Remplissage Versus Latarjet for Engaging Hill-Sachs Defects Without Substantial Glenoid Bone Loss: A Biomechanical Comparison
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Recurrent shoulder instability is commonly associated with Hill-Sachs defects. These defects may engage the glenoid rim, contributing to glenohumeral dislocation. Two treatment options to manage engaging Hill-Sachs defects are the remplissage procedure, which fills the defect with soft tissue, and the Latarjet procedure, which increases glenoid arc length. Little evidence exists to support one over the other.
We performed a biomechanical comparison of the remplissage procedure to the traditional Latarjet coracoid transfer for management of engaging Hill-Sachs defects in terms of joint stiffness (resistance to anterior translation), ROM, and frequency of dislocation.
Eight cadaveric specimens were tested on a shoulder instability simulator. Testing was performed with a 25% Hill-Sachs defect with an intact glenoid and after remplissage and Latarjet procedures. Joint stiffness, internal-external rotation ROM, and frequency of dislocation were assessed. Additionally, horizontal extension ROM was measured in composite glenohumeral abduction.
After remplissage, stiffness increased in adduction with neutral rotation (12.7 ± 3.7 N/mm) relative to the Hill-Sachs defect state (8.7 ± 3.3 N/mm; p = 0.016). The Latarjet procedure did not affect joint stiffness (p = 1.0). Internal-external rotation ROM was reduced in abduction after the Latarjet procedure (49° ± 14°) compared with the Hill-Sachs defect state (69° ± 17°) (p = 0.009). Horizontal extension was reduced after remplissage (16° ± 12°) relative to the Hill-Sachs defect state (34° ± 8°) (p = 0.038). With the numbers available, there was no difference between the procedures in terms of the frequency of dislocation after reconstruction: 84% of specimens (27 of 32 testing scenarios) stabilized after remplissage, while 94% of specimens (30 of 32 testing scenarios) stabilized after the Latarjet procedure.
Both procedures proved effective in reducing the frequency of dislocation in a 25% Hill-Sachs defect model, while neither procedure consistently altered joint stiffness.
In the treatment of shoulder instability with a humeral head bone defect and an intact glenoid rim, this study supports the use of both the remplissage and Latarjet procedures. Clinical studies and larger cadaveric studies powered to detect differences in instability rates are needed to evaluate these procedures in terms of their comparative efficacy at preventing dislocation, as any differences between them seem likely to be small.
- Armitage, MS, Faber, KJ, Drosdowech, DS, Litchfield, RB, Athwal, GS (2010) Humeral head bone defects: remplissage, allograft, and arthroplasty. Orthop Clin North Am. 41: pp. 417-425 CrossRef
- Boileau, P, O’Shea, K, Vargas, P, Pinedo, M, Old, J, Zumstein, M (2012) Anatomical and functional results after arthroscopic Hill-Sachs remplissage. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 94: pp. 618-626 CrossRef
- Boileau, P, Villalba, M, Héry, JY, Balg, F, Ahrens, P, Neyton, L (2006) Risk factors for recurrence of shoulder instability after arthroscopic Bankart repair. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 88: pp. 1755-1763 CrossRef
- Burkhart, SS, Beer, JF (2000) Traumatic glenohumeral bone defects and their relationship to failure of arthroscopic Bankart repairs: significance of the inverted-pear glenoid and the humeral engaging Hill-Sachs lesion. Arthroscopy. 16: pp. 677-694 CrossRef
- Burkhart, SS, Beer, JF, Barth, JR, Cresswell, T, Criswell, T, Roberts, C, Richards, DP (2007) Results of modified Latarjet reconstruction in patients with anteroinferior instability and significant bone loss. Arthroscopy. 23: pp. 1033-1041 CrossRef
- Degen, RM, Giles, JW, Thompson, SR, Litchfield, RB, Athwal, GS (2013) Biomechanics of complex shoulder instability. Clin Sports Med. 32: pp. 625-636 CrossRef
- Elkinson, I, Giles, JW, Faber, KJ, Boons, HW, Ferreira, LM, Johnson, JA, Athwal, GS (2012) The effect of the remplissage procedure on shoulder stability and range of motion: an in vitro biomechanical assessment. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 94: pp. 1003-1012 CrossRef
- Franceschi, F, Papalia, R, Rizzello, G, Franceschetti, E, Buono, A, Panascì, M, Maffulli, N, Denaro, V (2012) Remplissage repair–new frontiers in the prevention of recurrent shoulder instability: a 2-year follow-up comparative study. Am J Sports Med. 40: pp. 2462-2469 CrossRef
- Giles, JW, Boons, HW, Elkinson, I, Faber, KJ, Ferreira, LM, Johnson, JA, Athwal, GS (2013) Does the dynamic sling effect of the Latarjet procedure improve shoulder stability? A biomechanical evaluation. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 22: pp. 821-827 CrossRef
- Giles, JW, Boons, HW, Ferreira, LM, Johnson, JA, Athwal, GS (2011) The effect of the conjoined tendon of the short head of the biceps and coracobrachialis on shoulder stability and kinematics during in-vitro simulation. J Biomech. 44: pp. 1192-1195 CrossRef
- Giles, JW, Elkinson, I, Ferreira, LM, Faber, KJ, Boons, H, Litchfield, R, Johnson, JA, Athwal, GS (2012) Moderate to large engaging Hill-Sachs defects: an in vitro biomechanical comparison of the remplissage procedure, allograft humeral head reconstruction, and partial resurfacing arthroplasty. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 21: pp. 1142-1151 CrossRef
- Itoi, E, Yamamoto, N, Kurokawa, D, Sano, H (2013) Bone loss in anterior instability. Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 6: pp. 88-94 CrossRef
- Kedgley, AE, Mackenzie, GA, Ferreira, LM, Drosdowech, DS, King, GJ, Faber, KJ, Johnson, JA (2007) The effect of muscle loading on the kinematics of in vitro glenohumeral abduction. J Biomech. 40: pp. 2953-2960 CrossRef
- Kedgley AE, Mackenzie GA, Ferreira LM, Johnson JA, Faber KJ. In vitro kinematics of the shoulder following rotator cuff injury. Clin Biomech. (Bristol, Avon). 2007;22:1068–1073.
- King, GJ, Pillon, CL, Johnson, JA (2000) Effect of in vitro testing over extended periods on the low-load mechanical behaviour of dense connective tissues. J Orthop Res. 18: pp. 678-681 CrossRef
- Latarjet, M (1954) Treatment of recurrent dislocation of the shoulder [in French]. Lyon Chir 49: pp. 994-997
- Lippitt, SB, Vanderhooft, JE, Harris, SL, Sidles, JA, Harryman, DT, Matsen, FA (1993) Glenohumeral stability from concavity-compression: a quantitative analysis. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2: pp. 27-35 CrossRef
- Poppen, NK, Walker, PS (1978) Forces at the glenohumeral joint in abduction. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 135: pp. 165-170
- Provencher, MT, Frank, RM, Leclere, LE, Metzger, PD, Ryu, JJ, Bernhardson, A, Romeo, AA (2012) The Hill-Sachs lesion: diagnosis, classification, and management. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 20: pp. 242-252 CrossRef
- Purchase, RJ, Wolf, EM, Hobgood, ER, Pollock, ME, Smalley, CC (2008) Hill-Sachs “remplissage”: an arthroscopic solution for the engaging Hill-Sachs lesion. Arthroscopy. 24: pp. 723-726 CrossRef
- Sekiya, JK, Wickwire, AC, Stehle, JH, Debski, RE (2009) Hill-Sachs defects and repair using osteoarticular allograft transplantation: biomechanical analysis using a joint compression model. Am J Sports Med. 37: pp. 2459-2466 CrossRef
- Skendzel, JG, Sekiya, JK (2012) Diagnosis and management of humeral head bone loss in shoulder instability. Am J Sports Med. 40: pp. 2633-2644 CrossRef
- Veeger, HE, Helm, FC, Woude, LH, Pronk, GM, Rozendal, RH (1991) Inertia and muscle contraction parameters for musculoskeletal modelling of the shoulder mechanism. J Biomech. 24: pp. 615-629 CrossRef
- Wellmann, M, Ferrari, H, Smith, T, Petersen, W, Siebert, CH, Agneskirchner, JD, Hurschler, C (2012) Biomechanical investigation of the stabilization principle of the Latarjet procedure. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 132: pp. 377-386 CrossRef
- Wellmann, M, Petersen, W, Zantop, T, Herbort, M, Kobbe, P, Raschke, MJ, Hurschler, C (2009) Open shoulder repair of osseous glenoid defects: biomechanical effectiveness of the Latarjet procedure versus a contoured structural bone graft. Am J Sports Med. 37: pp. 87-94 CrossRef
- Wu, G, Helm, FC, Veeger, HE, Makhsous, M, Roy, P, Anglin, C, Nagels, J, Karduna, AR, McQuade, K, Wang, X, Werner, FW, Buchholz, B (2005) ISB recommendation on definitions of joint coordinate systems of various joints for the reporting of human joint motion. Part II. Shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand. J Biomech. 38: pp. 981-992 CrossRef
- Yagishita, K, Thomas, BJ (2002) Use of allograft for large Hill-Sachs lesion associated with anterior glenohumeral dislocation: a case report. Injury. 33: pp. 791-794 CrossRef
- Yamamoto, N, Itoi, E, Abe, H, Minagawa, H, Seki, N, Shimada, Y, Okada, K (2007) Contact between the glenoid and the humeral head in abduction, external rotation, and horizontal extension: a new concept of glenoid track. J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 16: pp. 649-656 CrossRef
- Remplissage Versus Latarjet for Engaging Hill-Sachs Defects Without Substantial Glenoid Bone Loss: A Biomechanical Comparison
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research®
Volume 472, Issue 8 , pp 2363-2371
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer US
- Additional Links
- Industry Sectors