Failure to Follow-Up Test Results for Ambulatory Patients: A Systematic Review
Serious lapses in patient care result from failure to follow-up test results.
To systematically review evidence quantifying the extent of failure to follow-up test results and the impact for ambulatory patients.
Medline, CINAHL, Embase, Inspec and the Cochrane Database were searched for English-language literature from 1995 to 2010.
Studies which provided documented quantitative evidence of the number of tests not followed up for patients attending ambulatory settings including: outpatient clinics, academic medical or community health centres, or primary care practices.
Four reviewers independently screened 768 articles.
Nineteen studies met the inclusion criteria and reported wide variation in the extent of tests not followed-up: 6.8% (79/1163) to 62% (125/202) for laboratory tests; 1.0% (4/395) to 35.7% (45/126) for radiology. The impact on patient outcomes included missed cancer diagnoses. Test management practices varied between settings with many individuals involved in the process. There were few guidelines regarding responsibility for patient notification and follow-up. Quantitative evidence of the effectiveness of electronic test management systems was limited although there was a general trend towards improved test follow-up when electronic systems were used.
Most studies used medical record reviews; hence evidence of follow-up action relied upon documentation in the medical record. All studies were conducted in the US so care should be taken in generalising findings to other countries.
Failure to follow-up test results is an important safety concern which requires urgent attention. Solutions should be multifaceted and include: policies relating to responsibility, timing and process of notification; integrated information and communication technologies facilitating communication; and consideration of the multidisciplinary nature of the process and the role of the patient. It is essential that evaluations of interventions are undertaken and solutions integrated into the work and context of ambulatory care delivery.
- Hickner, JM, Fernald, DH, Harris, DM, Poon, EG, Elder, NC, Mold, JW (2005) Issues and initiatives in the testing process in primary care physician offices. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 31: pp. 81-89
- Casalino, LP, Dunham, D, Chin, MH, Bielang, R, Kistner, EO, Karrison, TG (2009) Frequency of failure to inform patients of clinically significant outpatient test results. Arch Intern Med 169: pp. 1123-1129 CrossRef
- World Alliance for Patient Safety. World Health Organisation. Summary of the Evidence on Patient Safety: Implications for Research. In: Jha A, ed; 2008:1–118.
- Schiff GD. Getting Results—Reliably Communicating and Acting on Critical Test Results: Joint Commission Resources; 2006.
- Elder, NC, Graham, D, Brandt, E, Dovey, S, Phillips, P, Ledwith, J (2006) The Testing Process in Family Medicine: Problems Solutions and Barriers as Seen by Physicians and Their Staff. A study of the American Academy of Family Physicians' National Research Network. J Patient Saf 2: pp. 25-32
- Boohaker, EA, Ward, RE, Uman, JE, McCarthy, BD (1996) Patient notification and follow-up of abnormal test results. A physician survey. Arch Intern Med 156: pp. 327-331 CrossRef
- Murff, HJ, Gandhi, TK, Karson, AK, Mort, EA, Poon, EG, Wang, SJ (2003) Primary care physician attitudes concerning follow-up of abnormal test results and ambulatory decision support systems. Int J Med Inform 71: pp. 137-149 CrossRef
- Meza, JP, Webster, DS (2000) Patient preferences for laboratory test results notification. Am J Manag Care 6: pp. 1297-1300
- Keren, R, Muret-Wagstaff, S, Goldmann, DA, Mandl, KD (2003) Notifying emergency department patients of negative test results: pitfalls of passive communication. Pediatr Emerg Care 19: pp. 226-230 CrossRef
- Hickner, J, Graham, DG, Elder, NC, Brandt, E, Emsermann, CB, Dovey, S (2008) Testing process errors and their harms and consequences reported from family medicine practices: a study of the American Academy of Family Physicians National Research Network. Qual Saf Health Care 17: pp. 194-200 CrossRef
- Bates, DW (2005) Physicians and ambulatory electronic health records. Health Aff (Millwood) 24: pp. 1180-1189 CrossRef
- Elder, NC, Hickner, J, Graham, D (2008) Quality and safety in outpatient laboratory testing. Clin Lab Med 28: pp. 295-303 CrossRef
- Poon, EG, Gandhi, TK, Sequist, TD, Murff, HJ, Karson, AS, Bates, DW (2004) "I wish I had seen this test result earlier!": Dissatisfaction with test result management systems in primary care. Arch Intern Med 164: pp. 2223-2228 CrossRef
- Poon, EG, Wang, SJ, Gandhi, TK, Bates, DW, Kuperman, GJ (2003) Design and implementation of a comprehensive outpatient Results Manager. J Biomed Inform 36: pp. 80-91 CrossRef
- Wahls, TL, Cram, PM (2007) The frequency of missed test results and associated treatment delays in a highly computerized health system. BMC Fam Pract 8: pp. 32 CrossRef
- Roy, CL, Poon, EG, Karson, AS, Ladak-Merchant, Z, Johnson, RE, Maviglia, SM (2005) Patient safety concerns arising from test results that return after hospital discharge. Ann Intern Med 143: pp. 121-128
- Gandhi, TK (2005) Fumbled handoffs: one dropped ball after another. Ann Intern Med 142: pp. 352-358
- Bird, S (2004) Missing test results and failure to diagnose. Aust Fam Physician 33: pp. 360-361
- Berlin, L (1980) Malpractice and radiologists. AJR Am J Roentgenol 135: pp. 587-591
- Berlin, L (2009) Malpractice issues in radiology: res ipsa loquitur. AJR Am J Roentgenol 193: pp. 1475-1480 CrossRef
- Potchen, EJ, Bisesi, MA, Sierra, AE, Potchen, JE (1991) Mammography and malpractice. AJR Am J Roentgenol 156: pp. 475-480
- Graber, M (2005) Diagnostic errors in medicine: a case of neglect. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 31: pp. 106-113
- Leape, LL (1994) Error in medicine. JAMA 272: pp. 1851-1857 CrossRef
- Parker, D, Lawton, R (2003) Psychological contribution to the understanding of adverse events in health care. Qual Saf Health Care 12: pp. 453-457 CrossRef
- Hodges, B, Regehr, G, Martin, D (2001) Difficulties in recognizing one's own incompetence: novice physicians who are unskilled and unaware of it. Acad Med 76: pp. S87-S89 CrossRef
- Callen, J, Georgiou, A, Li, J, Westbrook, JI (2011) The safety implications of missed test results for hospitalised patients: a systematic review. BMJ Qual Saf 20: pp. 194-199 CrossRef
- Cram, P, Rosenthal, GE, Ohsfeldt, R, Wallace, RB, Schlechte, J, Schiff, GD (2005) Failure to recognize and act on abnormal test results: the case of screening bone densitometry. Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 31: pp. 90-97
- Schiff, GD, Kim, S, Krosnjar, N, Wisniewski, MF, Bult, J, Fogelfeld, L (2005) Missed hypothyroidism diagnosis uncovered by linking laboratory and pharmacy data. Arch Intern Med 165: pp. 574-577 CrossRef
- Chen, ZJ, Kammer, D, Bond, JH, Ho, SB (2007) Evaluating follow-up of positive fecal occult blood test results: lessons learned. J Healthc Qual: Promot Excell Healthc 29: pp. 16
- Chen, ET, Eder, M, Elder, NC, Hickner, J (2010) Crossing the finish line: follow-up of abnormal test results in a multisite community health center. J Natl Med Assoc 102: pp. 720-725
- Choksi, VR, Marn, CS, Bell, Y, Carlos, R (2006) Efficiency of a semiautomated coding and review process for notification of critical findings in diagnostic imaging. AJR Am J Roentgenol 186: pp. 933-936 CrossRef
- Ealovega, MW, Tabaei, BP, Brandle, M, Burke, R, Herman, WH (2004) Opportunistic screening for diabetes in routine clinical practice. Diabetes Care 27: pp. 9-12 CrossRef
- Elder, NC, McEwen, TR, Flach, JM, Gallimore, JJ (2009) Management of test results in family medicine offices. Ann Fam Med 7: pp. 343-351 CrossRef
- Elder, NC, McEwen, TR, Flach, J, Gallimore, J, Pallerla, H (2010) The management of test results in primary care: does an electronic medical record make a difference?. Fam Med 42: pp. 327-333
- Kern, LM, Callahan, MA, Brillon, DJ, Vargas, M, Mushlin, AI (2006) Glucose testing and insufficient follow-up of abnormal results: a cohort study. BMC Health Serv Res 6: pp. 87 CrossRef
- Moore, C, Wisnivesky, J, Williams, S, McGinn, T (2003) Medical errors related to discontinuity of care from an inpatient to an outpatient setting. J Gen Intern Med 18: pp. 646-651 CrossRef
- Moore, CR, Lin, JJ, O'Connor, N, Halm, EA (2006) Follow-up of markedly elevated serum potassium results in the ambulatory setting: implications for patient safety. Am J Med Qual 21: pp. 115-124 CrossRef
- Moore, C, Lin, J, McGinn, T, Halm, E (2007) Factors associated with time to follow-up of severe hyperkalemia in the ambulatory setting. Am J Med Qual 22: pp. 428-437 CrossRef
- Singh, H, Arora, HS, Vij, MS, Rao, R, Khan, MM, Petersen, LA (2007) Communication outcomes of critical imaging results in a computerized notification system. J Am Med Inform Assoc 14: pp. 459-466 CrossRef
- Singh, H, Thomas, EJ, Mani, S, Sittig, D, Arora, H, Espadas, D (2009) Timely follow-up of abnormal diagnostic imaging test results in an outpatient setting: are electronic medical records achieving their potential?. Arch Intern Med 169: pp. 1578-1586 CrossRef
- Singh, H, Thomas, EJ, Sittig, DF, Wilson, L, Espadas, D, Khan, MM (2010) Notification of abnormal lab test results in an electronic medical record: do any safety concerns remain?. Am J Med 123: pp. 238-244 CrossRef
- Stelfox, HT, Ahmed, SB, Fiskio, J, Bates, DW (2004) An evaluation of the adequacy of outpatient monitoring of thyroid replacement therapy. J Eval Clin Pract 10: pp. 525-530 CrossRef
- Etzioni, DA, Yano, EM, Rubenstein, LV, Lee, ML, Ko, CY, Brook, RH (2006) Measuring the quality of colorectal cancer screening: the importance of follow-up. Dis Colon Rectum 49: pp. 1002-1010 CrossRef
- Edelman, D (2002) Outpatient diagnostic errors: unrecognized hyperglycemia. Eff Clin Pract 5: pp. 11-16
- Gandhi, TK, Kachalia, A, Thomas, EJ, Puopolo, AL, Yoon, C, Brennan, TA (2006) Missed and delayed diagnoses in the ambulatory setting: a study of closed malpractice claims. Ann Intern Med 145: pp. 488-496
- Poon, EG, Haas, JS, Louise Puopolo, A, Gandhi, TK, Burdick, E, Bates, DW (2004) Communication factors in the follow-up of abnormal mammograms. J Gen Intern Med 19: pp. 316-323 CrossRef
- Romano, MJ, Stafford, RS (2011) Electronic health records and clinical decision support systems: impact on national ambulatory care quality. Arch Intern Med 171: pp. 897-903 CrossRef
- Linder, JA, Ma, J, Bates, DW, Middleton, B, Stafford, RS (2007) Electronic health record use and the quality of ambulatory care in the United States. Arch Intern Med 167: pp. 1400-1405 CrossRef
- Garg, AX, Adhikari, NK, McDonald, H, Rosas-Arellano, MP, Devereaux, PJ, Beyene, J (2005) Effects of computerized clinical decision support systems on practitioner performance and patient outcomes: a systematic review. JAMA 293: pp. 1223-1238 CrossRef
- Chaudhry, B, Wang, J, Wu, S, Maglione, M, Mojica, W, Roth, E (2006) Systematic review: impact of health information technology on quality, efficiency, and costs of medical care. Ann Intern Med 144: pp. 742-752
- O'Connor, PJ, Sperl-Hillen, JM, Rush, WA, Johnson, PE, Amundson, GH, Asche, SE (2011) Impact of electronic health record clinical decision support on diabetes care: a randomized trial. Ann Fam Med 9: pp. 12-21 CrossRef
- Bates, DW, Gawande, AA (2003) Improving safety with information technology. N Engl J Med 348: pp. 2526-2534 CrossRef
- Bates, DW (2000) Using information technology to reduce rates of medication errors in hospitals. BMJ 320: pp. 788-791 CrossRef
- Kuperman, GJ, Teich, JM, Tanasijevic, MJ, Ma'Luf, N, Rittenberg, E, Jha, A (1999) Improving response to critical laboratory results with automation: results of a randomized controlled trial. J Am Med Inform Assoc 6: pp. 512-522 CrossRef
- Greenes, DS, Fleisher, GR, Kohane, I (2000) Potential impact of a computerized system to report late-arriving laboratory results in the emergency department. Pediatr Emerg Care 16: pp. 313-315 CrossRef
- Callen, J, Paoloni, R, Georgiou, A, Prgomet, M, Westbrook, J (2010) The rate of missed test results in an emergency department: an evaluation using an electronic test order and results viewing system. Methods Inf Med 49: pp. 37-43
- Singh, H, Naik, AD, Rao, R, Petersen, LA (2008) Reducing diagnostic errors through effective communication: harnessing the power of information technology. J Gen Intern Med 23: pp. 489-494 CrossRef
- Piva, E, Sciacovelli, L, Zaninotto, M, Laposata, M, Plebani, M (2009) Evaluation of effectiveness of a computerized notification system for reporting critical values. Am J Clin Pathol 131: pp. 432-441 CrossRef
- Plebani, M (2009) Interpretative commenting: a tool for improving the laboratory-clinical interface. Clin Chim Acta 404: pp. 46-51 CrossRef
- Couchman, GR, Forjuoh, SN, Rascoe, TG, Reis, MD, Koehler, B, Walsum, KLv (2005) E-mail communications in primary care: what are patients' expectations for specific test results?. Int J Med Inform 74: pp. 21-30 CrossRef
- Berg, M, Langenberg, C, Berg, I, Kwakkernaat, J (1998) Considerations for sociotechnical design: experiences with an electronic patient record in a clinical context. Int J Med Inform 52: pp. 243-251 CrossRef
- Callen, JL, Braithwaite, J, Westbrook, JI (2008) Contextual implementation model: a framework for assisting clinical information system implementations. J Am Med Inform Assoc 15: pp. 255-262 CrossRef
- O'Leary, KJ, Liebovitz, DM, Feinglass, J, Liss, DT, Evans, DB, Kulkarni, N (2009) Creating a better discharge summary: Improvement in quality and timeliness using an electronic discharge summary. J Hosp Med 4: pp. 219-225 CrossRef
- Walraven, C, Seth, R, Austin, PC, Laupacis, A (2002) Effect of discharge summary availability during post-discharge visits on hospital readmission. J Gen Intern Med 17: pp. 186-192 CrossRef
- Bolton, P, Mira, M, Kennedy, P, Lahra, MM (1998) The quality of communication between hospitals and general practitioners: an assessment. J Qual Clin Pract 18: pp. 241-247 CrossRef
- Callen, J, McIntosh, J, Li, J (2010) Accuracy of medication documentation in hospital discharge summaries: A retrospective analysis of medication transcription errors in manual and electronic discharge summaries. Int J Med Inform 79: pp. 58-64 CrossRef
- Berlin, L (2009) Communicating results of all outpatient radiologic examinations directly to patients: the time has come. AJR Am J Roentgenol 192: pp. 571-573 CrossRef
- Berlin, L (2007) Communicating results of all radiologic examinations directly to patients: has the time come?. AJR Am J Roentgenol 189: pp. 1275-1282 CrossRef
- Hammerman, HJ (2009) Communicating imaging results to patients: OnSite results. AJR Am J Roentgenol 192: pp. 852-853 CrossRef
- American College of Radiology. ACR Practice Guideline for Communication of Diagnostic Imaging Findings. 2010:1-6. Accessed 12 May 2011. http://www.acr.org/secondarymainmenucategories/quality_safety/guidelines/dx/comm_diag_rad.aspx. 2010.
- Kilpatrick, ES (2001) Use of computer terminals on wards to access emergency test resutls: a retrospective audit. Br Med J 322: pp. 3 CrossRef
- Graber, M (2006) The physician and the laboratory: partners in reducing diagnostic error related to laboratory testing. Am J Clin Pathol 126: pp. S44-S47
- Unruh, KT, Pratt, W (2007) Patients as actors: the patient's role in detecting, preventing, and recovering from medical errors. Int J Med Inform 76: pp. S236-S244 CrossRef
- Wald, JS, Burk, K, Gardner, K, Feygin, R, Nelson, E, Epstein, M (2007) Sharing electronic laboratory results in a patient portal–a feasibility pilot. Stud Health Technol Inform 129: pp. 18-22
- Ley, P (1979) Memory for medical information. Br J Soc Clin Psychol 18: pp. 245-255 CrossRef
- Kessels, RP (2003) Patients' memory for medical information. J R Soc Med 96: pp. 219-222 CrossRef
- US Department of Health and Human Services, US Food and Drug Administration. 2004. Mammography Quality Standards Act (MQSA) MAMMOGRAPHY QUALITY STANDARDS ACT (MQSA) (AS AMENDED BY MQSRA of 1998 and 2004).Accessed September, 26, 2011. http://www.fda.gov/Radiation-EmittingProducts/MammographyQualityStandardsActandProgram/Regulations/ucm110823.htm.
- Priyanath, A, Feinglass, J, Dolan, NC, Haviley, C, Venta, LA (2002) Patient satisfaction with the communication of mammographic results before and after the Mammography Quality Standards Reauthorization Act of 1998. AJR Am J Roentgenol 178: pp. 451-456
- Shekelle, PG, Pronovost, PJ, Wachter, RM, Taylor, SL, Dy, SM, Foy, R (2011) Advancing the science of patient safety. Ann Intern Med 154: pp. 693-696
- Leape, LL, Berwick, DM, Bates, DW (2002) What practices will most improve safety? Evidence-based medicine meets patient safety. JAMA 288: pp. 501-507 CrossRef
- Wachter, RM (2010) Why diagnostic errors don't get any respect–and what can be done about them. Health Aff (Millwood) 29: pp. 1605-1610 CrossRef
- Failure to Follow-Up Test Results for Ambulatory Patients: A Systematic Review
- Open Access
- Available under Open Access This content is freely available online to anyone, anywhere at any time.
Journal of General Internal Medicine
Volume 27, Issue 10 , pp 1334-1348
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links
- patient safety
- test result follow-up
- medical errors
- primary care
- quality improvement
- Industry Sectors