Abstract
The conference paper by Mohanram (2005) provides evidence on the success of contextual financial statement analysis in the low book-to-market (i.e., glamour) stock setting. The economic benefits of the strategy are concentrated in the identification of glamour firms that will ultimately underperform the market. In contrast to traditional accounting-based anomalies, Mohanram’s growth-based trading strategy is stronger among large, heavily followed firms, suggesting that the mechanism behind the mispricing of glamour firms is different than the traditional information environment and dissemination arguments found in other settings. Despite the robustness of the reported results, the strategy faces implementation constraints due to (1) the relative costs associated with gathering industry-adjusted data and (2) the frictions and costs associated with capitalizing on expected price declines over a long horizon. Finally, the relative benefits of contextual analysis need to be assessed against the predictive benefits accruing to traditional financial statement analysis-based investment techniques.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. Ali L. Hwang M. Trombley (2003) ArticleTitleArbitrage Risk and the Book-to-Market Anomaly Journal of Financial Economics 69 355–373 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0304-405X(03)00116-8
M. D. Beneish C. M. C. Lee R. Tarpley (2001) ArticleTitleContextual Financial Analysis Through the Prediction of Extreme Returns Review of Accounting Studies 6 165–190
V. Bernard J. Thomas (1989) ArticleTitlePost-Earnings Announcement Drift: Delayed Price Response or Risk Premium Journal of Accounting Research 27 1–36
S. Bhojraj C. M. C. Lee D. Oler (2003) ArticleTitleWhat’s My Line: A Comparison of Industry Classification Schemes for Capital Markets Research Journal of Accounting Research 41 745–774 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.1475-679X.2003.00122.x
N. Chen F. Zhang (1998) ArticleTitleRisk and Return of Value Stocks Journal of Business 71 501–535 Occurrence Handle10.1086/209755
D. Collins G. Gong P. Hribar (2003) ArticleTitleInvestor Sophistication and the Mispricing of Accruals Review of Accounting Studies 8 251–276 Occurrence Handle10.1023/A:1024417513085
E. Fama K. French (1992) ArticleTitleThe Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns Journal of Finance 47 427–465
E. Fama K. French (1995) ArticleTitleSize and Book-to-Market Factors in Earnings and Returns Journal of Finance 50 131–155
E. Fama K. French (1997) ArticleTitleIndustry Costs of Equity Journal of Financial Economics 43 153–193 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0304-405X(96)00896-3
Fama, E. and K. French. (2004). “Profitability, Growth and Average Returns”. Working paper, University of Chicago
J. Griffin M. Lemmon (2002) ArticleTitleBook-to-Market Equity, Distress Risk, and Stock Returns Journal of Finance 57 2317–2336
B. Graham D. Dodd (1934) Security Analysis McGraw Hill New York
J. Lakonishok A. Shleifer R. Vishny (1994) ArticleTitleContrarian Investment, Extrapolation and Risk Journal of Finance 44 1541–1578
O. Lamont R. Thaler (2003) ArticleTitleCan the Market Add and Subtract? Mispricing in Tech Stock Carve-Outs Journal of Political Economy 111 227–268 Occurrence Handle10.1086/367683
R. LaPorta J. Lakonishok A. Shleifer R. Vishny (1997) ArticleTitleGood News for Value Stocks: Further Evidence on Market Efficiency Journal of Finance 52 859–874
Mohanram, P. (2005). “Separating Winners from Losers Among Low Book-to-Market Stocks Using Financial Statement Analysis.” Review of Accounting Studies 10 (2/3)
J Ohlson (1980) ArticleTitleFinancial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy Journal of Accounting Research 18 109–131
S Penman (1996) ArticleTitleThe Articulation of Price-Earnings Ratios and Market-to-Book Ratios and the Evaluation of Growth Journal of Accounting Research 34 235–260
J Piotroski (2000) ArticleTitleValue Investing: The Use of Historical Financial Statement Information to Separate Winners from Losers Journal of Accounting Research 38 1–41
Piotroski, J. (2005). “Further Evidence on the Relation Between Historical Financial Statement Information, Future Stock Returns and the Value/Glamour Effect.” Working paper, University of Chicago
S. Rangan R. Sloan (1998) ArticleTitleImplications of the Integral Method of Reporting for the Magnitude of Post-Earnings Announcement Drift The Accounting Review 73 353–371
Soliman M. (2004). Using Industry-Adjusted Dupont Analysis to Predict Future Profitability. Working paper, Stanford University
B. Trueman F. Wong X. Zhang (2000) ArticleTitleThe Eyeballs Have It: Searching for the Value in Internet Stocks Journal of Accounting Research 38 137–162
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Piotroski, J.D. Discussion of “Separating Winners from Losers among Low Book-to-Market Stocks using Financial Statement Analysis”. Rev Acc Stud 10, 171–184 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11142-005-1527-3
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11142-005-1527-3