Abstract
Only during a brief period in the aftermath of the revolution was a portion of the Soviet intelligentsia eager sincerely to cooperate with the Soviet system. Soon, with Stalin's repressions, the intelligentsia, and especially its elite — the intellectuals, or those involved in creative activities such as science, literature and the arts, became locked in permanent conflict with the government.
Once mass terror disappeared after Stalin's death in 1953, intellectuals faced the possibility of confronting the regime without fear of instant arrest and eventual death in the Gulag.
Moral choices became a serious problem, especially during the period of political reaction under Brezhnev in the 1970's, when the regime resorted to repressions (albeit in milder form than during Stalin's times) and corruption in order to prevent the oppositional activity of intellectuals. Brezhnev's regime was rather successful in this endeavor, an issue which was hotly debated by Russian intellectuals in the period ofglasnost' when soul-searching and recanting about their behavior of the 1970's.
The political conformism of intellectuals bore an interesting product, namely, a special mythology which had to exculpate passive intellectuals as well as those who corroborated with the authorities and betrayed their colleagues.
The goal of this paper is to analyze this mythology. The author makes a distinction between two kinds of mythology used by the intellectuals to justify their conformity — a ‘current’ mythology, which is employed for the vindication of contemporary deeds and a ‘retrospective’ mythology, the purpose of which is to acquit one of past actions. The importance of the mythology employed by the intellectuals goes beyond the Soviet experience and reminds one of the developments in the American intellectual community during the McCarthy era, as well as in German and French communities during the Second World War. As a theoretical basis for this paper, the author uses the concept of a two-level mentality which helps explain how people can easily separate their behavior from their system of values.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aksenov, V.,Skazhi Izum, Ann Arbor: Ardis, 1985.
Alekeeva, L.,Istoria Inakomyslia v SSSR. Noveishi Period, Benson, VA: Khronika Press, 1984.
Altaiev, D.,Dvoinoie soznanie intelligentsii i psevdo kul'tura, VRKhD, 1970, 9–32.
Amalrik, A.,Notes of a Revolutionary, New York: Knopf, 1982.
Babenyshev, A. (Ed.),Sakharovski Sbornik, New York: Khronika Press, 1981.
Babenyshev, S.,Tsena prozrenia, inVnutrennie Protivorechia (Vol. 2), New York: Chalidze, 1981.
Berdiaev, N. (Ed.),Vekhi, Moscow, 1909.
Bestuzhev-Lada, I., “Poeta otkryvaia ”,Nedelia, 1988, 29, 16–17.
Chernichenko, Iu., “Dve tainy,”Literaturnaja Gazeta, April 13, 1988.
Chukovskaia, L.,Otkrytoie Slovo, new York: Khronika, 1976.
Chukovskaia, L.,Zapiski ob Anne Akhmatovoi (Vols. 1 and 2), Paris: Ymka Press, 1976, 1980.
Chukovskaia, L.,Prozez Iskliuchenia, Paris: Ymka-Press, 1981.
Crekova (pseudonym),The Streetlamp, Moscow: Sovietski Pisatel’, 1966.
Crekova (pseudonym),The Department, Moscow: Sovietski Pisatel’, 1978.
Davydov, Iu.,Estetika Nigilisma, Moscow: Nauka, 1975.
Davydov, Iu.,Kritika Sotsial'no-Filosofskikh Vozzreni Frankfurtskoi Shkoly, Moscow: Nauka, 1977.
Davydov, Iu., “Begstvo ot Svobody,”Khudozhestvennaia Literatura, 1978.
Davydov, Iu.,Etika Liubvi i Metafisika Svoevolia, Moscow: Molodaia Gvardia, 1982.
Davydov, Iu., & Rodnianskai, I. (Eds.),Sotsiologia Kontr-Kul'tury, Moscow: Nauka, 1979.
Efimov, B.,Ja sozhaleiu, Ogoniok, 1988, 43, 3.
Ehrenburg, I., “Liudi, gody, zhizn',”Ogoniok, 1987, 25, 22–24.
Gabrilovich, E., “Tragedii i dramy schastlivogo kontsa,”Moskovskie Novosti, October 11, 1987.
Gerasimov, G.,Obshchestvo Potreblenia, Moscow: Znanie, 1984.
Ginzburg, L., “V poiskakh tozhdestva,”Sovietskaja Kul'tura, November 12, 1988.
Granin, D.,Iskateli, Moscow: Sovietski Pisatel’, 1954.
Granin, D.,Idu na Grozu, Moscow: Sovietski Pisatel', 1962.
Grossman, V.,Zhizn' i Sud'ba, Lausanne: L' age d'homme, 1980.
Hruby, P.,Fools and Heroes: The Changing Role of Communist Intellectuals in Czecholsolvakia, New York: Pergamon, 1980.
Iakovlev, N.,CIA Against the USSR, Moscow: Mysl', 1983.
Iampol'ski, B., “Moskovskaia Ulitsa,”Znamia, 1988, 2, 46–114; 3, 121–174.
Il'iana, E., “Memuary dissidentki,”Novoye Russkoye Slovo, April 1, 2, 1986.
Ivanov, V., “I dyshat pochva i sud'ba,”Literaturnaja Gazeta, June 1, 1988.
Khazanov, B.,Zapakh Zvezd, New York: Vremia i My, 1977.
Kheifets, M.,Mesto i Vremia (Evreiskie Zametki), Paris: Tretia Volna, 1978.
Kheifets, Io., “O druziakh-tovarishchakh,”Sovietskaja Kul'tura, October 20, 1987.
Kiesler, A., & Kiesler, S.,Conformity, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1969.
Kliamkin, I., “Pochemu trudno govorit' pravdu,”Novyi Mir, 1989, 2.
Kondrashov, S., “V chuzhoi stikhii,”Novyi Mir, 1985, 11, 5–130.
Kopelev, L.,Sotvorim Sebe Kumira, Ann Arbor: Ardis, 1978.
Korotich, V.,Litso Nenavisti, Moscow: Sovietski Pisatel’, 1985.
Korotich, V., “My-tol'ko kapli, a reka — narod,”Sovietskaja Kul'tura, August 8, 1986.
Kozhinov, V., “My meniaemsia? Polemicheskie zametki o kul'ture, zhizni i litdeiateliakh,Nash Sovremennik, 1987, 10, 160–174.
Krasin, V.,Sud, New York: Chaldize Publications, 1983.
Likhachev, D., “Ot pokainia k deistviu,”Literaturnaja Gazeta, September 9, 1987.
Lobanov, M., “Posleslovie,”Nash Sovremennik, 1988, 4, 154–159.
Milosz, Cz.,The Captive Mind, New York: Knopf, 1953.
Mlynarzh, Z.,Kholodom Veiet ot Kremlia, New York: Problems of Eastern Europe, 1983.
Neizvestnyi, E.,Govorit Neizvestnyi, Frankfurt: Posev, 1984.
Orlova, R.,Memoirs, New York: Random House, 1983.
Pankin, B., “Vozdukh 6-go etazha,”Komsomolskaja Pravda, 1988, 5.
Panova, V.,O Moei Zhizni, Knigakh i Chitateliakh, Leningrad: Lenizdat, 1975.
Plushch, L.,Na Karnavale Istorii, London Overseas Press, 1979.
Pomerants, G., “Tsena otrechenia,” in A. Babenyshev et al. (Eds.),Sakharovski Sbornik, 1981.
Popova, I., “Tsennostnyie Predstavlenia i “paradoksy” Samosoznania,”Sotsiologicheskie Issledovania, 1984, 4, pp. 29–36.
Rosiner, F.,Nekto Finkel'maier, London; Overseas Publications, 1981.
Seliunin, V.,Planirovat' ili upravliat'. Moskovskie Novosti, May 1, 1988.
Shlapentokh, V., “The study of values as a social phenomenon: the Soviet case,”Social Forces, 1982, 61 (Spring), 403–417.
Shlapentokh, V.,Love, Marriage and Friendship in the Soviet Union: Ideals and Practices, New York: Praeger, 1984a.
Shlapentokh, V., “Intellectuals as bearers of specific social values: there and here,”Russia, 1984b, 9, 3–26.
Shlapentokh, V.,Soviet Public Opinion and Ideology, New York: Praeger, 1986.
Shragin, B.,Protivostoianie Dukha, London: Overseas Publications, 1977.
Shtein, A., “I ne tol'ko o nem,”Teatr, March, 1988, 169–187.
Shtein, A., “Moie pokolenie,”Sovietskaja Kul'tura, May 23, 1987.
Shubkin, V.,Sotsiologicheskie Opyty, Moscow: Mysl', 1970.
Shubkin, V. (Ed.),Trudiashchaiasia Molodezh: Obrazovanie, Professia, Mobil'nost', Moscow: Nauka, 1984.
Shubkin, V.,Trudnoie proshchanie, Novyi Mir, 1989, 4, 165–184.
Simonov, K., “Glazami cheloveka moiego pokolenia,”Znamia, 1988, 3, 3–66; 4, 49–121; 5, 69–96.
Trifonov, I.,Studenty, Moscow: Pisatel', 1950.
Trifonov, I.,Vremia i Mesto, Moscow: Sovietski Pisatel', 1981.
Vaksberg, A., “Kost' mamonta,”Literaturnaja Gazeta, May 18, 1988.
Vishnevskaia, G.,Galina, New York: Random House, 1984.
Vodolazov, G., “Kto vinovat, chto delat' i kakoi schet?,” in Iu. Afanasiev (Ed.),Inogo ne Dano, Moscow: Progress, 1988, 441–467.
Zinoviev, A.,Ziaushchie Vysoty, Lausanne: L'Âge d'Homme, 1976.
Zinoviev, A.,Homo Sovieticus, Lausanne: L'Âge d'Homme, 1982.
Zipko, A., “O zonakh zakrytykh dlia mysli,”Nauka i Zhizn, 1988a, 11, 45–55.
Zipko, A., “Prevratnosti Chistogo sotsializma,”Nauka i Zhizn, 1988b, 12, 40–48.
Zipko, A., “Egoism mechtatelei,”Nauka i Zhizn', 1989, 1, 46–56.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shlapentokh, V. The justification of political conformism: The mythology of Soviet intellectuals. Studies in Soviet Thought 39, 111–135 (1990). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00838027
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00838027