Abstract
Power to gas (P2G)-methane, pumped hydroelectric storage (PHES) and compressed air energy storage (CAES) are three methods to store surplus electricity with high capacity and long discharge time. However, there is a few research included P2G—methane in comparing with other storage technologies in general and in terms of sustainability development. This paper explored and compared the cost, efficiency, position flexibility, storage capacity/discharge time, energy carrier vector and environmental issues of those storage technologies in terms of single criterion and group multi-criteria analysis. The single criterion data of each technology was reviewed from literature and compared with each other. The data from single criterion were normalised then used as inputs of the linear additive model. The weights of criteria were determined by sending out the weighting assessment form to 10 researchers. The comparison in terms of cost and efficiency showed that PHES is better than P2G and CAES. And P2G has many benefits such as: conversion of energy vector from electricity to gas which is available for renewable thermal and transport energy; longest storage time; and minimal impact on the environment. From sustainable development strategy perspective, the evaluation results of P2G, PHES and CAES are 4.03, 2.46 and 2.16, respectively. Which means P2G was assessed as preferable.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ahern EP, Deane P, Persson T, Gallachóir BÓ, Murphy JD (2015) A perspective on the potential role of renewable gas in a smart energy island system. Renew Energy 78:648–656
Akinyele DO, Rayudu RK (2014) Review of energy storage technologies for sustainable power networks. Sustain Energy Technol Assess 8:74–91. doi:10.1016/j.seta.2014.07.004
Barin A, Canha LN, Abaide AR, Magnago KF, Wottrich B, Machado RQ (2011) Multiple criteria analysis for energy storage selection. Energy Power Eng 3:557
Beckwith (1983) Review of environmental studies and issues on compressed air energy storage. http://www.osti.gov/scitech/servlets/purl/6390927
Belton V, Pictet J (1997) A framework for group decision using a MCDA model: sharing, aggregating or comparing individual information? J Decis Syst 6:283–303
Benjaminsson G, Benjaminsson J, Rudberg RB (2013) Power-to-Gas–A technical review. Tech. rep., Svenskt Gastekniskt CenterAB (SGC). http://www.sgc.se/ckfinder/userfiles/files/SGC284_eng.pdf
Bernstein BB (2015) Evaluating alternatives for decommissioning California’s offshore oil and gas platforms. Integr Environ Assess Manag 11(4):537–541
Boer DH (2012) The application of different types of large scale energy storage systems in the Dutch electricity system at different wind power penetration levels. An environmental, economical and energetic analysis on power-to-gas, compressed air energy storage and pumped hydro storage. Master thesis at University of Groningen & DNV KEMA
Bullough C, Gatzen C, Jakiel C, Koller M, Nowi A, Zunft S (2004) Advanced adiabatic compressed air energy storage for the integration of wind energy. In: Proceedings of the European wind energy conference, EWEC
Burkhardt M, Koschack T, Busch G (2015) Biocatalytic methanation of hydrogen and carbon dioxide in an anaerobic three-phase system. Bioresour Technol 178:330–333
Chakraborty S, Yeh C-H (2007) A simulation based comparative study of normalization procedures in multiattribute decision making. In: Proceedings of the 6th conference on 6th WSEAS Int. Conf. on artificial intelligence, knowledge engineering and data bases, Citeseer, pp 102–109
Chen H, Cong TN, Yang W, Tan C, Li Y, Ding Y (2009) Progress in electrical energy storage system: a critical review. Prog Nat Sci 19:291–312
Cheng H (1993) Pumped Storage. McGraw Hill, New York N.Y.
Connolly D (2007) An investigation into the energy storage technologies available, for the integration of alternative generation techniques. http://www.iwea.com/technologicaldevelopments
Deane JP, Gallachóir BÓ, McKeogh E (2010) Techno-economic review of existing and new pumped hydro energy storage plant. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 14:1293–1302
Denholm P, Kulcinski GL (2004) Life cycle energy requirements and greenhouse gas emissions from large scale energy storage systems. Energy Convers Manag 45:2153–2172
Dorini G, Kapelan Z, Azapagic A (2011) Managing uncertainty in multiple-criteria decision making related to sustainability assessment. Clean Technol Environ Policy 13:133–139
Drexhage J, Murphy D (2010) Sustainable development: from Brundtland to Rio 2012. Background paper prepared for consideration by the High Level Panel on Global Sustainability at its first meeting 19 Sept 2010
Electric Power Research Institute (2011) Quantifying the value of hydropower in the electric grid: plant cost elements. http://www.epri.com/abstracts/pages/productabstract.aspx?ProductID=000000000001023140
Elmegaard B, Brix W (2011) Efficiency of compressed air energy storage. In: 24th international conference on efficiency, cost, optimization, simulation and environmental impact of energy systems
Energy ARIfS (2010) Study of compressed air energy storage with grid and photovoltaic energy generation
Evans A, Strezov V, Evans TJ (2012) Assessment of utility energy storage options for increased renewable energy penetration. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 16:4141–4147. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2012.03.048
Gonzalez A, Gallachóir B, McKeogh E, Lynch K (2004) Study of electricity storage technologies and their potential to address wind energy intermittency in Ireland. https://www.seai.ie/uploadedfiles/FundedProgrammes/REHC03001FinalReport.pdf
Götz M et al (2015) Renewable power-to-gas: a technological and economic review. Renewable energy 85:1371–1390
Grond L, Paula S, Johan H (2013) System analyses power to gas: a technology review. http://issuu.com/ggnl/docs/systems_analyses_power_to_gas_-_tec
Hasan NS, Hassan MY, Majid MS, Rahman HA (2013) Review of storage schemes for wind energy systems. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 21:237–247. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2012.12.028
Huang Y-S, Chang W-C, Li W-H, Lin Z-L (2013) Aggregation of utility-based individual preferences for group decision-making. Eur J Oper Res 229:462–469
Ibrahim H, Ilinca A, Perron J (2008) Energy storage systems—characteristics and comparisons. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 12:1221–1250
Jentsch M, Trost T, Sterner M (2011) Evaluation of power-to-gas as long-term storage concept regarding electricity and CO2 sources. In: 6th International Renewable Energy Storage Conference-IRES 2011
Kim Y-M, Lee J-H, Kim S-J, Favrat D (2012) Potential and evolution of compressed air energy storage: energy and exergy analyses. Entropy 14:1501–1521
Kousksou T, Bruel P, Jamil A, El Rhafiki T, Zeraouli Y (2014) Energy storage: applications and challenges. Sol Energy Mater Sol Cells 120:59–80. doi:10.1016/j.solmat.2013.08.015
Lehner M, Tichler R, Steinmüller H, Koppe M (2014) Power-to-gas: technology and business models. Springer, Berlin
Lund H, Salgi G (2009) The role of compressed air energy storage (CAES) in future sustainable energy systems. Energy Convers Manag 50:1172–1179. doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2009.01.032
Luo X, Wang J, Dooner M, Clarke J (2015) Overview of current development in electrical energy storage technologies and the application potential in power system operation. Appl Energy 137:511–536. doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.09.081
Ma T, Yang H, Lu L (2014) Feasibility study and economic analysis of pumped hydro storage and battery storage for a renewable energy powered island. Energy Convers Manag 79:387–397. doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2013.12.047
Monica K (2000) Development of bulk energy storage & natura 2000. http://www.store-project.eu/documents/results/en_GB/development-of-bulk-energy-storage-natura-2000
Murphy JD, Thamsiriroj T (2011) What will fuel transport systems of the future? Mater Today 14:518–524. doi:10.1016/S1369-7021(11)70277-2
Persson T, Murphy J, Liebetrau J, Trommler MT (2014) A perspective on the potential role of biogas in smart energy grids. http://www.iea-biogas.net/files/daten-redaktion/download/Technical%20Brochures/Smart_Grids_Final_web.pdf
Pickard WF, Hansing NJ, Shen AQ (2009) Can large-scale advanced-adiabatic compressed air energy storage be justified economically in an age of sustainable energy? J Renew Sustain Energy 1:033102
Raza SS, Janajreh I, Ghenai C (2014) Sustainability index approach as a selection criteria for energy storage system of an intermittent renewable energy source. Appl Energy 136:909–920. doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.04.080
Rehman S, Al-Hadhrami LM, Alam MM (2015) Pumped hydro energy storage system: a technological review. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 44:586–598. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2014.12.040
Reiter G, Lindorfer J (2015) Global warming potential of hydrogen and methane production from renewable electricity via power-to-gas technology. Int J Life Cycle Assess 20:1–13
Sætre AL (2013) Variable speed pumped storage hydropower for balancing variable power production in continental Europe. http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:653081/FULLTEXT01.pdf
Salo AA (1995) Interactive decision aiding for group decision support. Eur J Oper Res 84:134–149
Schiebahn S, Grube T, Robinius M, Tietze V, Kumar B, Stolten D (2015) Power to gas: technological overview, systems analysis and economic assessment for a case study in Germany. Int J Hydrog Energy 40:4285–4294
Schwarzenegger A (2008) Compressed air energy storage scoping study for california. http://www.energy.ca.gov/2008publications/CEC-500-2008-069/CEC-500-2008-069.PDF
Sterner M (2009) Bioenergy and renewable power methane in integrated 100% renewable energy systems: limiting global warming by transforming energy systems. Kassel university press GmbH, Kassel
Ter-Gazarian AG (2011) Energy storage for power systems. Institution of Engineering and Technology
Triantaphyllou E (2013) Multi-criteria decision making methods: a comparative study. Springer, Berlin
Vandewalle J, Bruninx K, D’haeseleer W (2015) Effects of large-scale power to gas conversion on the power, gas and carbon sectors and their interactions. Energy Convers Manag 94:28–39. doi:10.1016/j.enconman.2015.01.038
Wang J-J, Jing Y-Y, Zhang C-F, Zhao J-H (2009) Review on multi-criteria decision analysis aid in sustainable energy decision-making. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 13:2263–2278. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2009.06.021
Wänn A, Leahy P, Reidy M, Doyle S, Dalton H, Barry P (2012) Environmental performance of existing energy storage installations. http://www.store-project.eu/en_GB/project-results
Wimmler C, Hejazi G, de Oliveira Fernandes E, Moreira C, Connors S (2015) Multi-criteria decision support methods for renewable energy systems on islands. J Clean Energy Technol 3:185–195
Yang C-J, Jackson RB (2011) Opportunities and barriers to pumped-hydro energy storage in the United States. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 15:839–844
Yekini Suberu M, Wazir Mustafa M, Bashir N (2014) Energy storage systems for renewable energy power sector integration and mitigation of intermittency. Renew Sustain Energy Rev 35:499–514. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2014.04.009
Zach K, Auer H, Lettner G (2011) Report summarizing the current status, role and costs of energy storage technologies. http://www.google.ie/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0CCMQFjAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.store-project.eu%2Fdocuments%2Fresults%2Fen_GB%2Freport-summarizing-the-current-status-role-and-costs-of-energy-storage-technologies&ei=O-cOVPGlA6XA7Ab1_oD4Dg&usg=AFQjCNFimpnwKCWOJoJi2Ctpfld542AbbQ
Zafirakis DP (2010) 2—Overview of energy storage technologies for renewable energy systems. In: Kaldellis JK (ed) Stand-alone and hybrid wind energy systems. Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge. doi:10.1533/9781845699628.1.29
Zhao H, Wu Q, Hu S, Xu H, Rasmussen CN (2015) Review of energy storage system for wind power integration support. Appl Energy 137:545–553. doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.04.103
Acknowledgments
This material is based upon works supported by the Science Foundation Ireland (SFI) under Grant No. 12/RC/2302. Researchers are employed by the SFI centre, MaREI. Gas Networks Ireland (GNI) co-founded the work through funding of the Gas Innovation Group. Ervia also co-funded the work. Dr. Ao Xia acknowledges Chongqing University for the start-up funds under the “One Hundred Talents Program”.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Vo, T.T.Q., Xia, A., Rogan, F. et al. Sustainability assessment of large-scale storage technologies for surplus electricity using group multi-criteria decision analysis. Clean Techn Environ Policy 19, 689–703 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-016-1250-8
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-016-1250-8