H. W. (1960). Mescalero Apache Subsistence Patterns and Socio-Political Organization, Sections I and II: A report of the Mescalero-Chiricahua Land Claims Project, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.

    Google Scholar 

  • Betzinez, J., and Nye, W. S. (1959). I Fought with Geronimo, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln.

    Google Scholar 

  • Binford, L. R. (1981). Smudge pits and hide smoking: The use of analogy in archaeological reasoning. American Antiquity 32: 1–12.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Bolton, H. E. (1948). Kino’s Historical Memoir of Pimeria Alta, University of California Press, Berkeley.

    Google Scholar 

  • Carmichael, D. L., and Farrer, C. R. (2012). We do not forget, we remember: Mescalero Apache origins and migration as reflected in place names. In Seymour, D. J. (ed.), From the Land of Ever Winter to the American Southwest: Athapaskan Migrations, Mobility, and Ethnogenesis, University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City, pp. 182–197.

    Google Scholar 

  • Cole, D. C. (1981). An Ethnohistory of the Chiricahua Apache Indian Reservation, 1872–1876. Doctoral dissertation. University of New Mexico, Albuquerque.

  • Cole, D. C. (1988). The Chiricahua Apache: From War to Reservation 1846–1876, University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.

    Google Scholar 

  • Colwell-Chanthaphonh, J. S. (2007). Massacre at Camp Grant: Forgetting and Remembering Apache History, University of Arizona Press, Tucson.

    Google Scholar 

  • Cremony, J. C. (1981). Life Among the Apaches, A. Roman, San Francisco.

    Google Scholar 

  • Croes, D. R. (2010). Courage and thoughtful scholarship = indigenous archaeology partnerships. American Antiquity 75: 211–216.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Debo, A. (1976). Geronimo: The Man, His Time, His Place, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Echo-Hawk, R. C. (1997). Forging a new ancient history for Native America. In Swidler, N., Dongoske, K., Anyon, R., and Downer, A. S. (eds.), Native Americans and Archaeologists: Stepping Stones to Common Ground, AltaMira, Walnut Creek, pp. 88–102.

    Google Scholar 

  • Echo-Hawk, R. C. (2000). Ancient history in the New World: Integrating oral traditions and the archaeological record in deep time. American Antiquity 65: 267–290.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Ezell, P. H. (1963). The Maricopas: An Identification from Documentary Sources, University of Arizona Press, Tucson.

    Google Scholar 

  • Faulk, O. B. (1969). The Geronimo Campaign, Oxford University Press, New York.

    Google Scholar 

  • Feinman, G. (1997). Thoughts on new approaches to combining the archaeological and historical records. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 4: 367–377.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Ferguson, T. J., and Colwell-Chanthaphonh, C. (2006). History is in the Land: Multivocal Tribal traditions in Arizona’s San Pedro Valley, University of Arizona Press, Tucson.

    Google Scholar 

  • Fogelin, L. (2007). Inference to the best explanation: A common and effective form of archaeological reasoning. American Antiquity 72: 603–625.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Forbes, J. D. (1960). Apache Navaho and Spaniard, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Frick-Wright, P. (2012). Otero Mesa, the remnant of a forgotten grassland, looks for a little recognition. Sierra Magazine (July/August). http://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/201207/otera-mesa-195.aspx.

  • Griffen, W. B. (1988). Apaches at War and Peace: The Janos Presidio, 1750–1858, University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.

    Google Scholar 

  • Griffen, W. B. (1991). The Chiricahua Apache population resident at the Janos Presidio, 1792 to 1858. Journal of the Southwest 33: 151–199.

    Google Scholar 

  • Hammond, G., and Rey, A. (1966). The Rediscovery of New Mexico, 1580–1594: The Explorations of Chamuscado, Espejo, Castaño de Sosa, Morlete, and Leyva de Bonilla and Humana, University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque.

    Google Scholar 

  • Henderson, R. N. (1957). Field notes of Mescalero-Chiricahua Land Claims Interviews with Chiricahua Tribal Members. Papers in possession of the author.

  • Hendricks, R. (2010). Suma Rebellion-171. New Mexico Office of the State Historian Web Site. http://www.newmexicohistory.org/filedetails.php?fileID=524.

  • Howard, O. O. (1894). The Instincts of Indian Children. Prepared for The Voice, January 17. Oliver Otis Howard Papers, George J. Mitchell Department of Special Collections & Archives, Bowdoin College Library, Brunswick, ME.

  • Lowie, R. H. (1917). Oral tradition and history. Journal of American Folk-Lore 30: 161–167.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Lyman, R. L., and O’Brien, M. J. (2001). The direct historical approach, analogical reasoning, and theory in Americanist archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 8: 303–342.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Martin, C. (1987). An introduction aboard the Fidele. In Martin, C. (ed.), The American Indian and the Problem of History, Oxford University Press, New York, pp. 3–26.

    Google Scholar 

  • Mason, R. J. (2000). Archaeology and Native North American oral traditions. American Antiquity 65: 239–266.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Matson, D. S., and Schroeder, A. H. (1957). Cordero’s Description of the Apache: 1796. New Mexico Historical Review 32: 335–356.

    Google Scholar 

  • Matson, D. S., and Schroeder, A. H. (1965). A Colony on the Move: Gaspar Castaño de Sosa’s Journal, 1590–1591, School of American Research, Santa Fe.

    Google Scholar 

  • McGhee, R. (2008). Aboriginalism and the problems of Indigenous archaeology. American Antiquity 73: 579–597.

    Google Scholar 

  • McGhee, R. (2009). Science, Truth and Power in Americanist Archaeology. Paper presented at the American Anthropological Association annual meeting, Philadelphia.

  • McGhee, R. (2010). Of strawmen, herrings, and frustrated expectations. American Antiquity 75: 239–243.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Mogollon, J. Y. F. (1712). Juan Ygnacio Florez Mogollon, Santa Fe, December 16, 1712, State Archives of New Mexico II, Santa Fe.

    Google Scholar 

  • Myers, F. R. (1986). Review: The politics of representation: Anthropological discourse and Australian Aborigines. American Ethnologist 13: 138–153.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Naylor, T. H., and Polzer, C. W. (1986). The Presidio and Militia on the Northern Frontier of New Spain, 1570–1700, University of Arizona Press, Tucson.

    Google Scholar 

  • Opler, M. E. (1996). An Apache Life-Way: The Economic, Social, and Religious Institutions of the Chiricahua Indians, University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln.

    Google Scholar 

  • Salmon, M. H. (1976). “Deductive” versus “inductive” archaeology. American Antiquity 41: 376–381.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Schaafsma, C. F. (2004). Truth dwells in the deeps: Southwest oral traditions and archaeological interpretations. Journal of the Southwest 46: 621–642.

    Google Scholar 

  • Schroeder, A. H. (1973). The Mescalero Apaches. Technical Manual: 1973 Survey of the Tularosa Basin, Human Systems Research, Tularosa, pp. 124–144.

    Google Scholar 

  • Schroeder, A. H. (1974). A study of the Apache Indians, part IV: The Mogollon, Copper Mine, Mimbres, Warm Spring, and Chiricahua Apaches. In Horr, D. (ed.), Apache Indians, IV, Garland, New York, pp. 9–326.

    Google Scholar 

  • Schuyler, R. L. (1968). The use of historic analogs in archaeology. American Antiquity 33: 390–392.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (1992). Apachean Archaeology in the Uplands of Southern Arizona. Unpublished manuscript in possession of the author.

  • Seymour, D. J. (1995). A behavioral approach to the recognition of inconspicuous Apachean sites. Paper presented at the 68th Annual Pecos Conference, Gila Wilderness and published as an appendix in Seymour 2002a, Conquest and concealment: After the El Paso Phase on Fort Bliss. Conservation Division, Directorate of Environment, Fort Bliss. Lone Mountain Report 525/528. El Paso.

  • Seymour, D. J. (2002a). Conquest and concealment: After the El Paso Phase on Fort Bliss. Conservation Division, Directorate of Environment, Fort Bliss. Lone Mountain Report 525/528. El Paso.

  • Seymour, D. J. (2002b). The Three Sisters Site: An Early Chokonen Apache Habitation Site in the Dragoon Mountains, Southeastern Arizona. Unpublished manuscript in possession of the author.

  • Seymour, D. J. (2004). A ranchería in the Gran Apachería: Evidence of intercultural interaction at the Cerro Rojo site. Plains Anthropologist 49: 153–192.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2007). Delicate diplomacy on a restless frontier: Seventeenth-century Sobaípuri social and economic relations in northwestern New Spain, Part I. New Mexico Historical Review 82: 469–499.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2008). Despoblado or Athapaskan heartland: A methodological perspective on ancestral Apache landscape use in the Safford area. In Purcell, D. E. (ed.), Crossroads of the Southwest: Culture, Ethnicity, and Migration in Arizona’s Safford Basin, Cambridge Scholars Press, New York, pp. 121–162.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2009a). The Cerro Rojo Site (LA 37188): A Large Mountain-Top Ancestral Apache Site in Southern New Mexico. Digital History Project. New Mexico Office of the State Historian. http://www.newmexicohistory.org/.

  • Seymour, D. J. (2009b). Distinctive places, suitable spaces: Conceptualizing mobile group occupational duration and landscape use. International Journal of Historical Archaeology 13: 255–281.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2009c). Nineteenth-century Apache wickiups: Historically documented models for archaeological signatures of the dwellings of mobile people. Antiquity 83: 157–164.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2009d). Evaluating eyewitness accounts of Native peoples along the Coronado Trail from the International Border to Cibola. New Mexico Historical Review 84: 399–435.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2010a). Contextual incongruities, statistical outliers, and anomalies: Targeting inconspicuous occupational events. American Antiquity 75: 158–176.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2010b). Cycles of renewal, transportable assets: Aspects of ancestral Apache housing. Plains Anthropologist 55: 131–150.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2012a). “Big trips” and historic Apache movement and interaction: Models for early Athapaskan migrations. In Seymour, D. J. (ed.), From the Land of Ever Winter to the American Southwest: Athapaskan Migrations, Mobility, and Ethnogenesis, University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City, pp. 377–409.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2012b). Isolating a pre-differentiation Athapaskan assemblage in the southern southwest: The Cerro Rojo Complex. In Seymour, D. J. (ed.), From the Land of Ever Winter to the American Southwest: Athapaskan Migrations, Mobility, and Ethnogenesis, University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City, pp. 90–123.

    Google Scholar 

  • Seymour, D. J. (2013). Apache platform cave-cache encampments: Implications for mobility strategies and the earliest Athabascans. Journal of Field Archaeology 38.

  • Seymour, D. J., and Harlan, M. E. (1996). Southern Apache Archaeology. Paper prepared for the Coronado National Forest in partial fulfillment of a Challenge Cost-Share Grant entitled, Apache Site Survey (CCS3-94-05-11). Ms. on file with authors.

  • Seymour, D. J., and Henderson, R. N. (2010). Focal Residential Strategies of The Southernmost Ancestral Apache. Chapter prepared for The Apache Presence in the Borderlands of the American Southwest, edited by David L. Carmichael. Book manuscript.

  • Seymour, D. J., and Robertson, G. (2008). A pledge of peace: Evidence of the Cochise-Howard Treaty campsite. Historical Archaeology 42: 154–179.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sladen, J. A. (1896). Making peace with Cochise, Chief of Chiricaua Indians, 1872. Manuscript on file at the USDA Coronado National Forest, Tucson.

  • Sonnichsen, C. L. (1986). The Mescalero Apaches, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sweeney, E. R. (1991). Cochise: Chiricahua Apache Chief, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sweeney, E. R. (1992). Merejildo Grijalva, Apache Captive, Army Scout, University of Texas, El Paso.

    Google Scholar 

  • Sweeney, E. R. (1997). Making Peace with Cochise: The 1872 Journal of Captain Joseph Alton Sladen, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Thomas, A. B. (1932). Forgotten Frontiers: A Study of the Spanish Indian Policy of Don Juan Bautista de Anza, Governor of New Mexico, 1777–1787, University of Oklahoma Press, Norman.

    Google Scholar 

  • Thomas, A. B. (1959). The Chiricahua Apache. University of New Mexico, Mescalero-Chiricahua Land Claims Project, Contract Research #290-154, Albuquerque.

  • Vansina, J. (1985). Oral Tradition as History, University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.

    Google Scholar 

  • Whiteley, P. M. (2002). Archaeology and oral tradition: The scientific importance of dialogue. American Antiquity 67: 405–415.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Wilcox, M. (2010). Saving Indigenous peoples from ourselves: Separate but equal archaeology is not scientific archaeology. American Antiquity 75: 221–227.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Wilmsen, E. N. (1989). We Are Here: Politics of Aboriginal Land Tenure, University of California Press, Berkeley.

    Google Scholar 

  • Wylie, A. (1985). The reaction against analogy. In Schiffer, M. B. (ed.), Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory, vol. 8, Academic, New York, pp. 63–111.

    Google Scholar 

  • Wylie, A. (1988). “Simple” analogy and the role of relevance assumptions: Implications of archaeological practice. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 2: 134–150.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Wylie, A. (1999). Why should historical archaeologists study capitalism? In Leone, M. P., and Potter Jr., P. B. (eds.), Historical Archaeologies of Capitalism, Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York, pp. 23–50.

    Chapter  Google Scholar 

  • Wylie, A. (2000). Questions of evidence, legitimacy, and the (dis)unity of science. American Antiquity 65: 227–237.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Wylie, A. (2002a). Archaeological cables and tacking: Beyond objectivism and relativism. In Wylie, A. (ed.), Thinking from Things: Essays in the Philosophy of Archaeology, University of California Press, Berkeley, pp. 161–167.

    Google Scholar 

  • Wylie, A. (2002b). Ethical dilemmas in archaeological practice: The (trans)formation of disciplinary identity. In Wylie, A. (ed.), Thinking from Things: Essays in the Philosophy of Archaeology, University of California Press, Berkeley, pp. 229–246.

    Google Scholar 

Download references

Acknowledgments

The title of this paper incorporates a comment by Michael Wilcox (2010, p. 224), that “artifacts, features, and human remains do not “speak back” in the same way that ethnographic subjects do.” I would like to thank a number of people for providing comments on various drafts of this paper, including Jeff Boyer, Mark E. Harlan, David V. Hill, Styve Homnick, Rosalind Hunter-Anderson, Robert McGhee, Alison E. Rautman, Michael B. Schiffer, and various anonymous reviewers. I alone am responsible for its content.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Deni J. Seymour.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Seymour, D.J. When Data Speak Back: Resolving Source Conflict in Apache Residential and Fire-Making Behavior. Int J Histor Archaeol 16, 828–849 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10761-012-0204-z

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10761-012-0204-z

Keywords

Navigation