Keeping the ‘Lady’ Safe: The Regulation of Femininity through Crime Prevention Literature
Cite this article as: Campbell, A. Crit Crim (2005) 13: 119. doi:10.1007/s10612-005-2390-z Abstract
Rape and the fear of rape have been understood by numerous feminists as an ideological weapon used by men to subordinate women. This paper argues that this analysis of power is overly reductive. The omnipresent threat of rape for women encourages them to engage in multiple ‘safe-keeping’ acts which have come to be a performative condition of normative femininity. These restrictive bodily acts (not dressing in certain ways, avoiding certain public locales) promoted through some strands of rape prevention literature, are not merely a reaction to the reality of rape, rather, these advisory narratives unwittingly operate to install rape as a fixed reality. Rape prevention literature (re)produces gendered bodies – the vulnerable/indefensible feminine and the potent/unstoppable masculine – which does not disrupt the possibility of rape, more exactly, it makes rape seem evermore inevitable and unstoppable.
About Women and Marketing, 1/31/1996 9(7), 1–3. On-line http://www.aardvarc.org/ Bart, P., Beneke, T. 1982Men on Rape St. Martin’s Press New York Google Scholar Bohmer, C., Parrot, A. 1993Sexual Assault on Campus: The Problem and the Solution Macmillan New York Google Scholar Bordo, S. 1991 Docile bodies, rebellious bodies: foucauldian perspectives on female psychopathology Hugh, Silverman eds. Writing the Politics of Difference SUNY Press New York Google Scholar Brantingham, Patricia L., Brantingham, Paul J. 1990 Situational crime prevention in practice Canadian Journal of Criminology 32 17 40 Google Scholar Butler, J. 1990Gender Trouble: Subversion and Identity Routledge London and New York Google Scholar Butler, J. 1993Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of Sex Routledge New York Google Scholar Cahill, A. 2001Rethinking Rape Cornell University Press Ithaca Google Scholar Clarke, R.V., Felson, M. 1993Routine activity and rational choice, Advances in Criminology Theory, Vol. 5 Transaction Publishers, Inc New Brunswick Google Scholar Clarke, R., Mayhew, P. 1980Designing Out Crime Home Office London Google Scholar Cohen, L.E., Felson, M. 1979 Social change and crime rate trends: a routine activities approach American Sociological Review 44 588 605 Google Scholar
Cosmopolitan (2000). September
Craven, D. 1997Sex Differences in Violent Victimization US Department of Justice Washington Google Scholar Dekeseredy, W., Burshtyn, H., Gordon, C. 1992 Taking woman abuse seriously: a critical response to the solicitor general of Canada’s crime prevention advice International Review of Victimology 2 157 167 Google Scholar Dowling, C. 2000The Frailty Myth: Redefining the Physical Potential of Women and Girls Random House Trade Paperbacks New York Google Scholar Fausto-Sterling, A. 2000Sexing the Body: Gender Politics and the Construction of Sexuality Basic Books New York Google Scholar Foucault, M. 1977Discipline and Punish Penguin London Google Scholar Gardner, C. 1990 Safe conduct: women, crime, and self in public places Social Problems 37 311 328 Google Scholar Gauntlett, D. 2002Media, Gender, and Identity: An Introduction Routledge London and New York Google Scholar Gerbner, G., Gross, L., Morgan, M., Signorelli, N. 1980Violence Profile No 11: Trends in Network Television Drama and Viewer Conceptions of Social Reality 1967–1979 The Annenberg School of Communications, University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, PA Google Scholar
Grauerholz, E. (1989). The Repeated Crime of Intra-Familial Rape. North Central Sociological Association
Grosz, E. 1994Volatile Bodies: Towards a Corporeal Feminism Indiana University Press Bloomington Google Scholar Grosz, E. 1995Space, Time, and Perversion Routledge London Google Scholar
Haber, H. (1996). Body politics and the muscled woman. In S. Hekman (ed.),
Feminist Interpretations of Michel Foucault. Pennsylvania State University Press, pp. 135–158 Hanmer, J., Saunders, S. 1984Well-Founded Fear Hutchinson London Google Scholar Hollander, J. 2004 ‘I can Take Care of Myself’. The impact of self-defence training on women’s lives Violence Against Women 103 205 235 CrossRef Google Scholar Jewkes, R. 2002 Intimate partner violence: causes and prevention The Lancet 359 9315 Google Scholar Kapur, R. 2002 The tragedy of victimization rhetoric: resurrecting the native in international/post-colonial feminist legal politics Harvard Human Rights Journal 15 1 37 Google Scholar Kilpatrick, D., Edmunds, C., Seymour, A. 1992Rape in America: A Report to the Nation National Victim Centre Arlington, VA Google Scholar Lauritsen, J., Schaum, R. 2004 The social ecology of violence against women Criminology 42 2 323 Google Scholar MacKinnon, C. 1987Feminism Unmodified: Discourses on Life and Law Harvard University Press Cambridge Google Scholar Madden Margaret, E., Sokol, Thomas J. 1997 Teaching women self-defence: pedagogical issues Feminist Teacher 11 133 151 Google Scholar Madden, M., Sokol, T. 1997 Teaching women self-defence: pedagogical issues Feminist Teacher 11 133 158 Google Scholar Madriz, E. 1997Nothing Bad Happens to Good Girls: Fear of Crime in Women’s Lives University of California Press Berkeley and London Google Scholar Marcus, S. 1992 Fighting Bodies, Fighting Words: A Theory of Politics of Rape Prevention Butler, J. Scott, J. eds. Feminists Theorize the Political Routledge London 385 403 Google Scholar Mawby, R., Walkgate, S. 1994Critical Victimology Sage London Google Scholar Mynatt, C., Allgeier, E. 1990 Risk factors, self-attributions, and adjustment problems among victims of sexual coercion Journal of Applied Social Psychology 20 130 153 Google Scholar Naffine, N. 1997Feminism and Criminology Polity Press Cambridge Google Scholar O’Malley, P. 1996 Risk and Responsibility Barry, T. Osborne, A. Rose, N. eds. Foucault and Political Reason UCL Press London Google Scholar Pineau, L. 1989 Date rape: a feminist analysis Law and Philosophy 8 217 43 CrossRef Google Scholar Rabinow, P. 1991The Foucault Reader Penguin London Google Scholar
Radford, J. (1987). Policing male violence. In J. Hanmer and Maynard M. (eds),
Women, Violence and Social Control. Macmillan, pp. 30–45 Rich, A. 1980 Compulsory heterosexuality and the lesbian existence Simpson, C. Spector, E. eds. Women: Sex and Sexuality Chicago University Press Chicago 62 91 Google Scholar Sanders, W. 1980Rape and Women’s Identity Sage Publications Beverley Hills Google Scholar Stanko, E. 1990 When precaution is normal Gelsthorpe, L. Morris, A. eds. Feminist Approaches in Criminology Open University Press Milton Keynes Google Scholar
Storey, J. (1993).
An Introductory Guide to Cultural Theory and Popular Culture Tewksbury, R., Musatine, , Ehrhardt, E. 2001 Lifestyle factors associated with the sexual assault of men: a routine activity theory analysis The Journal of Men’s Studies 9 153 178 Google Scholar The Suzy Lamplugh Trust 1999Living Safely: Personal Safety in Your Everyday Life The Suzy Lamplugh Trust London Google Scholar Thornhill, R., Palmer, C. 2000A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion MIT Press Cambridge Google Scholar Sanday, P. 1981 The social context of rape: a cross cultural study Journal of Social Issues 37 5 27 Google Scholar
Shugart, H. (1994). The Missing Text: Rape and Women’s Sexuality in Women and Language, Vol. 17, 1st March
Ullman, S., Knight, R. 1992 Fighting back: women’s resistance to rape Journal of Interpersonal Violence 7 31 43 Google Scholar Warr, M. 1985 Fear of rape among urban women Social Problems 32 238 250 Google Scholar White, J., Post, L. 2003 Understanding Rape: A Metatheoretical Framework Travis, C. eds. Evolution, Gender and Rape MIT Press Massachusetts Google Scholar
Widom, C. and Maxfield, M. (1984).
Sex roles and the victimization of women: evidence from the British Crime Survey
Wood, J. (1999). That wasn’t the real him.
Communication Quarterly 7(3)