Setting Goals and Measuring Success: Linking Patterns and Processes in Stream Restoration
10.1007/s10750-005-1512-7 Cite this article as: Ryder, D.S. & Miller, W. Hydrobiologia (2005) 552: 147. doi:10.1007/s10750-005-1512-7 Abstract
Successful stream restoration requires the setting of appropriate goals and an ability to measure restoration success using quantitative ecological indicators. At present, a dichotomy exists between the setting of restoration goals to enhance ecosystem ‘processes’ or ‘functions’ such as sustainability, and measuring the success of these goals using ‘patterns’ or ‘structural’ ecosystem attributes. The presence of a structural facade may be no indication of a viable ecosystem as this requires evaluation of whether key ecosystem processes have been restored and whether the system is ecologically sustainable. We briefly discuss the benefits and drawbacks associated with setting restoration goals and measuring their success based on ecosystem patterns and processes. Two case studies are provided based on measurements of biofilm chlorophyll
a and Dissolved Organic Carbon (DOC) to debunk the myth that these structural variables can be used as surrogates for ecosystem processes of productivity and respiration in rivers. We suggest that the discipline of restoration ecology will benefit and grow from a greater appreciation of the functional role of biological communities within stream ecosystems, and from targeting some restoration towards the re-establishment of structurally significant species and functionally significant processes. This approach to stream restoration with a well-founded conceptual base and defined scientific and management goals should expand our knowledge of stream function and contribute to the effective restoration of stream systems. Keywords restoration ecosystem structure ecosystem function river biofilm DOC References Bott, T. L., Kaplan, L. A. 1985 Bacterial biomass, metabolic state, and activity in stream sediments: relation to environmental variables and multiple assay comparisons Applied and Environmental Microbiology 50 508 522 Google Scholar Boulton, A. J. 1999 An overview of river health assessment: philosophies, practice, problems and prognosis Freshwater Biology 41 469 479 CrossRef Google Scholar Bunn, S. E., Davies, P. M. 2000 Biological processes in running waters and their implications for the assessment of ecological integrity Hydrobiologia 422/423 61 70 CrossRef Google Scholar Bunn, S. E., Davies, P. M., Mosisch, T. D. 1999 Ecosystem measures of river health and their response to riparian and catchment degradation Freshwater Biology 41 333 345 CrossRef Google Scholar Burns, A., Ryder, D. S. 2001a The emergence of biofilms as a monitoring tool in Australian riverine systems Ecological Restoration and Management 2 53 63 CrossRef Google Scholar Burns, A., Ryder, D. S. 2001b Response of bacterial extracellular enzymes to inundation of floodplain sediments Freshwater Biology 46 1299 1307 CrossRef Google Scholar Cairns, J., Jr 2000 Setting ecological restoration goals for technical feasibility and scientific validity Ecological Engineering 15 171 180 CrossRef Google Scholar Chapman, M. G., Underwood, A. J. 2000 The need for practical scientific protocols to measure successful restoration Wetlands (Australia) 19 28 49 Google Scholar Chròst, R. J. 1991 Environmental control of the synthesis and activity of aquatic microbial ectoenzymes Chròst, R.J. eds. Microbial Enzymes in Aquatic Environments Springer-Verlag New York 25 29 Google Scholar Claret, C., Boulton, A. J., Dole-Olivier, M.-J., Marmonier, P. 2001 Functional processes versus state variables: interstitial organic matter pathways in floodplain habitats Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 58 1594 1602 CrossRef Google Scholar Clarke, K. R., Warwick, R. M. 2001Change in Marine Communities: an Approach to Statistical Analysis and Interpretation2 PRIMER-E Plymouth Google Scholar Dahm, C. N., Grimm, N. B., Marmonier, P., Valett, H. M., Vervier, P. 1998 Nutrient dynamics at the interface between surface waters and groundwaters Freshwater Biology 40 427 451 CrossRef Google Scholar Dole-Olivier, M.-J., Marmonier, P., Creuzé des Châtelliers, M., Martin, D. 1994 Interstitial fauna associated with the alluvial floodplains of the Rhône River (France) Gibert, J. Danielopol, D. L. Stanford, J. A. eds. Groundwater Ecology Academic Press San Diego 313 347 Google Scholar Duffy, J. E. 2002 Biodiversity and ecosystem function: the consumer connection Oikos 99 201 219 CrossRef Google Scholar Dynesius, M., Nilsson, C. 1994 Fragmentation and flow regulation of river systems in the northern third of the world Science 266 753 762 Google Scholar Ehrenfeld, J. G. 2000 Defining the limits of restoration: the need for realistic goals Restoration Ecology 8 2 9 CrossRef Google Scholar Findlay, S., Hickey, C. W., Quinn, J. M. 1997 Microbial enzymatic response to catchment-scale variations in supply of dissolved organic carbon New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 31 701 706 Google Scholar Findlay, S., Sinsabaugh, R. L. 1999 Unravelling the sources and bioavailability of dissolved organic matter in lotic aquatic ecosystems Marine and Freshwater Research 50 781 790 CrossRef Google Scholar Findlay, S. E. G., Kiviat, E., Nieder, W. C., Blair, E. A. 2002 Functional assessment of a reference wetland set as a tool for science, management and restoration Aquatic Sciences 64 107 117 CrossRef Google Scholar French-McCay, D. P., Peterson, C. H., DeAlteris, J. T., Catena, J. 2003 Restoration that targets function as opposed to structure: replacing lost bivalve production and filtration Marine Ecology Progress Series 264 197 212 Google Scholar Gessner, M. O., Chauvet, E. 2002 A case for using litter breakdown to assess functional stream integrity Ecological Applications 12 498 510 Google Scholar Gessner, M. O., Inchausti, P., Persson, L., Raffaelli, D. G., Giller, P. S. 2004 Biodiversity effects on ecosystem functioning: insights from aquatic systems Oikos 104 419 422 CrossRef Google Scholar Giller, P. S., Hillebrand, H., Berninger, U.-G., Gessner, M. O., Hawkins, S., Inchausti, P., Inglis, C., Leslie, H., Malmqvist, B., Monaghan, T., Morin, P. J., O’Mullan, G. 2004 Biodiversity effects on ecosystem functioning: emerging issues and their experimental test in aquatic environments Oikos 104 423 436 CrossRef Google Scholar Goldstein, P. Z. 1999 Functional ecosystems and biodiversity buzzwords Conservation Biology 13 247 255 CrossRef Google Scholar Grayson, J. E., Chapman, M. G., Underwood, A. J. 1999 The assessment of restoration of habitat in urban wetlands Landscape and Urban Planning 43 227 236 CrossRef Google Scholar Hackney, C. T. 2000 Restoration of coastal habitats: expectation and reality Ecological Engineering 15 165 170 CrossRef Google Scholar Hobbs, R. J. 2003 Ecological management and restoration: Assessment, setting goals and measuring success Ecological Management and Restoration (Supplement) 4 S2 3 CrossRef Google Scholar Hobbs, R. J., Harris, J. A. 2001 Restoration ecology: repairing the Earth’s ecosystems in the new millennium Restoration Ecology 9 239 246 CrossRef Google Scholar Hobbs, R. J., Norton, D. A. 1996 Towards a conceptual framework for restoration ecology Restoration Ecology 4 93 110 Google Scholar Karr, J. R. 1996 Ecological integrity and ecological health are not the same Schulze, P.C. eds. Engineering with Ecological Constraints National Academy Press Washington, DC 97 109 Google Scholar Karr, J. R. 1999 Defining and measuring river health Freshwater Biology 41 221 234 CrossRef Google Scholar Keddy, P. 1999 Wetland restoration: the potential for assembly rules in the service of restoration Wetlands 19 716 732 Google Scholar Kentula, M. E. 2000 Perspectives on setting success criteria for wetland restoration Ecological Engineering 15 199 209 CrossRef Google Scholar Ladson, A., Tilleard, J., Ewing, S., Stewardson, M., Rutherford, I. 1999 Successful stream rehabilitation: first set the goals Rutherfurd, I. Bartley, R. eds. Proceedings of the Second Australian Stream Management Conference CRC for Catchment Hydrology Melbourne 381 387 Google Scholar Lake, P. S. 2005 Perturbation, restoration and seeking ecological sustainability in Australian flowing waters Hydrobiologia 552 109 120 Google Scholar Loreau, M. 2000 Biodiversity and ecosystem functioning: recent theoretical advances Oikos 91 3 17 CrossRef Google Scholar McArthur, M. D., Richardson, J. S. 2002 Microbial utilization of dissolved organic carbon leached from riparian litterfall Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 59 1668 1676 CrossRef Google Scholar McKee, K. L., Faulkner, P. L. 2000 Restoration of biogeochemical function in mangrove forests Restoration Ecology 8 247 259 CrossRef Google Scholar Miller, W. M., Boulton, A. J. 2005 Managing and rehabilitating ecosystem processes in regional urban streams in Australia Hydrobiologia 552 121 133 Google Scholar Minshall, G. W. 1988 Stream ecosystem theory: a global perspective Journal of the North American Benthological Society 7 263 288 Google Scholar Mosisch, T. D., Bunn, S. E. 1997 Temporal patterns of rainforest stream epilithic algae in relation to flow-related disturbance Aquatic Botany 58 181 193 CrossRef Google Scholar Odum, E. P. 1969 The strategy of ecosystem development Science 164 262 270 PubMed Google Scholar Palmer, M. A., Poff, N. L. 1997 The influence of environmental heterogeneity on patterns and processes in streams Journal of the North American Benthological Society 16 169 173 Google Scholar Paul, M. J., Meyer, J. L. 2001 Streams in the urban landscape Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 32 333 365 CrossRef Google Scholar Pedroli, B., Blust, G., Looy, K., Rooij, S. 2002 Setting targets in strategies for river restoration Landscape Ecology 17 5 18 CrossRef Google Scholar Peterson, C. G. 1996 Response of benthic algal communities to natural physical disturbance Stevenson, R. J. Bothwell, M. L. Lowe, R. L. eds. Algal Ecology: Freshwater Benthic Ecosystems Academic Press San Diego 375 403 Google Scholar Poff, N. L., Allan, J. D., Bain, M. B., Karr, J. R., Prestegaard, K. L., Richter, B. D., Sparks, R. E., Stromberg, J. C. 1997 The natural flow regime: a paradigm for river conservation and restoration BioScience 47 769 784 Google Scholar Pratt, J. R., Cairns, J., Jr. 1996 Ecotoxicology and the redundancy problem: understanding effects of community structure and function Newman, M. C. Jagoe, C. H. eds. Ecotoxicology: A Hierarchical Treatment Lewis Publishers New York 187 202 Google Scholar Ryder, D. S. 2004 Response of epixylic biofilm metabolism to water level variability in a regulated floodplain river Journal of the North American Benthological Society 23 214 223 CrossRef Google Scholar Simenstad, C. A., Thom, R. M. 1996 Functional equivalency trajectories of the restored Gog-Le-Hi-Te estuarine wetland Ecological Applications 6 39 56 Google Scholar
Society for Ecological Restoration Science and Policy Working Group, 2002. The SER Primer on Ecological Restoration. www.ser.org/.
Sutherland, L., D. S. Ryder & R. J. Watts, 2002. Ecological Assessment of Variable Flow Releases in the Mitta Mitta River, Victoria. Report to the Murray-Darling Basin Commission, Canberra.
Tett, P., Kelly, M. G., Hornberger, G. M. 1975 A method for the spectrophotometric measurement of chlorophyll a and pheophytin a in benthic microalgae Limnology and Oceanography 20 887 896 Google Scholar Tockner, K., Bretschko, G. 1996 Spatial distribution of particulate organic matter (POM) and benthic invertebrates in a river-floodplain transect (Danube, Austria): importance of hydrological connectivity Archiv für Hydrobiologie Supplementband 11 11 27 Google Scholar Walker, B. 1995 Conserving biological diversity through ecosystem resilience Conservation Biology 9 747 752 CrossRef Google Scholar Walsh, C. J., Breen, P. J. 1999 Urban stream rehabilitation through a decision-making framework to identify degrading processes and prioritise management actions Rutherfurd, I. Bartley, R. eds. Proceedings of the Second Australian Stream Management Conference CRC for Catchment Hydrology Melbourne 763 768 Google Scholar Ward, J. V. 1998 Riverine landscapes: Biodiversity patterns, disturbance regimes, and aquatic conservation Biological Conservation 83 269 78 CrossRef Google Scholar Ward, J. V., Tockner, K., Uehlinger, U., Malard, F. 2001 Understanding natural patterns and processes in river corridors as the basis for effective river restoration Regulated Rivers: Research, Management 17 311 323 Google Scholar Watts, R. J., Ryder, D. S. 2001 Developing biological indicators for the assessment of environmental flows Australian Journal of Water Resources 5 119 122 Google Scholar Wilkins, S., Keith, D. A., Adam, P. 2003 Measuring success: evaluating the restoration of a grassy eucalypt woodland on the Cumberland Plain, Sydney, Australia Restoration Ecology 11 489 503 CrossRef Google Scholar Williams, W. D. 1980An Ecological Basis for Water Resource Management ANU Press Canberra, Australia Google Scholar Williams, W. D. 2003Spaceship Earth Hardy Lewis, Adelaide Google Scholar Williams, W. D., Sládecková, A. 1997Water as a Limiting Resource: Conservation and Management International Association of Theoretical and Applied Limnology Stuttgart Google Scholar Zedler, J. B. 1996 Coastal mitigation in southern California: the need for a regional restoration strategy Ecological Applications 6 84 93 Google Scholar