Mycotoxin Reduction in Bt Corn: Potential Economic, Health, and Regulatory Impacts Article Received: 01 July 2005 Accepted: 16 November 2005 DOI:
Cite this article as: Wu, F. Transgenic Res (2006) 15: 277. doi:10.1007/s11248-005-5237-1 Abstract
Genetically modified (GM) Bt corn, through the pest protection that it confers, has lower levels of mycotoxins: toxic and carcinogenic chemicals produced as secondary metabolites of fungi that colonize crops. In some cases, the reduction of mycotoxins afforded by Bt corn is significant enough to have an economic impact, both in terms of domestic markets and international trade. In less developed countries where certain mycotoxins are significant contaminants of food, Bt corn adoption, by virtue of its mycotoxin reduction, may even improve human and animal health. This paper describes an integrated assessment model that analyzes the economic and health impacts of two mycotoxins in corn: fumonisin and aflatoxin. It was found that excessively strict standards of these two mycotoxins could result in global trade losses in the hundreds of millions $US annually, with the US, China, and Argentina suffering the greatest losses. The paper then discusses the evidence for Bt corn’s lower levels of contamination of fumonisin and aflatoxin, and estimates economic impacts in the United States. A total benefit of Bt corn’s reduction of fumonisin and aflatoxin in the US was estimated at $23 million annually. Finally, the paper examines the potential policy impacts of Bt corn’s mycotoxin reduction, on nations that are making a decision on whether to allow commercialization of this genetically modified crop.
Keywords Bt corn economic impacts health impacts mycotoxin reduction regulatory policy References Bakan, B, Melcion, D, Richard-Molard, D, Cahagnier, B 2002 Fungal growth and Fusarium mycotoxin content in isogenic traditional maize and genetically modified maize grown in France and Spain J Agric Food Chem 50 728 731 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar
Benedict J, Fromme D, Cosper J, Correa C, Odvody G and Parker R (1998) Efficacy of Bt Corn Events MON810, Bt11 and E176 in Controlling Corn Earworm, Fall Armyworm, Sugarcane Borer and Aflatoxin. Texas A&M University System, College Station, TX http://lubbock.tamu.edu/ipm/AgWeb/r_and_d/1998/Roy%20Parker/Bt%20Corn/BtCorn. html.
Buntin, GD, Lee, RD, Wilson, DM, McPherson, RM 2001 Evaluation of yieldgard transgenic resistance for control of fall armyworm and corn earworm (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) on corn Fla Entomol 84 37 42 Google Scholar
Cardwell KF, Desjardins A, Henry SH, Munkvold G and Robens J (2001) Mycotoxins: The Cost of Achieving Food Security and Food Quality, www.apsnet.org/online/feature/mycotoxin/top.html.
CAST (Council for Agricultural Science and Technology) (2003) Mycotoxins: Risks in Plant, Animal, and Human Systems. Task Force Report No. 139, Ames, Iowa.
Dowd, PF 1998 The involvement of arthropods in the establishment of mycotoxigenic fungi under field conditions Sinha, KK Bhatnagar, D eds. Mycotoxins in Agriculture and Food Safety Marcel Dekker New York Google Scholar Dowd, PF 2001 Biotic and abiotic factors limiting efficacy of Bt corn in indirectly reducing mycotoxin levels in commercial fields J Econ Ent 94 1067 1074 CrossRef Google Scholar Etcheverry, M, Nesci, A, Barros, G, Torres, A, Chulze, S 1999 Occurrence of Aspergillus section flavi and aflatoxin B1 in corn genotypes and corn meal in Argentina Mycopathologia 147 37 41 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar
FDA (Food and Drug Administration) (2000) Background Paper in Support of Fumonisin Levels in Corn and Corn Products Intended for Human Consumption. http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/fumonbg3.html.
FSA (Food Standards Agency) (2003) Contaminated maize meal withdrawn from sale. www.food.gov.uk/news/newsarchive/maize.
Gong, YY, Cardwell, K, Hounsa, A, Egal, S, Turner, PC, Hall, AJ, Wild, CP 2000 Dietary aflatoxin exposure and impaired growth in young children from Benin and Togo: cross sectional study BMJ 325 20 21 CrossRef Google Scholar Hammond, B, Campbell, K, Pilcher, C, Robinson, A, Melcion, D, Cahagnier, B, Richard, J, Sequeira, J, Cea, J, Tatli, F, Grogna, R, Pietri, A, Piva, G, Rice, L 2003 Reduction of fumonisin mycotoxins in Bt corn Toxicologist 72 1217 Google Scholar Hendricks, K 1999 Fumonisins and neural tube defects in south Texas Epidemiology 10 198 200 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Henry, SH, Bosch, FX, Troxell, TC, Bolger, PM 1999 Reducing liver cancer – global control of aflatoxin Science 286 2453 2454 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar
IARC (International Agency for Research on Cancer) (2002) Some Traditional Herbal Medicines, Some Mycotoxins, Naphthalene and Styrene. Monograph Volume 82,
James C (2003) Global Review of Commercialized Transgenic Crops: 2002. Feature: Bt Maize. International Service for the Acquisition of Agri-Biotech Applications (ISAAA) No. 29, Ithaca, NY.
Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) (2001) Safety evaluation of certain mycotoxins in food. WHO Food Additives Series 47, FAO food and Nutrition Paper 74.
Keyl, AC 1978 Aflatoxicosis in cattle Wyllie, TD Morehouse, LG eds. Mycotoxic Fungi, Mycotoxins, Mycotoxicoses Marcel Dekker New York 9 27 Google Scholar Li, FQ, Yoshiazawa, T, Kawamura, O, Luo, XY, Li, YW 2001 Aflatoxins and fumonisins in corn from the high-incidence area for human hepatocellular carcinoma in Guangxi, China J Agric Food Chem 49 4122 4126 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Lubulwa, ASG, Davis, JS 1994 Estimating the social costs of the impacts of fungi and aflatoxins in maize and peanuts Highley, E Wright, EJ Banks, HJ Champ, BR eds. Stored Product Protection: Proceedings of the 6th International Working Conference on Stored-product Protection CAB International Wallingford, UK 1017 1042 Google Scholar Marasas, WFO 1996 Fumonisins: History, World-Wide Occurrence and Impact Jackson, L eds. Fumonisins in Food Plenum Press New York Google Scholar Marasas, WFO, Riley, RL, Hendricks, KA, Stevens, VL, Sadler, TW, Gelineau-van Waes, J, Missmer, SA, Cabrera, J, Torres, O, Gelderblom, WCA, Allegood, J, Martinez, C, Maddox, J, Miller, JD, Starr, L, Sullards, MC, Roman, AV, Voss, KA, Wang, E., Merrill, AH, Jr 2004 Fumonisins disrupt sphingolipid metabolism, folate transport, and neural tube development in embryo culture and in vivo: a potential risk factor for human neural tube defects among populations consuming fumonisin-contaminated maize J Nutr 134 711 716 PubMed Google Scholar Miller, JD 2001 Factors that affect the occurrence of fumonisins Environ Health Perspect 109 321 324 PubMed Google Scholar
Miller JD and Marasas WFO (2002) Ecology of Mycotoxins in Maize and Groundnuts. Supplement to LEISA (Low External Input and Sustainable Agriculture) Magazine, 23–24.
Munkvold, GP, Hellmich, RL 1999 Comparison of fumonisin concentrations in kernels of transgenic Bt maize hybrids and nontransgenic hybrids Plant Dis 83 130 138 Google Scholar Odvody, GN, Chilcutt, CF, Parker, RD, Benedict, JH 2000 Aflatoxin and insect response of near-isogenic Bt and non-Bt commercial corn hybrids in south Texas Robens, JF eds. Proceedings of the 2000 Aflatoxin/Fumonisin Workshop USDA Agricultural Research Service Beltsville, MD Google Scholar
Ostlie K, Hutchison W and Hellmich R (1997) Bt Corn and European Corn Borer. NCR publication 602, University of Minnesota, St. Paul.
Pray CE, Bengali P and Ramaswami B (2006) The cost of biosafety regulation: the indian experience. In: Just R, Alston W and Huffman W (eds), Economics of Regulation of Agricultural Biotechnologies, Springer-Verlag, New York (in press).
Resnik, S, Neira, S, Pacin, A, Martinez, E, Apro, N, Latreite, S 1996 A survey of the natural occurrence of aflatoxins and zearalenone in Argentine field maize: 1983–1994 Food Addit Contam 13 115 120 PubMed Google Scholar Rheeder, JP, Marasas, WF, Vismer, HF 2002 Production of fumonisin analogs by Fusarium species Appl Environ Microbiol 68 2101 2105 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Robens, J, Cardwell, K 2003 The costs of mycotoxin management to the USA: management of aflatoxins in the United States J Toxicol Toxin Rev 2–3 143 156 Google Scholar Ross, PF, Rice, LG, Osweiler, GD, Nelson, PE, Richard, JL, Wilson, TM 1992 A review and update of animal toxicoses associated with fumonisin-contaminated feeds and production of fumonisins by Fusarium isolates Mycopathologia 17 109 114 CrossRef Google Scholar Shelby, RA, White, OG, Burke, EM 1994 Differential fumonisins production in maize hybrids Plant Dis 78 582 584 CrossRef Google Scholar Shephard, GS 2004 Mycotoxins worldwide: current issues in Africa Barug, D Egmond, HP Lopez-Garcia, R Osenbruggen, WA Visconti, A eds. Meeting the Mycotoxin Menace Wageningen Academic Wageningen, The Netherlands 81 88 Google Scholar Sinha, AK 1994 The impact of insect pests on aflatoxin contamination of stored wheat and maize Highley, E Wright, EJ Banks, HJ Champ, BR eds. Stored Product Protection: Proceedings of the 6th International Working Conference on Stored-product Protection CAB International Wallingford, UK 1059 1063 Google Scholar Sydenham, EW, Shephard, GS, Thiel, PG, Marasas, WFO, Stockenstrom, S 1991 Fumonisin contamination of commercial corn-based human foodstuffs J Agric Food Chem 39 2014 2018 CrossRef Google Scholar Turner, PC, Moore, SE, Hall, AJ, Prentice, AM, Wild, CP 2003 Modification of immune function through exposure to dietary aflatoxin in Gambian children Environ Health Perspect 111 217 220 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar
USDA (United States Department of Agriculture) (2003a) World Corn Trade. Foreign Agricultural Service: Production, Supply & Distribution.
USDA (2003b) World Coarse Grains Situation and Outlook. Foreign Agricultural Service (FAS) online, http://www. fas.usda.gov/grain/circular/2003/10-03/cgra_txt.htm.
USDA (2003c) Acreage. USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service, Agricultural Statistics Board.
USDA (2004) Acreage. USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service, Agricultural Statistics Board.
Egmond, HP 2002 Worldwide regulations for mycotoxins Adv Exp Med Biol 504 257 269 PubMed Google Scholar Wang, JS, Huang, T, Su, J, Liang, F, Wei, Z, Liang, Y, Luo, H, Kuang, SY, Qian, GS, Sun, G, He, X, Kensler, TW, Groopman, JD 2001 Hepatocellular carcinoma and aflatoxin exposure in Zhuqing Village, Fusui County, People’s Republic of China Cancer Epidemiol Markers 10 143 146 Google Scholar Wicklow, DT 1994 Preharvest origins of toxigenic fungi in stored grain Highley, E Wright, EJ Banks, HJ Champ, BR eds. Stored Product Protection: Proceedings of the 6th International Working Conference on Stored-product Protection CAB International Wallingford, UK 1075 1081 Google Scholar Williams, WP, Windham, GL, Buckley, PM, Daves, CA 2002 Aflatoxin accumulation in conventional and transgenic corn hybrids infested with southwestern corn borer (Lepidoptera: Crambidae) J Agric Urban Entomol 19 227 236 Google Scholar Wu, F 2004 Mycotoxin risk assessment for the purpose of setting international regulatory standards Environ Sci Technol 38 4049 4055 PubMed CrossRef Google Scholar Wu, F, Miller, JD, Casman, EA 2004 Bt corn and mycotoxin reduction: an economic perspective J Toxicol Toxin Rev 23 397 424 CrossRef Google Scholar Wyatt, RD 1991 Poultry Smith, JE Henderson, RS eds. Mycotoxins and Animal Foods CRC Press Boca Raton FL 553 606 Google Scholar