Date: 09 Nov 2012
EnviroGenomarkers: The Interplay Between Mechanisms and Difference Making in Establishing Causal Claims
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
According to Russo and Williamson (Int Stud Philos Sci 21(2):157–170, 2007, Hist Philos Life Sci 33:389–396, 2011a, Philos Sci 1(1):47–69, 2011b), in order to establish a causal claim of the form, ‘C is a cause of E’, one typically needs evidence that there is an underlying mechanism between C and E as well as evidence that C makes a difference to E. This thesis has been used to argue that hierarchies of evidence, as championed by evidence-based movements, tend to give primacy to evidence of difference making over evidence of mechanisms and are flawed because the two sorts of evidence are required and they should be treated on a par. An alternative approach gives primacy to evidence of mechanism over evidence of difference making. In this paper, we argue that this alternative approach is equally flawed, again because both sorts of evidence need to be treated on a par. As an illustration of this parity, we explain how scientists working in the ‘EnviroGenomarkers’ project constantly make use of the two evidential components in a dynamic and intertwined way. We argue that such an interplay is needed not only for causal assessment but also for policy purposes.
Bechtel, W., A. Abrahamsen. 2005. Explanation: A mechanist alternative. Studies in the History and Philosophy of the Biological and Biomedical Sciences 36:421–441.CrossRef
Boniolo, G., R. Faraldo, A. Saggion. 2011. Explicating the notion of ‘causation’: The role of extensive quantities. In: Causality in the sciences, eds. P. Illari, F. Russo, J. Williamson, 502–525. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef
Broadbent, A. 2011. Inferring causation in epidemiology: Mechanisms, black boxes, and contrasts. In Causality in the sciences, eds. P. Illari, F. Russo, J. Williamson, 45–69. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef
Brownson, R.C., E.A. Baker, T.L. Leet, K.N. Gillespie. 2003. Evidence-based public health. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brownson, R.C., J.G. Gurney, G.H. Land. 1999. Evidence-based decision making in public health. Journal of Public Health Management Practice 5(5):86–97.
Campaner, R. 2011. Understanding mechanisms in the health sciences. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 32:5–17.CrossRef
Casini, L., P.M. Illari, F. Russo, J. Williamson. 2011. Models for prediction, explanation and control: recursive Bayesian networks. Theoria 26(1), 5–33.
Chadeau-Hyam, M., T.J. Athersuch, H.C. Keun, M.D. Iorio, T.M. Ebbels, M. Jenab, C. Sacerdote, S.J. Bruce, E. Holmes, P. Vineis. 2011. Meeting-in-the-middle using metabolic profiling—A strategy for the identification of intermediate biomarkers in cohort studies. Biomarkers 16(1):83–88.CrossRef
Clarke, B. 2011. Causality in medicine with particular reference to the viral causation of cancers. PhD thesis, Department of Science and Technology Studies, University College London, London.
Darby, G., J. Williamson. 2011. Imaging technology and the philosophy of causality. Philosophy & Technology 24(2):115–136.CrossRef
Dowe, P. 1992. Wesley Salmon’s process theory of causality and the conserved quantity theory. Philosophy of Science 59(2):195–216.CrossRef
Dowe P. (2000) Causality and explanation: Review of Salmon. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 51:165–174CrossRef
Galea, S., M. Riddle, G.A. Kaplan. 2010. Causal thinking and complex system approaches in epidemiology. International Journal of Epidemiology 39:97–106.CrossRef
Gillies, D.A. 2011. The Russo–Williamson thesis and the question of whether smoking causes heart disease. In Causality in the sciences eds. P. Illari, F. Russo, J. Williamson, 110–125. Oxford: Oxford University PressCrossRef
Glennan, S. 2002. Rethinking mechanistic explanation. Philosophy of Science 69(Supplement):S342–S353.CrossRef
Glymour, C., P.W. Cheng. 1998. Causal mechanism and probability: A normative approach. In Rational models of cognition, eds. M. Oaksford, N. Chater. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hall, N. 2004. Two concepts of causation. In: Causation and counterfactuals eds. J. Collins, N. Hall, L. Paul, 225–276. Cambridge MA, London: MIT Press.
Hill, B. 1965. The environment of disease: Association or causation? Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 58:295–300.
Howick, J. 2011. Exposing the vanities—and a qualified defence—of mechanistic evidence in clinical decision-making. Philosophy of Science 78(5):926–940. Proceedings of the Biennial PSA 2010.
Illari, P.M. 2011a. Disambiguating the Russo–Williamson thesis. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 25(2):139–157.CrossRef
Illari P.M. (2011b) Why theories of causality need Production: An information transmission account. Philosophy & Technology 24(2):95–114.CrossRef
Illari P.M., J. Williamson. 2012. What is a mechanism? Thinking about mechanisms accross the sciences. European Journal for Philosophy of Science 2(1):119–135.CrossRef
Killoran, A., M.P. Kelly ed. 2010. Evidence-based public health. Effectiveness and efficiency. New York: Oxford University Press.
Machamer, P., L. Darden, C. Craver. 2000. Thinking about mechanisms. Philosophy of Science 67:1–25.CrossRef
Rappaport, S.M., Smith, M.T. 2010. Environment and disease risks. Science 330:460–461.
Reichenbach, H. 1956. The direction of time, 1971 edition. Berkeley, Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Russell, B. 1913. On the notion of cause. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 13:1–26.
Russell, B. 1948. Human knowledge. London: George Allen & Unwin.
Russo, F. 2009. Causality and causal modelling in the social sciences. Measuring variations. Methodos Series. New York: Springer.
Russo, F. 2011. Causal webs in epidemiology. Paradigmi XXXIX(1):67–98.
Russo, F. 2012. Public health policy, evidence, and causation. Lessons from the studies on obesity. Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy 15(2):141–151.CrossRef
Russo, F., J. Williamson. 2007. Interpreting causality in the health sciences. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 21(2):157–170.CrossRef
Russo, F., J. Williamson. 2011a. Epistemic causality in medicine. History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 33:389–396.
Russo, F., J. Williamson. 2011b. Generic versus single-case causality: The case of autopsy. European Journal for Philosophy of Science 1(1):47–69.CrossRef
Salmon, W.C. 1984. Scientific explanation and the causal structure of the world. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Salmon, W.C. 1997. Causality and explanation: A reply to two critiques. Philosophy of Science 64(3):461–477.CrossRef
Scarff, K.L., K.S. Ung, H. Nandurkar, P.J. Crack, C.H. Bird, P.I. Bird. 2004. Targeted disruption of spi3/serpinb6 does not result in developmental or growth defects, leukocyte dysfunction, or susceptibility to stroke. Molecular and Cellular Biology 24(9):4075–4082.CrossRef
Steel, D. 2007. Across the boundaries, extrapolation in biology and social science. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Thomas, D.C. 2006. High-volume “-omics” technologies and the future of molecular epidemiology. Epidemiology 17(5):490–491.CrossRef
Vineis, P., M. Chadeau-Hyam. 2011. Integrating biomarkers into molecular epidemiological studies. Current Opinion in Oncology 23(1):100–105.CrossRef
Vineis, P., Khan, A.E., Vlaanderen, J., Vermeulen, R. 2009. The impact of new research technologies on our understanding of environmental causes of disease: the concept of clinical vulnerability. Environmental Health 8(54)
Vineis, P., Perera, F. 2007. Molecular epidemiology and biomarkers in etiologic cancer research: The new in light of the old. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention 16(10):1954–1965.CrossRef
Weber, E. 2007. Conceptual tools for causal analysis in the social sciences. In Causality and probability in the sciences, eds. F. Russo, J. Williamson, 197–213. London: College Publications.
Weber, E. 2009. How probabilistic causation can account for the use of mechanistic evidence. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 23(3):277–295.CrossRef
Williamson, J. 2005. Bayesian nets and causality: Philosophical and computational foundations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Williamson, J. 2009. Probabilistic theories. In The Oxford handbook of causation, eds. H. Beebee, C. Hitchcock, P. Menzies, 185–212. Oxford: Oxford University Press.CrossRef
Williamson, J. 2011. Mechanistic theories of causality. Philosophy Compass 6(6):421–447.CrossRef
- EnviroGenomarkers: The Interplay Between Mechanisms and Difference Making in Establishing Causal Claims
Volume 3, Issue 4 , pp 249-262
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Disease causation
- Public health policy
- Russo–Williamson thesis