The Inheritance, Power and Predicaments of the “Brain-Reading” Metaphor
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
With the increasing sophistication of neuroimaging technologies in medicine, new language is being sought to make sense of the findings. The aim of this paper is to explore whether the “brain-reading” metaphor used to convey current medical or neurobiological findings imports unintended significations that do not necessarily reflect the genuine findings made by physicians and neuroscientists.
First, the paper surveys the ambiguities of the readability metaphor, drawing from the history of science and medicine, paying special attention to the sixteenth through nineteenth centuries. Next, the paper addresses more closely the issue of how metaphors may be confusing when used in medicine in general, and neuroscience in particular. The paper then explores the possible misleading effects associated with the contemporary use of the “brain-reading” metaphor in neuroimaging research.
Rather than breaking new ground, what we see in current scientific language is a persistence of both a constraining and expansive set of language practices forming a relatively continuous tradition linking current neuroimaging to past scientific investigations into the brain.
The use of the readability metaphor thus carries with it both positive and negative effects. Physicians and neuroscientists must resort to the use of terms already laden with abstracted meanings, and often burdened by tradition, at the risk of importing through these words connotations that do not tally with the sought-after objectivity of empirical science.
- Ackerknecht, EH (1968) A short history of medicine. Ronald Press Co, New York
- Amodio, DM, Frith, CD (2006) Meeting of minds: The medial frontal cortex and social cognition. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 7: pp. 268-277 CrossRef
- Anonymous, (2006) What’s on your mind?. Nature Neuroscience 9: pp. 981 CrossRef
- Anonymous, (2009) Abstractions. Nature 458: pp. 548
- Anonymous. 2010. Reading the brain without poking it. Source: e! Science News. http://esciencenews.com/articles/2009/06/29/reading.brain.without.poking.it. Accessed 2 November 2010.
- Appelbaum, PS (2009) Law & psychiatry: Through a glass darkly: Functional neuroimaging evidence enters the courtroom. Psychiatric Services 60: pp. 21-23 CrossRef
- Balladur, L Work, machines, and vapors in late eighteenth-century France. In: Buford, N, Day, J eds. (2006) Civilization: in French and Francophone literature (French literature series XXXIII). Rodopi, Amsterdam, pp. 159-170
- Barrie, A. 2008. Homeland security detects terrorist threats by reading your mind. Source: FoxNews.com. http://www.foxnews.com/printer_friendly_story/0,3566,426485,00.html. Accessed 2 November 2010.
- Bichat, X. 1813. A treatise on the membranes in general, and of different membranes in particular. (A new edition, enlarged by an historical notice of the life and writings of the author, by M. Husson, Paris, 1802) (trans. J.G. Coffin). Boston: Cummings and Hilliard.
- Blumenberg, H (1981) Die Lesbarkeit der Welt. Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main
- Caron, N. 2010. Brain reading technology no longer science fiction. Source: gamefwd. http://gamefwd.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=27:brain-reading-technology-no-longer-science-fiction&catid=9:technology&Itemid=8. Accessed 2 November 2010.
- Cheung, T (2010) Omnis fibra ex fibra: Fibre economies in Bonnet’s and Diderot’s models of organic order. Early Science and Medicine 15: pp. 66-104 CrossRef
- Childress, JF (1997) Practical reasoning in bioethics. Indiana University Press, Bloomington
- Coles, MGH (1989) Modern mind-brain reading—Psychophysiology, physiology, and cognition. Psychophysiology 26: pp. 251-269 CrossRef
- Conti, F, Corbellini, G (2008) Italian neuroscientists are ready to start the debate. Nature 451: pp. 627 CrossRef
- Daston, L, Galison, P (2007) Objectivity. MIT Press, Cambridge
- Charms, RC (2008) Applications of real-time fMRI. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 9: pp. 720-729 CrossRef
- Doby, T, Alker, GJ (1997) Origins and development of medical imaging. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale
- Eamon, W (1994) Science and the secrets of nature: Books of secrets in medieval and early modern culture. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
- Fenton, A, Meynell, L, Baylis, F (2009) Ethical challenges and interpretive difficulties with non-clinical applications of pediatric fMRI. The American Journal of Bioethics 9: pp. 3-13 CrossRef
- Foucault, M. 1994. The birth of the clinic: An archaeology of medical perception (trans. A.M. Sheridan). New York: Vintage Books.
- Friedman, M (2002) Kant, Kuhn, and the rationality of science. Philosophy of Science 69: pp. 171-190 CrossRef
- Friston, KJ (2009) Modalities, modes, and models in functional neuroimaging. Science 326: pp. 399-403 CrossRef
- Galilei, G. 1957. Discoveries and opinions of Galileo (trans. S. Drake). New York, NY: Anchor Books.
- Gilbert, F., and A. Wenger. 2010. Reading in the brain. Hektoen International Journal 2(2) (online). Source: Hektoen Institute of Medicine. http://www.hektoeninternational.org/ReadingintheBrain.html. Accessed 25 November 2010.
- Godart, G-L (1755) La physique de l’âme humaine. Par Mr. Godart, docteur en médecine. Aux dépens de la Compagnie, Berlin
- Golinski, J (2005) Making natural knowledge: Constructivism and the history of science. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
- Goodman, K The reading process. In: Carrell, PL, Devine, J, Eskey, DE eds. (2000) Interactive approaches to second language reading. Cambridge University Press, London, New York, pp. 11-21
- Haberfeld, E., J. Seidenfeld, D.J. Feivelson, and R.L. Fischbach. 2010. Neuroimaging: Visualizing brain structure and function. Source: Center for Bioethics at the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Columbia University. http://ccnmtl.columbia.edu/projects/neuroethics/module1/foundationtext/index.html. Accessed 23 June 2010.
- Hacking, I (2007) Representing and intervening: Introductory topics in the philosophy of natural science. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- Haggard, P (2008) Human volition: Towards a neuroscience of will. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 9: pp. 934-946 CrossRef
- Hartocollis, A. 2007. In support of sex attacker’s insanity plea, a look at his brain. Source: The New York Times (online). http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=940DE6D61431F932A25756C0A9619C8B63. Accessed 2 November 2010.
- Haynes, JD, Rees, G (2006) Decoding mental states from brain activity in humans. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 7: pp. 523-534 CrossRef
- Hutson, S (2005) Our bodies as we have never seen them before. New Scientist 188: pp. 26-29
- Ireland, C. 2007. Symposium: ‘Will brain imaging be lie detector test of the future?’ Source: Harvard Gazette. http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2007/02/symposium-will-brain-imaging-be-lie-detector-test-of-the-future/. Accessed 26 June 2010.
- Kamitani, Y, Tong, F (2005) Decoding the visual and subjective contents of the human brain. Nature Neuroscience 8: pp. 679-685 CrossRef
- Kay, KN, Naselaris, T, Prenger, RJ, Gallant, JL (2008) Identifying natural images from human brain activity. Nature 452: pp. 352-355 CrossRef
- Kay, LE (2000) Who wrote the book of life? A history of the genetic code. Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA
- Kerr, I, Binnie, M, Aoki, C (2008) Tessling on my brain: the future of lie detection and brain privacy in the criminal justice system. Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice 50: pp. 367-387
- Kevles, BH (1997) Naked to the bone: Medical imaging in the twentieth century. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ
- Krahn, T, Fenton, A, Meynell, L (2009) Novel neurotechnologies in film—A reading of Steven Spielberg’s minority report. Neuroethics 3: pp. 73-88 CrossRef
- Laennec, R.T.H. 1979. A treatise on the diseases of the chest in which they are described according to their anatomical characters, and their diagnosis established on a new principle by means of acoustick instruments (trans. J. Forbes). Birmingham, AL: Classics of Medicine Library.
- Lakoff, G, Johnson, M (1980) Metaphors we live by. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
- Langleben, DD (2008) Detection of deception with fMRI: Are we there yet?. Legal and Criminological Psychology 13: pp. 1-9 CrossRef
- Langleben, DD, Schroeder, L, Maldjian, JA, Gur, RC, McDonald, S, Ragland, JD (2002) Brain activity during simulated deception: An event-related functional magnetic resonance study. Neuroimage 15: pp. 727-732 CrossRef
- Le Camus, A, Ganeau, LÉ, Gissey, HS-P (1760) Memoires sur divers sujets de medecine. Et sur le cerveau, principe de la génération. chez Ganeau, libraire, Paris
- Logothetis, NK, Wandell, BA (2004) Interpreting the BOLD signal. Annual Review of Physiology 66: pp. 735-769 CrossRef
- Lovejoy, AO (2009) The great chain of being: A study of the history of an idea. Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick, NJ
- Martensen, RL (2004) The brain takes shape: An early history. Oxford University Press, New York
- Marks, JH (2007) Interrogational neuroimaging in counterterrorism: A “no-brainer” or a human rights hazard?. American Journal of Law and Medicine 33: pp. 483-500
- Martinez-Conde, S, Macknik, SL (2007) Windows on the mind. Scientific American 297: pp. 56-63 CrossRef
- Max-Planck-Gesellschaft. 2009. How to read brain activity with an EEG. Source: Science Daily. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/12/091204103751.htm. Accessed 2 November 2010.
- Merriam-Webster. 2010. Merriam-Webster online dictionary. Source: 2010 Merriam-Webster, Incorporated. http://www.merriam-webster.com/. Accessed 22 June 2010.
- Morgagni, G. 1761. De sedibus, et causis morborum per anatomen indagatis libri quinque. Dissectiones, et animadversiones, nunc primum editas, complectuntur propemodum innumeras, medicis, chirurgis, anatomicis profuturas. Multiplex praefixus est Index rerum, & nominum accoratissimus. Venetiis: Ex typographia Remondiniana.
- Morse, SJ (2006) Brain overclaim syndrome and criminal responsibility: A diagnostic note. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law 3: pp. 397-412
- NIMH. 2010. Neuroimaging and mental illness: A window into the brain. Source: National Institute of Mental Health. http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/neuroimaging-and-mental-illness-a-window-into-the-brain/neuroimaging-and-mental-illness-a-window-into-the-brain.shtml. Accessed 16 June 2010.
- Norman, KA, Polyn, SM, Detre, GJ, Haxby, JV (2006) Beyond mind-reading: Multi-voxel pattern analysis of fMRI data. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10: pp. 424-430 CrossRef
- OED. 2010. Oxford English Dictionary (online). Source: Oxford University Press 2010. http://www.oed.com/. Accessed 22 June 2010.
- Op de Beeck, HP, Haushofer, J, Kanwisher, NG (2008) Interpreting fMRI data: Maps, modules and dimensions. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 9: pp. 123-135 CrossRef
- O’Toole, AJ, Jiang, F, Abdi, H, Penard, N, Dunlop, JP, Parent, MA (2007) Theoretical, statistical, and practical perspectives on pattern-based classification approaches to the analysis of functional neuroimaging data. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 19: pp. 1735-1752 CrossRef
- Owen, AM, Coleman, MR (2008) Functional neuroimaging of the vegetative state. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 9: pp. 235-243 CrossRef
- Pearson, H (2006) Lure of lie detectors spooks ethicists. Nature 441: pp. 918-919 CrossRef
- Peirce, C.S. 1998. What is a sign? In The essential Peirce: Selected philosophical writings—Volume 2. (Peirce Edition Project). Bloomington and Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press, 4–10.
- Perelman, C, Olbrechts-Tyteca, L (1969) The new rhetoric: A treatise on argumentation. University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, IN
- Quintilian. 1920. The Institutio oratoria of Quintilian (trans. H.E. Butler). London: W. Heinemann.
- Rabinowitz, PJ (1998) Before reading: Narrative conventions and the politics of interpretation. Ohio University Press, Columbus, OH
- Sawday, J (1995) The body emblazoned: Dissection and the human body in Renaissance culture. Routledge, London
- Schrock, Karen (2007) Freeing a locked-in mind. Scientific American Mind 18: pp. 40-45 CrossRef
- Sherwin, S (1999) Foundations, frameworks, lenses: The role of theories in bioethics. Bioethics 13: pp. 198-205 CrossRef
- Sismondo, S (2010) An introduction to science and technology studies. Wiley-Blackwell, Chichester, West Sussex, UK
- Smith, C.U.M. 2010. Understanding the nervous system in the 18th century. In Handbook of clinical neurology, vol. 95 (3rd series): History of neurology, eds. S. Finger, F. Boller, and K.L. Tyler, 107–114. Amsterdam: Elsevier B.V.
- Smith, K. 2008. Mind-reading with a brain scan. Source: NatureNews. http://www.nature.com/news/2008/080305/full/news.2008.650.html. Accessed 16 June 2010.
- Spence, SA, Hunter, MD, Farrow, TF, Green, RD, Leung, DH, Hughes, CJ (2004) A cognitive neurobiological account of deception: Evidence from functional neuroimaging. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 359: pp. 1755-1762 CrossRef
- Stefansson, H (2007) The biology of behaviour: Scientific and ethical implications—Introduction. EMBO reports 8: pp. S1-S2 CrossRef
- Thompson, SK (2005) The legality of the use of psychiatric neuroimaging in intelligence interrogation. Cornell Law Review 90: pp. 1601-1637
- Dijck, J (2005) The transparent body: A cultural analysis of medical imaging. University of Washington Press, Seattle
- Vesalius, A. 1998. On the fabric of the human body. Book I, The bones and cartilages (trans. W.F. Richardson, and J.B. Carman). San Francisco: Norman Publishing.
- Staden, H (1995) Anatomy as rhetoric: Galen on dissection and persuasion. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences 50: pp. 47-66 CrossRef
- Waldby, C (2000) Virtual anatomy: From the body in the text to the body on the screen. Journal of Medical Humanities 21: pp. 85-107 CrossRef
- Watson, DB (1996) Opening the doors—Looking back to move forward. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry-Revue Canadienne de Psychiatrie 41: pp. 543-548
- Wenger, A, Gilbert, F (2007) Le cerveau à livre ouvert. Revue Médicale Suisse 3: pp. 2564-2566
- West, P. 2007. The nightmare of ‘pre-crime’. Source: SPECTATOR.CO.UK. http://www.spectator.co.uk/essays/all/313761/the-nightmare-of-precrime-is-already-with-us.thtml. Accessed 2 November 2010.
- Willingham, DT, Dunn, EW (2003) What neuroimaging and brain localization can do, cannot do, and should not do for social psychology. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85: pp. 662-671 CrossRef
- Wilson, C (1995) The invisible world: early modern philosophy and the invention of the microscope. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
- Zanzotto, FM, Croce, D Comparing EEG/ERP-like and fMRI-like techniques for reading machine thoughts. In: Yao, Y, Sun, R, Poggio, T, Liu, J, Zhong, N, Huang, J eds. (2010) Brain informatics: International conference, BI 2010, Toronto, ON, Canada, August 28–30, 2010: Conference Proceedings. Springer, Berlin, pp. 133-144
- Zwart, H (1998) Medicine, symbolization and the “real” body—Lacan’s understanding of medical science. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 1: pp. 107-117 CrossRef
- The Inheritance, Power and Predicaments of the “Brain-Reading” Metaphor
Volume 2, Issue 4 , pp 229-244
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Medical imaging
- Brain reading
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Novel Tech Ethics, Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University, 1234 Le Marchant St., Halifax, NS, Canada
- 2. History of Science Department, King’s University College at the University of Western Ontario, 266 Epworth Ave., London, ON, Canada