The presence of facial nerve weakness on diagnosis of a parotid gland malignant process
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Wierzbicka, M., Kopeć, T., Szyfter, W. et al. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol (2012) 269: 1177. doi:10.1007/s00405-011-1882-6
- 496 Downloads
The objectives of this article are to assess the frequency and significance of facial paralysis and undiagnosed nerve infiltration in patients with parotid malignancies. 103 patients with parotid gland malignancies were treated in a single institution, the tertiary center for ENT at the University Department in Poznan between 1996 and 2006. Facial palsy at the initial presentation was found in 32 patients. The stage of the primary tumor in the examined group of 103 patients is as follows: 20—T1, 31—T2, 20—T3, 32—T4. The correlation between facial nerve function before treatment and patients’ characteristics, including the treatment methods, were analyzed. Intact facial nerve function at patient presentation was a very strong prognostic factor determining the treatment and final outcome for malignant neoplasms of parotid gland. Similarly, T stage and a high-grade malignant histology had a direct influence on the duration of patients’ survival.
KeywordsParotid malignant tumors Facial nerve paralysis
Parotid tumors typically manifest as a painless lump in the preauricular region. The majority are benign; however, inflammatory symptoms (pain, reddened skin) and facial asymmetry are characteristics that strongly suggest a malignant lesion. The duration of complaints in such a histologically diverse group of benign tumors and malignancies can vary greatly. Facial nerve weakness alarms the patient, family, and General Practitioner and prompts an earlier referral and consultation. Preoperative facial nerve palsy is a manifestation of malignant infiltration and so far, the only preoperative indicator for planning total parotidectomy with nerve resection and facial reanimation [3, 6, 15]. When the facial nerve function is intact, early involvement with tumor cannot be definitively ruled out. Preoperative imaging (ultrasonography, computed tomography, and magnetic resonance) do not have the resolution for nerve structure visualization . Therefore, intraoperative nerve assessment is crucial in the decision making process as to whether the nerve should be resected.
The aims of the study are to (1) assess the frequency of facial paralysis and undiagnosed nerve infiltration in patients with parotid malignancies; (2) analyze the duration of symptoms before presentation; and (3) define the risk factors for nerve impairment and the impact of facial nerve involvement on treatment methods, outcomes, and survival.
One hundred and three patients had surgery for parotid gland malignancies in a single institution, the tertiary center for ENT as the University Department in Poznań between 1996 and 2006. Facial palsy, assessed in House–Brackmann 6-score scale (H-B), was identified at the initial presentation in 32 patients: 28 had total facial palsy (H-B 6) and 4 had partial facial palsy (H-B 2-5). In five other patients, intra-operative features of facial nerve infiltration were found although the facial mobility was normal preoperatively (H-B 1). The study group included 53 women and 50 men ranging in age from 12 to 87 years, with a mean age of 55 years.
The tumor histology was assessed according to WHO—1991 classification, modified in 2003: adenoid cystic carcinoma—27, acinic cell carcinoma —9, undifferentiated carcinoma—8, mucoepidermoid carcinoma—8, squamous cell carcinoma—18, anaplastic carcinoma—3, adenocarcinoma—7, lymphoma malignum—5, ex-pleomorphic carcinoma—6, and metastases—12. Twelve cases assessed on the base of histology as metastases had primaries in: skin (two malignant melanoma), kidney (two clarocellular cancer), prostatic gland (two adenocarcinoma), and upper aerodigestive tract (six squamous cell carcinoma). In preoperative oligobiopsy atypical cell or malignant cell were diagnosed in all cases from “metastases group.” Thus, these patients were primarily graded with T stage. Finally, 2 weeks after the procedure, the pathological examination revealed metastases and the further diagnostics of the primary was carried up. We would underline the difference between primary salivary tumors and metastatic process. In further analysis, this group would be distinguished and its outcomes compared with other histological entities.
The stage of the primary tumor in the examined group of 103 patients is as follows: 20—T1, 31—T2, 20—T3, 32—T4a. The diameter of the tumors in preoperative imaging (ultrasonography, computed tomography, or magnetic resonance imaging) ranged from 1 to 9 cm, with a mean 3 cm.
The duration of symptoms before the initial presentation ranged between 1 and 120 months, with a mean of 12 months. The mean duration of complaints in patients with facial palsy was 16.8 months and the mean duration of complaints in patients without facial palsy was 14.1 months. The duration of complaints for a particular histologic diagnosis was as follows: adenoid cystic carcinoma—15 months, acinic cell carcinoma—7 months, undifferentiated carcinoma—7 months, mucoepidermoid carcinoma–15 months, squamous cell carcinoma—6 months, and adenocarcinoma—34 months.
Taking into consideration the cancer histology, facial nerve paresis was noted in: 11 out of 27 with adenoid cystic, 5 out of 9 with acinic cell, 4 out of 8 with undifferentiated, 3 out of 8 with mucoepidermoid, 6 out of 18 with squamous cell, 4 out of 6 with ex-pleomorphic cancer, 1 out of 7 with adenocarcinoma, and in 0 out of 20 patients from the rest of the group (12 with metastases in parotid, 5 with lymphoma malignum, and 3 with anaplastic carcinoma).
All patients were treated surgically with the intent for complete resection. In most cases, the facial nerve was identified by anterograde dissection, but in some it was identified by the retrograde technique. A cable graft, when used, was harvested from the greater auricular nerve. All patients with nerve palsy were given adjuvant radiotherapy.
The data were analyzed statistically by Chi-square test to compare categorical variables between groups or non-parametric Kruskal–Wallis and Mann–Whitney test. The overall survival results were calculated using the Kaplan–Meier method and differences were analyzed by the log-rank test.
The correlation between facial nerve function before treatment and patients’ characteristics, including the treatment methods, were analyzed.
Correlation between duration of symptoms and paresis of the facial nerve at the initial presentation
Paresis of the facial nerve
Duration of symptoms (months)
Correlation between tumor size and facial nerve paresis at the initial presentation
Paresis of the facial nerve
Treatment of primary tumor
Partial lateral parotidectomy 37 patients
Lateral parotidectomy 34 patients
Total parotidectomy 32 patients
Neck dissection 6
Neck dissection 6
Neck dissection 15
Paresis of the facial nerve
Occurance of facial nerve paresis and treatment method
Facial nerve palsy
Partial lateral parotidectomy
In all patients, pathology was performed and the margins were assessed. Histological analysis revealed that in 18 out of 103 cases, free margins were not obtained (resection margins incomplete or close). This included 8 (25%) patients with facial nerve paresis and 10 (14%) patients without paresis. The difference was not statistically significant.
Local-regional control and disease-free survival were studied in the all of patients with parotid malignancies in a 3-year follow-up.
Comparison of recurrence frequency in patients with and without facial nerve paresis
Facial nerve paresis
Neck node control was 90% for non-paresis patients and 92% for patients with nerve paresis. Distant metastases were observed in only two patients, both without impaired nerve function.
The present study describes one center’s 10-year experience with parotid malignancy treatment with a focus on facial nerve status. In this retrospective analysis, the authors have taken into consideration patients’ age, gender, the duration of complaints (lump and facial paresis), preoperative clinical features of the primary (diameter, skin involvement, total or partial nerve paresis), histologic data, postoperative assessment of specimens, and outcome measures (time until relapse and survival).
In the examined group, facial nerve palsy appeared in nearly 33% of patients (32/103). This included 28 with total paralysis and 4 with partial paralysis. However, of the patients with parotid tumors of advanced stage, over 50% had facial nerve palsy as the presenting and dominant symptom. Facial nerve palsy was the clinical symptom in 60% of patients with adenoid cystic carcinoma and in 66% with squamous cell cancer. The paralysis was less frequent (33.3%) in cancers developing from mixed tumors. Taking into consideration metastases, O’Brien and co-authors proposed a new staging system for patients with metastatic squamous carcinoma (SCC) to the parotid irrespective of cervical nodal status. In a series of 87 patients, metastases were staged according to the clinical extent of disease in three groups: P1, tumor up to the 3 cm in diameter; P2, tumor greater than 3 cm up to 6 cm in diameter or multiple metastatis parotid nodes; P3, tumor greater than 6 cm in diameter, VII nerve palsy or skull invasion. Author recommends that the clinical staging system for cutaneous SCC of the head and neck should separate parotid and neck disease . The results of this study demonstrated, that patients with metastatic cutaneous SCC in both the parotid gland and neck had a significantly worse prognosis than those with in the parotid alone. These observations were confirmed in group of 232 patients by Bron et al.  and by Andruchow et al.  in multicenter study of 322 patients from six different institutions. For metastases to the parotid, none out of our 12 (100%) patients had a facial palsy. A similar observation was made by Moriniere et al. , who revealed facial nerve palsy in 33% of primary malignant tumors and in only 6% of metastasis to the parotid8. In Terhaard et al.’s  analysis describing 324 malignant tumors of the parotid, 27% of the patients were found with no facial paresis, 14% were observed with partial paralysis, and 7% had total paralysis. Preis and co-authors in their research presented a group of 66 patients. They found 8 patients with facial paralysis and in 16 others the infiltration was diagnosed intra-operatively. Salivary duct carcinoma was strongly associated with facial paresis .
The assessment of risk factors for facial nerve palsy, in cases of malignant tumors, was presented by Terhaard et al. . There was a statistically significant correlation between facial nerve paralysis and localization in deep lobe, old age, pain, and infiltration of perineurium. Huang et al., based on 60 patients with post-operative weakness of the facial nerve function, showed a significantly higher risk of paresis in operations for cancers greater than 4 cm. Post-operative paresis was also higher in patients with intra-operative signs of nerve infiltration (95.5%) versus no infiltration (51.3%). The authors mentioned above did not demonstrate a connection between the histology of the tumor and the presence of palsy. However, tumor size, presence in the deep lobe, and nerve infiltration were highly significant . This is confirmed by Preis et al., who recognized the location in the deep lobe and the size of the tumor as important factors. They did not show a correlation with age, sex, pain, and metastases to lymph nodes . Our research demonstrated that facial nerve palsy occurs significantly more in tumors greater than 4 cm. It is well known that malignant infiltration of the facial nerve happens more frequently with a longer duration of symptoms and an advanced stage. A longer duration of symptoms and a delayed initiation of treatment increase the risk of facial palsy, and worsen the outcome. This was confirmed in our research. Despite the fact that the results were not statistically significant, the duration of symptoms in patients with facial nerve palsy was nearly 3 months longer than in patients whose only symptom was a tumor. Non-radical surgery (positive surgical margins) was more prevalent in the paretic group (25%) versus the non-paretic group (14%). Local recurrence was higher in the paresis group (18.8 vs. 7%). Similar results were presented by Terhaardet al. They demonstrated that facial nerve palsy correlated with a significantly lower percentage of survival, 13% for total and 37% for partial paralysis, in comparison to 69% for patients without paresis . Our study clearly proved a correlation of both T stage and facial nerve palsy at presentation and the duration of survival of patients with parotid cancer.
The quality of life of the patients after radical removal of the cancer depends on the extent of resection, facial nerve preservation, and the preservation of neighboring structures such as the great auricular nerve, hypoglossal nerve, mandibular nerve, and the lateral wall of the pharynx [4, 11].
Removal of one or several of the facial nerve branches leads to long-term functional deficits, and facial muscle atrophy Cable graft techniques and neural repair are vital in the reconstruction and recovery of the resected facial nerve. Muscle rehabilitation is also important to preserve the mass of muscles while they are temporarily deprived of motor innervation [7, 14].
In the study from Holland, among 332 patients, the facial nerve was sacrificed in 21% of patients, and a reconstruction was performed in only 1/3 of those with sacrificed nerves (19/60) . Final results of treatment showed a partial paresis in 22% of patients and total paresis in 17%. In our analysis, a reconstruction was performed in five patients. Overall, 32 out of 103 were left with permanent facial paralysis, with 28 cases involving all three branches.
In our study, the incidence of facial nerve palsy due to malignant tumors of the parotid was not correlated with age, sex, duration of symptoms, and histological type of tumors. However, tumor size had a strong statistical correlation with paresis and emphasizes the importance of early diagnosis and treatment to optimize outcome. Facial nerve paresis had a very strong prognostic correlation with a poor outcome in the treatment of malignant neoplasm of parotid. Similarly, a high T stage, and a highly malignant histology, both have a directly negative influence on the patients’ survival.
In conclusion, on the basis of analyzed data, prognostic factors concerning pre-treatment risk of facial paresis did not show a correlation with gender, age, duration of history, and tumor histology. However, a longer duration of symptoms and a higher grade histology was observed in paresis group. Increased tumor diameter was the single factor that was statistically correlated with a risk of facial palsy.
Pre-treatment facial nerve status was prognostically significant. Facial nerve impairment before resection was very strongly predictive for a shorter disease-free survival. Facial nerve impairment was correlated with larger tumors and a higher histologic grade of malignancy.
Conflict of interest
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.