Summary
Using an interdisciplinary approach, the current position in the dental amalgam controversy and the potential impact of amalgam mercury on human health are reviewed. Aspects of materials science, corrosion, mercury exposure, toxicology, neurology and immunology are included.
New data on mercury exposure from corroded amalgam fillings in vivo are presented. The exposure can reach levels considerably over known threshold limit values. Also, measurements of mercury absorption from intraoral air are presented. The vital importance of avoiding a galvanic amalgam-gold coupling is emphasized. The symptomatology of a disabled patient, who recovered after amalgam removal, has been included.
It is concluded that discussion of the dental amalgam issue has suffered from the lack of an interdisciplinary approach. It would be wise to learn from the lesson of acrodynia, and consider amalgam mercury among other possible factors in neurological and immunological diseases of unclear etiology.
Similar content being viewed by others
Literatur
Abraham, J. E., Svare, C. W., and Frank, C. W., The effect of dental amalgam restorations on blood mercury levels. J. dent. Res.63 (1984) 71–73.
Adams, C. R., Ziegler, D. K., and Lin, J. T., Mercury intoxication simulating amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. JAMA250 (1983) 642–643.
Ahlqwist, M., Bengtsson, C., Furunes, B., Hollender, L., and Lapidus, L., Number of amalgam tooth fillings in relation to subjectively experienced symptoms. Commun. dent. oral Epidemiol.16 (1988) 227–231.
Ahlrot-Westerlund, B., Carlmark, B., Grönquist, S.-O., Johansson, E., Lindh, U., Theorell, H., and de Vahl, K., Altered distribution patterns of macro- and trace elements in human tissues of patients with decreased levels of blood selenium. Nutr. Res. Suppl.1 (1985) 442–450.
Baader, E. W., Quecksilbervergiftung, in: Handbuch der gesamten Arbeitsmedizin, vol. 2, pp. 158–176 (1961).
Baader, E. W., and Holstein, E. (Eds), Das Quecksilber, seine Gewinnung, technische Verwendung und Giftwirkung, R. Schoetz Verl., Berlin 1933.
Baasch, E., Theoretische Ueberlegungen zur Aetiologie der Sclerosis Multiplex. Die Multiple Sklerose eine Quecksilberallergie? Schw. Arch. Neurol. Neurochir. Psychiat.98 (1966) 1–18.
Barber, T. E., Inorganic mercury intoxication reminiscent of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. J. occup. Med.20 (1978) 667–669.
Berglund, A., Pohl, L., Olsson, S., and Bergman, M., Determination of the rate of release of intra-oral mercury vapor from amalgam. J. dent. Res.67 (1988) 1235–1242.
Bernaudin, J. F., Druet, E., Druet, P., and Masse, R., Inhalation or ingestion of organic or inorganic mercurials produces autoimmune disease in rats. Clin. Immunol. Immunopath.20 (1981) 129–135.
Bidstrup, P. L., Bonell, J. A., Harvey, D. G., and Locket, S., Chronic mercury poisoning in men repairing direct-current meters. Lancet2 (1951) 856–861.
Borinski, P., Die Herkunft des Quecksilbers in den menschlichen Ausscheidungen. Zahnärztl. Rundschau40 (1931) 223–230.
Boyd, M. A., and Richardson, A. S., Frequency of amalgam replacement in general dental practice. J. Can. dent. Ass.10 (1985) 763–766.
Brecht-Bergen, N., Korrosionsuntersuchungen an Zinn-Silber-Amalgamen. Zeitschr. Elektrochemie39 (1933) 927–935.
Brune, D., A model for recording mercury release from an amalgam surface. Biomaterials6 (1985) 357–359.
Brune, D., Metal release from dental biomaterials. Biomaterials7 (1986) 163–175.
Burgener, P., and Burgener, A., Erfahrungen über chronische Quecksilbervergiftungen. Schw. med. Wschr.8 (1952) 204–210.
Cantoni, O., Christie, N. T., Swann, A., Drath, D. B., and Costa, M., Mechanism of HgCl2 cytotoxicity in cultured mammalian cells. Molec. Pharmac.26 (1984) 360–368.
Chang, L. W., and Hartmann, H. A., Blood-brain barrier dysfunction in experimental mercury intoxication. Acta neuropath.21 (1972) 179–184.
Chavez, E., and Holguin, J. A., Mitochondrial calcium release as induced by Hg2+. J. biol. Chem.263 (1988) 3582–3587.
Cherian, M. G., Hursh, J. B., Clarkson, T. W., and Allen, J., Radioactive mercury distribution in biological fluids and excretion in human subjects after inhalation of mercury vapor. Arch. envir. Hlth33 (1978) 109–114.
Clarkson, T. W., The pharmacology of mercury compounds. A. Rev. Pharmac.12 (1972) 375–406.
Contrino, J., Marucha, P., Ribaudo, R., Ference, R., Bigazzi, P. E., and Kreutzer, D. L., Effects of mercury on human polymorphonuclear leukocyte function in vitro. Am. J. Path.132 (1988) 110–118.
Cremer, F., (Ed.), Die Fabrikation der Silber- und Quecksilber-Spiegel. Hartlebens Verlag, Wien/Leipzig 1904.
Daunderer, M., Amalgam. Klin. Toxikologie46 (1989) 1–54.
DeLong, R., Sakaguchi, R. L., Douglas, W. H., and Pintado, M. R., The wear of dental amalgam in an artificial mouth: a clinical correlation. Dent. Mater.1 (1985) 238–242.
Dencker, I., and Schütz, A., Kvicksilverinnehållet i kosten. Läkartidn.68 (1971) 4031–4033.
Dieter, M. P., Luster, M. I., Boorman, G. A., Jameson, C. W., Dean, J. H., and Cox, J. W., Immunological and biochemical responses in mice treated with mercuric chloride. Toxic. appl. Pharmac.68 (1983) 218.
Djerassi, E., and Berova, N., The possibilities of allergic reactions from silver amalgam restorations. Int. dent. J.19 (1969) 481–488.
Domanska-Janik, K., and Bourre, J. M., Effect of mercury on rabbit myelin CNP-ase in vitro. Neurotoxicology8 (1987) 23–32.
Dörffer, U., Anorexia hydrargyra. Kasuistik aus der Praxis. Monatschr. Kinderheilk.137 (1989) 472.
Druet, P., Hirsch, F., Sapin, C., Druet, E., and Bellon, B., Immune dysregulation and autoimmunity induced by toxic agents. Transpl. Proc.14 (1982) 482–484.
Eggleston, D. W., Effect of dental amalgam and nickel alloys on T-lymphocytes: preliminary report. J. Prosth. Dent.51 (1984) 617–623.
Eide, I., and Syversen, T. L. M., Uptake of elemental mercury and activity of catalase in rat, hamster, guinea-pig, normal and acatalasemic mice. Acta pharmac. toxic.51 (1982) 371–376.
Espevik, S., Dental Amalgam. A. Rev. Mater. Sci.7 (1977) 55–72.
Espevik, S., In vitro corrosion of dental amalgams with different Cu content. Scand. J. dent. Res.85 (1977) 631–636.
Espevik, S., and Mjör, I. A., Degradation of amalgam restorations in vivo, in: Corrosion and Degradation of Implant Materials, pp. 316–327. ASTM STP 684 (1979).
Fanconi, G., Botsztejn, A., and Schenker, P., Ueberempfindlichkeitsreaktionen auf Quecksilbermedikation im Kindesalter mit besonderer Berücksichtigung der Calomelkrankheit. Helv. paediatr. Acta2, suppl. 4 (1947) 3–46.
Fleischmann, P., Zur Frage der Gefährlichkeit kleinster Quecksilbermengen. Zschr. angew. Chem.41 (1928) 66–70.
Fraunhofer, J. A., and Staheli, P. J., Gold-amalgam galvanic cells. Br. dent. J.132 (1972) 357–362.
Fredin, B., Studies on the mercury release from dental amalgam fillings. Swed. J. Biol. Med.3 (1988) 8–15.
Friberg, L., and Vostal, J., (Eds), Mercury in the Environment, CRC Press, Cleveland 1972.
Frykholm, K. O., Mercury from dental amalgam. Its toxic and allergic effects and some comments on occupational hygiene. Acta odont. scand.15, suppl. 22 (1957) 1–108.
Gay, D. D., Cox, R. D., and Reinhardt, J. W., Chewing releases mercury from fillings. Lancet1 (1979) 985–986.
Gerstner, H. B., and Huff, J. E., Clinical toxicology of mercury. J. Toxic. envir. Hlth2 (1977) 491–526.
Gmelin's Handbuch der anorganischen Chemie, 34A, 2nd edn, Lief.
Guthrow, C. E., Johnson, L. B., and Lawless, K. R., Corrosion of dental amalgam and its component phases. J. dent. Res.46 (1967) 1372–1381.
Hahn, L. J., Kloiber, R., Vimy, M. J., Takahashi, Y., and Lorscheider, F. L., Dental ‘silver’ tooth fillings: a source of mercury exposure revealed by whole-body image scan and tissue analysis FASEB J.3 (1989) 2641–2646.
Harndt, E., ergebnisse klinischer Untersuchungen zur Lösung der Amalgam-Quecksilberfrage. Dt. zahnärztl. Wschr.33 (1930) 564–575.
Hugoson, A., Results obtained from patients referred for the investigation of complaints related to oral galvanism. Swed. dent. J. 10 (1986) 15–28.
Hursh, J. B., Clarkson, T. W., Cherian, M. G., Vostal, J., and Mallie, R. V., Clearance of mercury (Hg-197, Hg-203) vapor inhaled by human subjects. Arch. envir. Hlth31 (1976) 302–309.
Hyams, B. L., and Ballon, H. C., Dissimilar metals in the mouth as a possible cause of otherwise unexplainable symptoms. Can. med. Ass. J. (1933) 488–491.
Ingalls, T. H., Triggers for multiple sclerosis. Lancet2 (1986) 160.
Jontell, M., Haraldson, T., Persson, L.-O., and Öhman, S.-C., An oral and psychosocial examination of patients with presumed oral galvanism. Swed. dent. J.9 (1985) 175–185.
Jörgensen, K. D., Dental Amalgams (in danish) p. 8. Odontologisk Boghandels Forl. 1976.
Jörgensen, K. D., The mechanism of marginal fracture of amalgam fillings. Acta odont. scand.23 (1965) 347–389.
Jörgensen, K. D., and Saito, T., Structure and corrosion of dental amalgams. Acta odont. scand.28 (1970) 129–142.
Kantarjian, A. D., A syndrome clinically resembling amyotrophic lateral sclerosis following chronic mercurialism. Neurology11 (1961) 639–644.
Klock, B., Blomgren, J., Ripa, U., and Andrup, B., Effekt av amalgamavlägsnande på patienter som misstänker att de lider eller har lidit av amalgamförgiftning. Tandläkartidn.81 (1989) 1297–1302.
Knappwost, A., Gura, E., Fuhrmann, D., and Enginalev, A., Abgabe von Quecksilberdampf aus Dentalamalgamen unter Mundbedingungen. Zahnärztl. Welt/Reform94 (1985) 131–139.
Knolle, G., and Günther, B., Beitrag zu der Ätiologiehypothese: Amalgam und Multiple Sklerose. Schw. Monatschr. Zahnheilk.77 (1967) 761–776.
Kozono, Y., Moore, B. K., Phillips, R. W., and Swartz, M. L., Dissolution of amalgam in saline solution. J. biomed. Mat. Res.16 (1982) 767–774.
Kröncke, A., Ott, K., Petschelt, A., Schaller, K.-H., Szecsi, M., and Valentin, H., Ueber die Quecksilberkonzentrationen in Blut und Urin von Personen mit und ohne Amalgamfüllungen. Dt. zahnärztl. Z.35 (1980) 803–808.
Kussmaul, A., (Ed.), Untersuchungen über den constitutionellen Mercurialismus und sein Verhältniss zur constitutionellen Syphilis. Würzburg, 1861.
Lain, E., and Caughron, G. S., Electrogalvanic phenomena of the oral cavity caused by dissimilar metallic restorations. J. Am. dent. Ass.23 (1936) 1641–1652.
Lain, E., Schriever, W., and Caughron, G. S., Problem of electrogalvanism in the oral cavity caused by dissimilar dental metals. J. Am. dent. Ass.27 (1940) 1765–1772.
Lamm, O., and Pratt, H., Subclinical effects of exposure to inorganic mercury revealed by somatosensory-evoked potentials. Eur. Neurol.24 (1985) 237–243.
Lambrechts, P., Vuylsteke, M., Vanherle, G., and Davidson, C. L., Quantitative in vivo wear of posterior dental restorations, four-year result. J. dent. Res.62 (1985) 370, abstr. no. 1759.
Langworth, S., Elinder, C.-G., and Åkesson, A., Mercury exposure from dental fillings. I. Mercury concentrations in blood and urine. Swed. dent. J.12 (1988) 69–70.
Lavstedt, S., and Sundberg, H., Medicinska diagnoser och sjukdomssymtom relaterade till amalgamfyllningar, Tandläkartidn.81 (1989) 81–88.
Malmström, C., Cracking and cuspfractures in teeth with amalgam fillings. Tidskr. Landlaeger6 (1986) 65–68;8 (1988) 53–59.
Marek, M., Acceleration of corrosion of dental amalgams by abrasion. J. dent. Res.63 (1984) 1010–1013.
Marek, M., and Okabe, T., Corrosion behaviour of structural phases in high copper dental amalgams. J. biomed. Mat. Res.12 (1978) 857–866.
Marxkors, R., Korrosionserscheinungen an Amalgamfüllungen und deren Auswirkungen auf den menschlichen Organismus. Dt. Zahnärzteblatt24 (1970) 53–65.
Mateer, R. R., and Reitz, C. D., Corrosion of amalgam restorations. J. dent. Res.49 (1970) 399–407.
Mayer, R., and Diehl, W., Abgabe von Quecksilber aus Amalgamfüllungen in den Speichel, Dt. zahnärztl. Z.31 (1976) 855–859.
Maximum Allowable Concentrations of Mercury Compounds. Report of an International Committee. Arch. envir. Hlth19 (1969) 891-905.
Meeuwissen, R., Van Elteren, P., Eschen, S., and Mulder, J., Durability of amalgam restorations in premolars and molars in Dutch servicemen. Commun. dent. Hlth2 (1985) 293–302.
Moeschlin, S., (Ed), Klinik und Therapie der Vergiftungen. 6th edn. G. Thieme, Stuttgart 1980.
Müller-Fahlbusch, H., and Wöhning, T., Psychosomatische Untersuchung der mit Amalgamfüllungen in Verbindung gebrachten Beschwerden. Dt. zahnärztl. Z.38 (1983) 663–667.
Nordin, J., Yrkessjukdomar. Almqvist & Wiksell (1943) 184.
Nylander, M., Friberg, L., and Lind, B., Mercury concentrations in the human brain and kidneys in relation to exposure from dental amalgam fillings. Swed. dent. J.11 (1987) 179–187.
Nylander, M., Mercury in pituitary glands of dentists. Lancet1 (1986) 442.
Nystrand, A., Amalgam. Läkartidn.83 (1986) 505–522.
Oettingen, W.F., von, (Ed), Poisoning. A Guide to Clinical Diagnosis and Treatment. Saunder Co., 1958.
Patterson, J. E., Weissberg, B. G., and Dennison, P. J., Mercury in human breath from dental amalgams. Bull. envir. Contam. Toxic.34 (1985) 459–468.
Pelletier, L., Pasquier, R., Hirsch, F., Sapin, C., and Druet, P., In vivo self-reactivity of mononuclear cells to T cells and macrophages exposed to HgCl2. Eur. J. Immunol.15 (1985) 460–465.
Pleva, J., Mercury poisoning from dental amalgam. J. orthomol. Psychiat.12 (1983) 184–193.
Pleva, J., Corrosion and mercury release from dental amalgam. J. orthomol. Med.4 (1989) 141–158.
Poulsson, E., (Ed), Lehrbuch der Pharmakologie. 6th edn. 1922, 16th edn 1949.
Rahola, T., Hattula, T., Korolainen, A., and Miettinen, J. K., Elimination of free and protein-bound ionic mercury (203Hg2+) in man. Ann. clin. Res.5 (1973) 214–219.
Rehde, O., (Ed), Invalidiserande huvudvärk, pp. 117–121. R-Dental AB, Falun, Sweden 1985. (ISBN 91-7810-137-9.)
Robinson, C. J. G., Abraham, A. A., and Balazs, T., Induction of anti-nuclear antibodies by mercuric chloride in mice. Clin. exp. Immunol.58 (1984) 300–306.
Rost, A., Amalgamschäden. Zahnärztl. Prax.20 (1976) 475–480.
Rupp, N. W., and Pfaffenberger, G. O., Significance to health of mercury used in dentistry: a review. J. Am. dent. Ass.82 (1971) 1401–1407.
Sapin, C., Mandet, C., Druet, E., Günther, G., and Druet, P., Immune complex type disease induced by HgCl2: Genetic control of susceptibility. Transpl. Proc.13 (1981) 1404–1406.
Sakar, N. K., Marshall, G. W., Moser, J. B., and Greener, E. H., In vivo and in vitro corrosion products of dental amalgam. J. dent. Res.54 (1975) 1031–1038.
Schneider, V., Untersuchungen zur Quecksilberabgabe aus Silberamalgam-Füllungen mit Hilfe flammenloser Atomabsorption. Dt. zahnärztl. Z.32 (1977) 475–476.
Schneider, P. E., and Sarkar, N. K., Mercury release from Dispersalloy amalgam. 1982, IADR Abstr. No. 630.
Schoonover, I. C., and Souder, W., Corrosion of dental alloys. J. Am. dent. Ass.28 (1941) 1278–1291.
Schulz, H., Wirkung und Anwendung der inorganischen Arzneistoffe. G. Thieme, Leipzig 1907.
Sies, H., (Ed.), Oxidative Stress. Academic Press, London 1985.
Smith, D. L. Jr., Mental effects of mercury poisoning. South. med. J.71 (1978) 904–905.
Smith, R. G., Vorwald, A. J., Patil, L. S., and Mooney, T. F., Effects of exposure to mercury in the manufacture of chlorine, Am. ind. Hyg. Ass. J.31 (1970) 687–700.
Snapp, K. R., Boyer, D. B., Peterson, L. C., and Svare, C. W., The contribution of dental amalgam to mercury in blood, J. dent. Res.68 (1989) 780–785.
Steffensen, K., Om kronisk kvicksölvforgiftning foraarsaget af tandplomber. Ugeskr. Laeg.96 (1934) 855–858.
Stock, A., Die Gefährlichkeit des Quecksilberdampfes. Z. angew. Chem.39 (1926) 461–466.
Stock, A., Die Gefährlichkeit des Quecksilberdampfes und der Amalgame. Med. Klin.22 (1926) 1250–1252.
Stock, A., Die Gefährlichkeit des Quecksilbers und der Amalgam-Zahnfüllungen. Z. angew. Chem.41 (1928) 663–672.
Stock, A., Die chronische Quecksilber- und Amalgamvergiftung, Arch. Gewerbepath.7 (1936) 388–413.
Stock, A., Die chronische Quecksilber- und Amalgamvergiftung. Zahnärztl. Rundschau10 (1939) 403–407.
Stock, A., and Cucuel, F., Der Quecksilbergehalt der menschlichen Ausscheidungen und des menschlichen Blutes. Z. angew. Chem.47 (1934) 641–647.
Stock, A., and Heller, R., Die Bestimmung kleiner Quecksilbermengen. Z. angew. Chem.39 (1926) 466–468.
Storlazzi, E. D., and Elkins, H. B., The significance of urinary mercury. I. Occupational mercury exposure. II. Mercury absorption from mercury-bearing dental fillings and antiseptics. J. ind. Hyg. Toxic.23 (1941) 459–465.
Struntz, H., (Ed.), Verrat an Deiner Gesundheit. Albert Amann Verlag, München 1956.
Stutte, H., and Groh, I., Zur Neuropathologie der Quecksilbervergiftung im Kindesalter. Fortschr. Neurol. Psychiat.29 (1961) 464–474.
Störtebecker, R., Direct transport of mercury from the oronasal cavity to the cranial cavity as a cause of dental amalgam poisoning. Swed. J. Biol. Med.3 (1989) 8–21.
Svare, C. W., Peterson, L. C., Reinhardt, J. W., Boyer, D. B., Frank, C. W., Gay, D. D., and Cox, R. D., The effect of dental amalgams on mercury levels in expired air. J. dent. Res.60 (1981) 1668–1671.
Taskinen, H., Kinnunen, E., and Riihimäki, V., A possible case of mercury-related toxicity resulting from the grinding of old amalgam restorations, Scand. J. envir. Hlth15 (1989) 302–304.
Till, T., and Maly, K., Zum Nachweis der Lyse von Hg aus Silberamalgam von Zahnfüllungen, Der Praktische Arzt32 (1978) 1042–1056.
Till, T., Untersuchungen über den Temperatureinfluss auf elektrochemische Vorgänge an metallischen Zahnreparaturmaterialien. Zahnärztl. Welt/Reform83 (1974) 980–982.
Tompsett, S. L., and Smith, D. C., Mercury in biological materials. J. clin. Path.12 (1959) 219–221.
Trachtenberg, I. M., (Ed.), Chronic Effects of Mercury on Organisms. Transl. from Russian. U.S. Dept. of Health, Education and Welfare DHEW Publ. 74–473, 1974.
Uetrech, J., Mechanism of hypersensitivity reactions: proposed involvement of reactive metabolites generated by activated leukocytes. Trends pharmac. Sci.10 (1989) 463–467.
Vimy, M. J., and Lorscheider, F. L., Intra-oral mercury released from dental amalgam, J. dent. Res.64 (1985) 1069–1071.
Vimy, M. J., and Lorscheider, F. L., Serial measurements of intraoral air mercury: estimation of daily does from dental amalgam. J. dent. Res.64 (1985) 1072–1075.
Vimy, M. J., Takahashi, Y., and Lorscheider, F. L., Maternal-fetal distribution of mercury (203Hg) released from dental amalgam fillings. Am. J. Physiol.258 (1990) R939-R945.
Viola, P. L., L'influenza del cloro sull'intossicazione da vapori di mercurio. Med. Lavoro58 (1967) 60–65.
Viola, P. L., and Cassano, G. B., The effect of chlorine on mercury vapor intoxication. Autoradiographic study. Med. Lavoro59 (1968) 437–444.
Vrijhoef, M. M. A., Vermeersch, A. G., and Spanauf, A. J., Dental Amalgam. Quintessence Publ. Co. Inc. 1980.
Wagner, E., Beitrag zur Klärung des Korrosionsverhaltens der Silber-Zinn Amalgame. Dt. zahnärztl. Z.17 (1962) 99–106.
Walls, A. W. G., Wallwork, M. A., Holland, I. S., and Murray, J. J., The longevity of occlusal amalgam restorations in first permanent molars of child patients, Br. dent. J.158 (1985) 133–136.
Warkany, J., Acrodynia—Postmortem of a disease. Am. J. Dis. Child.112 (1966) 147–156.
Warkany, J., and Hubbard, D. M., Acrodynia and mercury. J. Pediatr.42 (1953) 365–386.
Webb, J. L., (Ed.), Enzyme and metabolic inhibitors, vol. 2, pp. 841. Academic Press, London 1966.
Wesselhaeft, W. P., A few suggestions about mercurial fillings for teeth. Proc. int. Hannemann Ass.16 (1896) 200–209.
Zamm, A. V., Candida albicans therapy. Is there ever an end to it? Dental mercury removal: an effective adjunct. J. orthomol. Med.1 (1986) 261–266.
Zangger, H., Erfahrungen über Quecksilbervergiftungen. Arch. Gewerbepath.1 (1930) 539–560.
Ziff, M. F., and Ziff, S., Tracking the elusive mercury TLV. Bio-Probe Newsletter 3, dec. 1986, 1–24 (Editorial office 4401 Real Ct., Orlando, Fl. 32 808, USA.)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hanson, M., Pleva, J. The dental amalgam issue. A review. Experientia 47, 9–22 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02041243
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02041243