Reviving Brain Death: A Functionalist View
Recently both whole brain death (WBD) and higher brain death (HBD) have come under attack. These attacks, we argue, are successful, leaving supporters of both views without a firm foundation. This state of affairs has been described as “the death of brain death.” Returning to a cardiopulmonary definition presents problems we also find unacceptable. Instead, we attempt to revive brain death by offering a novel and more coherent standard of death based on the permanent cessation of mental processing. This approach works, we claim, by being functionalist instead of being based in biology, consciousness, or personhood. We begin by explaining why an objective biological determination of death fails. We continue by similarly rejecting current arguments offered in support of HBD, which rely on consciousness and/or personhood. In the final section, we explain and defend our functionalist view of death. Our definition centers on mental processing, both conscious and preconscious or unconscious. This view provides the philosophical basis of a functional definition that most accurately reflects the original spirit of brain death when first proposed in the Harvard criteria of 1968.
- Bernat, J.L. 2006. The whole-brain concept of death remains optimum public policy. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 34(1): 35–43. CrossRef
- Bernat, J.L., C.M. Culver, and B. Gert. 1981. On the definition and criterion of death. Annals of Internal Medicine 94(3): 389–394. CrossRef
- Damasio, A. 1999. The feeling of what happens: Body and emotion in the making of consciousness. New York: Harcourt.
- Haidt, J. 2001. The emotional dog and its rational tail: A social intuitionist approach to moral judgment. Psychological Review 108(4): 814–834. CrossRef
- James, S.D. 2012. Conjoined twins Abbey and Brittany Hensel: “Normal—whatever that is.” ABC Good Morning America, August 17. http://abcnews.go.com/Health/conjoined-twins-abby-brittany-hensel-astound-doctors-normalcy/story?id=17021596. Accessed March 6, 2013.
- LiPuma, S.H. 2013. Continuous sedation until death as physician assisted suicide/euthanasia: A conceptual analysis. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 38(2): 190–204.
- Lizza, J. 2010. Commentary on the incoherence of determining death by neurological criteria. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 19(4): 393–395. CrossRef
- McMahan, J. 2006. An Alternative to brain death. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 34(1): 35–43. CrossRef
- Miller, F.G., and R.D. Truog. 2009. The incoherence of determining death by neurological criteria. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 19(2): 185–193. CrossRef
- Miller, F.G., and R.D. Truog. 2010. The incoherence of determining death by neurological criteria: Reply to John Lizza. Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 19(4): 397–399. CrossRef
- Naccache, S., and L. Naccache. 2001. Towards a cognitive neuroscience of consciousness: Basic evidence and a workspace framework. Cognition 79(1–2): 1–37.
- Neil, M. 2012. As conjoined twins enter the world of work, some new definitions of work may be needed. ABA Journal, August 27. http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/as_conjoined_twins_enter_the_world_of_work_some_new_legal_definitions/. Accessed March 6, 2013.
- Parvizi, J., and A. Damasio. 2001. Consciousness and the brainstem. Cognition 79(1–2): 135–159. CrossRef
- President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. 1981. Defining death: Medical, legal, and ethical issues in the determination of death. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office.
- President’s Council on Bioethics. 2008. Controversies in the determination of death. Washington: President’s Council on Bioethics.
- Shewmon, D.A. 2001. The brain and somatic integration: Insights into the standard biological rationale for equating “brain death” with death. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 26(5): 457–478. CrossRef
- Veatch, R.M. 1993. The impending collapse of whole brain definition of death. The Hastings Center Report 23(4): 18–24. CrossRef
- Veatch, R.M. 2005. The death of whole-brain death: The plague of the disaggregators, somaticists, and mentalists. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 30(4): 353–378. CrossRef
- Reviving Brain Death: A Functionalist View
Journal of Bioethical Inquiry
Volume 10, Issue 3 , pp 383-392
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Whole brain death
- Higher brain death
- Cardiopulmonary death
- Determination of death
- Industry Sectors