Deterministic probability: neither chance nor credence
- Aidan Lyon
- … show all 1 hide
Purchase on Springer.com
$39.95 / €34.95 / £29.95*
Rent the article at a discountRent now
* Final gross prices may vary according to local VAT.
Some have argued that chance and determinism are compatible in order to account for the objectivity of probabilities in theories that are compatible with determinism, like Classical Statistical Mechanics (CSM) and Evolutionary Theory (ET). Contrarily, some have argued that chance and determinism are incompatible, and so such probabilities are subjective. In this paper, I argue that both of these positions are unsatisfactory. I argue that the probabilities of theories like CSM and ET are not chances, but also that they are not subjective probabilities either. Rather, they are a third type of probability, which I call counterfactual probability. The main distinguishing feature of counterfactual-probability is the role it plays in conveying important counterfactual information in explanations. This distinguishes counterfactual probability from chance as a second concept of objective probability.
- Albert D. (2000) Time and chance. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
- Batterman R. (1992) Explanatory instability. Noûs 26: 325–348 CrossRef
- Bigelow J. (1976) Possible worlds foundations for probability. Journal of Philosophical Logic 5(3): 299–320
- Bigelow J. (1977) Semantics of probability. Synthese 36(4): 459–472 CrossRef
- Diaconis P. (1998) A place for philosophy? The rise of modeling in statistical science. Quarterly of Applied Mathematics 56(4): 797–805
- Eagle A. (2004) Twenty-one arguments against propensity analyses of probability. Erkenntnis 60: 371–416 CrossRef
- Earman J. (1986) A primer on determinism. Reidel, Dordrecht
- Frigg R. (2008) Chance in Boltzmannian statistical mechanics. Philosophy of Science 75(5): 670–681 CrossRef
- Frigg R., Hoefer C. (2009) Determinism and chance from a Humean perspective. In: Dieks D., Gonzalez W., Hartmann S., Weber M., Stadler F., Uebel T. (eds) The present situation in the philosophy of science. Springer, Berlin
- Graves L., Horan B., Rosenberg A. (1999) Is indeterminism the source of the statistical character of evolutionary theory?. Philosophy of Science 66: 140–157 CrossRef
- Hájek A. (1997) ‘Mises Redux’-redux: Fifteen arguments against finite frequentism. Erkenntnis 45: 209–227
- Hájek A. (2003) What conditional probability could not be. Synthese 137(3): 273–323 CrossRef
- Hoefer C. (2007) The third way on objective probability: A sceptic’s guide to objective chance. Mind 116(463): 549–596 CrossRef
- Jackson F., Pettit P. (1992) In defense of explanatory ecumenism. Economics and Philosophy 8(1): 1–21 CrossRef
- Kahneman D., Slovic P., Tversky A. (1982) Judgement under uncertainty: Heuristics and biases. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
- Laplace, P. (1814). A philosophical essay on probabilities. New York: Dover (1951)
- Levi I. (1990) Chance. Philosophical Topics 18(2): 117–149
- Lewis D. (1980) A subjectivist’s guide to objective chance. In: Jeffrey R.C. (eds) Studies in inductive logic and probability (Vol. II). University of California Press, Berkeley
- Lewis, D. (1986). A subjectivist’s guide to objective chance. In Philosophical papers (Vol. II, pp. 83–132). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Lewis D. (1994) Humean supervenience debugged. Mind 103: 473–490 CrossRef
- Loewer B (2001) Determinism and chance. Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 32: 609–620 CrossRef
- Lyon, A. (2009). Three concepts of probability. Ph.D. thesis, Australian National University.
- Millstein R. (2003a) How not to argue for the indeterminism of evolution: A look at two recent attempts to settle the issue. In: Hüttemann A. (eds) Determinism in physics and biology. Paderborn, Mentis, pp 91–107
- Millstein R. L. (2003b) Interpretations of probability in evolutionary theory. Philosophy of Science 70: 1317–1328 CrossRef
- Norton, J. (2006). The dome: An unexpectedly simple failure of determinism. Philsci-Archive.
- Popper K. R. (1959) The propensity interpretation of probability. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 10(37): 25–42 CrossRef
- Popper K. (1982) Quantum theory and the schism in physics. Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ
- Putnam, H. (1975). Philosophy and our mental life. In Readings in philosophy of psychology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Railton P. (1981) Probability, explanation, and information. Synthese 48(2): 233–256 CrossRef
- Rosenberg A. (1994) Instrumental biology or the disunity of science. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
- Rosenberg A. (2001) Discussion note: Indeterminism, probability, and randomness in evolutionary theory. Philosophy of Science 68(4): 536–544 CrossRef
- Schaffer J. (2007) Deterministic chance?. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 58(2): 113–140 CrossRef
- Sober E. (1984) The nature of selection. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
- Sober E. (1999) The multiple realizability argument against reductionism. Philosophy of Science 66(4): 542–564 CrossRef
- Sober, E. (2010). Evolutionary theory and the reality of macro probabilities. In E. Eells & J. Fetzer (Eds.), Probability in science. La Salle, IL: Open Court.
- Sterelny K. (1996) Explanatory pluralism in evolutionary biology. Biology and Philosophy 11: 193–214 CrossRef
- Sterelny K., Kitcher P. (1988) The return of the gene. The Journal of Philosophy 85(7): 339–361 CrossRef
- Strevens, M. (2006). Probability and chance. Encyclopedia of philosophy (2nd ed.). Detroit: Macmillan Reference USA.
- Weber M. (2001) Determinism, realism, and probability in evolutionary theory. Philosophy of Science 68(3): S213–S224 CrossRef
- Weber M. (2005) Darwinism as a theory for finite beings. In: Hösle V., Illies C. (eds) Darwinism and philosophy. University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, pp 275–297
- Winsberg, E. (2006). Probability and chance. Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics. doi:10.1016/j.shpsb.2008.05.005.
- Deterministic probability: neither chance nor credence
Volume 182, Issue 3 , pp 413-432
- Cover Date
- Print ISSN
- Online ISSN
- Springer Netherlands
- Additional Links
- Objective probability
- Probability concepts
- Industry Sectors
- Aidan Lyon (1)
- Author Affiliations
- 1. Philosophy Program, Research School of Social Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra, Australia