The debate over Diagnosis Related Groups
Cite this article as: Spiegel, A.D. & Kavaler, F. J Community Health (1985) 10: 81. doi:10.1007/BF01326513 Abstract
With the advent of the Prospective Payment System (PPS) using Diagnosis Related Groups (DRGs) as a classification method, the pros and cons of that mechanism have been sharply debated. Grouping the comments into categories related to administration/management, DRG system and quality of care, a review of relevant literature highlights the pertinent attitudes and views of professionals and organizations. Points constantly argued include data utilization, meaningful medical classifications, resource use, gaming, profit centers, patient homogenieity, severity of illness, length of stay, technology limitations and the erosion of standards.
Allen D. Spiegel, M.P.H., Ph.D. and Florence Kavaler, M.D., M.P.H. are Professors of Preventive Medicine & Community Health at Downstate Medical Center, 450 Clarkson Avenue, Box #43, Brooklyn, New York 11203
Medicare Program: Prospective Payment for Medicare Inpatient Hospital Services: Final Rule. Part VI, January 3, 1984, p. 235.
Meyer JA: Increased Consumer Cost-Conscious and Competition.
Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine
Wallace AG, Ellenbogen PS: DRGs: A Positive Side of the Ledger.
North Carolina Medical Journal
Neuhauser D: A Message to Physicians.
Kaemmerer C: A New Reimbursement System. DRGs Are Coming.
Rajani K, Dally AD: Medicare DRGs: Facts and Fallacies.
Wisconsin Medical Journal
Yasko JM, Fleck A: Prospective Payment (DRGs): What Will Be the Impact on Cancer Care?
Oncology Nursing Forum
Bird S, Mailhot C: DRGs: A New Way to Reimburse Hospital Costs.
Beth Israel Hospital, Newark, N.J. Outline notes for address on DRGs. Undated.
Powers DK: Presentation to Subcommittee on Health and the Environment, House Energy and Commerce Committee, Washington, D.C., November 22, 1982.
Bradley D: Per-Case Prospective Payment Under the DRG Methodology. A Three Year Experience in New Jersey. Morristown Memorial Hospital, Morristown, N.J. Undated.
Riddick Jr. FA: The Doctor and the DRG.
Hospital Peer Review. Officials Spot Inequities in DRG Cost Control Program. 6(2):13–15, 1981.
Health Research and Educational Trust of New Jersey.
DRG Evaluation. Volume III Case-Mix Classification, Data, and Management. Princeton, N.J., February 1984, p. 22.
Richards Jr. JF: Prospective Reimbursement and DRGs.
Journal of the Florida Medical Association
Bentley JD, Butler PW:
The DRG Case Mix of a Sample of Teaching Hospitals: A Technical Report
. Washington, D.C.: Association of American Medical Colleges, December 1981.
Henry L: Hospital Concern Shown With New Pay Method Based on Case-Mix, Diagnosis Related Groups.
(14):22–24 (July 16), 1980.
New Jersey Hospital Association.
The DRG Maze. Unravelling the Mysteries of Hospital Reimbursement in New Jersey. Princeton, N.J., 1980.
Friedman E: Getting to Know Us. Hospitals May Finally Learn the True Cost and Pricing.
(6):74, 78–82 (March 16), 1983.
Keith SN: Prospective Payment for Hospital Costs Using Diagnosis Related Groups: Will Cost Inflation Be Reduced?
Journal of the National Medical Association
Grimaldi PL: Can State Rate Review Programs Curb Costs Without Harming Quality?
(2):6, 10–22, 22, 1981.
Levey GS: Government Revamp of the Health Care System: Effect on Patient Care and Research.
Williams SV, Kominski GF, Dowd BE, Soper KA: Methodological Limitations in Case Mix Hospital Reimbursement, With a Proposal for Change.
:17–31 (Spring), 1984.
American Medical News. DRG Programs Should Be Approached Cautiously. Cautiously. (Editorial). 26(24):4 (June 24), 1983.
Who Shall Live? Health, Economics, and Social Choice
. N.Y.: Basic Books, Inc., 1974.
Doremus HD: DRGs May Be Raising False Expectations.
(15):47–51 (August 1), 1980.
Healthcare Financial Management Association. Analysis of Department of Health and Human Services Prospective Payment Proposal. Washington, D.C., January 14, 1983.
Burick D, Nackel J: Diagnosis Related Groups: Tool for Management.
Hospital & Health Services Administration
The Revised DRGs. Their Importance in Medicare Payments to Hospitals. E&W No. J58442. May 1983, p. 3.
Johnson AN, Appel GL: Hospitals Will Fight Biased DRG System.
Hughes Jr. GS: Diagnosis-Related Groups (letter).
Annals of Internal Medicine
Alper PR: Moderating Hospital Costs.
Medical World News
(10):76 (May 28), 1984.
McIllrath S: Revised Grace Panel Report: No DRGs for Physician.
American Medical News
(4):1, 25–26 (January 27), 1984.
American Medical News. DRGs Raise Questions for Medicine, Council Says. 26(18):32 (May 13), 1983. Copyright information
© Human Sciences Press 1985