Nagayama, K. & Danev, R. Biophys Rev (2009) 1: 37. doi:10.1007/s12551-008-0006-z
After slow progress in the efforts to develop phase plates for electron microscopes, functional phase plate using thin carbon film has been reported recently. It permits collecting high-contrast images of close-to-life biological structures with cryo-fixation and without staining. This report reviews the state of the art for phase plates and what is innovated with them in biological electron microscopy. The extension of thin-film phase plates to the material-less type using electrostatic field or magnetic field is also addressed.
Theoretically, electron microscopy is compatible with three different types of phase plate: thin-film, electrostatic, and magnetic. However, designing functional phase plates has been an arduous process that has suffered from unavoidable technical obstacles such as phase-plate charging and difficulties associated with micro-fabrication of electrostatic and magnetic phase plates. Firstly, this review introduces phase-contrast schemes able to visualize transparent objects usually unseen with conventional microscopic methods. Secondly, it deals with recent studies on biological applications ranging from proteins, viruses to cells. Thirdly, the key technology to overcome the obstacle of phase-plate charging—the anti-static thin-film phase plate—is reported. Lastly, next generation phase plates to overcome the issue of electron loss inherent in the thin-film phase plates are discussed.
Methodology of phase plates in electron microscopy
The first phase visualization technique in optics was innovated at the end of the nineteenth century as Schlieren optics using the Foucault knife-edge, which halfly covers the back-focal plane of the objective lens (Fig. 1c). The Zernike phase contrast (ZPC; Fig. 1b) and the Smith/Nomarski differential interference contrast (DIC) methods followed. In electron microscopy, instead, defocus phase contrast (DPC) was devised and developed by Scherzer which is now a standard in material electron microscopy (Fig. 1a; Scherzer 1949). The extension of ZPC to electron microscopy has been attempted for 60 years after the Boersch suggestion (Boersch 1947) but only recently one approach, using thin film phase plates, has been realized with substantial success (Danev and Nagayama 2001). This same group has also demonstrated a phase-plate version of DIC (Danev et al. 2002; Fig. 1d). The typical phase contrast, ZPC, and the oldest scheme, Schlieren optics, that is known in the electron microscopist community as single-sideband imaging, both can be realized with use of simple phase plates as shown in Fig. 1. However, the Smith/Nomarski phase contrast, DIC, does not appear to be included in the simplest mode, as it employs a design to insert a birefringent optical device even before the objective lens. This methodological discord has been removed with a novel scheme that includes a semicircular phase-plate inserted at the back-focal-plane after the objective lens as a spatial filter to retard the electron waves by π (180°; Danev et al. 2002). This setup was termed Hilbert differential contrast (Danev and Nagayama 2004).
Application of thin-film phase plates to biological samples
The standard method of the sample preparation has been useful but also recognized troublesome by the destructive features using fixation, dehydration, resin-embedding, staining, and thin-sectioning. The issues inherent in the traditional approach have all, but the image contrast been solved by cryo-techniques. Rapidly frozen ice-embedded specimens can provide close-to-life micrographic images as these samples are free from artifacts induced by the standard preparation method (Danev and Nagayama 2004; Van Harreveld and Crowell 1964; Heuser et al. 1979). This cryo-microscopy has been successfully utilized in electron cryo-tomography (Beck et al. 2007); (Deng et al. 2008) but not widely accepted partially because of costly instrumentation but mainly due to the low image contrast for unstained specimens.
Applications of Zernike phase-contrast TEM
In ZPC, the finite size of the central hole limits the recoverable lower spatial frequencies. For a 300 kV TEM system, for example, Zernike phase plate with a hole size of 0.5 μm in diameter, results in a cut-on frequency about 0.05 nm−1 (20 nm−1). Given this limitation, applications of ZPC-TEM can cover structural studies of relatively small biological systems.
Figure 2a and b illustrate the differences between a conventional and a ZPC image for a chaperonin protein, GroEL. Several competing groups intensively pursued high-resolution 3D structures of this protein with single particle analysis based on conventional images (Fig. 2b) (Ludtke et al. 2004; Saibil 2006; Stagg et al. 2006; Ludtke et al. 2008). The most difficult component of the single particle analysis when performed with the conventional approach is the first step, identification of the images that correspond to protein molecules. Images of ZPC have a great advantage in this particle identification as shown in (Fig. 2a; Danev and Nagayama 2008). The difference in the image contrast is theoretically rationalized by the difference in recoverable frequency components, which are characterized by image transfer processes with different contrast transfer functions (CTFs) defined in the Fourier space. Typical examples for CTFs, a sinusoidal form for the conventional and a cosinusoidal form for ZPC are inserted in Fig. 2a and b. Contrast transfer functions can be experimentally determined by analyzing diffractograms as shown in the insets of Fig. 2a and b.
Two other examples of ZPC images are shown in Fig. 2c and d. One unresolved issue regarding endocytosis is the determinant for the membrane invagination. Many researchers have proposed that specific proteins mediate this process. Images obtained by phase-contrast cryo-TEM with a Zernike phase plate revealed that a recently discovered protein was associated with membrane invaginations (Shimada et al. 2007). Figure 2c shows a tubulate lipid membrane tightly wrapped by a filamentous polymer comprising a dimer of the protein, EFC/F-BA-domain. X-ray crystallographic studies predicted that the spacing of the polymer wrapping around lipid is about 3.5 nm, which fairly coincided with the spacing of 4.0 nm as experimentally determined (Fig. 2c).
Figure 2d shows images for influenza A viruses in the ice-embedded state (Yamaguchi et al. 2008). The glycoprotein spices and the lipid layers of the viral envelope were clearly resolved with high contrast and without CTF artifacts.
Application of Hilbert differential contrast TEM
The most striking application of HDC-TEM to biology was the phase-contrast image of an entire cell in an ice-embedded state (Kaneko et al. 2005, 2006; Nitta et al. 2009). These results were completely unexpected in the TEM community, as whole-mounted cells have been considered too thick to be visualized without sectioning. The HDC-TEM images display topographic features and appear similar to images obtained with differential interference contrast light microscopy (Danev et al. 2002) as shown in Fig. 3 (Kaneko et al. 2005). Surrounded by smooth cell walls, the thylakoid membranes and carboxysomes are visible inside the micrograph of HDC (Fig. 3a). These structural features were compared with micrographs obtained with conventional TEM images of ultrathin sections of chemically fixed and resin-embedded cyanobacteria (Fig. 3c). What was firstly recognized was the empty holes in the conventional image as shown by an arrow in Fig. 3c. They were attributed to the vacancy of spherical polyphosphate bodies, which were clearly visible with ZPC as electron dense objects as shown by the arrow in Fig. 3a. Contrary to these two images, fine structures inside the cell are almost invisible in the image for ice-embedded unstained cells obtained with the conventional method (Fig. 3b).
Workable phase plates made of carbon thin films
TEM pioneers noted that contamination on the surface of phase plates by insulating materials was the source of the charge. The phase plate itself is not charged when made of a conducting material such as carbon. Efforts for hunting after actual origins of contaminants clarified that there were three sources for charged contaminants: organic materials, metal oxides, and inorganic materials, which were unavoidably integrated into or onto phase plates during the fabrication procedure (Nagayama 2005). For the final answer to settle the dilemma of fabricating or not fabricating, they employed an old idea—electrostatic shielding. The charge-induced potential can be shielded by wrapping charges with conductive material such as carbon. In the final step of phase-plate production, either sides of the phase plate, likely contaminated with organic materials, metal oxides, or inorganic materials, are coated with carbon in a vacuum evaporator. Consequently, once grounded, the electrostatic potential arising from charges is eliminated. The schematic of a three-layered phase plate constructed with a carbon wrapping finish is shown in Fig. 4.
Next-generation phase plates
One of the disadvantages in using thin-film phase-plates is electron loss due to electron scattering (Danev and Nagayama 2001). In his pioneering work, Boersch proposed other options for phase plates—electrostatic potential type. The sophisticated version of the Zernike phase plate containing a static ring electrode that can arbitrarily control the amount of phase shift was firstly proposed as the numerical work (Matumoto and Tonomura 1996) and recently three groups have reported that the electrostatic phase plate is technically tractable with the use of advanced microfabrication technology (Majorovits et al. 2007; Cambie et al. 2007; Huang et al. 2006). All three reports confirmed that the phase shift by π/2 corresponds to ZPC, but efficient phase contrast has yet to be reported in part due to the large outer diameter of the rings blocking the lower frequency components (remember 0.5–1.0 μm in diameter for the hole of the Zernike phase plate with thin films). In the design of these electrostatic phase plates, except for the Berkeley group, insulators prone to be changed are utilized to separate electrodes.
In addition to electrostatic potential, another factor that can affect the electron phase is vector potential. The Aharonov–Bohm (AB) effect emerged as a test to prove the reality of the vector potential (Aharonov and Bohm 1959). A decisive answer to this test was provided by the Hitachi group by using a small permalloy ring perfectly shielded with a superconducting material (Tonomura et al. 1986). In connection with this elegant result, the Hitachi group proposed to use a small permalloy ring to shift the phase of the incident electrons by π/2, while demands to fabricate the Zernike AB phase plate seemed to be a technical blockage.
Recently, the Nagayama group offered a solution to overcome the technical difficulty. They proposed applying the AB effect to the Hilbert phase plate to control the extent of the phase change desired for HDC. One of the examples using a thin bar magnet is shown in Fig. 5c, which has desirable characteristics such as very small electron-intercepting area and an exclusive usage of conducting materials (Nagayama 2008).
Another type of material-less phase plate which was proposed recently is the anamorphotic design (Schröder et al. 2007). Figure 5b shows a schematic of the slit-like phase plate which uses electrostatic fields and must be positioned at an anamorphotic diffraction plane. Such a plane has different magnifications in x and y directions producing a high aspect ratio stretched diffraction pattern that must be oriented along the slit of the phase plate. The realization of this type of phase plate depends mainly on the ability to produce the anamorphotic plane. It will require complicated multiple multipole optical system, similar to the ones found in Cs and Cc correctors, and has yet to be realized and tested.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.