Abstract
The multiple species concepts currently in use by the scientific community (e.g. Morphological, Biological, Phylogenetic) are united in that they all aim to capture the process of divergence between populations. For example, the Biological Species Concept defines a species as a natural group of organisms that is reproductively isolated from other such groups. Here we synthesize nearly a century of research on the ciliate genus Paramecium that highlights the shortcomings of our prevailing notions on the nature of species. In this lineage, there is discordance between morphology, mating behavior, and genetics, features assumed to be correlated, at least after sufficient time has passed, under all species concepts. Intriguingly, epigenetic phenomena are well documented in ciliates where they influence features such as germline/soma differentiation and mating type determination. Consequently, we hypothesize that divergence within ciliate populations is due to a dynamic interaction between genetic and epigenetic factors. The growing list of examples of epigenetic phenomena that potentially impact speciation (i.e. by influencing the dynamics of sex chromosomes, fate of hybrids, zygotic drive and genomic conflicts) suggests that interactions between genetics and epigenetics may also drive divergence in other eukaryotic lineages.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ainouche ML, Jenczewski E (2010) Focus on polyploidy. New Phytol 186:1–4
Allen SL, Farrow SW, Golembiewski PA (1973) Esterase variations between the 14 syngens of Paramecium aurelia under axenic growth. Genetics 73:561–573
Allen SL, Adams J, Rushford CL (1983) Interspecies relationships in the Paramecium aurelia complex: acid phosphatase variation. J Eukaryot Microbiol 30(1):143–147
Barnett A (1966) A circadian rhythm of mating type reversals in Paramecium multimicronucleatum, syngen 2, and its genetic control. J Cell Physiol 67(2):239–270
Beale GH, Preer JR Jr (2008a) Chapter 5: the determination of mating types in Paramecium. Paramecium: genetics and epigenetics. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 51–62
Beale GH, Preer JR Jr (2008b) Chapter 12: Epigenetics. Paramecium: genetics and epigenetics. CRC Press, Boca Raton, pp 175–182
Bleyman L (1996) Ciliate genetics. In: Hausmann K, Bradbury PC (eds) Ciliates: cells as organisms. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart, pp 291–324
Brown JD, O’Neill RJ (2010) Chromosomes, conflicts, and epigenetics: chromosomal speciation revisited. Annu Rev Genom Human Genet 11:291–316
Catania F, Wurmser F, Potehkin AA, Pryzboś E, Lynch M (2009) Genetic diversity in the Paramecium aurelia species complex. Mol Biol Evol 26(2):421–431
Coleman AW (2005) Paramecium aurelia revisited. J Eukaryot Microbiol 52(1):68–77
Coyne RS, Chalker DL, Yao M-C (1996) Genome downsizing during ciliate development: nuclear division of labor through chromosome restructuring. Annu Rev Genet 30:557–578
de Queiroz K (2007) Species concepts and species delimitation. Syst Biol 56(6):876–886
Dobzhansky T (1940) Speciation as a stage in evolutionary divergence. Am Nat 74:312–321
Donoghue MJ (1985) A critique of the biological species concept and recommendations for a phylogenetic alternative. Bryologist 88(3):172–181
Giraud T, Refrégier G, Le Gac M, de Vienne DM, Hood ME (2008) Speciation in fungi. Fungal Genet Biol 45:791–802
Harrison RG (1998) Linking evolutionary pattern and process: the relevance of species concepts for the study of speciation. In: Howard DJ, Berlocher SH (eds) Endless forms: species and speciation. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 19–31
Hegarty MJ, Batstone T, Barker GL, Edwards KJ, Abbott RJ, Hiscock SJ (2011) Nonadditive changes to cytosine methylation as a consequence of hybridization and genome duplication in Senecio (Asteraceae). Mol Ecol 20(1):105–113
Hey J (2006) On the failure of modern species concepts. Trends Ecol Evol 21(8):447–450
Hori M, Tomikawa I, Pryzboś E, Fujishima M (2006) Comparison of the evolutionary distances among syngens and sibling species of Paramecium. Mol Phylogenet Evol 38:697–704
Jennings HS, Raffel D, Lynch RS, Sonneborn TM (1932) The diverse biotypes produced by conjugation within a clone of Paramecium aurelia. J Exper Zool 62(2):363–408
Juranek SA, Lipps HJ (2007) New insights into the macronuclear development in ciliates. Int Rev Cytol 262:219–251
Lolle SJ, Victor JL, Young JM, Pruitt RE (2005) Genome-wide non-mendelian inheritance of extra-genomic information in Arabidopsis. Nature 434:505–509
Lynn DH (1996) Systematics of ciliates. In: Hausmann K, Bradbury PC (eds) Ciliates: cells as organisms. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart, pp 51–72
Mayden RL (2002) On biological species, species concepts and individuation in the natural world. Fish Fish 3:171–196
Mayr E (1942) Systematics and the origin of species from the viewpoint of a zoologist. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, p xxi
Mayr E (1996) What is a species, and what is not? Philos Sci 63(2):262–277
Mayr E, Provine WB (1981) The evolutionary synthesis. B Am Acad Arts Sci 34(8):17–32
McGrath CL, Zufall RA, Katz LA (2006) Ciliate genome evolution. In: Katz LA, Bhattacharya D (eds) Genomics and evolution in microbial eukaryotes. Oxford University Press, New York, pp 64–77
McManus GB, Katz LA (2009) Molecular and morphological methods for identifying plankton: what makes a successful marriage? J Plank Research 31:1119–1129
Meiklejohn CD, Tao Y (2009) Genetic conflict and sex chromosome evolution. Trends Ecol Evol 25(4):215–223
Meyer E, Chalker DL (2007) Epigenetics of ciliates. In: Allis CD, Jenuwein T, Reinberg D, Caperros M-L (eds) Epigenetics. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor, pp 127–150
Mishler BD, Donoghue MJ (1982) Species concepts: a case for pluralism. Syst Zool 31(4):491–503
Miyake A (1996) Fertilization and sexuality in ciliates. In: Hausmann K, Bradbury PC (eds) Ciliates: cells as organisms. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart, pp 243–290
Nanney DL (1960) Temperature effects on nuclear differentiation in variety 1 of Tetrahymena pyriformis. Physiol Zool 33(2):146–151
Orias E (1981) Probable somatic DNA rearrangements in mating type determination in Tetrahymena thermophila: a review and a model. Devel Genet 2:185–202
Parfrey LW, Katz LA (2010) Dynamic genomes of eukaryotes and the maintenance of genomic integrity. Microbe 5(4):156–163
Paulin JJ (1996) Morphology and cytology of ciliates. In: Hausmann K, Bradbury PC (eds) Ciliates: cells as organisms. Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart, pp 1–40
Phadke SS, Zufall RA (2009) Rapid diversification of mating systems in ciliates. Biol J Linn Soc 98:187–197
Preer JR Jr (2000) Epigenetic mechanisms affecting macronuclear development in Paramecium and Tetrahymena. J Eukaryot Microbiol 47(6):515–524
Pryzboś E, Prajer M, Greczek-Stachura M, Skotarczak B, Maciejewska A, Tarcz S (2007) Genetic analysis of the Paramecium aurelia species complex (Protozoa: Ciliophora) by classical and molecular methods. Syst Biodivers 5(4):417–434
Rassoulzadegan M, Grandjean V, Gounon P, Vincent S, Gillot I, Cuzin F (2006) RNA-mediated non-mendelian inheritance of an epigenetic change in the mouse. Nature 441:469–474
Rebollo R, Horard B, Hubert B, Vieira C (2010) Jumping genes and epigenetics: towards new species. Gene 454:1–7
Rice WR, Gavrilets S, Friberg U (2008) Sexually antagonistic “zygotic drive” of the sex chromosomes. PLOS Genet. doi:10.1371/journal.pgen.1000313
Schlegel M, Meisterfeld R (2003) The species problem in protozoa revisited. Europ J Protistol 39:349–355
Schloegel JJ (1999) From anomaly to unification: Tracy Sonneborn and the species problem in protozoa, 1954–1957. J Hist Biol 23(1):93–132
Sonneborn TM (1937) Sex, sex inheritance and sex determination in Paramecium aurelia. Proc Nat Acad Sci 23(7):378–385
Sonneborn TM (1938) Mating types in Paramecium aurelia: diverse conditions for mating in different stocks; occurrence, number and interrelations of the types. P Am Philos Soc 79(3):411–434
Sonneborn TM (1957a) Breeding systems, reproductive methods, and species problems in protozoa. In: Mayr E (ed) The species problem. American Association for the Advancement of Science, Washington DC, pp 155–324
Sonneborn TM (1957b) Diurnal change of mating type in Paramecium. Anat Rec 128:626
Sonneborn TM (1975) The Paramecium aurelia complex of fourteen sibling species. T Am Microsc Soc 94(2):155–178
Sonneborn TM, Lynch RS (1932) Racial differences in the early physiological effects of conjugation in Paramecium aurelia. Biol Bull 62(3):258–293
Sonneborn TM, Lynch RS (1934) Hybridization and segregation in Paramecium aurelia. J Exper Zool 67(1):1–72
Tait A (1970) Enzyme variation between syngens in Paramecium Aurelia. Biochem Genet 4(4):461–470
Yao M-C, Duharcourt S, Chalker DL (2002) Genome-wide rearrangements of DNA in ciliates. In: Craig NL, Craigie R, Gellert M, Lambowitz A (eds) Mobile DNA II. ASM Press, Washington DC, pp 730–758
Zufall RA, McGrath CL, Muse SV, Katz LA (2006) Genome architecture drives protein evolution in ciliates. Mol Biol Evol 23(9):1681–1687
Acknowledgments
L. A. K. is extremely grateful to R.G. Harrison for the excellent training and continued support. L. A. K. is also supported by grants from the National Science Foundation (DEB RUI:0919152, DEB 043115, DEB 0816828) and National Institutes of Health (1R15GM081865-01).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hall, M.S., Katz, L.A. On the nature of species: insights from Paramecium and other ciliates. Genetica 139, 677–684 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10709-011-9571-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10709-011-9571-3