Restoration of renal function in zebrafish models of ciliopathies
The ciliopathies are a class of rare human genetic disease whose aetioligies lie in defective primary cilia. Typical ciliopathies include Bardet–Biedl syndrome (BBS), nephronophthisis (NPHP), Jeune, Joubert, oro-facial-digital (OFD1) and Meckel (MKS) syndromes. All ciliopathies have the common denominator of renal disease, often including tubular cysts. In this study, we have modelled a range of ciliopathies in zebrafish and shown in all cases that knocking down these genes causes cystic lesions in the kidney. We have identified two drugs, rapamycin and roscovitine, which ameliorate the renal phenotype, both morphologically and functionally. This is the first study in which zebrafish has been used to identify potential therapeutic modalities for ciliopathic renal disease, and the results pave the way for further investigations in mammalian models.
KeywordsCiliopathy Kidney cysts Rapamycin Roscovitine Therapeutics
Primary cilia function to detect signalling molecules and mechanical stimuli, such as fluid flow. Mutations in genes encoding some of the approximately 1000 ciliary proteins cause ciliopathies. Renal disease is a common denominator of ciliopathies, often presenting with tubular cysts, lobulation and clubbing [1, 2]. Published mouse models exist for several ciliopathy genes (Bbs1, 2, 4, 6; Ofd1; Alms1, Pkhd), and they develop renal cysts but often not until several months of age .
The zebrafish is developing as a valid model for investigating human cystic kidney diseases . The zebrafish pronephros develops after 2 days post-fertilisation (dpf), and the presence of cysts is easily screened at 3 dpf. These cysts often compromise renal function, resulting in body oedema by 4 dpf. Transparency of the embryos makes morphological scoring rapid, and the large clutches enables scalability. Ex vivo development allows therapeutic compounds to be added directly to the water in which the eggs are incubated . Our aim is to create fish models for most of the known human ciliopathies, screen them for a kidney phenotype and then try to identify compounds that could prevent cyst formation and potentially restore function.
Between 2 and 4.5 ng of translation and splice-blocking morpholino oligonucleotides (MOs) (Gene Tools, Philomath, OR) were used against the following genes (disease caused by human mutations in brackets): bbs4, bbs6, bbs8 (Bardet–Biedl syndrome); nphp2 (nephronophthisis); nphp5 (Senior–Loken syndrome); nphp6 (Joubert syndrome); mks1, mks3 (Meckel syndrome); ofd1 (oro-facial-digital syndrome type I). The MO sequences are available on request. Renal lesion sizes were quantified by drawing an outline on a lateral image of the swelling at 5 dpf using AxioImager ver. 4.4 software (Carl Zeiss Microimaging, Thornwood, NY).
Rapamycin (2–100 nM; Sigma, St. Louis, MO) and roscovitine (5–100 μM; Sigma) were dissolved in 1% DMSO and added directly to fish water at 24 hpf. Controls were treated with DMSO only. For the functional assay, embryos were injected with MO or control MO and, 24 h later, treated with drug or vehicle. At 72 hpf, they were anaesthetised in tricaine, immobilised in 2.5% methyl cellulose, and 1 nl of 10-kDa rhodamine–dextran (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) was injected into the pericardium. Images of the fluorescent embryos were collected at 1, 3, and 24 h post-injection. A region of 100 × 100 pixels containing the heart was selected , and the fluorescence intensity measured using ImageJ software (available at: http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij). At least ten embryos were measured for each treatment, and average fluorescent intensity at each timepoint was measured. The percentage of fluorescence remaining after 24 hpf was used to determine the efficiency of renal filtration.
We recently showed that mutations in a core intraflagellar transport (IFT) gene, IFT80, cause Jeune syndrome, a ciliopathy featuring skeletal dysplasia, renal cysts, polydactyly and situs inversus . The zebrafish morphant showed cystic kidneys, random body situs (our unpublished data) and a down-turned body-axis; all features reminiscent of bona fide ciliary mutants. Other previously published zebrafish ciliopathy morphants, including bbs4, bbs6 and nphp2, also show similar phenotypes [7, 8].
Several drugs have been shown to retard or reverse the growth of kidney cysts, but none have ever been tested in trials for the treatment of ciliopathy-associated renal disease. The anti-proliferative rapamycin is a small molecule inhibitor of the mTOR pathway . mTOR interacts with the C-terminus of polycystin-1 (PC1), a protein mutated in autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease which localises to the cilium . We reasoned that rapamycin might be a good candidate to test on our ciliopathy models and hypothesised that dysfunction of ciliopathy proteins could result in the mislocalisation of PC1 and consequent inappropriate activation of mTOR in the kidney. If this were the case, then rapamycin would ameliorate cyst formation in our morphants.
To test this, we added 10 nM rapamycin to the zebrafish water at 24 hpf. The addition of rapamycin to uninjected controls had no effect (Fig. 1a,a′). The left-hand column of Fig. 1 (Fig. 1a–g) shows renal oedema at 5 dpf in every ciliopathy morphant tested that had been treated with vehicle (DMSO) alone. The right-hand column (Fig. 1a′–g′) shows how every morphant treated with rapamycin shows almost complete restoration of renal size and morphology. This is quantified in Fig. 1i where the size of the oedematous swelling is measured with and without rapamycin for all morphants tested. The other phenotypes caused by the MO (curly tail, cardiac oedema, otolith defects) are unaffected by the addition of rapamycin, suggesting a kidney-specific effect.
In the absence of rapamycin, 100% of mks1 morphants, the mutations of which are lethal in humans, died by 5 dpf and necrosed (Fig. 1f). However, upon the addition of rapamycin, 75% of mks1 morphants survived (Fig. 1f′). This suggests that rapamycin was able to prevent the early lethality of mks1 morphants.
We extended the study to include roscovitine, a cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor recently shown to inhibit cyst progression in murine models of polycystic kidney disease . The addition of roscovitine at 6 hpf caused embryos to die before the tail-bud stage due to widespread apoptosis (data not shown). When roscovitine was added at 24 hpf, we observed partial amelioration of the renal phenotype and cardiac oedema (Fig. 1h). Figure 1j shows that roscovitine reduced the size of swelling in the kidney in a dose-dependent fashion, but the effect is far less dramatic than with rapamycin.
It is clear that roscovitine and rapamycin were able to rescue the oedema caused by the cysts. That rapamycin rescued the lethality of the mks1 morphants suggests that it also has some positive effect on renal function. To assay the effect on renal function, we adapted the protocol of Hentschel et al. . We injected the hearts of control and morphant embryos, both treated and untreated with drugs, with rhodamine-labelled 10-kDa dextran and followed the passage of fluorescent dextran out of the embryo. If kidney function is normal, the dextran will be filtered through the glomerulus and excreted in the urine, resulting in a disappearance of fluorescence 24 h after injection. This was apparent in control embryos (Fig. 1k,k′ and m,m′), but in ift80 morphants only around 50% of the dextran was excreted from the embryo, indicating a 50% loss of filtration capacity (Fig. 1l,l′ and n,n′).
An accumulation of dextran in the pronephric duct implies a backing-up in the pronephros, likely due to a reduced ability to filter the bloodstream (Fig. 1n′). This impairment of filtration is unlikely to be a secondary effect of compromised circulation as the dextran had diffused into the peripheral vasculature of the morphant embryos just as quickly as in the controls (Fig. 1l). Despite cardiac oedema in the morphants, the heart beat at the same rate and with the contractile force as in the controls (data not shown).
Treatment with rapamycin was able to partially rescue the filtering capacity of the kidney, as evidenced by a faint fluorescence remaining in the heart and pronephros 24 h post-injection (Fig. 1o,o′). When roscovitine was added to these morphants, there was also a significant reduction in retained dextran compared to untreated fish, but there was more residual fluorescence in the heart and pronephros than in rapamycin-treated embryos (Fig. 1p,p′). Therefore, roscovitine is not as effective at restoring renal function in the morphant as rapamycin.
These functional assays were repeated using bbs4 morphants (and nphp2, not shown), as another example of a ciliopathy gene causing a different disease when mutated in humans. Figure 1q shows the amount of fluorescence remaining in the heart 24 h post-injection: 9% of the dextran remains in the controls, but in both ift80 and bbs4 morphants, only about 55% is removed. Rapamycin had no effect on kidney function in the controls, but it did improve filtering capacity by approximately 2.3-fold and approximately threefold in ift80 and bbs4 morphants, respectively, as calculated by comparing the amount of fluorescence remaining in the heart with or without drug treatment.
The addition of roscovitine improved filtering capacity by approximately 1.2-fold and approximately 1.8-fold in ift80 and bbs4 morphants, respectively. These data suggest that the bbs4 morphant kidney phenotype is less severe than the ift80 one as the function is restored to a greater extent. It also suggests that rapamycin is twice as effective at restoring renal function in zebrafish as roscovitine. Rapamycin had a greater effect on functional restoration when added at 24 hpf than at 4 hpf.
The studies reported here validate the zebrafish as a model for human ciliopathies. As there is currently a shortage of mouse models for ciliopathies, many of which suffer from embryonic lethality, have variable temporal cyst development and, moreover, must often be euthanised and sectioned to reveal the cysts, it is far more efficient to screen the phenotypes in the fish . We have demonstrated the virtue of the fish as a preclinical drug screening tool capable of quantitatively differentiating between the efficacy of two different compounds, with the potential to assay functional repair as well as morphological rescue. We have also observed similar levels of renal structural and functional repair with another known anti-cyst drug, paclitaxel (data not shown).
Renal disease is the greatest contributor to morbidity and mortality in ciliopathy patients . However, as the ciliopathies are rare diseases with relatively few patients, there is little commercial incentive to develop orphan drugs and perform clinical trials. Nevertheless, it is important to develop therapies to treat these patients. This preliminary study provides proof of principle for a high-throughput screen using a small-molecule library to identify more compounds. These can then be tested on mouse models with the ultimate aim of treating ciliopathy patients. The approach also validates the use of pre-existing therapies for new diseases that may have similar pathomechanisms to polycystic kidney disease.
Thanks to Masazumi Tada for provision of zebrafish injection facilities and to Adrian Woolf for helpful discussions. This work was funded by the Medical Research Council (JLT) and the Wellcome Trust (PLB).
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.