Epistemic and social scripts in computer–supported collaborative learning Article Received: 30 November 2003 Accepted: 20 August 2004 DOI:
Cite this article as: Weinberger, A., Ertl, B., Fischer, F. et al. Instr Sci (2005) 33: 1. doi:10.1007/s11251-004-2322-4 Abstract
Collaborative learning in computer-supported learning environments typically means that learners work on tasks together, discussing their individual perspectives via text-based media or videoconferencing, and consequently acquire knowledge. Collaborative learning, however, is often sub-optimal with respect to how learners work on the concepts that are supposed to be learned and how learners interact with each other. One possibility to improve collaborative learning environments is to conceptualize epistemic scripts, which specify how learners work on a given task, and social scripts, which structure how learners interact with each other. In this contribution, two studies will be reported that investigated the effects of epistemic and social scripts in a text-based computer-supported learning environment and in a videoconferencing learning environment in order to foster the individual acquisition of knowledge. In each study the factors ‘epistemic script’ and ‘social script’ have been independently varied in a 2 × 2-factorial design. A total of 182 university students of educational science participated in these two studies. Results of both studies show that social scripts can be substantially beneficial with respect to the individual acquisition of knowledge, whereas epistemic scripts apparently do not always lead to the expected effects.
Keywords computer-supported collaborative learning CSCL cooperation scripts computer-mediated communication discussion boards videoconferencing References Baker, M., Lund, K. 1997 Promoting reflective interactions in a CSCL environment Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 13 175 193 Google Scholar Brooks, L.W., Dansereau, D.F. 1983 Effects of structural schema training and text organization on expository prose processing Journal of Educational Psychology 75 811 820 Google Scholar Brown, A.L., Palincsar, A.S. 1989 Guided, cooperative learning and individual knowledge acquisition Resnick, L.B. eds. Knowing, Learning, and Instruction. Essays in the Honour of Robert Glaser Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ 393 451 Google Scholar Chan, C.K.K. 2001 Peer collaboration and discourse patterns in learning from incompatible information Instructional Science 29 443 479 Google Scholar Chi, M.T.H., Feltovich, P.J., Glaser, R. 1981 Categorization and representation of physics problems by experts and novices Cognitive Science 5 121 152 Google Scholar Chinn, C.A., Brewer, W.F. 1993 The role of anomalous data in knowledge acquisition: A theoretical framework and implications for science instruction Review of Educational Research 63 1 49 Google Scholar Clark, D., Weinberger, A., Jucks, I., Spitulnik, M., Wallace, R. 2003 Designing effective science inquiry in text-based computer supported collaborative learning environments International Journal of Educational Policy, Research & Practice 4 55 82 Google Scholar Cohen, E.G. 1994 Restructuring the classroom: Conditions for productive small groups Review of Educational Research 64 1 35 Google Scholar Dansereau, D.F., Collins, K.W., McDonald, B.A., Holley, C.D., Garland, J.C., Diekhoff, G., Evans, S.H. 1979 Development and evaluation of a learning strategy program Journal of Educational Psychology 71 64 73 Google Scholar Dillenbourg, P. 2002 Over-scripting CSCL: The risks of blending collaborative learning with instructional design Kirschner, P.A. eds. Three Worlds of CSCL. Can We Support CSCL Open Universiteit Nederland Heerlen 61 91 Google Scholar Doise, W. 1990 System and metasystem in cognitive operations Carretero, M. Pope, M.L. Simons, P.R.J. Pozo, J.I. eds. Learning and Instruction: European Research in an International Context Pergamon Elmsford, NY 125 139 Google Scholar Dufresne, R.J., Gerace, W.J., Thibodeau Hardiman, P., Mestre, J.P. 1992 Constraining novices to perform expertlike problem analyses: Effects on schema acquisition The Journal of the Learning Sciences 2 307 331 Google Scholar
Ertl, B.M. (2003). Kooperatives Lernen in Videokonferenzen: Förderung von individuellem und gemeinsamem Lernerfolg durch external repräsentierte Strukturangebote [Cooperative learning in videoconferences: Facilitation of individual and collaborative learning outcome through externally represented structuring tools]. Doctoral dissertation, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, Munich, Germany. Available at: http://edoc.ub.unimuenchen.de/archive/00001227/01/Ertl_Bernhard_M.pdf.
Fischer, F. (2001). Gemeinsame Wissenskonstruktion. Analyse und Förderung in computerunterstützten Kooperationsszenarien [Collaborative knowledge construction. Analysis and facilitation in computer-supported collaborative scenarios]. Professorial dissertation, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, Munich, Germany.
Fischer, F., Bruhn, J., Gräsel, C., Mandl, H. 2002 Fostering collaborative knowledge construction with visualization tools Learning and Instruction 12 213 232 Google Scholar Geyken, A., Mandl, H., Reiter, W. 1998 Selbstgesteuertes Lernen mit Tele-Tutoring [Selfguided learning with tele-tutoring]. Schwarzer, R. eds. Multimedia und TeleLearning [Multimedia and telelearning] Campus Frankfurt a. M. 181 196 Google Scholar
Guzley, R.M., Avanzino, S. & Bor, A. (2001). Simulated computer-mediated / video-interactive distance learning: A test of motivation, interaction satisfaction, delivery, learning & perceived effectiveness. Journal of Computer Mediated Communication 6.
Herrenkohl, L.R., Guerra, M.R. 1998 Participant structures, scientific discourse, and student engagement in fourth grade Cognition and Instruction 16 433 475 Google Scholar Hesse, F.W., Garsoffky, B., Hron, A. 1997 Interfacedesign für computerunterstütztes kooperatives Lernen [Interface design for computer-supported cooperative learning]. Issing, L.J. Klimsa, P. eds. Informationen und Lernen mit Multimedia (Information and learning with multimedia)2nd ed Beltz Weinheim 253 267 Google Scholar Hogan, K., Nastasi, B.K., Pressley, M. 2000 Discourse patterns and collaborative scientific reasoning in peer and teacher-guided discussions Cognition and Instruction 17 379 432 Google Scholar Hron, A., Hesse, F.W., Reinhard, P., Picard, E. 1997 Strukturierte Kooperation beim computerunterstützten kollaborativen Lernen [Structured cooperation in computer-supported collaborative learning] Unterrichtswissenschaft 25 56 69 Google Scholar Hytecker, V.I., Dansereau, D.F., Rocklin, T.R. 1988 An analysis of the processes influencing the structured dyadic learning environment Educational Psychologist 23 23 37 Google Scholar King, A. 1994 Guiding knowledge construction in the classroom: Effects of teaching children how to question and how to explain American Educational Research Journal 31 338 368 Google Scholar King, A. 1999 Discourse patterns for mediating peer learning O’Donnell, A.M. King, A. eds. Cognitive Perspectives on Peer Learning Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ 87 115 Google Scholar Kollar, I., Fischer, F., Hesse, F.W. 2003 Cooperation scripts for computer-supported collaborative learning Wasson, B. Baggetun, R. Hoppe, U. Ludvigsen, S. eds. Proceedings of the International Conference on Computer Support for Collaborative Learning–CSCL 2003, COMMUNITY EVENTS–Communication and Interaction InterMedia Bergen, NO 59 61 Google Scholar Larson, C.O., Dansereau, D.F., O’Donnell, A.M., Hytecker, V.I., Lambiotte, J.G., Rocklin, T.R. 1985 Effects of metacognitive and elaborative activity on cooperative learning and transfer Contemporary Educational Psychology 10 342 348 Google Scholar Mandl, H., Gruber, H., Renkl, A. 1996 Communities of practice toward expertise: Social foundation of university instruction Baltes, P.B. Staudinger, U. eds. Interactive Minds. Life-Span Perspectives on the Social Foundation of Cognition Cambridge University Press Cambridge 394 411 Google Scholar Nastasi, B.K., Clements, D.H. 1991 Research on cooperative learning: Implications for practice School Psychology Review 20 110 131 Google Scholar
Nussbaum, E.M., Hartley, K., Sinatra, G.M., Reynolds, R.E. & Bendixen, L.D. (2002). Enhancing the quality of online discussions. Paper presented at the Annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans, LA.
O’Donnell, A.M. 1999 Structuring dyadic interaction through scripted cooperation O’Donnell, A.M. King, A. eds. Cognitive Perspectives on Peer Learning Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ 179 196 Google Scholar O’Donnell, A.M., Dansereau, D.F. 1992 Scripted cooperation in student dyads: A method for analyzing and enhancing academic learning and performance. Hertz Lazarowitz, R. Miller, N. eds. Interactions in Cooperative Groups. The Theoretical Anatomy of Group Learning Cambridge University Press Cambridge, MA 120 141 Google Scholar Palincsar, A.S., Herrenkohl, L.R. 1999 Designing collaborative contexts: Lessons from three research programs. O’Donnell, A.M. King, A. eds. Cognitive perspectives on peer learning Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ 151 177 Google Scholar Piaget, J. 1932/1965Moral Judgment of the Child Free Press New York Google Scholar Reiser, B.J. 2002 Why scaffolding should sometimes make tasks more difficult for learners Stahl, G. eds. Computer Support for Collaborative Learning: Foundations for a CSCL Community. Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ 255 264 Google Scholar Salomon, G., Globerson, T. 1989 When teams do not function the way they ought to International Journal of Educational Research 13 89 99 Google Scholar Scardamalia, M., Bereiter, C. 1996 Computer support for knowledge-building communities Koschmann, T. eds. CSCL: Theory and Practice of an Emerging Paradigm Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ 249 268 Google Scholar Scarr, S., McCartney, K. 1983 How people make their own environments: A theory of genotype-environment effects Child Development 54 424 435 Google Scholar Suthers, D.D. 2003 Representational guidance for collaborative inquiry Andriessen, J.E.B. Baker, M. Suthers, D.D. eds. Arguing to Learn. Confronting Cognitions in Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning Environments Kluwer Dordrecht 27 46 Google Scholar Suthers, D.D., Hundhausen, C.D. 2001 Learning by constructing collaborative representations: An empirical comparison of three alternatives Dillenbourg, P. Eurelings, A. Hakkarainen, K. eds. European Perspectives on Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning University of Maastricht Maastricht, NL 577 592 Google Scholar Teasley, S. 1997 Talking about reasoning: How important is the peer in peer collaboration? Resnick, L.B. Säljö, R. Pontecorvo, C. Burge, B. eds. Discourse, Tools and Reasoning: Essays on Situated Cognition Springer Berlin 361 384 Google Scholar Veerman, A.L., Treasure-Jones, T. 1999 Software for problem solving through collaborative argumentation Coirier, P. Andriessen, J.E.B. eds. Foundations of Argumentative Text Processing Amsterdam University Press Amsterdam 203 230 Google Scholar Webb, N.M., Farivar, S. 1999 Developing productive group interaction in middle school O’Donnell, A.M. King, A. eds. Cognitive Perspectives on Peer Learning Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ 117 149 Google Scholar Webb, N.M., Jonathan, D., Fall, T., Fall, R. 1995 Constructive activity and learning in collaborative small groups Journal of Educational Psychology 87 406 423 Google Scholar
Weinberger, A. (2003).
Scripts for computer-supported collaborative learning. Effects of social and epistemic cooperation scripts on collaborative knowledge construction. Doctoral dissertation, Ludwig-Maximilians-University, Munich, Germany. Available at: http://edoc.ub.uni-muenchen.de/archive/00001120/01/Weinberger_ Armin.pdf. Weinberger, A., Fischer, F., Mandl, H. 2002 Fostering computer supported collaborative learning with cooperation scripts and scaffolds Stahl, G. eds. Computer Support for Collaborative Learning:Foundations for a CSCL Community. Proceedings of the Conference on Computer Support for Collaborative Learning (CSCL) 2002, Boulder, USA Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ 573 574 Google Scholar Weinberger, A., Fischer, F., Mandl, H. 2003 Gemeinsame Wissenskonstruktion in computervermittelter Kommunikation: Wirkungen von Kooperationsskripts auf den Erwerb anwendungsorientierten Wissens? [Collaborative knowledge construction in computer-mediated communication: Effects of cooperation scripts on acquisition of application-oriented knowledge] Zeitschrift für Psychologie 211 86 97 Google Scholar
Weinberger, A. & Mandl, H. (2003). Computer-mediated knowledge communication. Special Issue: New Media in Education.
Studies in Communication Sciences: 81–105. Weiner, B. 1985 An attributional theory of achievement motivation and emotion Psychological Review 92 548 573 Google Scholar Zhang, J., Norman, D.A. 1994 Representations in distributed cognitive tasks Cognitive Science 18 87 122 Google Scholar