Abstract
This article presents a case study from the history of cardiology, namely, the development towards the acceptance of the coronary theory of angina pectoris. I show that the arguments which were considered decisive against the theory were not answered at the time the theory was accepted. I also point out that the experimental and practical success of the theory cannot be used to support the initial choice because, in the subsequent development, the field researchers became preoccupied with new questions and problems. In spite of this, there is a sense in which the field of angina research has progressed, but it remains a challenge to exactly characterise in what sense this is the case.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Benson, H., and McCallie, D. P.: 1979, ‘Angina Pectoris and the Placebo Effect’, New England Journal of Medicine 300, 1424–29.
Cobb, L. A., Thomas, G. I., Dillard, D. H., Merendino, K. A., and Bruce, R. A.: 1959, ‘An Evaluation of Internal-Mammary-Artery Ligation by a Double-blind Technic’, New England Journal of Medicine 260, 1115–18.
Dietrich, S., and Schwiegk, H.: 1933, ‘Angina pectoris und Anoxie des Herzmuskels’, Zeitschrift für klinische Medizin 125, 195–242.
Doppelt, G.: 1978, Kuhn's Epistemological Relativism: An Interpretation and Defense’, Inquiry 21, 33–86.
Doppelt, G.: 1986, ‘Relativism and the Reticulational Model of Scientific Rationality’, Synthese, 69, 225–52.
Doppelt, G.: 1988, ‘The Philosophical Requirements for an Adequate Conception of Scientific Rationality’, Philosophy of Science 55, 104–33.
Feil, J., and Siegel, M. L.: 1928, ‘Electrocardiographic Changes during Attacks of Angina Pectoris’, American Journal of the Medical Sciences 175, 255–60.
Hacking, I.: 1983, Representing and Interventing. Introductory Topics in the Philosophy of Natural Science, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Harrison, T. R.: 1935, Failure of the Circulation, Williams & Wilkins Company, Baltimore.
Kleyn, J. B.: 1934, ‘Der Einfluss der Psyche auf das Elektrokardiogramm im Zusammenhang mit den Veränderungen des Elektrokardiogrammes während eines Anfalles von Angina pectoris’, Zeitschrift für Kreislaufforschung 26, 353–57.
Lie, R. K.: 1987, Theory Change in Cardiovascular Research, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Minnesota, University Microcrofilms International, Ann Arbor, MI.
Malliani, A.: 1986, ‘The Elusive Link between Transient Myocardial Ischemia and Pain’, Circulation 73, 201–04.
Maseri, A., Chierchia, S., Davies, G., and Glazier, J.: 1985, ‘Mechanisms of Ischemic Cardiac Pain and Silent Myocardial Ischemia’, American Journal of Medicine 79 (suppl. 3A), 7–11.
Pardee, H. E. B.: 1920, ‘An Electrocardiographic Sign of Coronary Artery Obstruction’, Archives of Internal Medicine 26, 244–57.
Rotschild, M. A., and Kissin, M.: 1933, ‘Induced General Anoxemia Causing S-T Deviation in the Electrocardiogram’, American Heart Journal 8, 745–54.
Rozanski, A., and Berman, D. S.: 1987, ‘Silent Myocardial Schemia. I. Pathophysiology, Frequency of Occurrence, and Approaches toward Detection’, American Heart Journal 114, 615–26.
Smith, F. M.: 1918, ‘The Ligation of Coronary Arteries with Electrocardiographic Study’, Archives of Internal Medicine 22, 8–27
Vineberg, A., Munro, D. D., Cohen, H., and Buller, W.: 1955, ‘Four Years' Clinical Experience with Internal Mammary Artery Implantation in the Treatment of Human Coronary Artery Insufficiency Including Additional Experimental Studies’, Journal of Thoracic Surgery 29, 1–36.
Wood, F. C., and Wolferth, C. C.: 1931, ‘Angina Pectoris. The Clinical and Electrocardiographic Phenomena of the Attack and their Comparison with the Effects of Experimental Temporary Coronary Occlusion’, Archives of Internal Medicine 47, 339–65.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Lie, R.K. Patterns of theory change in biomedicine: A case study from cardiology. Synthese 89, 75–88 (1991). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00413800
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00413800