Contextual inhibition of fatty acid synthesis by metformin involves glucose-derived acetyl-CoA and cholesterol in pancreatic tumor cells
- First Online:
- Cite this article as:
- Cantoria, M.J., Boros, L.G. & Meuillet, E.J. Metabolomics (2014) 10: 0. doi:10.1007/s11306-013-0555-4
- 2.8k Views
Metformin, a generic glucose lowering drug, inhibits cancer growth expressly in models that employ high fat/cholesterol intake and/or low glucose availability. Here we use a targeted tracer fate association study (TTFAS) to investigate how cholesterol and metformin administration regulates glucose-derived intermediary metabolism and macromolecule synthesis in pancreatic cancer cells. Wild type K-ras BxPC-3 and HOM: GGT(Gly) → TGT(Cys) K12 transformed MIA PaCa-2 adenocarcinoma cells were cultured in the presence of [1,2-13C2]-d-glucose as the single tracer for 24 h and treated with either 100 μM metformin (MET), 1 mM cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS), or the dose matching combination of MET and CHS (CHS–MET). Wild type K-ras cells used 11.43 % (SD = ±0.32) of new acetyl-CoA for palmitate synthesis that was derived from glucose, while K-ras mutated MIA PaCa-2 cells shuttled less than half as much, 5.47 % [SD = ±0.28 (P < 0.01)] of this precursor towards FAS. Cholesterol treatment almost doubled glucose-derived acetyl-CoA enrichment to 9.54 % (SD = ±0.24) and elevated the fraction of new palmitate synthesis by over 2.5-fold in MIA PaCa-2 cells; whereby 100 μM MET treatment resulted in a 28 % inhibitory effect on FAS. Therefore, acetyl-CoA shuttling towards its carboxylase, from thiolase, produces contextual synthetic inhibition by metformin of new palmitate production. Thereby, metformin, mutated K-ras and high cholesterol each contributes to limit new fatty acid and potentially cell membrane synthesis, demonstrating a previously unknown mechanism for inhibiting cancer growth during the metabolic syndrome.
KeywordsTargeted tracer fate association studyTTFASSystem-wide association study13C glucose-derived acetyl-CoACholesterolContextual drug effect
Fatty acid synthase
Stable isotope-based dynamic metabolic profiling
Kirsten rat sarcoma viral oncogene homolog
Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma
Gas chromatography–mass spectrometry
Isotopolome-wide association study
System-wide association study
- EZTopolome (reference)
Isotopolome-wide association study array (normalized)
Targeted tracer fate associations
Targeted tracer fate association study
Metformin (1,1-dimethylbiguanide) is the first-line oral therapy prescribed for type 2 diabetes (Viollet et al. 2012). It is a potent anti-hyperglycemic and insulin-sensitizing drug that works by decreasing hepatic gluconeogenesis, activating insulin receptor tyrosine phosphorylation (Viollet et al. 2012), decreasing intestinal glucose absorption, and increasing skeletal muscle and adipose tissue glucose uptake (del Barco et al. 2011). Moreover, metformin increases the more active mitochondria-bound hexokinase and actin-bound phosphofructokinase in streptozotocin-induced diabetic male Swiss mice hearts, enhancing glucose sensitivity of those organs (da Silva et al. 2012).
Interestingly, numerous studies have reported a lower risk of cancer (Evans et al. 2005; Monami et al. 2011; Ruiter et al. 2012; Libby et al. 2009) and a reduced risk of cancer-related mortality in diabetics (Bo et al. 2011; Bowker et al. 2006) treated with metformin compared to diabetics that were prescribed other glucose-lowering therapies. Recently, improved survival was observed in diabetic pancreatic cancer patients who were taking metformin (Sadeghi et al. 2012). Published treatment protocols suggest that lactic acidosis is potentially a very serious (Fitzgerald et al. 2009) but a rare side effect of metformin, although the link with metformin has been questioned (Preiss and Sattar 2009).
Various mechanisms of action for metformin’s anti-cancer properties have been published, such as its ability to inhibit the mammalian target of rapamycin complex I (mTORC1) in an AMP activated protein kinase (AMPK)-mediated manner (Mihaylova and Shaw 2011). Other reported mechanisms are the AMPK-independent suppression of mTORC1 activation via inhibition of the Regulator complex (Kalender et al. 2010; Sancak et al. 2008, 2010) and the up regulation of the mTORC1 inhibitor REDD1 (regulated in development and DNA damage responses) (Ben Sahra et al. 2011). Metformin has also been shown to prevent insulin/IGF1 crosstalk with G protein coupled receptor (GPCR) signaling (Kisfalvi et al. 2009) and to induce p53-dependent cell cycle arrest and apoptosis (Ben Sahra et al. 2010b).
Metabolic downstream targets of metformin involve the electron transport chain (ETC) complex I (Whitaker-Menezes et al. 2011; Gonzalez-Barroso et al. 2012; Dykens et al. 2008), which results in energy depletion in cancer cells. The addition of metformin with 2DG induces cell death and promotes ATP depletion, underscoring the importance of oxidative phosphorylation as a cancer therapeutic target (Cheong et al. 2011). In addition, it is demonstrated that metformin inhibits glycolytic flux by suppressing the translocation of glucokinase from the nucleus into cytosol in rat hepatocytes, possibly due to its ATP-depleting properties (Guigas et al. 2006).
In vivo, metformin decreases the expression of acetyl CoA carboxylase, fatty acid synthase and citrate lyase, which are involved in hepatic fatty acid synthesis (Bhalla et al. 2012; Algire et al. 2010). Kim et al. (2011) demonstrated that metformin hinders the AMPK-dependent transactivation of nuclear receptor TR4, which then fails to bind to TR4RE on the SCD1 5′ promoter for impairing SCD1 gene expression. This results in the inhibition of lipogenesis and up regulation of β-oxidation in hepatocytes (Kim et al. 2011).
Metabolic adaptation of transformed mammalian cells to codon K12K-ras mutation is identical in fibroblasts (Vizan et al. 2005) and MIA PaCa-2 cells, the latter harboring the GGT → TGT mutation (Lopez-Crapez et al. 1997). The mutant phenotype exhibits greatly increased glycolysis with a low flux along pathways that produce lipid synthesis precursors via the oxidative branch of the pentose cycle, pyruvate dehydrogenase and citrate synthase. The K-ras oncogene also mediates a metabolic phenotype that readily trades glucose-derived acetyl-CoA between cholesterol synthesis, controlled by biosynthetic thiolases, and the fatty acid synthase precursor malonyl-CoA, controlled by acetyl-CoA carboxylase. In the presence of either synthetic (C75) or natural (luteolin) FAS inhibitors, cholesterol synthesis readily serves as the alternate route for glucose-derived acetyl-CoA use in MIA PaCa-2 cells (Harris et al. 2012). This channeling of acetyl-CoA between palmitate and cholesterol syntheses serves as the marker of drug efficacies inhibiting metabolic enzymes that compete for the glucose-derived acetyl-CoA substrate.
In the present study we evaluated the metabolic effects of a physiologically relevant dosage of metformin on two pancreatic cancer cell lines. We show metformin, in the context of available acetyl-CoA and cholesterol, limits fatty acid synthesis in pancreatic tumor cells with mutated K-ras. This explains how metformin controls K-ras induced malignant cell growth via limiting new fatty acid production necessary for cancer cell formation in patients with insulin resistance and the metabolic syndrome. The results of our report provide metabolic explanations for studies showing an anti-cancer effect of metformin in animals fed with a high energy (39.8 % lard) diet (Algire et al. 2008, 2010).
2 Materials and methods
2.1 Cell culture and proliferation
BxPC-3 and MIA PaCa-2 pancreatic cancer cells were purchased from American Type Culture Collection (Manassas, VA, USA). Cell culture media, penicillin–streptomycin (P/S) and trypsin–EDTA were purchased from Mediatech (Manassas, VA, USA). BxPC-3 cells were cultured in RPMI media and MIA PaCa-2 cells were grown in DMEM. Both media were supplemented with 10 % FBS from PAA Laboratories, Inc., (Pasching, Austria) and 1 % P/S. The cells were incubated at 37 °C, 5 % CO2 and 95 % humidity and passaged with 0.25 % trypsin–EDTA once the cells reached 75–80 % confluence. Cells treated with cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS; Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO), from now on referred to as BxPC3-CHS and MIA PaCa-2-CHS, were incubated in media supplemented with 1 mM CHS complexed to 1 % BSA for 2 weeks prior to metabolomics analysis. The 1 mM cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS) dose was used because when compared BxPC-3 (no CHS) versus BxPC-3 (pre-treated with CHS supplementation in the media for 2 weeks) we observed, via western blot, that the CHS-treated cells were more resistant to the AKT inhibitor PH-427, which indicates in vitro biological activity in K-ras negative cells.
Cell proliferation was assessed by plating 1 × 105 cells into T-25 cm2 flasks. Cells were immediately treated with 100 μM metformin for 72 h as appropriate. The doubling times of BxPC-3 cells and MIA PaCa-2 are 48–60 and 40 h, respectively (Deer et al. 2010). Based on these reported doubling times, we decided to use 72 h for cell proliferation measurements to ensure that the cells have undergone one round of doubling before counting. Cells were then counted using trypan blue exclusion.
2.1.1 MTT assay
BxPC-3 and MIA PaCa-2 cells were plated at 2,000 and 500 cells, respectively in 96-well plates and incubated for 24 h in complete RPMI or DMEM media (+1 mM CHS). The following day (day 1), cells were treated with either vehicle (PBS) or 100 μM metformin and incubated for 4 days. On day 5, 50 μL of 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) was added to the wells. After 4 h of incubation, the resulting precipitates were dissolved in 100 μL DMSO. Plates were read at 540 nm using the Synergy 2 Microplate Reader.
2.2 Stable glucose isotope
Summary of metabolic profiles of BxPC-3 (light shaded columns 3–6) and MIA PaCa-2 (dark shaded columns 7–10) pancreatic adenocarcinoma cells (PDAC)
Isotopomer fragment dimension
CHS + MET
CHS + MET
Glucose content (media-CAS: 50-99-7; 6)
(mg %; mg/100 mL)
Glucose consumption (media-CAS: 50-99-7; 7)
(mg %/hour/million cells)
Glucose tracer (media-CAS: 138079-87-5; 280)
13C-labeled fraction (m/z242) (Σm)
39.32**, a (±0.005)
Glucose tracer (media-CAS: 138079-87-5; 283)
13C-m2 (m/z242) (m2/Σm)
96.94**, a (±0.07)
Lactate (media-CAS: 50-21-5; 20)
13C-m2 (m/z328) (m2/Σm)
Lactate (media-CAS: 50-21-5; 22B)
Peak-area (abundance × 102)
1334** (± 38)
3456* (± 467)
Glutamate (media-CAS: 617-65-2; 78)
13C-m1 (m/z198) (m1/Σm)
43.03*, a (±1.05)
Glutamate (media-CAS: 617-65-2; 79)
13C-m2 (m/z198) (m2/Σm)
46.11*, a (±1.19)
Glutamate (media-CAS: 617-65-2; 81)
13C-m4 (m/z198) (m4/Σm)
7.62**, a (±0.27)
6.31**, a (±0.12)
Glutamate (media-CAS: 617-65-2; 87B)
(pellet-CAS: 57-10-3; 98)
13C-labeled fraction (m/z270) (Σm)
15.3**, a (±0.48)
11.3**, a (±0.41)
Palmitate (pellet-CAS: 57-10-3; 101)
Chain elongation-13C-m2 (m/z270) (m2/Σm)
Palmitate (pellet-CAS: 57-10-3; 102)
Fraction of new synthesis (FNS) (% of total)
17.16**, a (±0.57)
12.31**, a (±0.61)
Palmitate (pellet-CAS: 57-10-3; 103)
Ace-CoA enrichment (percent of total)
9.43**, a (±0.32)
Cholesterol (pellet-CAS: 57-88-5; 235)
13C labeled fraction (Σm)
0.03**, a (±0.001)
0.04**, a (±0.002)
Cholesterol (pellet-CAS: 57-88-5; 236)
13C content (Σmn)
0.03*, a (± 0.004)
0.02*, a (±0.002)
Cholesterol (pellet- CAS: 57-88-5; 238H)
Peak-area_CHOL(C:27) (abundance × 104)
5.14*, a (±0.36)
5.32**, a (±0.28)
2.3 Product extraction and derivatization
Extraction and derivatization procedures for glucose, cholesterol, fatty acids, lactate, CO2 and glutamate were previously published (Harrigan et al. 2006; Harris et al. 2012). Sterols and fatty acids were extracted by saponification of Trizol (500 μL, Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) cell extract after removal of the upper glycogen- and RNA-containing supernatant using 30 % KOH and 70 % ethanol (300 μL each) for 2 h. Sterol extraction was performed using 5 mL petroleum ether (EMD, Gibbstown, NJ) with repeated shaking for 20 s three times. The molecular ion of cholesterol was monitored at the m/z 386 ion cluster. Fatty acids were extracted by further acidification using 6 N hydrochloric acid to pH below 2.0 and repeated vortexing with 5 mL petroleum ether. Fatty acids (palmitate) were monitored at m/z 270 using canola oil as positive control. The enrichment of acetyl units in media and cell pellet palmitate in response to CHS and metformin treatments was determined using the mass isotopomer distribution analysis (MIDA) approach. Acetyl-CoA and fractions of new synthesis were calculated from the m4/m2 ratio using the formula m4/m2 = (n−1)/2·(p/q), where n is the number of acetyl units, p is the 13C labeled precursor acetate fraction and q is the 12C labeled natural acetate fraction (p + q = 1) (Lee 1996). Additional details of mathematical approaches are described in by Lee et al. (1992) for spectra processing and 13C positional distribution diagnostics.
For glucose extraction, 500 μL each of 0.3 N barium hydroxide and 0.3 N zinc sulfate were added to 100 μL media. Samples were vortexed and centrifuged for 15 min at 10,000 rpm. Supernatant was dried on air over heat and were derivatized by adding 150 μL hydroxylamine solution and incubated for 2 h at 100 °C followed by addition of 100 μL of acetic anhydride. Samples were incubated at 100 °CC for 1 h and dried under nitrogen over heat as previously described in the fatty acids derivatization section. Ethyl acetate (200 μL) was added. Peak glucose ion was detected at m/z 187 cluster.
Lactate was extracted from media through acidification of 100 μL media with HCl and addition of 1 mL of ethyl acetate. The resulting aqueous layer was dried under nitrogen over heat and derivatized using lactate standard solution as positive control. Two hundred microlitre of 2,2-dimethoxypropane was added followed by 50 μL of 0.5 N methanolic HCl. Samples were incubated at 75 °C for an hour. Sixty microlitre of n-propylamine was added and samples were heated for 100 °C for an hour followed by addition of 200 μL dichloromethane. Heptafluorobutyric anhydride (15 μL) was added followed by 150 μL of dichloromethane and samples were subjected to GC/MS. M1 and m2 lactate were differentiated to distinguish the pentose phosphate flux from anaerobic glycolysis (Lee 1996; Lee et al. 1998) and the ion cluster at m/z 328 was examined.
Media glutamate was converted into its n-trifluoroacteyl-n-butyl derivative and monitored at ion clusters at m/z152 and m/z198.
13CO2Assay for CO2 was generated by adding equal volumes (50 μL) of 0.1N NaHCO3 and 1N HCl to spent media and 12CO2/13CO2 ion currents were monitored and calculated from the m/z44 and m/z45 peak intensities, respectively, using 13CO2/13CO2 of cell culture cabinet’s CO2 thank as the reference ratio for 13CO2 Δ calculations.
2.4 Gas chromatography/mass spectrometry
Agilent 5975 Inert XL Mass Selective Detector connected to HP6890N Network gas chromatograph was used to detect mass spectral data under the following settings: GC inlet 230 °C, MS source 230 °C, MS Quad 150 °C (Harris et al. 2012). For media CO2, glucose, lactate and glutamate analyses, an HP-5 column (30 m length × 250 μm diameter × 0.25 μm thickness) was used while a DB-23 column (60 m length, 250 μm diameter × 0.15 μm thickness) was used for fatty acid measurement.
Mass spectral analyses were obtained by consecutive and independent injections of 1 μL sample using an autosampler with optimal split ratios for column loading (106 > abundance > 104 abundance). Data was accepted if the standard sample deviation was below 10 % of the normalized peak intensity (integrated peak area of ion currents; 100 %) among repeated injections. Data download was performed in triplicate manual peak integrations using modified (background subtracted) spectra under the overlapping isotopomer peaks of the total ion chromatogram (TIC) window displayed by the Chemstation (Agilent, Palo Alto, CA) software. A two-tailed independent sample t test was used to test for significance (P < 0.05, P < 0.01) between control and treated groups (*, **) or between cell lines (#).
2.6 Visual system wide association interface
Rapid system-wide association study (SWAS) evaluation of both cell lines was performed by the color assisted visual isotopolome data matrix screening tool (Harrigan et al. 2006), to diagnose phenotypic differences and response to drug treatment.
2.7 Practical note to multiple SWAS entry interpretations
Please note that there is a distinct functional relevance of each value in Table 1, which is the source matrix for the SWAS interface. For example, there are four table entries for palmitate, which show close to equilibrium non-treatment responsive chain elongation of shorter (C14:0) acyl chain by a single acetyl unit from glucose to form 13C m2 palmitate (101). On the other hand there are significant differences in new palmitate synthesis, which results in altered 13C labeled fractions (98), as well as its synthesis from scratch (FNS; 102) with varying glucose derived acetyl-CoA enrichments (103). For System level interpretations we take into account that a significant inhibitory effect of metformin in net new palmitate synthesis from glucose may be considered more rate limiting on new membrane synthesis and cell proliferation, while its effect on elongating a previously existing shorter acyl chain is not affected. Therefore, multiple SWAS interface entries for the same product clarify the potential biological impact(s) of MET treatment on important precursor-product relationships in a complex biological system.
3.1 Cell viability
3.2 Cell proliferation
The ability of MET to affect cell proliferation for 72 h in all groups was assessed by counting using the trypan blue exclusion method. MET treatment did not significantly alter cell proliferation in control or CHS-treated cells (Fig. 1b). As expected, MIA PaCa-2 cells showed shorter doubling times than BxPC-3 cells did.
3.3 Heavy [1,2-13C2]-d-glucose enrichment and cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS) media preparation
3.4 Complete glucose oxidation
3.5 Lactate synthesis
We observed an expected over 75 % 13C m2 lactate via glycolysis in the glucose derived (labeled) lactate species in media (Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) ID 20 and 22B; Table 1, media lactate panel 22 and 22B). On the other hand, 13C m2 glutamate positional labeling, which is a surrogate of pyruvate dehydrogenase activity for pyruvate’s entry into the TCA cycle, increased in CHS-MET MIA PaCa-2 cells, supporting metformin’s ability to increase TCA cycle cataplerosis at the expense of anaplerosis (anabolic use of pyruvate for new net oxaloacetate and citrate production, also confirmed with increasing m2/m1) in this group (Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) ID 79 and 81; Table 1, media glutamate panel 79 and 81). Extracellular glutamate concentration TIC surrogates shown as GC/MS peak areas decreased in both cell lines after CHS and MET treatments, which also indicates a uniform decrease in ketoglutarate and glutamate output of TCA cycle (Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) ID 87B; Table 1, media glutamate panel 87B). While glutamate’s 13C m4 fractions are small in wild type K-ras BxPC-3 cells (<1 %), there is a prominent 13C m4 glutamate fraction in K-ras mutated MIA PaCa-2 cells (Table 1, media glutamate panel 81). In MIA cells CHS and CHS + MET prominently inhibits oxaloacetate’s replenishment from glucose for new citrate synthesis via pyruvate carboxylase and by repeated cycling. Due to decreased m1 (Table 1, 78) pyruvate carboxylase is also a potential target of the CHS + MET treatment.
3.6 Fatty acid palmitate synthesis
Significant phenotypic differences between BxPC-3 and MIA PaCa-2 cells continue in terms of de novo fatty acid synthesis deriving from the tracer glucose. There is an 8.95 % (±0.24 %) of glucose-derived palmitate labeled in BxPC-3 cells, while only 4.61 % (±0.20 %) (~half) in MIAPaCa-2 (Table 1, pellet palmitate panel 98). This shows that at baseline, MIA PaCa-2 cells are less lipogenic from glucose in comparison with control BxPC-3. Both cell types reach equilibrium in palmitate’s acetyl-CoA enrichment from glucose after 4 h of culturing (data not shown).
3.7 Sterol ring synthesis
As cholesterol and de novo fatty acid syntheses compete for acetyl-CoA, external cholesterol (CHS) administration blocked new sterol synthesis shown by the severely decreased 13C labeled cholesterol fractions with severely increased concentrations (total ion current) values (Table 1, pellet cholesterol panel 235, 236, 238H). However, in K-ras transformed cells the addition of cholesterol in the form of CHS increased the glucose derived acetyl-CoA enrichment and the fraction of newly synthesized (FNS) palmitate from the tracer glucose derived acetyl-CoA. Cholesterol supplementation had no effect on BxPC-3′s already high glucose-derived acetyl-CoA enrichment in palmitate. Hence, addition of CHS did not increase de novo palmitate synthesis in BxPC-3 cells, yet, there was an up-regulation, close to double, in glucose-derived synthesis of new palmitate in CHS-supplemented MIA PaCa-2 cells (Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) ID 102, 103; Table 1, pellet palmitate panel 102, 103). CHS + MET treatment significantly decreased de novo palmitate synthesis both BxPC-3 versus control and MIA PaCa-2 versus CHS. This suggests that metformin clearly is able to inhibit glucose-derived acetyl-CoA flux via fatty acid synthase in the context of acetyl-CoA availability and its consumption by acetyl-CoA carboxylase when sterol synthesis is blocked.
3.8 System wide associations
The rapid system-wide association study (SWAS) evaluation of both cell lines, using the color assisted visual isotopolome data matrix screening tool (Harrigan et al. 2006), confirmed phenotypic differences by increased lactate production in treated MIA PaCa-2 cells [Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) media 22B; square labeled as 1], the ready uptake of cholesteryl-hemi succinate by both cell lines [Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) pellets 238H; squares labeled as 2], acetyl-CoA shuttling towards newly synthesized palmitate [Fig. 2—EZTopolome(K-ras) pellets 102 and 103; squares labeled as 3] in the presence of CHS.
Various studies have implicated metformin as a potential anti-cancer agent. However, metformin’s mechanism of action against cancer remains to be determined (Pollak 2012). Because metformin affects critical metabolic pathways to ameliorate diabetic symptoms, and because cancer cell proliferation is dependent upon altered metabolism, we investigated how this drug controls metabolic flux in two PDAC cell lines, BxPC-3 and MIA PaCa-2, using [1,2-13C2]-d-glucose as the tracer and GC/MS. We used the stable isotope-labeled dynamic metabolic profiling (SiDMAP) (Boros et al. 2003) approach as 13C tracers provide the most comprehensive means of characterizing cellular metabolism and uniquely labeled 13C substrates offer probes of specific reactions within complex networks. The choice of tracer largely determines the precision available to estimate metabolic fluxes in complex mammalian systems, with [1,2-13C2]-d-glucose providing the most precise estimates for glycolysis, the pentose phosphate pathway, and the overall metabolic network (Metallo et al. 2009).
In dose escalating studies 1 mM metformin has been reported to potentiate the cell proliferation inhibitory effect of the hexokinase inhibitor 2DG (Sandulache et al. 2011). At a higher concentration (5 mM), metformin was shown to cause cell death when combined with 2DG (Cheong et al. 2011). In the present study, we show that a physiologically relevant dosage of metformin (100 μM) (Wiernsperger and Rapin 1995) is able to impair glucose utilization through inhibition of FAS when new cholesterol synthesis is limited. We raise for the first time that metformin may inhibit pyruvate carboxylase flux, indicated by decreased m1 but increased m2 in glutamate, TCA cycle output and likely ATP production (not measured) in the CHS-MIA PaCa-2 cancer cell line. In support of the role of metformin in ATP depletion, others have published evidence indicating that metformin only and when combined with 2DG decreases total ATP in human gastric cancer parenteral p-SK4 (Cheong et al. 2011) and prostate cancer cells LNCaP (Ben Sahra et al. 2010a, b), compared to their untreated controls. Previous studies have also implicated contextual factors that enable metformin’s anti-cancer properties (Menendez et al. 2012).
Palmitate is the sole product of FAS and its dependence on acetyl- and malonyl-CoA availabilities is evident; palmitate’s 13C positional labeling from glucose-derived acetate demonstrates a robust, over twofold increase in response to CHS. As cellular metabolic reprogramming is evident after cholesterol pre-treatment in pancreatic cancer cells, the same may occur in the obese diabetic cancer patient with increased circulating cholesterol. The presence of cholesterol establishes the flux-based context in which efficacies of metformin are high because of tissue specificities in which FAS gene expression is already high due to negative feedback (low product concentrations). Such modalities include pancreatic cancer (Walter et al. 2009).
Interestingly, in primary cultured rat hepatocytes, metformin affected neither fatty acid oxidation nor triglyceride synthesis (Fulgencio et al. 2001), yet in an in vivo model of colon (Algire et al. 2010) and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) (Bhalla et al. 2012) with circulating cholesterol, metformin readily decreased FAS expression. In our study metformin was effective in altering palmitate synthesis only after glucose-derived acetyl-CoA was re-directed towards acetyl-CoA carboxylase from biosynthetic thiolase, HMG-CoA and cholesterol synthesis by CHS administration. This finding suggests that metformin may inhibit acetyl-CoA carboxylase, which has been suggested as a cancer promoting enzyme (Wakil and Abu-Elheiga 2009), providing malonyl-CoA precursor directly for FAS.
Determining the cause of the apparent differences in the effects of metformin between BxPC-3 and MIA PaCa-2 cell lines represents an exciting research endeavor. A recent study has shown that, in vitro, RAS diffusion is slowed after cholesterol loading in COS-7 cells (Goodwin et al. 2005). Given the evidence that mutations in K-ras show distinct metabolic phenotypes (Vizan et al. 2005), it is possible that difference in K-ras status between BxPC-3 (WT K-ras) and MIA PaCa-2 (mutated K-ras), besides apparent differences in the culture media, contribute significantly to their diverse response to cholesterol, with MIA PaCa-2 being responsive by increasing acetyl-CoA availability for FAS, comparable to that of BxPC-3. After this metabolic adaptation of MIA PaCa-2 cells to glucose-derived acetyl-CoA shuttling towards FAS, metformin acts as an inhibitor of new fatty acid synthesis, while in BxPC-3 metformin dilutes glucose-derived acetate with no apparent decrease in the rate of new palmitate formation via FAS. Despite the numerous genetic and phenotypic differences between BxPC-3 and MIA PaCa-2 cells (Deer et al. 2010), it is evident that extracellular cholesterol uniformly decreases 13C labeling for intracellular cholesterol synthesis in both cell lines. Consequently, extracellular cholesterol increases acetyl-CoA shuttling towards FAS from glucose in MIA PaCa-2 cells. The sterol ring is an unrecyclable carbon sink when newly synthesized from glucose derived acetyl-CoA in cells; therefore CHS as an external supply introduces significant effects in redistributing acetyl-CoA among cholesterol and fatty acid synthesis pathways, as shown in our paper. This necessitates the introduction of 13C tracer-based metabolic flux research tools in the genetic and signaling research agendas of human cancers as well as metabolic diseases in order to better understand the response of whole biological systems to common drugs.
We acknowledge a potential limitation of this study, succinate of CHS being a potential substrate for TCA cycle metabolism. The dose at which CHS was administrated (1 mM) is 1/25th of that of glucose (4.5 g/glucose/L (25mM)) in media. We observed no significant decrease in 13CO2Δ values after CHS treatment, which is an important assurance that this hemisuccinate did not dilute the TCA cycle substrate pool to any measurable extent. No such dilution was expected from cholesterol under any circumstance due to its stable C:27 carbon ring that lacks oxidation by mammalian cells.
Another limitation may be that this study did not test cell membrane synthesis/turnover directly from isolated membranes for their labeled palmitate pool. We use the connection between inhibited FAS and limited cell membrane synthesis because undifferentiated cells contain the majority, over 90 %, of phospho-sphingo- and triglyceride-derived fatty acids in nuclear and plasma membranes. This fraction yields most derivatized methyl-palmitate for GC–MS analyses after saponification of tumor cell pellets. Previous work with fractionated fat pools of cultured undifferentiated murine myoblasts (Espinoza et al. 2010) confirms the assumption that transformed cell use FAS for new membrane synthesis and proliferation. Palmitate synthesis via FAS for new membrane formation became a target to treat cancer (Flavin et al. 2010 for review). A similar mechanism is suggested herein for metformin in the presence of cholesterol.
Whilst the four measured metabolites and their 13C isotopomer ratios from glucose generate a highly informative matrix, they do not describe the full extent of glucose metabolism. Published methods are available for isotopolome‐wide labeling studies with LC‐MS (Creek et al. 2012) and GC‐MS (Hiller et al. 2013). Targeted tracer fate association studies (TTFA or TTFAS) after drug treatment may provide significantly more information in the future than do either a non-targeted tracer fate detection (NTFD) approach or a limited product IWAS. It is important to point out that even a relatively low but steady increase in the rate of glucose-derived new acetate can contribute to enlarged palmitate pools, over time. Even though there are only a few percent increases in glucose-derived acetyl-CoA to new palmitate synthesis above that in control cells, this surrogate marker of newly contributed acetyl-CoA yields a potentially large new palmitate pool for membrane synthesis; although the majority, ~85 % of acetyl-CoA are still recycled from existing (unlabeled) fatty acids, similar to other transformed cell systems (Bulotta et al. 2003). Another important point is that glucose is a reliable source for new acetyl-CoA synthesis as plasma concentrations, especially in diabetes, are constantly high. In the metabolic syndrome this is combined with high circulating cholesterol, which together yields a reliable new acetyl-CoA pool (glucose) and an inhibitor of new cholesterol synthesis (cholesterol) for tumor cells to thrive with more new palmitate. Metformin limits this new fraction of palmitate synthesis in the context of metabolic changes in a diabetic host, potentially, based on our observations.
Using the same principles as genome-wide association studies (GWAS), this paper demonstrates the effect of metformin by a targeted isotopolome-wide association study (IWAS) approach. This is readily expanded towards system-wide associations (SWAS) when comparing specific metabolic fingerprints, as well as the effect of Metformin in the presence of nutritional factor cholesterol in obesity, in two genetically diverse tumor cell lines. Although it may seem ambitious, IWAS presented in a heat map (EZotopolome) reveals that metformin under high cholesterol contributes to limit new fatty acid and potentially plasma and nuclear membrane synthesis, demonstrating a previously unknown mechanism for inhibiting cancer growth during the metabolic syndrome.
5 Concluding remarks
In conclusion, metformin possesses FAS inhibitory properties in the context of the combined metabolic effects of available acetyl-CoA and extracellular cholesterol. Such contextual synthetic inhibition of FAS by metformin may partly explain the drug’s demonstrated ability to decelerate growth in some cancers of the diabetic patient (Li et al. 2009) or patients with metabolic syndrome. One of the observed side effects, lactic acidosis, is also consistent with our report that the product of glucose metabolism is lactic acid when cholesterol and fatty acid new syntheses are inhibited in the presence of MET.
We thank F. Tracy Lagunero for metabolite extraction/processing, Péter Csaba Bíró for assisting in the cell proliferation studies, Maria Csikos, Ana Geri, Csaba Geri for blinded spectra processing, Ferenc Nádudvari for preparing the EZTopolome visual data review panels and Dale Chenoweth of Austin, Texas, for co-editing the manuscript. This work was supported by the Hirshberg Foundation for Pancreatic Cancer Research to EJM, by the National Needs Fellow (NNF) training grant from the USDA [Grant 2010-38420-20369] for MJC, by the UCLA Center for Excellence in Pancreatic Diseases of the NCI [Grant 1 P01 AT003960-01A1] and the UCLA Clinical and Translational Science Institute [Grant UL1TR000124] to LGB.
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.