The Impact of Health Plan Physician-Tiering on Access to Care
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
In an attempt to improve quality and control costs, health plans are creating tiered products that encourage enrollees to seek care from “high-value” physicians. However, tiered products may limit access to care because patients may have to travel unreasonable distances to visit the nearest high-value physician.
To assess geographic access to high-value physicians, particularly for disadvantaged populations.
Cross-sectional observational study.
Physicians and adult patients in Massachusetts.
Travel time from census block centroid to nearest physician address under two scenarios: patients can see (1) any physician or (2) only high-value physicians.
Among the physicians, 768 (20.9%) primary care physicians (PCPs), 225 (26.6%) obstetricians/gynecologists, 69 (10.3%) cardiologists, and 31 (6.0%) general surgeons met the definition of high-value. Statewide mean travel times to the nearest PCP, obstetrician/gynecologist, cardiologist, or general surgeon under the two scenarios (any physician vs. only high-value physicians) were 2.8 vs. 4.8, 6.0 vs. 7.2, 7.0 vs. 12.4, and 6.6 vs. 14.8 minutes, respectively. Across the four specialties, between 89.4%–99.4% of the population lived within 30 minutes of the nearest high-value physician. Rural populations had considerably longer travel times to see high-value physicians, but other disadvantaged populations generally had shorter travel times than comparison groups.
Most patients in Massachusetts are likely to have reasonable geographic access to high-value physicians in tiered health plans. However, local demographics, especially rural residence, should be taken into consideration when applying tiered health plans broadly. Future work should investigate whether patients can and will switch to receive care from high-value physicians.
- O’Kane, M (2010) Tiered networks: strategies of engagement for patients and physicians. Am J Manag Care 16: pp. 96-97
- Sinaiko, AD, Rosenthal, MB (2010) Consumer experience with a tiered physician network: early evidence. Am J Manag Care 16: pp. 123-130
- Adams, JL, McGlynn, EA, Thomas, JW (2010) Incorporating statistical uncertainty in the use of physician cost profiles. BMC Health Serv Res 10: pp. 57 CrossRef
- Adams, JL, Mehrotra, A, Thomas, JW (2010) Physician cost profiling–reliability and risk of misclassification. N Engl J Med 362: pp. 1014-1021 CrossRef
- Mehrotra, A, Adams, JL, Thomas, JW, McGlynn, EA (2010) The impact of different attribution rules on individual physician cost profiles. Ann Intern Med 152: pp. 649-654
- Scholle, SH, Roski, J, Adams, JL (2008) Benchmarking physician performance: reliability of individual and composite measures. Am J Manag Care 14: pp. 833-838
- National Healthcare Disparities Report 2008. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Rockville
- Bloche, MG (2007) Consumer-directed health care and the disadvantaged. Health Aff (Millwood) 26: pp. 1315-1327 CrossRef
- Casalino, LP, Elster, A, Eisenberg, A (2007) Will pay-for-performance and quality reporting affect health care disparities?. Health Aff (Millwood) 26: pp. w405-w414 CrossRef
- Chien, AT, Chin, MH, Davis, AM (2007) Pay for performance, public reporting, and racial disparities in health care: how are programs being designed?. Med Care Res Rev 64: pp. 283S-304 CrossRef
- Adams, JL, Thomas, JW, McGlynn, EA (2010) Physician cost profiling—Reliability and risk of misclassification. Detailed methodology and sensitivity analyses. RAND, Santa Monica
- Minnesota Medical Association. The Tiering of Minnesota Physicians; 2006.
- Reid, RO, Friedberg, MW, Adams, JL (2010) Associations between physician characteristics and quality of care. Arch Intern Med 170: pp. 1442-1449 CrossRef
- Brennan, TA, Spettell, CM, Fernandes, J (2008) Do managed care plans’ tiered networks lead to inequities in care for minority patients?. Health Aff (Millwood) 27: pp. 1160-1166 CrossRef
- Criteria for designation of areas having shortages of primary medical care professionals health resources and services administration; relevant excerpts from 42 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), Chapter 41, Part 45, Appendix A October 41, 1993;1934-1948.
- Morse S. Converting addresses to/from latitude/longitude in one step. Available at: http://stevemorse.org/jcal/latlon.php. Accessed November 29,2010.
- Council on Graduate Medical Education. Evaluation of Specialty Physician Workforce Methodologies. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; 2000.
- Rodgers, GP, Conti, JB, Feinstein, JA (2009) ACC 2009 survey results and recommendations: addressing the cardiology workforce crisis A report of the ACC board of trustees workforce task force. J Am Coll Cardiol 54: pp. 1195-1208 CrossRef
- The Lewin Group Cardiology Workforce Assessment. Association of American Medical Colleges; 2009.
- Cofer, JB, Burns, RP (2008) The developing crisis in the national general surgery workforce. J Am Coll Surg 206: pp. 790-795 CrossRef
- Massachusetts Division of Health Care. Finance and Policy Primary care in Massachusetts: An overview of trends and opportunities: Boston, MA, 2010.
- Massachusetts Medical Society. Massachusetts health reform: fact sheet: Boston, MA, 2010.
- Merritt Hawkins & Associates. 2009 Survey of physician appointment wait times: Irving, TX; 2009.
- Sinaiko, A, Rosenthal, M (2010) Consumer experience with a tiered physician network: early evidence. Am J Manag Care 16: pp. 123-130
- Center for Workforce Studies. 2009 State Physician Workforce Data Book. Association of American Medical Colleges; 2009.
- The Impact of Health Plan Physician-Tiering on Access to Care
Journal of General Internal Medicine
Volume 26, Issue 4 , pp 440-445
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links
- high value care
- Industry Sectors