Environmental influence on the bottom and near-bottom megafauna communities of the Dogger Bank: a long-term survey
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Sonnewald, M. & Türkay, M. Helgol Mar Res (2012) 66: 503. doi:10.1007/s10152-011-0286-8
- 366 Downloads
This paper deals with climate-driven changes of the species composition of the bottom and near-bottom megafauna of the Dogger Bank (central North Sea), which was sampled each summer with a 2-m beam trawl on a yearly basis since 1991. The station grid consists of 37 stations, covering an area of approximately 17.000 km². A selection of commoner species is analysed and correlated with temperature data gained during the research period. Temperatures are derived from our own measurements, combined with CTD data from the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea. The results show a decrease in biodiversity and a clear regime shift around the beginning of the 21st century, combined with rising mean bottom temperatures. In addition, details are given about the Dogger Bank hydrography and the climate sensitivity and abundance of the main species caught with the beam trawl. Our long-term study reveals the changes in the community structure of the megafauna of the Dogger Bank over a period of almost two decades. It suggests a link between changes in species composition/abundance and changes in the environment, especially the marine climate.
KeywordsMegafauna Climate sensitivity Biodiversity loss Beam trawl survey Dogger Bank North Sea
The important role of climate-induced changes in the ecology (not only) of the marine environment is, in some cases, well documented (Ottersen et al. 2001; Stenseth et al. 2002). Climate-driven regime shifts of planktonic species have been observed in the past (Reid et al. 2003). The main driving force seems to be the continuous increase in the North Atlantic Oscillation Index, causing higher means in sea surface temperatures (SST) as well as milder winters in the northern hemisphere (Hurrell 1995; Stenseth et al. 2002). Although the influence of changing SST on the different marine trophic levels is rather complex (Kirby and Beaugrand 2009), former as well as recent studies revealed the effects of changing SST’s—especially in winter—on the abundance and distribution of endobenthic (Beukema 1992; Buchanan and Moore 1986; Kröncke et al. 1998; Reiss et al. 2006; Wieking and Kröncke 2001; Ziegelmeier 1970) and epibenthic species in the North Sea (Neumann et al. 2008, 2009a).
In this study, climatic influences on faunal assemblages caught with the beam trawl have been our main focus. They mainly include epibenthic, but also demersal and endobenthic species, as well as three pelagic fishes and one hyperbenthic cephalopod (Fig. 7). Our research area, the Dogger Bank, is a sandbank in the central North Sea, covering an area of approximately 21,000 km², with a depth range around 12–40 m. Our research grid is located within the 30 m depth contour and lies in the exclusive economic zones of three countries: UK, the Netherlands and Germany. The Dogger Bank builds the northern end of a “southern” species community cluster with its northern edge being adjacent to faunal assemblages typical for the northern North Sea (Frauenheim et al. 1989, Jennings et al. 1999a). As introduced and summarised in Sonnewald and Türkay (2011), several detailed and ongoing studies concerning the infauna of the Dogger Bank have been undertaken ever since, but concerning the typical faunal assemblages caught by beam trawl, only sparse information was available.
The main focus of this study is to check the Dogger Bank (epi)benthic animal communities for changes in biodiversity, as well as whether there are species affected by changes in climate over the last two decades.
Materials and methods
Methods and range of temperature records, including sampling effort
After recording the environmental conditions, a 2-m beam trawl with a mesh size of 1 cm² was deployed and towed for one nautical mile at two knots on each site. Once aboard, the fauna was sieved using three different mesh sizes (10 mm, 5 mm and 300 μm), and the fractions smaller than 1 cm² were separated. The megafauna (>1 cm, corresponding to the mesh size of the net) was then identified to species level, and the individuals were counted on board ship. The fine fractions (<1 cm), as well as undetermined or rare faunal elements, were preserved in 5% formaldehyde in seawater (rarely in EtOH 99%) for laboratory determination.
Diversity and distance analyses
Species is not quantifiable or recorded only with relative abundances (sessile animal colonies)
Number of individuals does not exceed 10 on any cruise
Species is only detected on one cruise, and number of individuals is below 10
Using these restrictions, 126 of 185 species were omitted from the list, leaving 59 species, considered to be common enough and thus relevant for quantitative analysis and called SpL hereafter.
In order to determine diversity changes within the research period, the Shannon-Wiener Index (H′) (Spellerberg and Fedor 2003) and the Simpson Index (D) (Simpson 1949) were calculated, using the SpL data of all cruise years.
The total abundance of each SpL species per cruise was 4th root transformed, and a multidimensional scaling plot (MDS) was generated for distance analysis, using a similarity matrix after Bray and Curtis (1957) in the software package Primer v6, in order to obtain additional information on the degree of similarity of the species composition at all cruise years.
To provide the best possible temperature resolution, surface and water column temperature data collected on our cruises were combined with publicly available CTD data provided online by the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES). This combined dataset (123.798 entries) was converted and analysed with the aid of the programme Ocean Data View (ODV).
The mean temperature of the water column during summer was estimated by generating a section from the north-east to the south-west of the sandbank, including the values for all years (1991–2010) from July 01 to August 31. This technique resulted in the detection of a thermocline at approximately 15 m. This depth was used to separate the surface and bottom layer of the water column. Thus, temperature means were calculated for the surface and bottom layer during each summer (July 01–August 31) and each year.
A Spearman’s rank correlation analysis was performed, comparing the yearly abundance of each species with the mean summer bottom water temperature. The species were sorted by their Spearman’s indices, from high to low.
Diversity and distance analyses
All trend lines in Fig. 6 show an upward trend in the mean temperatures on a small degree scale, with the mean summer bottom temperature (MSBT) trend being significantly non-zero (P = 0.026) in a linear regression.
Diversity and distance analyses
The diversity indices in Fig. 2 exhibit a clear downward trend, at least since the year 2002. This result is further supported by a previously detected decrease in species richness across the research period (Sonnewald and Türkay 2011). Although species richness is not totally identical with biodiversity (Spellerberg and Fedor 2003), it is—together with species abundance—an important measurable key factor. Disregarding the driving forces, these results show that a decrease in biodiversity could have negative effects on the ecosystem of the Dogger Bank. Although controversially discussed by Lehman and Tilman (2000), a reduction in biodiversity could reduce the ecosystem productivity and temporal stability, which may result in an increased vulnerability regarding fisheries, invasive species and changing environmental conditions.
As described in Kröncke and Knust (1995), the Dogger Bank hydrography is influenced by different water bodies. In summer, the south-west of the bank is characterised by an influx of warmer water from the southern North Sea and the English Channel, while the north-eastern part of the bank is under the influence of cooler water from the north. In Fig. 5, these summer temperature anomalies, the so-called “eddies” (Kröncke and Knust 1995), are visible near the bottom layer in the west (2°E–2.5°E) and in the east (3°E to beyond 4°E). The western temperature anomaly is caused by warmer water coming from the southern North Sea and the British Channel. The eastern anomaly is caused by the influx of cooler water from the north. The fauna reacts to this distribution of water bodies in establishing distinct communities as explained in Frauenheim et al. 1989. As shown by the distribution of animal communities through cluster analysis, the Dogger Bank is situated at the crossroad of these water bodies.
The resolution of the mean temperature per year in Fig. 6 lacks absolute accuracy, because temperature data were unavailable for some months, resulting in imprecise yearly means. Instead, the more dense summer CTD data of ICES, also supported by our own CTD data, were taken for the statistical analysis of trends.
All temperature means shown in Fig. 6 (excluding the MSBTs), only show an upwards trend but fail to pass a significance test by a linear regression. The most conclusive factor for a weak trend seemed to be the time frame of our observation. There must have been a major temperature rise of the SST just before the 1990s (O’Brien et al. 2000). For our study area, the temperatures before 1991 were not taken into account due to very sparse data availability from ICES and the lack of own CTD data. Nevertheless, clear temperature anomalies have also been detected at selected stations at the southern and northern North Sea since the beginning of the 1990s (Hughes et al. 2010), thus the observed upwards trend in our dataset seems meaningful, although some trends were non-significant.
When correlating the mean yearly water temperatures with species abundance, the first step is to verify the relevance of yearly temperature means for growth and reproduction of marine species. Literature provides several examples of marine animals showing a “reaction” to annual means in temperature. Neumann et al. (2009b) used temperature anomalies derived from mean surface and bottom temperatures for a conclusive Spearman’s rank correlation with mean species abundance. Taylor (1958) showed a positive correlation of cod size/lifespan and annual means of the sea surface temperature. Perry et al. (2005) showed that temperature means are good proxies, even if winter and summer values are calculated separately, and have an effect on the distribution range of several fish species. This makes clear that isolated summer and winter values cannot explain the whole distribution characteristics. Some authors also use a restricted time frame for the analysis of specific questions, like O’ Brien et al. (2000), who used the mean sea surface temperature in the period of February to June to explain cod recruitment. Again, winter to summer months are included in the period used for analysis, which shows that different times of the year have to be taken into account when discussing marine climatic influences on organisms. In consequence, we use yearly mean temperatures for our correlation analysis, as these reflect the temperature range of an entire year.
Figure 7 demonstrates that there is a distinction between species correlating positively and species correlating negatively with increasing temperatures, as well as a central cluster of species, showing no significant correlation with the MSBTs concerning their abundance. The animal with the most positive Spearman’s correlation index is Luidia sarsi. In the study area, this species was first observed with a sudden and high abundance in the year 2003, where we also observed a temperature peak in the summer and yearly means (Figs. 6, 8). Maybe this comparatively warm year was one among other factors facilitating the establishment of L. sarsi at the Dogger Bank. Its yearly abundance decreased again in the following years, with a smaller peak in 2009, correlating with a smaller rise in temperatures than in 2003. Concerning its further distribution, this species is not uncommon to the North Sea, but according to Frauenheim et al. (1989), it is common in the northern regions but rare in the southern ones of the North Sea. This is supported by observations on benthic material sampled North Sea wide on the ZISCH Cruises by RV Valdivia (Frauenheim et al. 1989). It is most likely that L. sarsi formerly used the northern introduction route into the North Sea (Shetlands/Orkneys), because it is not found until today at the eastern British Channel and the area south of the Dogger Bank. In addition to the west coast of the British Isles, the species is reported from the Mediterranean and the Azores (Hayward and Ryland 1998; Mifsud et al. 2009). Even if this species correlates with comparatively higher temperatures, there is no clear indication that temperature is the only driving force promoting the establishment of L. sarsi on the Dogger Bank.
Luidia sarsi is followed by Liocarcinus depurator, a swimming crab with a distribution range from the east Atlantic coast of North-West Africa to the Hebrides, being common in the North Sea and the Mediterranean (Christiansen 1969; d’Udekem d’Acoz 1999). In our study, it first appeared in 1999 on the Dogger Bank. Since then, its abundance tended to go up with a first peak in 2003 and a second one in 2009, but in summer 2010, its abundance decreased again remarkably. One possible reason is the effects of the cold winter of 2009/2010.
The echinoderm Psammechinus miliaris has been common at the Dogger Bank since the beginning of our study, but its abundance also seems to positively correlate with temperature peaks, at least in 2003 and 2009, where it was recorded with a high number at several stations.
The flatfishes Arnoglossus laterna and Buglossidium luteum are two of the main faunal elements of the Dogger Bank, usually being present on all stations. The yellow sole B. luteum dominates most of the catches, on average being 13 times as numerous as A. laterna. Both flatfishes correlate with elevated temperatures, maybe due to a better food supply caused by a higher primary production in the food web in warmer years (Kirby and Beaugrand 2009). In addition, A. laterna shows a significant (P = 0.0001) increase in the number of individuals per year over the research period.
The species with the most negative Spearman’s rank, the lesser sandeel Ammodytes marinus, shows an inverted abundance trend. This species is common in the North Atlantic up to eastern Greenland, Iceland, the Barents Sea and the North Sea (Kaschner et al. 2008). After an initial period of high abundance during the first years (1991–1997) of our long-term research, this species vanished from our catches. In contrast to the increasing abundance of some southern fish (Beare et al. 2004), the sandeel A. marinus showed the opposite trend during our study period. Its disappearance correlates with rising temperatures, but the effect of commercial fisheries on A. marinus as a target species cannot be disregarded (Pedersen et al. 1999). In the east of the Dogger Bank, this species was recorded via echosounder acoustic data by Van der Kooij et al. (2008) in the years 2004, 2005 and 2006. We cannot confirm these data obtained by echosounding through our sampling efforts. Since 1999, we were not able to catch any individuals of A. marinus. This corresponds to a dramatic decrease in sandeel landings, reported by ICES (2010, Fig. 18.104.22.168). During the period in question, we only detected a few specimens of Ammodytes tobianus, a close relative of A. marinus. The overall picture shown through the analysis of catch data confirms the negative correlation of sandeel abundance with rising temperatures.
A number of kinds of impacts have been discussed in the ecological literature as possible structuring features for the epibenthic and near-bottom communities. These will be discussed here in detail with reference to the Dogger Bank.
Little is known concerning trawling (or fishing) efforts at the Dogger Bank. Overall, only an estimation of trawling frequency seems possible for the Dogger Bank area. The works of Jennings and Kaiser (1998) and Jennings et al. (1999b, 2000) characterise the Dogger Bank as a medium- to less-affected fishing zone compared with other areas of the North Sea, with a slight decrease in trawling effort from 1990 to 1995. As mentioned in Jennings et al. (1999b), the trawling data of Belgium and France are not included in these reports due to unavailability. Jennings et al. (2001) also examined two areas adjacent to the Dogger Bank (Hills and Silver Pit) and correlated sampled biomass with trawler sightings by fishery protection flights in a 5-year time frame. This study revealed a trawling intensity of up to 6,5 times a year, resulting in highly significant decreases in bivalve and spatangoid infauna. For the epifauna, no significant correlation of trawling and biomass was detected in their work. Kröncke (1992) states that for benthic community changes at the Dogger Bank, damage by fishery is an unimportant factor. Even the sandeel fishery is regarded as an exercise with light gear, seasonally restricted to spring, resulting in weak sea floor damage. We conclude that the possible effect of trawling cannot be stronger for the epifauna than the endofauna. Therefore, we cannot see any serious impact that could be used for the interpretation of our data.
Low winter temperatures
Another example is the bivalve Arctica islandica. The growth rings of its shell are a good index for climatic events, impressively demonstrated by Schöne et al. (2003, 2005). Additionally, the shell of A. islandica together with the shells of Mya truncata and Chamelea striatula can be used to show sediment re-suspension strength due to storms, as shown by Witbaard et al. (2005).
The results of this study show clearly that water temperature is a significant factor for explaining species abundances and composition of the bottom fauna of the Dogger Bank. In our study area, factors like fishing pressure seem to play a minor role compared to long-term temperature shifts. It was apparent that species appearance and disappearance (presence-absence events) do not constitute the totality of observable changes, but there are clear positive and negative correlations of the abundance of individual species with a particular temperature regime. Appearance and disappearance of species would thus be the extreme ends of a scale of increase and decrease. These correlations were detected by the analysis of long time series, and it will be of great interest to see how the species with a positive or negative correlation towards warmer temperatures will move on the scale and when they will possibly drop out or get more abundant. These events can only be followed up by ongoing long-term monitoring.
We thank the Biodiversity and Climate Research Centre (BiK-F) in Frankfurt am Main for funding our work and data analysis, as well as the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea for providing such detailed CTD data. We also thank the crew (the old sea bears as well as the newcomers) of the research vessel Senckenberg, who always gave and still give their best for our cruises to succeed. Special thanks go to Dr. R.G. Hartnoll for proofreading of the manuscript for this publication.