Duplicate publication and ‘paper inflation’ in the fractals literature
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
The similarity of documents in a large database of published Fractals articles was examined for redundancy. Three different text matching techniques were used on published Abstracts to identify redundancy candidates, and predictions were verified by reading full text versions of the redundancy candidate articles. A small fraction of the total articles in the database was judged to be redundant. This was viewed as a lower limit, because it excluded cases where the concepts remained the same, but the text was altered substantially.
Far more pervasive than redundant publications were publications that did not violate the letter of redundancy but rather violated the spirit of redundancy. There appeared to be widespread publication maximization strategies. Studies that resulted in one comprehensive paper decades ago now result in multiple papers that focus on one major problem, but are differentiated by parameter ranges, or other stratifying variables. This ‘paper inflation’ is due in large part to the increasing use of metrics (publications, patents, citations, etc) to evaluate research performance, and the researchers’ motivation to maximize the metrics.
- Braumoeller BF, Gaines BJ. (Dec 2001) Actions Do Speak Louder Than Words: Deterring Plagiarism with the Use of Plagiarism-Detection Software. PS-Political Science & Politics 34 (4): 835–839. CrossRef
- Monostori K, Finkel R, Zaslavsky A, Hodasz G, Pataki M. (2002) Comparison of Overlap Detection Techniques. Computational Science-ICCS 2002, Pt I, Proceedings Lecture Notes In Computer Science 2329: 51–60.
- Cook DE, Mellor L, Frost G, Creutzburg R. (2002) Knowledge Management and the Control of Duplication. Engineering and Deployment of Cooperative Information Systems, Proceedings Lecture Notes in Computer Science 2480: 396–402.
- Hoad TC, Zobel J. (Feb 1 2003) Methods for Identifying Versioned and Plagiarized Documents. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 54 (3): 203–215. CrossRef
- Gilbert FJ, Denison AR. (Jul 2003) Research Misconduct. Clinical Radiology 58 (7): 499–504. CrossRef
- Pecorari D. (Dec 2003) Good and Original: Plagiarism and Patchwriting in Academic Second-Language Writing. Journal of Second Language Writing 12 (4): 317–345. CrossRef
- Chen X, Francia B, Li M, Mckinnon B, Seker A. (Jul 2004) Shared Information and Program Plagiarism Detection. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 50 (7): 1545–1551. CrossRef
- Bao JP, Shen JY, Liu XD, Liu HY, Zhang XD. (2004) Finding Plagiarism Based on Common Semantic Sequence Model. Advances in Web-Age Information Management: Proceedings Lecture Notes in Computer Science 3129: 640–645. CrossRef
- Doherty M. (Nov 1996) Misconduct of Redundant Publication. Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases 55 (11): 783–785. CrossRef
- Jefferson T. (Apr 1998) Redundant Publication in Biomedical Sciences: Scientific Misconduct or Necessity? Science and Engineering Ethics 4 (2): 135–140.
- Schein M, Paladugu R. (Jun 2001) Redundant Surgical Publications: Tip of the Iceberg? Surgery 129 (6): 655–661. CrossRef
- Bailey BJ. (Mar 2002) Duplicate Publication in the Field of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery. Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery 126 (3): 211–216. CrossRef
- Von Elm E, Poglia G, Walder B, Tramer MR. (Feb 25 2004) Different Patterns of Duplicate Publication — An Analysis of Articles Used in Systematic Reviews. Jama-Journal of the American Medical Association 291 (8): 974–980. CrossRef
- Mojon-Azzi SM, Jiang XY, Wagner U, Mojon DS. (May 2004) Redundant Publications in Scientific Ophthalmologic Journals — the Tip of the Iceberg?. Ophthalmology 111 (5): 863–866. CrossRef
- Gwilym SE, Swan MC, Giele H. (Jul 2004) One in 13 ‘Original’ Articles in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery are Duplicate or Fragmented Publications. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery-British Volume 86b (5): 743–745. CrossRef
- Maderlechner G, Suda P, Bruckner T. (Nov 1997) Classification of Documents by Form and Content. Pattern Recognition Letters 18 (11–13): 1225–1231. CrossRef
- Atlam ES, Fuketa M, Morita K, Aoe J. (Nov 2003) Documents Similarity Measurment Using Field Association Terms. Information Processing & Management 39 (6): 809–824. CrossRef
- Dobrynin V, Patterson D, Rooney N. (2004) Contextual Document Clustering. Advances in Information Retrieval, Proceedings Lecture Notes in Computer Science 2997: 167–180. CrossRef
- Shin K, Han SY, Gelbukh A. (2004) Advanced Clustering Technique for Medical Data Using Semantic Information. Micai 2004: Advances in Artificial Intelligence Lecture Notes in Computer Science 2972: 322–331. CrossRef
- Li WY, Ng WK, Lim EP. (2004) Spectral Analysis of Text Collection for Similarity-Based Clustering. Advances in Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining, Proceedings Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence 3056: 389–393.
- Bansal N, Blum A, Chawla S. (Jul–Sep 2004) Correlation Clustering. Machine Learning 56 (1–3): 89–113. CrossRef
- Salton G, Buckley C (Aug 30 1991) Text Matching for Information-Retrieval. Science 253 (5023): 1012–1015. CrossRef
- Hui SC, Fong ACM. (2004) Document Retrieval from a Citation Database Using Conceptual Clustering and Co-Word Analysis. Online Information Review 28 (1): 22–32. CrossRef
- Leuski A, Allan J. (Jun 2004) Interactive Information Retrieval Using Clustering and Spatial Proximity. User Modeling and User-Adapted Interaction 14 (2–3): 259–288. CrossRef
- Muresan G, Harper DJ. (Aug 2004) Topic Modeling for Mediated Access to Very Large Document Collections. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology 55 (10): 892–910. CrossRef
- Chang Y, Kim M, Ounis I. (2004) Construction of Query Concepts in a Document Space Based on Data Mining Technques. Flexible Query Answering Systems, Proceedings Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence 3055: 137–149.
- Kostoff, RN, Shlesinger M, and Malpohl G. (March 2004) Fractals roadmaps using bibliometrics and database tomography. Fractals. 12:1. 1–16. CrossRef
- Kostoff RN, Eberhart HJ, and Toothman DR. (1997) Database Tomography for information retrieval. Journal of Information Science 23: 4. CrossRef
- Kostoff RN. (May 2000) The underpublishing of science and technology results. The Scientist. 14:9. 6–6. 1.
- Kostoff RN, Johnson D, Del Rio JA, Bloomfield LA, Shlesinger MF, and Malpohl G. (2005) Duplicate publication and ‘paper inflation’ in the fractals literature. DTIC Technical Report Number ADA440622 (http://www.dtic.mil/). Defense Technical Information Center. Fort Belvoir, VA.
- Benedetto D, Caglioti E, Loreto V. (Jan 28 2002) Language trees and zipping. Physical Review Letters 88 (4) 048702: 1–4. CrossRef
- Duplicate publication and ‘paper inflation’ in the fractals literature
Science and Engineering Ethics
Volume 12, Issue 3 , pp 543-554
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Additional Links
- Text Mining
- Redundant Publications
- Text Matching
- Paper Inflation
- Document Plagiarism
- Concept Matching
- Greedy String Tiling
- Data Compression
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Office of Naval Research, 875 North Randolph Street, 22217, Arlington, VA, USA
- 2. Centro de Investigación en Energía UNAM, Temixco, Mor, México
- 3. University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, USA
- 4. University of Karlsruhe, 76128, Karlsruhe, Germany