Judicial oversight of policing: investigations, evidence and the exclusionary rule
First Online: 12 February 2011 DOI:
Cite this article as: Daly, Y.M. Crime Law Soc Change (2011) 55: 199. doi:10.1007/s10611-011-9279-4 Abstract
Police procedures and practices in the investigation of crime are shaped by many things. One particularly important constituent part of the development of investigative procedures and practices is the approach of the courts to the admissibility at trial of evidence obtained in a certain manner. While a judge can only address the specifics of whatever cases are brought before him, the judiciary as a whole have a significant role to play in terms of police accountability and governance through their development and application of any exclusionary rules of criminal evidence. This article examines the judicial oversight of policing by way of the exclusion of improperly obtained evidence at trial. Its central focus is on the development and operation of the exclusionary rule in Ireland, though relevant law in other jurisdictions, including England and Wales, the United States, Canada and New Zealand, is also considered. Particular attention is paid to the recent Irish Supreme Court decision of DPP v Cash, and its ramifications for judicial oversight of policing.
Dr. Yvonne Marie Daly is currently a visiting researcher at the Faculty of Law, University of Auckland, New Zealand.
Balance in the Criminal Law Review Group. (2007).
Final Report. Dublin.
Choo, A. L.-T., & Nash, S. (2003). Evidence law in England and Wales: the impact of the Human Rights Act 1998.
International Journal of Evidence & Proof, 7
Choo, A. L-T., & Nash, S. (1999). What’s the matter with section 78?
Criminal Law Review, December, pp 929–940.
Consedine, S. (2004). R v Shaheed: the first twenty months.
Canterbury Law Review, 10
Conway, V., Daly, Y. M., & Schweppe, J. (2010).
Irish criminal justice: Theory practice and procedure
. Dublin: Clarus.
Criminal Justice Act, 1984.
Criminal Justice Act, 1984 (Treatment of Persons in Custody in Garda Síochána Stations) Regulations, 1987.
Criminal Justice Act, 2007.
Criminal Justice (Drug Trafficking) Act, 1996.
Criminal Justice (Forensic Evidence and DNA Database System) Bill 2010.
Daly, Y. M. (2006). Does the buck stop here?: an examination of the pre-trial right to legal advice in light of O’Brien v D.P.P.
Dublin University Law Journal, 28
Daly, Y. M. (2009). Unconstitutionally obtained evidence in Ireland: protectionism, deterrence and the winds of change.
Irish Criminal Law Journal, 19
Dripps, D. (2001). The case for the contingent exclusionary rule.
American Criminal Law Review, 38
Fennell, C. (2009).
The law of evidence in Ireland
(3rd ed.). Dublin: Bloomsbury Professional, Chapter 4.
Heffernan, L. (2009). DNA and fingerprint data retention: S. and Marper v United Kingdom.
European Law Review, 34
Kamisar, Y. (2003). In defense of the search and seizure exclusionary rule.
Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, 26
Keane, A. (2008).
The modern law of evidence
(7th ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Law Reform Commission. (2004).
Consultation Paper on the Establishment of a DNA Database. Dublin: LRC CP29-2004.
Leahy, E. (1995). Genetic profiling and the reasonable doubt.
Medico-Legal Journal of Ireland, 1
Martin, F. (1992). The rationale of the exclusionary rule of evidence revisited.
Irish Criminal Law Journal, 2
McGrath, D. (2004). The exclusionary rule in respect of unconstitutionally obtained evidence.
Dublin University Law Journal., 26
McGrath, D. (2005).
. Dublin: Thomson Round Hall, Chapter 7.
Misuse of Drugs Act 1977.
New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, 1990.
O’Malley, T. (2009).
The criminal process
. Dublin: Round Hall, Chapter 19.
Optican, S. (2004). The new exclusionary rule: interpretation and application of R v Shaheed.
New Zealand Law Review, 3
Optican, S., & Sankoff, P. (2003). The new exclusionary rule: a preliminary assessment of R v Shaheed.
New Zealand Law Review, 1
Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.
Police and Criminal Evidence Act, 1984 Code of Practice for the Detention, Treatment and Questioning of Persons by Police Officers (Code of Practice C).
Sklansky, D. A. (2007–2008). Is the exclusionary rule obsolete?
Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, 5(2), 567–584.
Walsh, D. (2002).
. Dublin: Thomson Round Hall, Chapter 9.
Google Scholar Copyright information
© Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011