Personal Agency across Generations: Evolutionary Psychology or Religious Belief?
- Joseph LoizzoAffiliated withColumbia University Center for Buddhist Studies and Weill Cornell Center for Integrative MedicineNalanda Institute for Contemplative Science Email author
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Although the authors of modern scientific psychology agreed on precious little, Freud and Jung both insisted that any complete science of psychology requires some way to explain the intergenerational inheritance of character traits or personal habits of mind and action. Yet neither they nor their heirs in contemporary philosophy, psychology or cognitive science have been able to provide a plausible conceptual framework, much less a mechanism to account for the conservation of forms of personal agency across multiple lives. Is there a role in contemporary philosophy and psychology for an intergenerational theory of human agency informed by the Buddhist theory of karma? This paper argues the affirmative case, offering both a current scientific reading of karma and a Buddhist scientific approach to the metaphysical and metapsychological problems caused by the divergence of modern science and religion in the West. The model of intergenerational agency I present here is based on a comparative study of ordinary language philosophy in ancient India and the contemporary West. Its premise is that most theories of moral development and psychological agency are limited by the insistence on a substantial or essential ground for the designation of a person or self. Ordinary language philosophy offers greater conceptual freedom because it accepts a distinctively human theory of self as a linguistic construction that refers to mind/body systems and elements in which there is no substantial or essential self. This conceptual freedom permits a model of human agency as an open system of linguistic reference that can be transmitted across generations in the course of language acquisition. Such a system is not merely discursive in that language serves to guide the social construction not just of discursive thinking but also of learned patterns of perception and action mastered together with language in the course of neuropsychological development. This model has implications for both Buddhist and Western worldview, popular and scientific, as well as for bioethics and the practice of psychotherapy.
KeywordsAgency Karma Reincarnation Intergenerational transmission Evolutionary psychology Bioethics Ordinary language philosophy Nagarjuna Chandrakirti Wittgenstein
- Personal Agency across Generations: Evolutionary Psychology or Religious Belief?
Volume 50, Issue 3 , pp 429-452
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Intergenerational transmission
- Evolutionary psychology
- Ordinary language philosophy
- Joseph Loizzo (1) (2)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Columbia University Center for Buddhist Studies and Weill Cornell Center for Integrative Medicine, New York, NY, USA
- 2. Nalanda Institute for Contemplative Science, 300 Central Park West, Suite 1D, New York, NY, 10024, USA