Monte Carlo Simulation Study of Diffuse Scattering in PZT, Pb(Zr,Ti)O_{3}
- First Online:
DOI: 10.1007/s11661-009-9860-y
- Cite this article as:
- Welberry, T., Goossens, D., Withers, R. et al. Metall and Mat Trans A (2010) 41: 1110. doi:10.1007/s11661-009-9860-y
Abstract
Transverse polarized diffuse streaks have been observed in diffraction patterns of Pb(Zr_{1−x}Ti_{x})O_{3} (PZT) ceramics for compositions ranging from x = 0.3 (rhombohedral phase) to x = 0.7 (tetragonal phase) including the important morphotropic phase boundary (MPB) region (x = 0.48). The streaks correspond to diffuse planes of scattering in three dimensions, and these are oriented normal to the (cubic) \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions. A Monte Carlo (MC) model has been developed that convincingly reproduces the observed diffraction patterns. In this model, the displacements of Pb ions running in chains along each of the \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions are directed along the chain and are strongly correlated from cell to cell. There is no evidence of lateral correlation. Neighboring chains are essentially independent. At this stage, it is not clear what role the local order revealed by the scattering might play in governing the exceptional piezo-electric properties of the material, but its presence requires the currently accepted models for the average structure to be reassessed.
1 Introduction
The majority of work that has been carried out to characterize the atomic scale structure of the different phases has used X-ray or neutron powder diffraction together with Rietveld analysis.[2–5] For the high-temperature (paraelectric) phase, Kuroiwa et al.[5] found that PZT has a simple cubic perovskite structure, but with a disordered Pb site such that the Pb is displaced away from the center of its surrounding cage of 12 O^{2−} ions into any one of a number of symmetry-related positions. For Zr-rich compositions, the Pb ions appeared to be distributed over eight possible sites, each shifted along one of the \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions, whereas for Ti-rich compositions, the Pb ions appeared to be distributed over the 12 possible sites shifted in the \( \langle 110\rangle_{c} \) directions. Here, the subscript c refers to the cubic perovskite cell.
Given this strong body of evidence for the nature of the rhombohedral phase, it was therefore surprising when it was discovered that highly structured diffuse scattering was present in electron diffraction patterns.[3] Although the diffuse scattering patterns that have been observed were most distinct for compositions around x = 0.3, they have been observed across the entire rhombohedral composition range, even extending into the MPB region and the tetragonal phase.[3] Because these existing structural models are ordered (apart from the occupational disorder of the perovskite B-site cations), they are unable to account for the presence of this highly structured diffuse scattering.
Although the crystals are clearly rhombohedral, with the rhombohedral axis c_{h} being slightly larger than a_{c} × 2√3 and a_{h} ≈ a_{c} × √2, the diffuse scattering appears to retain overall cubic symmetry. Consequently, to demonstrate the origins of the scattering, a model that retained average cubic symmetry was constructed. At any site in this model crystal, a Pb atom was displaced by a fixed amount along any one of the eight possible \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions with equal probability. This was assumed in order to ensure that diffuse planes occurred normal to each of the different \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions, and so basically the same diffraction pattern is obtained whether it is recorded, for example, down the [531]_{c} zone axis, as in Figure 3, or down [5\( \overline{3} \)1]_{c}, [135]_{c}, etc.
The problem with this model is that, while it appears to give a good description of the observed diffuse scattering, it is quite incompatible with the published structural models for the rhombohedral phase, derived from powder diffraction, that have cation shifts only along a single [111]_{c} direction. In fact, this model might be considered to be appropriate for the high-temperature cubic phase of PZT, where a multisite Pb position has been proposed. Although no diffuse diffraction patterns for the high-temperature phase of PZT are available, very similar diffraction patterns showing the same kind of transverse polarized streaks are observed in the related material PZLT, which is cubic at ambient temperatures.[7]
The aim of the present article is to show how this conflict can be resolved by assuming that the low-temperature phases contain a residual component of the disorder that is ubiquitous in the high-temperature phase. This means that the structural modeling of these phases needs to be reappraised, which in turn will have significant ramifications for the understanding of the origins of the material’s properties.
2 Proposed Model
In order to test whether this is a viable explanation for the PZT case, we set up the following model: Suppose that the occupancy of each Pb site is defined by an eight-state variable, σ_{ijk}. The different values of σ_{ijk} specify along which of the cubic \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions the particular Pb ion is displaced. The indices i, j, and k define the position of a particular unit cell in the crystal along the cubic x, y, and z directions, respectively. We suppose that a fraction, p, of these correspond to displacements along [111]_{c} and a fraction (1 – p)/7 to displacements along each of the other seven \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions. Thus, p = 0.125 corresponds to the cubic situation where all eight \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions are equivalent, while p = 1.0 corresponds to the perfectly ordered rhombohedral case with Pb displacements along [111]_{c} only. A quantity M = (p − 0.125)/0.875 would then correspond to an occupancy variable comparable to the magnetization in Figure 5.
A second comparable set of variables,ρ_{ijk}, is used to represent the displacements of the (Zr,Ti) B-site cations. In our earlier study, the value of each of these variables was calculated approximately by prescription from the values of the eight surrounding σ_{ijk} variables. In the present case, both sets of variables were included in the interaction model.
Irrespective of any correlations that might exist between the σ_{ijk} and ρ_{ijk} variables, the preceding description defines an average structure, which will give rise to Bragg peak intensities. The first aim in assessing this disordered model as a viable representation of the real PZT structure is to see whether an ordered structural model can equally well fit the Bragg peak intensities (powder diffraction data) produced by it. Section III is concerned with these aspects of the study.
The second aim in assessing this disordered rhombohedral model is to investigate whether it is still able to produce diffuse scattering patterns in agreement with the observed patterns and still display essentially cubic symmetry for values of p ≫ 0.125. In order to do this, a model is developed in which the neighboring Pb and (Zr,Ti) ions interact and so produce correlations between the σ_{ijk} and ρ_{ijk} variables. Section IV is concerned with these aspects of the study.
3 Simulated Powder Diffraction
Atomic Fractional Coordinates and Site Occupancies in the Simulated Model Structure; This Was Constructed in the Space Group P1 with a = b = c = 4.10 Å and α = β = γ = 89.5 Deg
Atom | Occupancy | x | y | z |
---|---|---|---|---|
O1 | 1.00 | 0.50 | 0.50 | 0.00 |
O2 | 1.00 | 0.50 | 0.00 | 0.50 |
O3 | 1.00 | 0.00 | 0.50 | 0.50 |
Pb1 | 0.51 | 0.07 | 0.07 | 0.07 |
Pb2 | 0.07 | 0.07 | 0.93 | 0.07 |
Pb3 | 0.07 | 0.93 | 0.07 | 0.07 |
Pb4 | 0.07 | 0.07 | 0.07 | 0.93 |
Pb5 | 0.07 | 0.93 | 0.93 | 0.93 |
Pb6 | 0.07 | 0.07 | 0.93 | 0.93 |
Pb7 | 0.07 | 0.93 | 0.93 | 0.07 |
Pb8 | 0.07 | 0.93 | 0.07 | 0.93 |
Ti1 | 0.204 | 0.53 | 0.53 | 0.53 |
Ti2 | 0.028 | 0.47 | 0.53 | 0.53 |
Ti3 | 0.028 | 0.53 | 0.47 | 0.53 |
Ti4 | 0.028 | 0.53 | 0.53 | 0.47 |
Ti5 | 0.028 | 0.53 | 0.47 | 0.47 |
Ti6 | 0.028 | 0.47 | 0.53 | 0.47 |
Ti7 | 0.028 | 0.47 | 0.47 | 0.53 |
Ti8 | 0.028 | 0.47 | 0.47 | 0.47 |
Zr1 | 0.306 | 0.55 | 0.55 | 0.55 |
Zr2 | 0.042 | 0.55 | 0.55 | 0.45 |
Zr3 | 0.042 | 0.55 | 0.45 | 0.55 |
Zr4 | 0.042 | 0.45 | 0.55 | 0.55 |
Zr5 | 0.042 | 0.55 | 0.45 | 0.45 |
Zr6 | 0.042 | 0.45 | 0.55 | 0.45 |
Zr7 | 0.042 | 0.45 | 0.45 | 0.55 |
Zr8 | 0.042 | 0.45 | 0.45 | 0.45 |
The fit is excellent and this simple experiment has clearly demonstrated that a model containing no disorder can perfectly well fit powder diffraction data obtained from fairly drastically disordered crystal, even when the Rietveld modeling makes no allowance for this disorder. This suggests that it is possible that Rietveld studies of PZT are not sensitive to the type of disorder we are positing, and that the disorder apparent from our electron diffraction experiments is indeed present, but usually undetected, in most if not all PZT samples.
This result has important implications for any studies in which Rietveld refinement is used to model a structure that has the potential to contain disorder. If disorder is present and not suspected, then refinement using a purely ordered model will clearly lead to a flawed description, even if the refinement gives a good fit. While an average structure model will not model the local ordering, it must allow the local ordering to exist. In this case, this means that the Pb sites must be modeled as split or disordered sites; otherwise, there are no different displacements that can be locally ordered by the Monte Carlo (MC) model. Just as averaging across the disorder model must recover the average structure, the average structure must be one that allows the disorder to exist. This is an important piece of information for a Rietveld refinement. We have shown that if heed is paid to the local bond-valence requirements of constituent ions and judicial use made of constraints and restraints, a realistic model that includes the disorder and describes the average satisfactorily can be found.
3.1 Monte Carlo Simulation of Disorder
A MC computer model was set up using the σ_{ijk} and ρ_{ijk} variables described earlier, which represent cation displacements along the eight different [111]_{c} directions away from their idealized cubic site positions. For use in the equations that follow, these variables are considered to have unit length.
Eight Different Values Taken by ψ_{N} = (x, y, z), Which Defines The Possible Values of the Displacement Variables σ_{ijk} and ρ_{ijk}*
N | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
x | ε | −ε | ε | ε | −ε | ε | −ε | −ε |
y | ε | ε | −ε | ε | −ε | −ε | ε | −ε |
z | ε | ε | ε | −ε | ε | −ε | −ε | −ε |
The normal MC algorithm[16] was used as follows. Two sites in the crystal, i_{1}, j_{1}, k_{1} and i_{2}, j_{2}, k_{2}, were chosen at random, and the variables associated with them, σ_{i1,j1,k1} or ρ_{i1,j1,k1} and σ_{i2,j2,k2} or ρ_{i2,j2,k2}, were interchanged. For each interchange, either two σ variables were used or two ρ. The contribution to the energy of all terms dependent on the interchanged variables was computed using Eq. [3] before and after the change was made. The energy difference, ΔE = E_{new} − E_{old}, was used to decide whether the new configuration should be kept or the system returned to the original configuration. A pseudorandom number, η, chosen uniformly in the range 0 → 1, was compared with the transition probability, P = exp(−ΔE/k_{B}T), where T is the temperature and k_{B} the Boltzmann’s constant. If η < P, the new configuration was accepted, while if η > P, it was rejected and the system returned to the original state. An MC cycle is defined as that number of such individual steps needed to visit each site once on average. In the simulations presented in this article, we assumed T = 1/k_{B} and 500 cycles of iteration were used.
After each cycle of iteration counting, statistics were obtained from the σ_{ijk} and ρ_{ijk} arrays to obtain values for the correlations that had been induced between neighboring displacements.
Such correlation coefficients were calculated for neighbors in each of the 8 \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions, N. These values were compared to a particular target correlation value that was desired, and the discrepancy at any stage was used to adjust the value of the corresponding J_{N} for the next cycle. In this way, the iteration progressed toward a final distribution in which the same nearest neighbor correlation had been induced for each of the eight types of \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) shifts. After some experimentation, it was found that the fact that over 50 pct of the shifts were directed along [111]_{c} meant that there was a strong likelihood that neighbors in this direction would take on the desired structure even if there was no correlation as such. Hence, the correlation in this direction was not well defined for such a small statistical sample and better results were obtained when J_{N} was set to zero for N corresponding to this polar direction. In the examples presented here, therefore, shifts in the polar direction were not directly correlated, but correlations were induced in the other 7 \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions, as given by Eq. [3]. For the p = 0.51 example, the resulting value of J_{N}/k_{B}T was 50, while for the p = 0.70 example, a much higher value of J_{N}/k_{B}T = 3200 was required.
4 Results of MC
Despite the fact that the models are strongly rhombohedral with over 50 and 70 pct of the cations displaced in a single \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) direction, the form of the diffuse scattering patterns that have been achieved is very similar to that of patterns obtained for a purely cubic model that has equal occurrence of all eight different \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) shifts. Coupled with the powder refinement results described in Section III, this provides a convincing explanation of what is happening in the real material.
Of particular significance in the discussion of the diffuse scattering in PZT is the “transverse polarized” nature of the scattering discussed in Section II. This requires that the direction of correlation of the displaced cations is parallel to the displacement direction. This results in the extinction of the zeroth-order diffuse plane, as indicated in Figure 2. For the models presented here, it should be noted that, as p increases from 0.125 to the values 0.51 or 0.70 used in these examples, the average cation position shifts from the original position at the center of the coordination polyhedra along the [111] vector. This average position is what is observed in the powder refinements. In the present case, the basic off-center shift of the Pb ions was taken to be (δ, δ, δ) with δ = 0.07 in fractional coordinates referred to the simple cubic cell. This fixed shift was used throughout. The average position of the Pb site corresponding to the two simulations was (q, q, q) with q = 0.031 for p = 0.51 and q = 0.046 for p = 0.70.
The effect of this can be seen in the diffraction patterns of Figure 9. For Figures 9(a) and (c), the [531] zone axis corresponds to a situation corresponding to Figure 10(a), where the average Pb site position is shifted with its largest component out of the plane of the paper. Consequently, viewed from this direction, the correlated displacements are still fairly close to parallel to the correlation direction, and these two patterns still have the appearance of transverse polarization.
In contrast, for Figures 9(b) and (d), the average position is shifted along [1\(\bar{1}\)1]_{c} and corresponds to the situation shown in Figure 10(b). The shift of the average position now has a large lateral component. Consequently, the displacements giving rise to the diffuse bands in these patterns are no longer in the same direction as the correlation and the scattering is no longer completely transverse polarized. The zeroth-order band stretching between the two “A’s” is quite strong, although for the other main set of bands, the zeroth-order position stretching between “B’s” is still virtually absent. The effect is much more marked for the p = 0.70 case, as would be expected.
The significance of this is that such effects should be observable in the real material. Generally speaking, observed patterns have invariably appeared to be strongly “transverse polarised;” however, no systematic survey has been carried out to see if exceptions occur. In fact, on close scrutiny of the pattern shown in Figure 3, though the numbered set of diffuse lines does appear to show the extinction of the zeroth-order line, there is some slight indication of intensity in the zeroth order of the other, unmarked set of prominent lines.
Another consideration that may affect the ability to observe these effects is that such electron diffraction patterns are invariably obtained by illumination of a relatively large area of specimen, and the possibility that different twinned orientations are simultaneously present cannot be ruled out.
5 Conclusions
In this article, we have shown that in order to explain the diffuse scattering that is observed in the room-temperature phases of PZT, it must be accepted that these still contain a significant amount of the disorder that is present in the high-temperature (paraelectric) phase. At present this is at odds with the currently accepted structural models that have been used to describe the low temperature rhombohedral and tetragonal phases. For these, a perfectly ordered model is assumed in which the Pb ions are all displaced along the same direction.
A model has been developed that allows a large fraction, p (>50 pct), of the cations to be displaced away from the center of their coordination polyhedra along a single \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) direction but still having a significant fraction displaced in each of the other seven \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions. It has been shown that such a disordered model will give a powder diffraction pattern that can be fitted quite satisfactorily with a model that assumes no disorder. At the same time, the model gives diffuse scattering patterns very similar to those observed with electron diffraction.
Bond valence or apparent valence calculations show invariably in these Pb perovskite systems that the Pb ions are so underbonded that they must shift away from the center of their coordination polyhedron by about 0.5 Å. The shift that is actually observed in powder Rietveld refinements is rather less.[2,4] The current model suggests that what is being measured is the average shift, which is dependent on p and is given by Eq. [1].
The model developed here to show the origins of the diffuse planes of scattering used a basic MC energy (Eq. [2] and [3]) that induced correlations along independent chains of Pb and (Zr/Ti) ions. No consideration was given to the possibility of lateral correlations nor to any local relaxation processes. As a result of this, the diffuse planes of scattering in the calculated patterns are of virtually uniform intensity. It is clear that the observed patterns do show some variation of intensity along the length of the streaks, and this presents an opportunity for further study. It might be noted here that the patterns that have been observed for PZLT[7] show a variation somewhat different from those for PZT, although the basic pattern of diffuse sheets is the same.
For the purposes of the simulations presented here, the geometric rhombohedral distortion of the parent cubic cell was ignored. Clearly, if the occupancy parameter p is 0.125, making the average cation sites conform to the cubic symmetry, there will be no reason for the cubic cell to distort. As soon as p becomes >0.125 and the displacements in one of the \( \langle 111\rangle_{c} \) directions becomes dominant (even if only slightly), then such a rhombohedral distortion would follow naturally. The magnitude of the distortion would be expected to depend not only on the magnitude of p, but also on the fine details of the chemical bonding and local interactions.
Acknowledgments
The support of the Australian Research Council and the Australian Partnership for Advanced Computing is gratefully acknowledged. One of the authors (DJG) thanks the Australian Institute for Nuclear Science and Engineering for financial support. KZB-K gratefully acknowledges the support of the Research Grant Council (RGC), Grant No. BQ-891.