Solitude without Souls: Why Peter Unger hasn’t Established Substance Dualism
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.Get Access
Unger has recently argued that if you are the only thinking and experiencing subject in your chair, then you are not a material object. This leads Unger to endorse a version of Substance Dualism according to which we are immaterial souls. This paper argues that this is an overreaction. We argue that the specifically Dualist elements of Unger’s view play no role in his response to the problem; only the view’s structure is required, and that is available to Unger’s opponents. We outline one such non-Dualist view, suggest how to resolve the dispute, respond to some objections, and argue that ours is but one of many views that survive Unger’s challenge. All these views are incompatible with microphysicalism. So Unger’s discussion does contain an insight: if you are the only conscious subject in your chair, then microphsyicalism is false. Unger’s mistake was to infer Substance Dualism from this; for microphysicalism is not the only alternative to Dualism.
- Baker, L. R. (2000). Persons and bodies. Cambridge University Press.
- Fara, D. G. (2004). Gap principles, penumbral consequence, and infinitely higher-order vagueness. In Beall, J. C. (Ed.), Liars and heaps: New essays on the semantics of paradox: ch9. OUP. Published under the name “Delia Graff”.
- Fine, K (2008) Coincidence and form. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 82: pp. 101-118 CrossRef
- Fine, K (2003) The non-identity of a material thing and its matter. Mind 112: pp. 195-234 CrossRef
- Lewis, D. (1993). Many but almost one. In Bacon, J., Campbell, K. & Reinhardt, L. (Eds.), Ontology, causality and mind: Essays on the philosophy of D. M. Armstrong: ch2. Cambridge University Press.
- Sider, T (2003) Maximality and microphysical supervenience. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 41: pp. 139-149 CrossRef
- Unger, P. (2006). All the power in the world. OUP.
- Unger, P. (2004). The mental problems of the many. In Zimmerman, D. W. (Ed.), Oxford Studies in Metaphysics Volume, 1, 195–222. OUP. Reprinted in Unger (2006), Philosophical Papers Volume, 2, 183–208. OUP.
- Unger, P (1980) The problem of the many. Midwest studies in philosophy 5: pp. 411-467 CrossRef
- van Inwagen, P. (1990). Material beings. Cornell University Press.
- Wiggins, D (1968) On being in the same place at the same time. The Philosophical Review 77: pp. 90-9 CrossRef
- Wiggins, D. (2001). Sameness and substance renewed. Cambridge University Press.
- Wright, C. (2010). The illusion of higher-order vagueness. In Dietz, R. & Moruzzi, S. (Eds.), Cuts and Clouds: Vagueness, its Nature and Logic: ch30. OUP.
- Solitude without Souls: Why Peter Unger hasn’t Established Substance Dualism
Volume 41, Issue 1 , pp 109-125
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Problem of the many
- Substance dualism