Abstract
History can serve as a useful tool for better understanding contemporary mental health programs. At present, much interest is directed at apparent parallels between 19th century moral treatment and modern milieu therapies, especially the therapeutic community. A common emphasis on a humane living environment is typically cited as the major parallel between the treatments. However, on closer examination, it appears that moral treatment and the therapeutic community exemplify different conceptions of what constitutes a humane living environment. Moreover, the two overall treatment philosophies differ significantly. These differences are tied to the historical contexts and responses to cultural stress in the mid-19th and mid-20th centuries, and consequent conceptions of mental well-being. A heretofore overlooked, but suggestive parallel between the treatments, which may help explain their efficacy, is the importance of peer self-help as a therapeutic tool. However, whereas the therapeutic community actively encourages peer self-help, 19th century asylum superintendents were unaware of its value.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bockoven JS:Moral Treatment in Community Mental Health. New York, Springer Publishing Company, 1972.
Bond ED: Therapeutic forces in early American hospitals.Am J Psychiatry 113:407–408, 1956.
Caplan R:Psychiatry and Community in Nineteenth Century America. New York, Basic Books, 1969.
Carlson ET, Dain N: The psychotherapy that was moral treatment.Am J Psychiatry 117:519–524, 1960.
Cumming J, Cumming E:Ego and Milieu. Chicago, Aldine Publishing Company, 1962.
Filstead WJ, Rossi JJ: Therapeutic milieu, therapeutic community and milieu therapy. In WJ Filstead and JJ Rossi (eds):The Therapeutic Community. New York, Behavioral Publications, 1973.
Rees TP: Back to moral treatment and community care.J Ment Sci 103:303–313, 1957.
Sprafkin RP: The rebirth of moral treatment.Prof Psychology 8:161–169, 1977.
New York State Asylum.Annual Report, 1847.
Pennsylvania Hospital.Annual Report, 1844.
Eastern State Asylum.Annual Report, 1843.
Bloomingdale Asylum.Annual Report, 1847.
Maine Insane Asylum.Annual Report, 1844, 1848.
Davis PB:Two Years and Three Months In the New York Lunatic Asylum at Utica; Together With the Outlines of Twenty Years Peregrinations in Syracuse. Syracuse, published by author, 1855.
Brigham A: The Moral Treatment of Insanity.Am J Insanity 4:1–15, 1847.
Myers K, Clark DH: Results in a therapeutic community.Br J Psychiatry 120:51–57, 1972.
Foucault M:Madness and Civilization. New York, New American Library, 1965.
Rothman DJ:The Discovery of the Asylum. Boston, Little, Brown and Co., 1971.
Grob GN:Mental Institutions in America. New York, The Free Press, 1973.
Ray I:Mental Hygiene. Boston, Ticknor and Fields, 1863.
Jarvis E: Causes of insanity: An address delivered before the Norfolk, Massachusetts, District Medical Society. Boston, 1851.
Clark DH: The therapeutic community.Br J Psychiatry 131:545–565, 1977.
Manning NP: What Happened to the Therapeutic Community? InYearbook of Social Policy, 1975. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1975.
Jones M: Therapeutic community concepts and the future. In WJ Filstead and JJ Rossi (eds):The Therapeutic Community. New York, Behavioral Publications, 1973.
Rapoport RN:Community as Doctor. Springfield, Ill., Charles C Thomas, 1960.
Hollander R: A new service ideology: The third mental health revolution.Prof Psychol 11:561–566, 1980.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hollander, R. Moral treatment and the therapeutic community. Psych Quart 53, 132–138 (1981). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01064897
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01064897