The Impact of Consumer-Directed Health Plans and Patient Socioeconomic Status on Physician Recommendations for Colorectal Cancer Screening
Purchase on Springer.com
$39.95 / €34.95 / £29.95*
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.
Consumer-directed health plans are increasingly common, yet little is known about their impact on physician decision-making and preventive service use.
To determine how patients’ deductible levels and socioeconomic status may affect primary care physicians’ recommendations for colorectal cancer screening.
Design, Setting, and Participants
Screening recommendations were elicited using hypothetical vignettes from a national sample of 1,500 primary care physicians. Physicians were randomized to one of four vignettes describing a patient with either low or high socioeconomic status (SES) and either low- or high-deductible plan. Bivariate and multivariate analyses were used to examine how recommendations varied as a function of SES and deductible.
Rates of recommendation for home fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, colonoscopy, and inappropriate screening, defined as no screening or office-based fecal occult blood testing.
A total of 528 (49%) eligible physicians responded. Overall, 7.2% of physicians recommended inappropriate screening; 3.2% of patients with high SES in low-deductible plans received inappropriate screening recommendations and 11.4% of patients with low SES in high-deductible plans for an adjusted odds ratio of 0.22 (0.05–0.89). The odds of a colonoscopy recommendation were over ten times higher (AOR 11.46, 5.26–24.94) for patients with high SES in low-deductible plans compared to patients with low SES in high-deductible plans. Funds in medical savings accounts eliminated differences in inappropriate screening recommendations.
Patient SES and deductible-level affect physician recommendations for preventive care. Coverage of preventive services and funds in medical savings accounts may help to mitigate the impact of high-deductibles and SES on inappropriate recommendations.
- Goodman JC. What is consumer-directed care? Health Aff. 2006;25:w540–w543. CrossRef
- Miller T. Getting on the soapbox: views of an innovator in consumer-directed care. Health Aff. 2006;25:w549–w551. CrossRef
- Bush GW. Executive order: promoting quality and efficient health care in federal government administered or sponsored health care programs. Available at: http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2006/08/20060822-2.html. Accessed June 6, 2008.
- American Health Insurance Plans Center for Policy and Research. January 2008 Census Shows 6.1 Million People Covered by HSA/High-Deductible Health Plans. Washington D.C.: American Health Insurance Plans; 2008.
- Wharam JF, Landon BE, Galbraith AA, et al. Emergency department use and subsequent hospitalizations among members of a high-deductible health plan. JAMA. 2007;297:1093–1102. CrossRef
- Davis K, Doty MM, Ho A. How high is too high? Implications of high-deductible health plans. New York City: The Commonwealth Fund; 2005.
- The Kaiser Family Foundation. National Survey of Enrollees in Consumer Directed Health Plans. Washington D.C.: The Henry J. Kaiser Foundation; 2006.
- Rowe J, Brown-Stevenson T, Downey R, Newhouse J. The effect of consumer-directed health plans on the use of preventive and chronic illness services. Health Aff. 2008;27:113–120. CrossRef
- Busch S, Barry C, Vegso S, Sindelar J, Cullen M. Effects of a cost-sharing plan on use of preventive services at one large employer. Health Aff. 2006;25:1529–1536. CrossRef
- America’s Health Insurance Plans Center for Policy and Research. A Survey of Preventive Benefits in Health Savings Account (HSA) Plans, July 2007. Washington, D.C.: America’s Health Insurance Plans; 2007.
- The Kaiser Family Foundation and Health Research and Education Trust. Employer Health Benefits 2007 Annual Survey. The Kaiser Family Foundation and HRET; 2007.
- Buntin MB, Damberg C, Haviland A, et al. Consumer-directed health plans: early evidence about effects on cost and quality. Health Aff. 2006;25:w516w–530. CrossRef
- Fronstin P, Collins S. Findings from the 2007 EBRI/Commonwealth Fund Consumerism in Health Survey. Washington D.C.: EBRI; 2008.
- Swan J, Breen N, Coates R, Rimer B, Lee N. Progress in cancer screening practices in the United States: results from the 2000 National Health Interview Survey. Cancer. 2003;97:1528–1540. CrossRef
- Lemon S, Zapka J, Puleo E, Luckmann R, Chasan-Taber L. Colorectal cancer screening participation: comparisons with mammography and prostate-specific antigen screening. Am J Pub Health. 2001;91:1264–1272. CrossRef
- Ananthakrishnan A, Schellhase K, Sparapani R, Laud P, Neuner J. Disparities in colon cancer screening in the Medicare population. Arch Intern Med. 2007;167:258–264. CrossRef
- Phillips K, Ladabaum S-YLU, Haas J, et al. Trends in colonoscopy for colorectal cancer screening. Med Care. 2007;45:160–167. CrossRef
- Liang S-Y, Phillips KA, Nagamine M, Ladabaum U, Haas JS. Rates and predictors of colorectal cancer screening. Preventing Chronic Disease. 2006;3:1–13. CrossRef
- Sox H. Office-based testing for fecal occult blood: do only in case of emergency. Ann Intern Med. 2005;142:146–148.
- Nadel M, Shapiro J, Klabunde C, et al. A national survey of primary care physicians’ methods for screening for fecal occult blood. Ann Intern Med. 2005;142:86–94.
- Klabunde CN, Frame PS, Meadow A, Jones E, Nadel M, Vernon SW. A national survey of primary care physicians’ colorectal cancer screening recommendations and practices. Prev Med. 2003;36:352–362. CrossRef
- Zapka J, Puleo E, Cickers-Lahti M, Luckmann R. Healthcare system factors and colorectal cancer screening. Am J Prev Med. 2002;23:28–35. CrossRef
- Lewis S, Jensen N. Screening sigmoidoscopy: factors associated with utilization. J Gen Intern Med. 1996;11:542–544. CrossRef
- Mandelson M, Curry S, Anderson L. Colorectal cancer screening participation by older women. Am J Prev Med. 2000;19:149–154. CrossRef
- Guerra C, Schwartz J, Armstrong K, Brown J, Hughes-Halbert C, Shea J. Barriers of and facilitators to physician recommendations of colorectal cancer screening. J Gen Intern Med. 2007;22:1681–1688. CrossRef
- Taylor WC. A 71-yearl-old woman contemplating a screening colonoscopy. JAMA. 2006;295:1161–1167. CrossRef
- Claxton G, Gabel JR, Gil I, et al. Health benefits in 2006: premium increases moderate, enrollment in consumer-directed health plans modest. Health Aff. 2006;25:w476–w485. CrossRef
- Byers T, Levin B, Rothenberger D, Dodd G, Smith R. American Cancer Society Guidelines for Early Detection of Colorectal Polyps and Cancer: update 1997. CA-Cancer J Clin. 1997;47:154–160. CrossRef
- United States Preventive Service Task Force. Screening for colorectal cancer: recommendation and rationale. Ann Intern Med. 2002;137:129–131.
- Parente S, Feldman R, Christianson J. Employee choice of consumer-driven health insurance in a multiplan, multiproduct setting. Health Serv Res. 2004;39:1091–1111. CrossRef
- America’s Health Insurance Plans Center for Policy and Research. January 2007 Census Shows 4.5 Million People Covered by HSA/High-Deductible Health Plans. Washington D.C.: America’s Health Insurance Plans; 2007.
- Greene J. State Approaches to Consumer Direction in Medicaid. New Jersey: Center for Health Care Strategies, Inc.; 2007.
- Mallya G, Pollack C, Polsky D. Are primary care physicians ready to practice in a consumer-driven environment? Am J Manag Care. Forthcoming, 2008.
- Alexander GC, Hall MA, Lantos JD. Rethinking professional ethics in the cost-sharing era. Am J Bioethics. 2006;6:w17–w22. CrossRef
- Pignone M. Cost-effectiveness analyses of colorectal cancer screening: a systematic review for the US preventive services task force. Ann Int Med. 2002;137:132–141.
- Glied SA, Remler DK. The Effect of Health Savings Accounts on Health Insurance Coverage. New York: The Commonwealth Fund; 2005.
- Denberg TD, Kim FJ, Flanigan RC, et al. The influence of patient race and social vulnerability on urologist treatment recommendations in localized prostate carcinoma. Med Care. 2006;44:1137–1141. CrossRef
- Bernheim S, Ross J, Krumholz H, Bradley E. Influence of patients’ socioeconomic status on clinical management decisions: a qualitative study. Ann Fam Med. 2008;6:53–59. CrossRef
- Brennan T, Reisman L. Value-based insurance design and the next generation of consumer-driven health care. Health Aff. 2007;26:w204–w207. CrossRef
- Bloche MG. Consumer-directed health care and disadvantage. Health Aff. 2007;26:1315–1327. CrossRef
- Rosenthal M, Hsuan C, Milstein A. A report card on the freshman class of consumer-directed health plans. Health Aff. 2005;24:1592–1600. CrossRef
- Fuhrmans V. Insurer reveals what doctors really charge: to help people compare fees, Aetna posts some online; a potential bargaining tool. The Wall Street Journal. August 18, 2005.
- Rubenstein S. Patients get new tools to price health care. The Wall Street Journal. June 13, 2006.
- Pham HH, Alexander GC, O’Malley AS. Physician consideration of patients’ out-of-pocket costs in making common clinical decisions. Arch Intern Med. 2007;167:663–668. CrossRef
- Alexander GC, Casalino LP, Meltzer DO. Patient-physician communication about out-of-pocket costs. JAMA. 2003;290:953–958. CrossRef
- Alexander GC, Casalino LP, Meltzer DO. Physician strategies to reduce patients’ out-of-pocket prescription costs. Arch Intern Med. 2005;165:633–636. CrossRef
- Alexander GC, Casalino LP, Tseng C-W, McFadden D, Meltzer DO. Barriers to patient-physician communication about out-of-pocket costs. J Gen Intern Med. 2004;19:856–860. CrossRef
- The Impact of Consumer-Directed Health Plans and Patient Socioeconomic Status on Physician Recommendations for Colorectal Cancer Screening
Journal of General Internal Medicine
Volume 23, Issue 10 , pp 1595-1601
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Additional Links
- consumer-directed health plans
- patient socioeconomic status
- physician decision-making
- colorectal cancer screening
- Industry Sectors
- Author Affiliations
- 1. The Robert Wood Johnson Clinical Scholars Program, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA
- 2. Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA
- 3. Philadelphia VA Medical Center, Philadelphia, PA, USA
- 4. University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA
- 5. The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA