Abstract
Immigrants now compose approximately 12 of the population of the United States and a sizable proportion of the workforce. Yet in contrast to research on other traditionally under-represented groups (e.g., women, African Americans), there are relatively few studies on issues related to being an immigrant in the U.S. workforce. This study examined English-only workplace policies, focusing on reactions to business justifications – explanations that justify managerial decisions as business necessities – for these policies. We contrasted the reactions of individuals coming from immigrant families, where at least one parent was an immigrant to the U.S., with those of persons from non-immigrant families. Results of an experiment indicated that business justifications were successful in influencing the attitudes of non-immigrants toward the English-only policies, but did not influence the attitudes of individuals from immigrant families. Probing the reasons for this effect, a thought-listing protocol suggested that non-immigrants mentioned more of the business benefits of the English-only policy than did individuals from immigrant families. Further, business justifications for the English-only policy led individuals from immigrant families, but not those from non-immigrant families, to view the organization as being less ethical and less concerned with the welfare of its workers. The implications of messages from management being understood differently by different demographic groups are discussed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anonymous: 2000, September 2, ‘8 Ex-workers Who Sued Firm over “English-only” Policy Get Settlement’, St. Louis Post-Dispatch A8.
Bartol, K. M. and D. C. Martin: 1990, ‘When Politics Pay: Factors Influencing Managerial Compensation Decisions’,Personnel Psychology 43, 599–614.
Batson, D. C., S. C. Sympson, J. L. Hindman, P. Decruz, R. M. Todd, J. L. Weeks, G. Jennings and C. Burris: 1996, “I've Been There Too': Effect on Empathy of Prior Experience with a Need’, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 22, 474–482.
Bies, R. J.: 1987, ‘The Predicament of Injustice: The Management of Moral Outrage.’ in L. L. Cummings and B. M. Staw (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, vol. 9. (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT), 289–319.
Bies, R. J. and D. L. Shapiro: 1987, ‘Interactional Fairness Judgments: The Influence of Causal Accounts’, Social Justice Review 1, 199–218.
Bies, R. J. and D. L. Shapiro: 1988, ‘Voice and Justification:Their Influence on Procedural Fairness Judgments.' Academy of Management Journal 31, 676–685.
Brief, A. P., J. Dietz, R. R. Cohen, S. D. Pugh and J. B Vaslow: 2000, ‘Just Doing Business: Modern Racism and Obedience to Authority as Explanations for Employment Discrimination.' Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 81(1), 72–97.
Cacioppo, J. T., C. R. Glass and T. V. Merluzzi: 1979, ‘Self-Statements and Self-Evaluations: A Cognitive-Response Analysis of Heterosocial Anxiety’, Cognitive Therapy & Research 3(3), 249–262.
Catanzarite, L.: 2000, ‘Brown-Collar Jobs: Occupational Segregation and Earnings of Recent-Immigrant Lati-nos’, Sociological Perspectives 43(1), 45–75.
Catanzarite, L.: 2002, ‘Dynamics of Segregation and Earnings in Brown-Collar Occupations’, Work and Occupations: An International Sociological Journal 29(3), 300–345.
Crocker, J. and B. Major: 1989, ‘Social Stigma and Self-Esteem: The Self-Protective Properties of Stigma’, Psychological Review 96(4), 608–630.
Davidson, M. and R. Friedman: 1998, ‘When Excuses Don't Work: The Persistent Injustice Effect among Black Managers’, Administrative Science Quarterly 43, 154–183.
Elliott, J. R.: 2001, ‘Referral Hiring and Ethnically Homogeneous Jobs: How Prevalent Is the Connection and for Whom?' Social Science Research 30(3), 401–425.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: 2003a, 'EEOC Settles English-Only Suit for $2.44 Million against University of Incarnate Word’, http:// www.eeoc.gov/ press/4–20-01.html.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: 2003b, 'Charge Statistics FY 1992 through FY 2002’, http:// www.eeoc.gov/stats/charges.html.
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: 2003c, 'Code for Federal Regulations (Title 29, Chapter 14): Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (Part 1606.7): Guidelines on National Origin Discrimination: Speak English-Only Rules’, Washington, DC: Author (http://www.access.gpo.gov/nara/cfr/wai-sidx_00/29cfr1606_00.html).
Esses, V. M., J. F. Dovidio, L. M. Jackson and T. L. Armstrong: 2001, ‘The Immigration Dilemma: The Role of Perceived Group Competition, Ethnic Pre-judice, and National Identity’, Journal of Social Issues 57, 389–412.
Fiske, S. and S. Taylor: 1991, Social Cognition (McGraw-Hill, New York).
Greenberg, J.: 1990, ‘Looking Fair vs. Being Fair: Man-aging Impressions of Organizational Justice’, in B. M. Staw and L. L. Cummings (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, vol. 12. (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT), pp. 111–157.
Greenberg, J.: 1994, ‘Using Socially Fair Treatment to Promote Acceptance of a Work Site Smoking Ban’, Journal of Applied Psychology 79, 288–297.
Greenberg, J.: 1996, The Quest for Justice: Essays and Experiments (Sage, London).
Hewitt, J. P., and R. Stokes: 1975, ‘Disclaimers’, American Sociological Review 40, 1–11.
Iceland, J.: 1999, ‘Earnings Returns to Occupational Status: Are Asian Americans Disadvantaged?' Social Science Research 28(1), 45–65.
Jansen, P. and F. de Jongh: 1997, Assessment Centres: A Practical Handbook (Wiley, Chicester, England).
Lewis, D. E.: 2000, July 2. 'English-Only Policies Pit Workers’ Rights against Employers’, Boston Globe: H8.
Petersen, L.-E., and Dietz, J. 2000: 'social Discrimination in a Personnel Selection Context: The Effects of an Authority's Instruction to Discriminate and Followers’ Authoritarianism’, Journal of Applied Social Psychology 30(1), 206–220.
Reitz, R. G.: 2003, ‘Educational Expansion and the Employment Success of Immigrants in the United States and Canada, 1970–1990’, in R. Breton and J. G. Reitz (eds.), Globalization and Society: Processes of -Differentiation Examined (Greenwood Press, New York).
Sanders, J., V. Nee and S. Sernau: 2002, ‘Asian Immi-grants’ Reliance on Social Ties in a Multiethnic Labor Market’, Social Forces 81(1), 281–314.
Schippmann, J. S., E. P. Prien and J. A. Katz: 1990, 'Reliability and Validity of In-Basket Performance Measures’, Personnel Psychology 43, 837–859.
Schlenker, B. R.: 1980, Impression Management (Brooks/ Cole, Monterrey, CA).
Scott, M. B. and S. M. Lyman: 1968, ‘Accounts’, Socio-logical Review 23, 46–62.
Seijts, G. H.: 2002, ‘Milking the Organization: The Effect of Breastfeeding Accommodation on Perceived Fair-ness and Organizational Attractiveness’, Journal of Business Ethics 40, 1–13.
Sitkin, S. B., and R. J. Bies: 1993, ‘Social Accounts in Conflict Situations — Using Explanations to Manage Conflict’, Human Relations 46, 349–370.
Skarlicki, D. P., R. Folger and J. Gee: 2004, ‘When Social Accounts Backfire: The Exacerbating Effects of a Polite Message or an Apology on Reactions to an Unfair Outcome’, Journal of Applied Social Psychology. 34(2), 322–341.
Tajfel, H. and J. C. Turner: 1986, ‘The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behaviour’, in S. Worchel and W. G. Austin (eds.), Psychology of Intergroup Relations: (Nelson-Hall, Chicago), pp. 7–24.
Thornton, G. C., III: 1992, Assessment Centers in Human Resource Management (Addison-Wesley, New York).
U.S. Census Bureau: 2003, June, 'Population by Sex, Age, and Citizenship Status’, Http://landview.cen-sus. gov/population/socdemo/foreign/ppl-162/tab01–01.pdf.
Weick, K. E.: 1965, ‘Laboratory experimentation with organizations’, in J. G. March (ed.), Handbook of Organizations (Rand McNally, Chicago), 194–260.
Zhang, P. and J. Sanders: 1999, ‘Extended Stratifi-cation: Immigrant and Native Differences in Indi-vidual and Family Labor’, The Sociological Quarterly 40(4), 681–704.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Dietz, J., Pugh, S. I Say Tomato, You Say Domate:Differential Reactions to English-only Workplace Policies by Persons from Immigrant and Non-immigrantFamilies. Journal of Business Ethics 52, 365–379 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-004-1539-0
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-004-1539-0