Abstract
Comparisons of Japan with Western countries have long been used to explore the relationship between technology and culture. In the 1950s and 1960s such work sought to determine if technological imperatives were diminishing cultural differences. In the 1970s, 1980s and early 1990s many sought to identify aspects of Japanese culture that might lie at the root of Japan’s technological successes. This article argues that we should now undertake more micro and more systematic comparative studies that are more directly grounded in theory. Studies concentrating on engineers and the practice of engineering would seem to be an especially promising starting point.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abegglen J (1958) The Japanese factory. Free Press, Glencoe, IL
Abegglen J, Stalk G (1985) Kaisha. Basic Books, New York
Abetti P (1994) Impact of technology on functional roles and strategies: illustrative cases in the USA, Japan and France, and lessons learned. Int J Technol Manage 9:529–546
Aoki M (1988) Information, incentives, and bargaining in the Japanese economy. Cambridge University Press, New York
Aryee S, Leong CC (1991) Career orientation and work outcomes among industrial R&D professionals. Gr Org Stud 16(2):193–205
Bjiker WE (1987) The social construction of Baekelite: towards a theory of social invention. In: Bjiker WE, Hughes T and Pinch TJ (eds) The social construction of technological systems, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Bond MH, Hofstede G (1990) The cash value of Confucian values. In: Clegg SR, Redding G (eds) Capitalism in contrasting cultures, de Gruyter, Berlin
Campbell J (1995) Culture, innovative borrowing, and technology management. In: Liker J, Ettlie JE and Campbell JC (eds) Engineered in Japan, Oxford University Press, New York
Clark K, Fujimoto T (1989) Lead time in automobile product development: explaining the Japanese advantage. J Engin Technol Manage 6(1):25–58
Clark K, Fujimoto T (1991) Product development performance. Harvard Business School Press, Cambridge, MA
Clegg SR, Redding SG (eds) (1990) Capitalism in contrasting cultures. de Gruyter, Berlin
Cole RE (1971) Japanese blue collar. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA
Cole RE (1973) Functional alternatives and economic development: an empirical example of permanent employment in Japan. Amer Sociol Rev 38:424–438
Cole RE (1978) The late developer hypothesis: an evaluation of its relevance for Japanese employment practices. J Japan Stud 4:247–265
Cole RE (1989) Strategies for learning. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA
Cole RE (1999) Managing quality fads: how American business learned to play the quality game. Oxford University Press, New York
Cusumano MA, Takeishi A (1991) Supplier relations and management: a survey of Japanese, Japanese-transplant, and U.S. auto plants. Strat Manage J 12:563–588
Dertouzos M, Lester R, Solow R and MIT Commission on Industrial Productivity (1989) Made in America: regaining the productive edge. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
Dore R (1973) British factory-Japanese factory. University of California Press, Berkeley, CA
Dowlatshahl S (1996). An empirical assessment of continuing education needs. J Manage Engin 12(5):37–44
Duke B (1986) The Japanese school: lessons for industrial America. Praeger, New York
Earley PC (1993) East meets West meets Mideast: further explorations of collectivistic and individualistic work groups. Acad Manage J 36(2):319–348
Frey J, Finan W (1991) Engineering education in Japan: a career-long process. Engin Educ 81:66–472
Funk J (1992) The teamwork advantage: an inside look at Japanese product and technology development. Productivity Press, Cambridge, MA
Gerpott T, Domsch M and Keller R (1988) Career orientations in different countries and companies: an empirical investigation of West German, British and U.S. industrial R&D professionals. J Manage Stud 25(5):439–462
Grayson L (1987a) Technology in Japan: advancing the frontiers. Engin Educ 4/5:687–696
Grayson L (1987b) Japan’s intellectual challenge. In: Christensen D (ed) Engineering excellence, IEEE Press, New York
Hall ET, Hall MR (1987) Hidden differences. Anchor Books, New York
Harrison GL, McKinnon JL, Wu A and Chow CW (2000) Cultural influences on adaptations to fluid work groups and teams. J Int Busin Stud 31(3):489–505
Helper S, Sako M (1995). Supplier relations in Japan and the United States: are they converging? Sloan Manage R 36:77–84
Hofstede G (1980) Culture’s consequences. Sage, Beverly Hills, CA
Hofstede G (1993) Cultural constraints in management theories. Acad Manage Exec 7(1):81–94
Hofstede G (1997) Cultures and organizations: software of the mind. McGraw Hill, New York
Hull F, Azumi K (1989) Teamwork in Japanese and U.S. labs. Res Technol Manage 32:21–26
Hull F, Hage J and Azumi K (1985) R&D management strategies: America versus Japan. IEEE Trans Engin Manage EM-32(2):78–83
Kaufman H (1991) Continuing education for Japanese engineers is in-house and on the job. Engin Educ 7/8:473
Kim Y, Cha J (2000) Career orientations of R&D professionals in Korea. R&D Manage 30(2):121–137
Kinmouth E (1991) Japanese engineers and American myth makers. Pacif Aff 64(3):328–350
Kusunoki K, Numagami T (1998) Interfunctional transfers of engineers in Japan: empirical findings and implications for cross-functional integration. IEEE Trans Engin Manage 45(3):250–262
Lam A (1996) Engineers, management and work organization: a comparative analysis of engineers’ work roles in British and Japanese electronics firms. J Manage Stud 33(2):183–212
Lederman L (1994) Strategies among some nations: France, the Federal Republic of Germany, Japan, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Pol Stud J 22:279–295
Liker J, Ettlie J and Campbell J (eds) (1995) Engineered in Japan: Japanese technology-management practices. Oxford University Press, New York
Liker J, Fruin NM, and Adler P (1999) Remade in America: transplanting and transforming Japanese management systems. Oxford University Press, New York
Lynn LH (1991) Cultural differences and the management of engineering in U.S.-Japanese joint ventures. In: Proceedings of PICMET ‘91, Portland, Oregon, October 1991
Lynn LH (2000) Technology competition policies and the semiconductor industries of Japan and the United States: a fifty-year retrospective. IEEE Trans Engin Manage 47:200–210
Lynn LH, Piehler H and Zahray W (1989) Engineering graduates in the United States and Japan: a comparison of their numbers, and empirical study of their careers and methods of information transfer. Carnegie-Mellon University Press, Pittsburgh, PA
Lynn LH, Piehler H and Kieler M (1993) Engineering careers, job rotation and gatekeepers in Japan and the United States. J Engin Technol Manage 10:53–72
Mansfield E (1988) The speed and cost of industrial innovation in Japan and the United States: external vs. internal technology. Manage Sci 34(10):1157–1168
March J (1965) Introduction. In: March J (ed) Handbook of organizations, Rand McNally, Chicago, IL
Moritani M (1982) Japanese technology. Simul Press, Tokyo
Moritz EG (1996) Systematic, pragmatic, analytic—a comparison of the Japanese, American and Geman approaches to machine tool design. In: Rasumussen L, Rauner F (eds) Industrial cultures and production. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Morris MH, Davis DL and Allen JW (1994) Fostering corporate entrepreneurship: cross-cultural comparisons of the importance of individualism versus collectivism. J Int Bus Stud 25(1):65–89
Mueller F (1994) Societal effect, organizational effect and globalization. Org Stud 15(3):407–428
National Science Board (1998) Science and engineering Indicators—1998. National Science Foundation (NSB 98–1), Arlington, VA
Nobeoka K, Cusumano MA (1995) Multiproject strategy, design transfer, and product performance: a survey of automobile development projects in the US and Japan. IEEE Trans Engin Manage 42(4):397–409
Porter M, Takeuchi H and Sakakibara M (2000) Can Japan compete? Perseus, Cambridge, MA
Rasmussen L, Rauner F (eds) (1996) Industrial cultures and production. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Rosenberg N, Steinmueller W (1988) Why are Americans such poor imitators? Amer Econ Rev 78(2):229–234
Ruth K (1996) Industrial culture—an action-oriented view at innovation and production. In: Rasmussen L, Rauner F (eds) Industrial cultures and production. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg New York
Ruth K (1997) Turning difference into advantage—East/West characteristics of industrial culture and their impacts on innovation in the 21st century. In: Yoshimi I (ed) Proceedings of the International Conference on Manufacturing Milestones toward the 21st Century—MM21. Tokyo: Japan Society of Mechanical Engineering.
Science and Technology Agency (1998) Kagaku Gijutsu Yoran 1998. Ministry of Finance Printing, Tokyo (in Japanese)
Sobek DK, Liker JK and Ward AC (1998) Another look at how Toyota integrates product development. Harv Bus Rev 76(4):36–50
Takahashi N (1992) Engineering education in Japan. IEEE Communic Mag 11:28–36
Tsuji M, Nanni A (1994) Civil engineering undergraduate education in Japan: system overview. J Prof Iss Engin 120(2):135–144
Tushman M, Anderson P (1986) Technological discontinuities and organizational environments. Admin Sci Quart 31:439–465
Wakasugi R (1992) Why are Japanese firms so innovative in engineering technology? Res Pol 21:1–12
Westney D (1993) Country patterns in R&D organization: the United States and Japan. In: Kogut B (ed) Country competitiveness: technology and the organization of work. Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK
Westney D, Sakakibara K (1985) Comparative study of the training, careers, and organization of engineers in the computer industry in Japan and the United States. MIT-Japan Science and Technology Program (September)
Whitehill AM (1991) Japanese management: tradition and transition. Routledge, London
Womack J, Jones D (1996) Lean thinking. Simon and Schuster, New York
Womack J, Jones D and Roos D (1990) The machine that changed the world. MacMillan, New York
Wood S, Brown G (1998) Commercializing nascent technology: the case of laser diodes at Sony. J Prod Innov Manage 15:167–183
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Research for this paper was supported by National Science Foundation Award SES-0080644.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lynn, L.H. Culture and engineering in the USA and Japan. AI & Soc 17, 241–255 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-003-0280-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-003-0280-z