Abstract
The evolution of molecules, developmental circuits, and new species are all characterized by the accumulation of incompatibilities between ancestors and descendants. When specific interactions between components are necessary at any of these levels, this requires compensatory coevolution. Theoretical treatments of compensatory evolution that only consider the endpoints predict that it should be rare because intermediate states are deleterious. However, empirical data suggest that compensatory evolution is common at all levels of molecular interaction. A general solution to this paradox is provided by plausible neutral or nearly neutral intermediates that possess informational redundancy. These intermediates provide an evolutionary path between coadapted allelic combinations. Although they allow incompatible end points to evolve, at no point was a deleterious mutation ever in need of compensation. As a result, what appears to be compensatory evolution may often actually be “pseudocompensatory.” Both theoretical and empirical studies indicate that pseudocompensation can speed the evolution of intergenic incompatibility, especially when driven by adaptation. However, under strong stabilizing selection the rate of pseudocompensatory evolution is still significant. Important examples of this process at work discussed here include the evolution of rRNA secondary structures, intra- and inter-protein interactions, and developmental genetic pathways. Future empirical work in this area should focus on comparing the details of intra- and intergenic interactions in closely related organisms.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Atchley W, Wollenberg K, Fitch W, Terhalle W, Dress A (2000). Correlations among amino acid sites in bHLH protein domains: an information theoretic analysis. Mol Biol Evol 17:164–178
Barker J, Moth J (2001). Linkage maps of D. simulans: an update of Sturtevant (1929) with additional loci. Dros Inf Serv 84:205–206
Barton N. (1989). The divergence of a polygenic system subject to stabilizing selection, mutation, and drift. Gent Res Camb 54:59–77
Carter A, Wagner G (2002). Evolution of functionally conserved enhancers can be accelerated in large populations: a population-genetic model. Proc R Soc Lond B 269:953–960
Charlesworth D. (2000). How can two-gene models of self-incompatibility generate new specificities? Plant Cell 12:309–310
Chen R, Grobler J, Hurley J, Dean A (1996). Second-site suppression of regulatory phosphorylation in Escherichia coli isocitrate dehydrogenase. Protein Sci 5:287–295
Crick F, Barnett L, Brenner S, Watts-Tobin R. (1961). General nature of the genetic code for proteins. Nature 192:1227–1232
Fay D, Large E, Han M, Darland M (2003). lin-35/Rb and ubc-18, an E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme, function redundantly to control pharyngeal morphogenesis in C. elegans. Development 130:3319–3330
Force A, Lynch M, Pickett F, Amores A, Yan Y, Postlethwait J (1999). Preservation of duplicate genes by complementary, degenerative mutations. Genetics 151:1531–1545
Fraser H, Hirsh A, Steinmetz L, Scharfe C, Feldman M (2002). Evolutionary rate in the protein interaction network. Science 296:750–752
Gavrilets S. (1997). Evolution and speciation on holey adaptive landscapes. Trends Ecol Evol 12:307–312
Graustein A, Gaspar JM, Walters JR, Palopoli MF (2002). Levels of DNA polymorphism vary with mating system in the nematode genus Caenorhabditis. Genetics 161:99–107
Gutell R, Lee J, Cannone J (2002). The accuracy of ribosomal RNA comparative structure models. Curr Opin Struct Biol 12:301–310
Haag E, Ackerman A (2005) Intraspecific variation in fem-3and tra-2, two rapidly coevolving nematode sex-determining genes. Gene pp TBA
Haag E, Kimble J (2000). Regulatory elements required for development of C. elegans hermaphrodites are conserved in the tra-2 homologue of C. remanei, a male/female sister species. Genetics 155:105–116
Haag E, Molla M (2005) Compensatory evolution of interacting gene products through multifunctional intermediates. Evolution 59:1620–1632
Haag E, True J (2001). From mutants to mechanisms? Assessing the candidate gene paradigm in evolutionary biology. Evolution 55:1077–1084
Haag E, Wang S, Kimble J (2002). Rapid coevolution of the nematode sex-determining genes fem-3 and tra-2. Curr Biol 12:2035–2041
Haldane J. (1931). A mathematical theory of natural selection. Part VIII: metastable populations. Proc Camb Phil Soc 27:137–143
Haldane J (1932). The Causes of Evolution. Cornell Univ. Press, Ithaca, NY
Hellberg M, Moy G, Vacquier V (2000). Positive selection and propeptide repeats promote rapid interspecific divergence of a gastropod sperm protein. Mol Biol Evol 17:458–466
Hickson R, Simon C, Cooper A, Spicer G, Sullivan J, Penny D (1996). Conserved sequence motifs, alignment, and secondary structure for the third domain of animal 12S rRNA. Mol Biol Evol 13:150–169
Higgs P (1998). Compensatory neutral mutations and the evolution of RNA. Genetica 102/103:91–101
Hill R, Carvalho C, Salogiannis J, Schlager B, Pilgrim D, Haag E (2006) Genetic flexibility in the convergent evolution of hermaphroditism in Caenorhabditis nematodes. Dev Cell 10:531–538
Hirsch N, Zimmerman L, Grainger R (2002). Xenopus, the next generation: X. tropicalis genetics and genomics. Dev Dyn 225:422–433
Hodgkin J, Brenner S (1977). Mutations causing transformation of sexual phenotype in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans. Genetics 86:275–287
Johnson N, Porter A (2000). Speciation via parallel, directional selection on regulatory genetic pathways. J Theor Biol 205:527–542
Johnson NA, Porter AH (2006) Evolution of branched regulatory genetic pathways: directional selection on pleiotropic loci accelerates developmental system drift. Genetica (in␣press)
Jordan I, Wolf Y, Koonin E (2003). No simple dependence between protein evolution rate and the number of protein–protein interactions: only the most prolific interactors tend to evolve slowly. BMC Evol Biol 3:1–8
Kachroo A, Nasrallah M, Nasrallah J (2002). Self-incompatibility in the Brassicaceae: receptor-ligand signaling and cell–cell communication. Plant Cell 14(Suppl): S227–S238
Kachroo A, Schopfer C, Nasrallah M, Nasrallah J (2001). Allele-specific receptor-ligand interactions in Brassica self-incompatibility. Science 293:1824–1826
Kimura M (1983) The neutral theory of molecular evolution, Cambridge University Press
Kimura M (1985). The role of compensatory neutral mutations in molecular evolution. J Genet 64:7–19
Kondrashov A, Sunyaev S, Kondrashov F (2002). Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibilities in protein evolution. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99:14878–14883
Kresge N, Vacquier V, Stout D (2001). Abalone lysin: the dissolving and evolving sperm protein. BioEssays 23:95–103
Kuwabara PE (1996). Interspecies comparison reveals evolution of control regions in the nematode sex-determining gene tra-2. Genetics 144:597–607
Kuwabara PE, Shah S (1994). Cloning by synteny: identifying C. briggsae homologues of C. elegans genes. Nucleic Acids Res 22:4414–4418
LaMunyon C, Ward S (1997). Increased competitiveness of nematode sperm bearing the male X chromosome. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94:185–189
Ludwig M, Bergman C, Patel N, Kreitman M (2000). Evidence for stabilizing selection in a eukaryotic enhancer element. Nature 403:564–567
Ludwig M, Patel N, Kreitman M (1998). Functional analysis of eve stripe 2 enhancer evolution in Drosophila: rules governing conservation and change. Development 125:949–958
Lum D, Kuwabara P, Zarkower D, Spence A (2000). Direct protein–protein interaction between the intracellular domain of TRA-2 and the transcription factor TRA-1A modulates feminizing activity in C. elegans. Genes Dev 14:3153–3165
Lynch M, Force A (2000). The probability of duplicate gene preservation by subfunctionalization. Genetics 154:459–473
Lynch M, O’Hely M, Walsh B, Force A (2001). The probability of preservation of a newly arisen gene duplicate. Genetics 159:1789–1804
Matton D, Luu D, Xike Q, Bertrand C, Morse D, Cappadocia M (1999). The production of an S-RNase with dual specificity suggests a novel hypothesis for the generation of new S-alleles. Plant Cell 11:2087–2097
Mehra A, Gaudet J, Heck L, Kuwabara PE, Spence AM (1999). Negative regulation of male development in Caenorhabditis elegans by a protein–protein interaction between TRA-2A and FEM-3. Genes Dev 13:1453–1463
Michalakis Y, Slatkin M (1996). Interaction of selection and recombination in the fixation of negative-epistatic genes. Genet Res Camb 67:257–269
Morosyuk S, Lee K, Santalucia JJ, Cunningham P (2000). Structure and function of the conserved 690 hairpin in Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA: analysis of the stem nucleotides. J Mol Biol 300:113–126
Muse S (1995). Evolutionary analyses of DNA sequences subject to constraints of secondary structure. Genetics 139:1429–1439
Phillips P (1996). Waiting for a compensatory mutation: phase zero of the shifting-balance process. Genet Res Camb 67:271–283
Phillips P, Otto S, Whitlock M (2000) Beyond the Average. In: Wolf J, Brodie III ED, Wade MJ (eds) Epistasis and the Evolutionary Process. Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp20–38
Poteete A, Dao-Pin S, Nicholson H, Matthews B (1991). Second-site revertants of an inactive T4 lysozyme mutant restore activity by restructuring the active site cleft. Biochemistry 30:1425–1432
Rockman M, Wray G (2002). Abundant raw material for cis-regulatory evolution in humans. Mol Biol Evol 19:1991–2004
Romano L, Wray G (2003). Conservation of Endo16 expression in sea urchins despite evolutionary divergence in both cis and trans-acting componenets of transcriptional regulation. Development 130:4187–4199
Rousset F, Pelandakis M, Solignac M (1991). Evolution of compensatory substitutions through G:U intermediate stat in Drosophila rRNA. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88:10032–10036
Schierup M, Mable B, Awadalla P, Charlesworth D (2001) Identification and characterization of a polymorphic receptor kinase gene linked to the self-incompatibility locus of Arabidopsis lyrata. Genetics 158:387–399
Srinivasan J, Sinz W, Jesse T, Wiggers-Perebolte L, Jansen K, Buntjer J, van der Meulen M, Sommer R (2003) An integrated physical and genetic map of the nematode Pristionchus pacificus. Mol Genet Genomics 269:715–722
Stephan W (1996) The rate of compensatory evolution. Genetics 144:419–426
Stoltzfus A (1999) On the possibility of constructive neutral evolution. J Mol Evol 49:169–181
Stothard P, Pilgrim D (2003) Sex determination gene and pathway evolution in nematodes. BioEssays 25:221–231
Sturtevant A (1929) The genetics of Drosophila simulans. Carnegie Inst Wash Publ 339:50–61
Swanson W, Vacquier V (1995) Extraordinary divergence and positive Darwinian selection in a fusagenic protein coating the acrosomal process of abalone spermatozoa. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92:4957–4961
Swanson W, Vacquier V (2002) The rapid evolution of reproductive proteins. Nature Rev Gen 3:137–144
Tamarina N, Ludwig M, Richmond R (1997) Divergent and conserved features in the spatial expression of the Drosophila pseudoobscura esterase-5B gene and the esterase-6 gene of Drosophila melanogaster. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 94:7735–7741
True J, Haag E (2001) Developmental system drift and flexibility in evolutionary trajectories. Evol Dev 3:109–119
Uyenoyama M, Newbigin E (2000) Evolutionary dynamics of dual-specificity self-incompatibility alleles. Plant Cell 12:310–312
Uyenoyama M, Zhang Y, Newbigin E (2001) On the origin of self-incompatibility haplotypes: transition through self-compatible intermediates. Genetics 157:1805–1817
Wang S, Kimble J (2001) The TRA-1 transcription factor binds TRA-2 to regulate sexual fates in Caenorhabditis elegans. EMBO J 20:1363–1372
Watanabe M, Ito A, Takada Y, Ninomiya C, Kakizakia T, Takahata Y, Hatakeyama K, Hinata K, Suzuki G, Takasaki T, Satta Y, Shiba H, Takayama S, Isogai A (2000) Highly divergent sequences of the pollen self-incompatibility (S) gene in class-I S haplotypes of Brassica campestris (syn. rapa) L. FEBS Lett 473:139–144
Waterston R, Lindblad-Toh K, Birney E, a. m. o. o. t. M.G.S. Consortium. (2002) Initial sequencing and comparative analysis of the mouse genome. Nature 420:520–562
Wilkins A (2002) The Evolution of Developmental Pathways. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA
Wollenberg K, Atchley W (2000) Separation of phylogenetic and functional associations in biological sequences by using the parametric bootstrap. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:3288–3291
Wray G, Hahn M, Abouheif E, Balhoff J, Pizer M, Rockman M, Romano L (2003) The evolution of transcriptional regulation in eukaryotes. Mol Biol Evol 20:1377–1419
Zhang J, Rosenberg H (2002) Complementary advantageous substitutions in the evolution of an antiviral RNase of higher primates. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99:5486–5491
Zuckerkandl E (1965) The evolution of hemoglobin. Sci Am. 212:110–118
Acknowledgements
The author thanks Arlin Stoltzfus for excellent conversations, and Allan Force and Norman Johnson for sharing relevant unpublished manuscripts. This work was supported from startup funds from the University of Maryland and an RE Powe, Jr. Faculty Enhancement Award from the Oak Ridge Associated Universities.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Haag, E.S. Compensatory vs. pseudocompensatory evolution in molecular and developmental interactions. Genetica 129, 45–55 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10709-006-0032-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10709-006-0032-3