Abstract
This paper presents a comparative analysis of three American (Enron, WorldCom and HealthSouth) and three European (Parmalat, Royal Ahold and Vivendi Universal) corporate failures. The first part of the analysis is based on a theoretical framework including six areas of ethical climate; tone at the top; bubble economy and market pressure; fraudulent financial reporting; accountability, control, auditing, and governance; and management compensation. The second and third parts consider the analysis of these cases from fraud perspective and in terms of firm-specific characteristics (ownership structure) and environmental context (coverage in media and academic literature, regulatory and corporate governance frameworks). The research analyses shed light on the fact that, despite major differences between Europe and U.S. in terms of political institutions, laws and regulations as well as managerial practices, there are significant similarities between six groups. The analysis also demonstrates that, the ethical dilemma has been coupled with ineffective boards, inefficient corporate governance and control mechanisms, distorted incentive schemes, accounting irregularities, failure of auditors, dominant CEOs, dysfunctional management behavior and the lack of a sound ethical tone at the top. Significant similarities were also observed in the analysis from the fraud triangle perspective. However, there are several major differences between the six corporate failure cases particularly with regard to ownership structure, coverage in media, and legal, regulatory and governance frameworks. This research study may have several academic and practical contributions, particularly because of multidisciplinary, international features, and comparative analyses used in the paper.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Emphases are ours.
Ibid.
Reported earnings include all charges except those related to discontinued operations, the impact of cumulative accounting changes, and extraordinary items, as defined by accounting standards.
The measure of operating earnings focuses on the earnings from a company’s principal operations, with the goal of making the numbers comparable across different time periods. The use of this measure seems to come from internal management controls used when a business unit manager is not responsible for managing corporate level costs.
Berle and Means were the first to raise this issue, relating it to the shift from an economy based on relatively small enterprises, owned and managed by individuals or small groups of individuals, to one dominated by large, multi-unit enterprises whose shareholdings are widely dispersed and whose shareholders are no longer likely to be in control. According to this approach, company owners, by surrendering control and responsibility over their properties, have surrendered the right to have the corporation operated in their sole interest.
See Soltani (2007) for discussion on ISA 240 of IFAC, 2007 and PCAOB-AU Section 316 and these three conditions including several examples of each one.
A major part of the information regarding the historical background of these groups was extracted from their annual reports and company’s press releases.
The Caymans, in the Caribbean, has become very famous with the Parmalat case, but the Cayman Islands is one of the ‘tax havens’ the most used by international companies.
Euronext is the joint market between Paris, Amsterdam, Brussels and Lisbon Stock Exchanges. This was created in the wake of the implementation of European financial market.
Major part of the information was extracted from the annual reports and Form 20 F.
In the Fair Funds provisions of the SOX Act of 2002, Congress gave the SEC increased authority to distribute ill-gotten gains and civil money penalties to harmed investors. The Commission has returned more than $4 billion to investors for the period 2002-august 2008 (SEC 2008).
References
AICPA. (2002). Statement on auditing standards (SAS) no. 99: Consideration of fraud in a financial statement audit. Durham: American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
The American Assembly. (2003, November). The future of the accounting profession. The 103rd American Assembly. Columbia University, New York, 21 pp.
Angel, J. J., & McCabe, D. M. (2008). The effects of managerial compensation: The case of executive stock options. Journal of Business Ethics, 78, 225–235.
Armstrong, C. S., Jagolinzer, A. D., & Larcker, D. F. (2010). Chief executive officer equity incentives and accounting irregularities. Journal of Accounting Research, 48(2), 225–271.
Arnaud, A. (2006). Conceptualizing and measuring ethical work climate: Development and validation of the ethical climate index (ECI). In Academy of Management Best Conference Paper. SIM.
Arnold, B., & de Lange, P. (2004). Enron: An examination of agency problems. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(6–7), 751–767.
Ashbaugh-Skaife, H., Collins, D. W., Kinney, W. R., & Lafond, R. (2008). The effect of SOX internal control deficiencies and their remediation on accrual quality. The Accounting Review, 83(1), 217–250.
Baker, C. R., & Hayes, R. (2004). Reflecting from over substance: The case of Enron Corp. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(6–7), 767–787.
Bédard, J. (2011). Discussion of “The relationship between perceived tone at the top and earnings quality”. Contemporary Accounting Research, 28(4), 1225–1229.
Benediktsson, M. O. (2010). The deviant organization and the bad apple CEO: Ideology and accountability in media coverage of corporate scandals. Social Forces, 88(5), 2189–2216.
Berle, A. A., & Means, G. C. (1932). Modern corporation and private property. New York: Macmillan.
Berson, Y., Oreg, S., & Dvir, T. (2008). CEO values, organizational culture and firm outcomes. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 29(5), 615–633.
Brody, R. G., Lowe, J. D., & Pany, K. (2003). Could $51 million be immaterial when Enron reports income of $105 million-commentary? Accounting Horizons, 17(2), 153–160.
Brody, R. G., Melendy, S. R., & Perri, F. S. (2011). Commentary from the American Accounting Association’s 2011 annual meeting panel on emerging issues in fraud research. Accounting Horizons, 26(3), 513–531.
Brower, H. H., & Shrader, C. B. (2000). Moral reasoning and ethical climate: Not-for-profit vs. for-profit boards of directors. Journal of Business Ethics, 26, 147–167.
Brown, M. E., Trevino, L. K., & Harrison, D. A. (2005). Ethical leadership: A social learning perspective for construct development and testing. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 97(2), 117–134.
Buchholz, A. K. (2012). SAS 99: Deconstructing the fraud triangle and some classroom suggestions. Journal of Leadership, Accountability and Ethics, 9(2), 109–118.
Bulutlar, F., & Öz, E. U. (2009). The effects of ethical climates on bullying behavior in the workplace. Journal of Business Ethics, 86, 273–295.
Chaubey, M. D. (2006). HealthSouth Corporation: Fraud, greed and corporate governance. In International Conference on Management Cases. http://www.ds.psu.edu/Documents/Academics/HealthSouth_Corporation_Case.pdf.
Coffee, J. C., Jr. (2004). Overcriminalization? National Law Journal, 26(48), 13.
Coffee, J. C., Jr. (2005). A theory of corporate scandals: Why the US and Europe differ. Review of Economic Policy, 21(2), 198–211.
Coffee, J. C., Jr. (2007). Law and the market: The impact of enforcement. Working paper presented at the ESRC/GOVNET workshop, Australian National University.
Cohen, J., Ding, Y., Lesage, C., & Stolowy, H. (2010). Corporate fraud and managers’ behavior: Evidence from the press. Journal of Business Ethics, 95, 271–315.
Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO). (2004). The internal control framework. Executive summary. http://www.coso.org/ic-integratedframework-summary.htm.
Craig, R. J., & Amernic, J. H. (2004). Enron discourse: The rhetoric of a resilient capitalism. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(6–7), 813–853.
Cressey, D. R. (1973). Other people’s money: A study in the social psychology of embezzlement (revised edition). Montclair, NJ: Patterson Smith Publishing Corporation.
Cullen, J. B., Victor, B., & Stephens, C. (1989). An ethical weather report: Assessing the organization’s ethical climate. Organizational Dynamics, 18(2), 50–63.
Cullinan, C. (2004). Enron as a symptom of audit process breakdown: Can the Sarbanes-Oxley Act cure the disease? Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(6–7), 853–865.
De Jong, A., De Jong. D. V., Mertens, G., & Roosenboom, P. (2005). Royal ahold: A failure of corporate governance and an accounting scandal. Working paper.
Desai, M. (2012, March). Restoring U.S. competitiveness context. Harvard Business Review, 124–133.
Directors’ Report. (2003). Report of investigation by the special investigative committee of the board of directors of WorldCom, Inc.
Dorminey, J., Fleming, A. S., Kranacher, M. J., & Riley, R. A. (2010). Beyond the fraud triangle. The CPA Journal, 17–23.
Dorminey, J., Fleming, A. S., Kranacher, M. J., & Riley, R. A. (2012). The evolution of fraud theory. Issues in Accounting Education, 27(2), 555–579.
Dossi, A., Patelli, L., & Zoni, L. (2010). The missing link between corporate performance measurement systems and chief executive officer incentive plans. Journal of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, 25(4), 532–558.
Doyle, J. W. Ge., & McVay, S. (2007). Accruals quality and internal control over financial reporting. The Accounting Review, 82(5), 1141–1170.
Duh, M., Belak, J., & Milfelner, B. (2010). Core values, culture and ethical climate as constitutional elements of ethical behavior: Exploring differences between family and non-family enterprises. Journal of Business Ethics, 97, 473–489.
Enriques, L. (2003). Bad apples, bad oranges: A comment from old Europe on post-Enron corporate governance reforms. Wake Forest Law Review, 38, 911–934.
European Commission. (2011). Green Paper—the EU corporate governance framework. COM(2011) 164 final.
Ferrell, O. C., & Ferrell, L. (2011). The responsibility and accountability of CEOs: The last interview with Ken Lay. Journal of Business Ethics, 100, 209–219.
Frink, D. D., & Klimoski, R. J. (1998). Toward a theory of accountability in organizations and human resource management. In G. R. Ferris (Ed.), Research in personal and human resource management (Vol. 16, pp. 1–51). Stamford: CT/JAI Press.
Graham, J. W. (1995). Leadership, moral development and citizenship behavior. Business Ethics Quarterly, 5, 43–54.
Greiling, D., & Spraul, K. (2010). Accountability and the challenges of information disclosure. PAQ, 34, 338–377.
Hall, J. L. (2012). Performance and accountability in a time of economic crisis. Editor’s introduction. Public Performance & Management Review, 35(3), 485–488.
Hambrick, D. C. (2007). Upper echelons theory: An update. Academy of Management Review, 32(2), 334–343.
Hermanson, D. R., Ivancevich, D. M., & Ivancevich, S. H. (2008, November). Tone at the top: Insights from section 404. Strategic Finance, 39–45.
Hogan, C. E., Rezaee, Z., Riley, R. A., & Velury, U. K. (2008). Financial statement fraud: Insights from the academic literature. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 27(2), 231–252.
Hunton, J. E., Hoitash, R., & Thibodeau, J. C. (2011). The relationship between perceived tone at the top and earnings quality. Contemporary Accounting Research, 28(4), 1190–1224.
Huson, M. R., Tian, Y., Wiedman, C. I., & Wier, H. A. (2012). Compensation committees’ treatment of earnings components in CEOs’ terminal years. The Accounting Review, 87(1), 231–259.
Jones, R., & Wu, Y. W. (2010). Executive compensation, earnings management and shareholder litigation. Review of Quantitative Financial Accounting, 35, 1–20.
Kaptein, M. (2010). The ethics of organizations: A longitudinal study of the U.S. working population. Journal of Business Ethics, 92, 601–618.
Karpoff, J. M., Lee, D. S., & Martin, G. S. (2007). The legal penalties for financial misrepresentation. http://ssrn.com/abstract=93333.
Kolb, R. (2011). Must CEOs be saints? Contra moriarty on CEO abstemiousness. Business Ethics Quarterly, 21(4), 679–686.
Koppell, J. G. S. (2005). Pathologies of accountability: ICANN and the challenge of multiple accountabilities disorder. Public Administration Review, 65(1), 94–108.
Lamberton, B., Mihalek, P. H. & Smith, C. S. (2005, March). The tone at the top and ethical conduct connection. Strategic Finance 37–39.
Littman, A. (2010). The fraud triangle: Fraudulent executives, complicit auditors and intolerable public injury. Mill Valley, CA: Snowball Narrative.
Malone, F. L., & Pitre, R. (2009). The HealthSouth “Family”, Chap. 25. In S. Matulich & D. M. Currie (Eds.), The handbook of frauds, scams, and swindles—failures of ethics in leadership (pp. 315–336). Boca Raton: Taylor & Francis.
Martin, K. D., & Cullen, J. B. (2006). Continuities and extensions of ethical climate theory: A meta-analysis review. Journal of Business Ethics, 69, 175–194.
McClelland, D. (1961). The achieving society. Princeton, NJ: Van Nostrand Company Inc.
McMahon, L. (1995). Corporate accountability in Australia: Managing the information environment for corporate accountability. Journal of Business Ethics, 14, 673–681.
Micewski, E., & Troy, C. (2007). Business ethics—deontologically revisited. Journal of Business Ethics, 72, 17–25.
Monks, R. G. (1993). Growing corporate governance: From George III to George Bush. In B. Sutton (Ed.), The legitimate corporation. Oxford: Blackwell.
Moriarty, J. (2009). How much compensation can CEOs permissibly accept? Business Ethics Quarterly, 19(2), 235–250.
Moriarty, J. (2011). The sky’s the limit: A reply to Kolb. Business Ethics Quarterly, 21(4), 686–691.
Morrison, M. A. (2004). Rush to judgment: The lynching of Arthur Andersen & Co. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(3), 335–376.
Murphy, P. R., Free, C., & Branston, C. (2012). The role of ethical climate in fraud. Annual Meeting of the American Accounting Association, August, Washington.
National Commission on Fraudulent Financial Reporting (The Treadway Commission). (1987). Report of the National Commission on Fraudulent Financial Reporting, Washington, DC.
Norton Rose Group. (2003). The Higgs reports: Views of the role and effectiveness of non-executive (pp. 31).
O’Connell, B. T. (2004). Crimes and misdemeanours: The death of Arthur Andersen. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(3), 333–335.
Persons, O. (2006). The effects of fraud and lawsuit revelation on U.S. executive turnover and compensation. Journal of Business Ethics, 64, 405–419.
PricewaterhouseCoopers. (2004). Commissioner’s report on the reasons of the insolvency of Parmalat Finanziaria S.p.A. and those of its subsidiaries included in the proposal of composition with creditors.
Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). (2007). An audit of internal control over financial reporting performed that is integrated with an audit of financial statements, Auditing Standard No. 5.
Ramamoorti, S. (2008). The psychology and sociology of fraud: integrating the behavioral sciences component into fraud and forensic accounting curricula. Issues in Accounting Education, 23(4), 521–533.
Reed, L. L., Vidaver-Cohen, D., & Colwell, S. R. (2011). A new scale to measure executive servant leadership: development, analysis, and implications for research. Journal of Business Ethics, 101, 415–434.
Reinstein, A., & McMillan, J. J. (2004). The Enron debacle: More than a perfect storm. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(6–7), 955–971.
Reinstein, A., & Weirich, T. (2002, December). Accounting issues at Enron. The CPA Journal, 72.
Rezaee, Z. (2005). Causes, consequences, and deterrence of financial statement fraud. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 16(3), 277–299.
Rockness, H., & Rockness, J. (2005). Legislated ethics: From Enron to Sarbanes-Oxley, the impact on corporate America. Journal of Business Ethics, 57, 31–54.
Royle, M. T., & Hall, A. T. (2012). The relationship between McClelland’s theory of needs, feeling individually accountable, and informal accountability for others. International Journal of Management and Marketing Research, 5(1), 21–42.
Schneider, B. (1975). Organizational climates: An essay. Personnel Psychology, 28, 447–479.
Schroeder, D. (2002). Ethics from the top: Top management and ethical business. Business Ethics: A European Review, 11(3), 260–267.
Schwartz, M. S., Dunfee, T. W., & Kline, M. J. (2005). Tone at the top: An ethics code for directors? Journal of Business Ethics, 58, 79–100.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). (2003a). SEC versus HealthSouth Corporation and Richard M. Scrushy. Civil Action No. CV-03-J-0615-S.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). (2003b). SEC charges Parmalat with financial fraud accounting and auditing enforcement Release No. 1936/December. Litigation Release No. 18527.
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). (2008). SEC announces distribution of $48 million to defrauded Vivendi Universal Investors. Press Release. http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2008/2008-172.htm.
Shleifer, A., & Vishny, R. W. (1997). A survey of corporate governance. The Journal of Finance, 52(2), 737–783.
Senate Report. (2002). The role of the board of directors in Enron’s collapse. Report prepared by the permanent subcommittee on investigation of the committee on governmental affairs, US Senate Report 107-70.
Shapiro, D. M. (2011, May/June). Better understanding accounting fraud. The Journal of Corporate Accounting & Finance, 61–64.
Shin, Y. (2012). CEO ethical leadership, ethical climate, climate strength, and collective organizational citizenship behaviour. Journal of Business Ethics, 108, 299–312.
Solieri, S. A., Felo, A. J., & Hodowanitz, J. (2009). Richard Scrushy: The rise and fall of the King of Health Care, Chap. 26. In S. Matulich & D. M. Currie (Eds.), The handbook of frauds, scams, and swindles—failures of ethics in leadership (pp. 337–354). Boca Raton: Taylor & Francis.
Soltani, B. (2007). Auditing: An international approach. Harlow: Prentice Hall-Pearson Education.
Strader, J. K. (2002). Understanding white collar crime. Newark, NJ: LexisNexis.
Sutherland, E. H. (1939). The white-collar criminal. The speech delivered to a joint meeting of the American Sociologist Society and the American Economic Association.
Sutherland, E. H. (1949). White collar crime. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Trevino, L. K., & Weaver, G. R. (2003). Managing ethics in business organizations: Social scientific perspectives. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Unerman, J., & O’Dwyer, B. (2004). Enron, WorldCom, Andersen et al.: A challenge to Modernity. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(6–7), 971–995.
Vaughan, D. (1999). The dark side of organizations: mistakes, misconduct, and disaster. Annual Review of Sociology, 25, 271–305.
Victor, B., & Cullen, J. B. (1987). A theory and measure of ethical climate in organizations. In W. C. Frederick (Ed.), Research in corporate social performance and policy (pp. 51–71). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
Victor, B., & Cullen, J. B. (1988). The organizational bases of ethical work climates. Administrative Sciences Quarterly, 33, 101–125.
Vivendi Universal. (2003, December 23). Vivendi Universal: Final settlement with the SEC.
Wimbush, J. C., & Shepard, J. M. (1994). Toward an understanding of ethical climate: Its relationship to ethical behavior and supervisory influence. Journal of Business Ethics, 13, 637–647.
Wimbush, J. C., Shepard, J. M., & Markham, S. E. (1997). An empirical examination of the relationship between ethical climate and ethical behavior from multiple levels of analysis. Journal of Business Ethics, 16, 1705–1716.
Wolfe, D. T., & Hermanson, D. R. (2004, December). The fraud diamond: considering the four elements of fraud. The CPA Journal, 38–42.
Acknowledgments
The author would like to thank Professor Alex Michalos, editor-in chief of the Journal for his careful follow up and feedback. I would like to express my special appreciation to reviewer 1 for providing valuable recommendations and advice during the review process. The helpful assistance provided by the Springer’s staff is very much appreciated.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Soltani, B. The Anatomy of Corporate Fraud: A Comparative Analysis of High Profile American and European Corporate Scandals. J Bus Ethics 120, 251–274 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-013-1660-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-013-1660-z